The stupid premise that....
#21
(07-22-2026, 10:33 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-22-2026, 10:31 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-22-2026, 10:25 AM)Fido Wrote:
(07-22-2026, 10:10 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I don't understand why being a business leader automatically means anything? I wouldn't think it wise to put the CEO or CFO of a large, multinational logistics company in charge of a large transport infrastructure development company as an example. We've seen with Boeing how financial nous doesn't translate to being an appropriate fit as leader of an engineering company.

Of course it doesn't, BB. But the logic of "anyone with a brain can do it" is probably a less-favourable route to take, I would suggest. The straitjacket is obviously tighter in a public sector position but experience of productivity gains coupled with improving customer experience would be of great benefit.


So would someone with experience being involved in designing and delivering large infrastructure projects, or someone who is involved in producing key research outputs but you don't see the same clamour for engineering managers or research scientists to get into government in the same view as you do the vague "business leader" trope from sections of the right. It just seems like a lazy criticism to me.

Don't you? I think that's exactly what we need.

Not from the right I don't. From engineering/scientific research institutes and specific senior individuals I do
Reply
#22
(07-22-2026, 10:49 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote:
(07-22-2026, 09:41 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Feels a bit like the outdated claims that you need to have played the game at the highest level to be a good manager

I am finding it an argument that is rather detached from reality. Ministers are figureheads and leaders making the decisions. The govt dept heads and civil servants will be the people with the experience and skills of budget management etc. 

It is a bit of another Daily Mail dog whistle argument imo. Becoming par for the course 

Javid and Sunak were bankers (no typo on the b). 

I rest my case your honour.

I still don't think £80-90k a year is a lot of money for the level of responsibility and the standard we expect for people running the country.
Reply
#23
(07-22-2026, 10:39 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I still haven't managed to understand Proth's square circle of Maggie being his most revered politician with next to no experience outside of politics

A clear political & economic philosophy and the strength of character to carry it through? I think it also helped that she was surrounded by several political giants at the time, something sorely lacking on all sides of the House now. She was also "lucky" to inherit a absolute crisis which gave her political capital to get through 1979-81 and she was also lucky that Labour reacted to defeat by electing Michael Foot as leader. 

Was anyone ever in any doubt what she stood for?

Does anyone have any ideas yet what Starmer, Sunak, May, Johnson or Cameron stood for? Does anyone have any idea what Andy Burnham's burning political philosophy is?

That's why it's easy to revere her in the same way as the left reveres Clement Attlee.

And before BB says it - both of them stole several clothes from the Liberals.
Reply
#24
(07-22-2026, 11:06 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-22-2026, 10:39 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I still haven't managed to understand Proth's square circle of Maggie being his most revered politician with next to no experience outside of politics

A clear political & economic philosophy and the strength of character to carry it through? I think it also helped that she was surrounded by several political giants at the time, something sorely lacking on all sides of the House now. She was also "lucky" to inherit a absolute crisis which gave her political capital to get through 1979-81 and she was also lucky that Labour reacted to defeat by electing Michael Foot as leader. 

Was anyone ever in any doubt what she stood for?

Does anyone have any ideas yet what Starmer, Sunak, May, Johnson or Cameron stood for? Does anyone have any idea what Andy Burnham's burning political philosophy is?

That's why it's easy to revere her in the same way as the left reveres Clement Attlee.

And before BB says it - both of them stole several clothes from the Liberals.

Last time we had a politician who we were in no doubt over what he stood for you campaigned against him in favour of one, maybe two of the names you list above.
Reply
#25
(07-22-2026, 11:06 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-22-2026, 10:39 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I still haven't managed to understand Proth's square circle of Maggie being his most revered politician with next to no experience outside of politics

A clear political & economic philosophy and the strength of character to carry it through? I think it also helped that she was surrounded by several political giants at the time, something sorely lacking on all sides of the House now. She was also "lucky" to inherit a absolute crisis which gave her political capital to get through 1979-81 and she was also lucky that Labour reacted to defeat by electing Michael Foot as leader. 

Was anyone ever in any doubt what she stood for?

Does anyone have any ideas yet what Starmer, Sunak, May, Johnson or Cameron stood for? Does anyone have any idea what Andy Burnham's burning political philosophy is?

That's why it's easy to revere her in the same way as the left reveres Clement Attlee.

And before BB says it - both of them stole several clothes from the Liberals.

She was so good, that she allowed a weak despotic country to invade our land which led to a 100s of military deaths. She should have resigned, a politician would do that now if the same thing happened.
Reply
#26
(07-22-2026, 11:06 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-22-2026, 10:39 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I still haven't managed to understand Proth's square circle of Maggie being his most revered politician with next to no experience outside of politics

A clear political & economic philosophy and the strength of character to carry it through? I think it also helped that she was surrounded by several political giants at the time, something sorely lacking on all sides of the House now. She was also "lucky" to inherit a absolute crisis which gave her political capital to get through 1979-81 and she was also lucky that Labour reacted to defeat by electing Michael Foot as leader. 

Was anyone ever in any doubt what she stood for?

Does anyone have any ideas yet what Starmer, Sunak, May, Johnson or Cameron stood for? Does anyone have any idea what Andy Burnham's burning political philosophy is?

That's why it's easy to revere her in the same way as the left reveres Clement Attlee.

And before BB says it - both of them stole several clothes from the Liberals.

Is this another ironic post? You campaigned for Brexit - has anyone identified what this was for? Johnson stood for Getting Brexit Done which was a political and economical philosophical shitshow from the get go. In fairness to Starmer, Sunak and May, they were just managing the chickens coming home to roost after years of mismanagement and treating the UK as a set of accounts.
Reply
#27
(07-22-2026, 11:54 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(07-22-2026, 11:06 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-22-2026, 10:39 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I still haven't managed to understand Proth's square circle of Maggie being his most revered politician with next to no experience outside of politics

A clear political & economic philosophy and the strength of character to carry it through? I think it also helped that she was surrounded by several political giants at the time, something sorely lacking on all sides of the House now. She was also "lucky" to inherit a absolute crisis which gave her political capital to get through 1979-81 and she was also lucky that Labour reacted to defeat by electing Michael Foot as leader. 

Was anyone ever in any doubt what she stood for?

Does anyone have any ideas yet what Starmer, Sunak, May, Johnson or Cameron stood for? Does anyone have any idea what Andy Burnham's burning political philosophy is?

That's why it's easy to revere her in the same way as the left reveres Clement Attlee.

And before BB says it - both of them stole several clothes from the Liberals.

Is this another ironic post? You campaigned for Brexit - has anyone identified what this was for? Johnson stood for Getting Brexit Done which was a political and economical philosophical shitshow from the get go. In fairness to Starmer, Sunak and May, they were just managing the chickens coming home to roost after years of mismanagement and treating the UK as a set of accounts.

Maybe going to Eton should disqualify anyone from holding Office?
Reply
#28
(07-22-2026, 11:02 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(07-22-2026, 10:49 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote:
(07-22-2026, 09:41 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Feels a bit like the outdated claims that you need to have played the game at the highest level to be a good manager

I am finding it an argument that is rather detached from reality. Ministers are figureheads and leaders making the decisions. The govt dept heads and civil servants will be the people with the experience and skills of budget management etc. 

It is a bit of another Daily Mail dog whistle argument imo. Becoming par for the course 

Javid and Sunak were bankers (no typo on the b). 

I rest my case your honour.

I still don't think £80-90k a year is a lot of money for the level of responsibility and the standard we expect for people running the country.

I totally agree. MPs should have 200k minimum imo.
I also agree with Proth on what he said about PLP and the 2024 intake.
Honestly, I wouldn't have most of them working for me.
Reply
#29
One thing I will agree with Proth on is that anyone who has ever said they want to be an MP is automatically disqualified.
Reply
#30
(07-22-2026, 11:54 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(07-22-2026, 11:06 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-22-2026, 10:39 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I still haven't managed to understand Proth's square circle of Maggie being his most revered politician with next to no experience outside of politics

A clear political & economic philosophy and the strength of character to carry it through? I think it also helped that she was surrounded by several political giants at the time, something sorely lacking on all sides of the House now. She was also "lucky" to inherit a absolute crisis which gave her political capital to get through 1979-81 and she was also lucky that Labour reacted to defeat by electing Michael Foot as leader. 

Was anyone ever in any doubt what she stood for?

Does anyone have any ideas yet what Starmer, Sunak, May, Johnson or Cameron stood for? Does anyone have any idea what Andy Burnham's burning political philosophy is?

That's why it's easy to revere her in the same way as the left reveres Clement Attlee.

And before BB says it - both of them stole several clothes from the Liberals.

Is this another ironic post? You campaigned for Brexit - has anyone identified what this was for? Johnson stood for Getting Brexit Done which was a political and economical philosophical shitshow from the get go. In fairness to Starmer, Sunak and May, they were just managing the chickens coming home to roost after years of mismanagement and treating the UK as a set of accounts.

Sorry I missed the confirmation that you understood the answer to your question?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: