Posts: 613
Threads: 47
Joined: Apr 2019
Reputation:
2
in order to be successful in government you need to have experience running a company with a profit motive. It is the most ludicrous proposition you often here. Typically made by people who themselves have started a company and run a business and think of themselves as special because of it. You often here Tories and Reform people making this argument. Well, perhaps they should outline how many businesses the UKs greatest ever leader (Churchill) ran in his lifetime. Or likewise JFK.
Posts: 7,444
Threads: 372
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
Willy waving for the hard of thinking or those with some sort of warped ego usually.
As Paddock observed earlier, you can’t debate with them because they’re incapable of listening or reflecting.
Raw Sausage
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(07-21-2026, 08:26 PM)Logic1 Wrote: in order to be successful in government you need to have experience running a company with a profit motive. It is the most ludicrous proposition you often hear. Typically made by people who themselves have started a company and run a business and think of themselves as special because of it. You often hear Tories and Reform people making this argument. Well, perhaps they should outline how many businesses the UKs greatest ever leader (Churchill) ran in his lifetime. Or likewise JFK.
Not one person in the cabinet. Zero.Zilch. The Business Secretary even lied about being a solicitor FFS.
Posts: 151
Threads: 5
Joined: Jun 2026
Reputation:
1
(07-21-2026, 08:26 PM)Logic1 Wrote: in order to be successful in government you need to have experience running a company with a profit motive. It is the most ludicrous proposition you often here. Typically made by people who themselves have started a company and run a business and think of themselves as special because of it. You often here Tories and Reform people making this argument. Well, perhaps they should outline how many businesses the UKs greatest ever leader (Churchill) ran in his lifetime. Or likewise JFK.
We've been there before, many times: there used to be a poster who regularly sneered at other contributors for (his words) 'never having had a proper job'. You might remember the individual in question; he'll undoubtedly be back in a different guise at some point.
I'd always assumed he'd spent his formative years as either something like a high-rise scaffolder, or possibly a rigger out on Sullom Voe. Turned out he'd spent his entire working life in banking and financial services; heaviest thing he'd ever lifted was a stapler.
Posts: 613
Threads: 47
Joined: Apr 2019
Reputation:
2
(07-22-2026, 12:44 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (07-21-2026, 08:26 PM)Logic1 Wrote: in order to be successful in government you need to have experience running a company with a profit motive. It is the most ludicrous proposition you often hear. Typically made by people who themselves have started a company and run a business and think of themselves as special because of it. You often hear Tories and Reform people making this argument. Well, perhaps they should outline how many businesses the UKs greatest ever leader (Churchill) ran in his lifetime. Or likewise JFK.
Not one person in the cabinet. Zero.Zilch. The Business Secretary even lied about being a solicitor FFS.
I would imagine Boris Johnson's government had many former business people in it and links with business people e.g. Michelle Mone. Yet it was one of the most clueless, inept governments on record.
The basic idea that just because someone has run a business, they have magical powers relative to other people is just simple lunacy and makes absolutely no sense. All humans are generally made of the same stuff, our brains have similar architecture so there is no reason to suppose that someone who has run a business would be better at being Chancellor than someone who was a journalist or worked for a trade union.
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
The irony of the 'Greatest politician of our lifetime', to quote some on here, never had a real job beyond a bit of 'junior researcher at a chemical company' seems to be ignored.
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(07-22-2026, 08:18 AM)Logic1 Wrote: (07-22-2026, 12:44 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (07-21-2026, 08:26 PM)Logic1 Wrote: in order to be successful in government you need to have experience running a company with a profit motive. It is the most ludicrous proposition you often hear. Typically made by people who themselves have started a company and run a business and think of themselves as special because of it. You often hear Tories and Reform people making this argument. Well, perhaps they should outline how many businesses the UKs greatest ever leader (Churchill) ran in his lifetime. Or likewise JFK.
Not one person in the cabinet. Zero.Zilch. The Business Secretary even lied about being a solicitor FFS.
I would imagine Boris Johnson's government had many former business people in it and links with business people e.g. Michelle Mone. Yet it was one of the most clueless, inept governments on record.
The basic idea that just because someone has run a business, they have magical powers relative to other people is just simple lunacy and makes absolutely no sense. All humans are generally made of the same stuff, our brains have similar architecture so there is no reason to suppose that someone who has run a business would be better at being Chancellor than someone who was a journalist or worked for a trade union.
So if you were recruiting a new CFO for a company would you tend to look for candidates that had strong financial experience or someone with none whatsoever? Surely the situation is similar?
I think the question is whether how we should attract people with the right qualities and experience to leadership roles in government instead of picking from a small group of what are essentially just acolytes.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(07-22-2026, 08:18 AM)Logic1 Wrote: (07-22-2026, 12:44 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (07-21-2026, 08:26 PM)Logic1 Wrote: in order to be successful in government you need to have experience running a company with a profit motive. It is the most ludicrous proposition you often hear. Typically made by people who themselves have started a company and run a business and think of themselves as special because of it. You often hear Tories and Reform people making this argument. Well, perhaps they should outline how many businesses the UKs greatest ever leader (Churchill) ran in his lifetime. Or likewise JFK.
Not one person in the cabinet. Zero.Zilch. The Business Secretary even lied about being a solicitor FFS.
I would imagine Boris Johnson's government had many former business people in it and links with business people e.g. Michelle Mone. Yet it was one of the most clueless, inept governments on record.
The basic idea that just because someone has run a business, they have magical powers relative to other people is just simple lunacy and makes absolutely no sense. All humans are generally made of the same stuff, our brains have similar architecture so there is no reason to suppose that someone who has run a business would be better at being Chancellor than someone who was a journalist or worked for a trade union.
I don't think anyone is claiming anything about magical powers. Just basic competence in managing budgets, assessing likely behavioural impacts or the opportunity cost of policymaking. I don't believe any member of the government has applied an innovation in their working lives that has saved money or improved productivity.
I find that final contention quite bewildering too, though that said we have just suffered "an economist" as Chancellor so maybe you're right. We're about to find out.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
Feels a bit like the outdated claims that you need to have played the game at the highest level to be a good manager
Posts: 613
Threads: 47
Joined: Apr 2019
Reputation:
2
(07-22-2026, 09:08 AM)Fido Wrote: (07-22-2026, 08:18 AM)Logic1 Wrote: (07-22-2026, 12:44 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (07-21-2026, 08:26 PM)Logic1 Wrote: in order to be successful in government you need to have experience running a company with a profit motive. It is the most ludicrous proposition you often hear. Typically made by people who themselves have started a company and run a business and think of themselves as special because of it. You often hear Tories and Reform people making this argument. Well, perhaps they should outline how many businesses the UKs greatest ever leader (Churchill) ran in his lifetime. Or likewise JFK.
Not one person in the cabinet. Zero.Zilch. The Business Secretary even lied about being a solicitor FFS.
I would imagine Boris Johnson's government had many former business people in it and links with business people e.g. Michelle Mone. Yet it was one of the most clueless, inept governments on record.
The basic idea that just because someone has run a business, they have magical powers relative to other people is just simple lunacy and makes absolutely no sense. All humans are generally made of the same stuff, our brains have similar architecture so there is no reason to suppose that someone who has run a business would be better at being Chancellor than someone who was a journalist or worked for a trade union.
So if you were recruiting a new CFO for a company would you tend to look for candidates that had strong financial experience or someone with none whatsoever? Surely the situation is similar?
I think the question is whether how we should attract people with the right qualities and experience to leadership roles in government instead of picking from a small group of what are essentially just acolytes. If I was appointing a CFO, I would expect them to have business experience in the context of the job. If I was appointing the head of nursing for a hospital likewise etc. We elect politicians from a diversity of backgrounds. They make decisions based on policy put to the electorate. The civil servants, who are experts then deliver that policy. Unless you believe in some mythical deep state conspricay theory.
If you want to change the composition of people who are elected to parliament, join a political party and take part in the selection process.
Nevertheless, my premise is certainly correct, you do not need to have expertise in business in order to be a successful politician/minister. The key is strong political awareness. Rachel Reeves is a trained economist, yet her political awareness (likewise Keir Staremer) meant she failed.
|