The stupid premise that....
#11
(07-22-2026, 09:52 AM)Logic1 Wrote:
(07-22-2026, 09:08 AM)Fido Wrote:
(07-22-2026, 08:18 AM)Logic1 Wrote:
(07-22-2026, 12:44 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-21-2026, 08:26 PM)Logic1 Wrote: in order to be successful in government you need to have experience running a company with a profit motive. It is the most ludicrous proposition you often hear. Typically made by people who themselves have started a company and run a business and think of themselves as special because of it. You often hear Tories and Reform people making this argument. Well, perhaps they should outline how many businesses the UKs greatest ever leader (Churchill) ran in his lifetime. Or likewise JFK.

Not one person in the cabinet. Zero.Zilch. The Business Secretary even lied about being a solicitor FFS.

I would imagine Boris Johnson's government had many former business people in it and links with business people e.g. Michelle Mone. Yet it was one of the most clueless, inept governments on record.

The basic idea that just because someone has run a business, they have magical powers relative to other people is just simple lunacy and makes absolutely no sense. All humans are generally made of the same stuff, our brains have similar architecture so there is no reason to suppose that someone who has run a business would be better at being Chancellor than someone who was a journalist or worked for a trade union.

So if you were recruiting a new CFO for a company would you tend to look for candidates that had strong financial experience or someone with none whatsoever? Surely the situation is similar?

I think the question is whether how we should attract people with the right qualities and experience to leadership roles in government instead of picking from a small group of what are essentially just acolytes.
If I was appointing a CFO, I would expect them to have business experience in the context of the job. If I was appointing the head of nursing for a hospital likewise etc. We elect politicians from a diversity of backgrounds. They make decisions based on policy put to the electorate. The civil servants, who are experts then deliver that policy. Unless you believe in some mythical deep state conspricay theory.

If you want to change the composition of people who are elected to parliament, join a political party and take part in the selection process. 

Nevertheless, my premise is certainly correct, you do not need to have expertise in business in order to be a successful politician/minister. The key is strong political awareness. Rachel Reeves is a trained economist, yet her political awareness (likewise Keir Staremer) meant she failed.

Well if you're that sure of yourself then no point in continuing the debate, FFS sake. Bear in mind though we are talking about decision-making heads within the cabinet with enormous budgets for things that affect the whole country.

But herein lies the truth of this whole thing in bold. That people want what's good for them as opposed to what should be the right direction for the country. Being a good politician should be about taking better courses of action but bringing the electorate along in terms of the final goal. Strong leaders of large businesses know this. Not sure why it should be too different in a governmental situation.
Reply
#12
I don't understand why being a business leader automatically means anything? I wouldn't think it wise to put the CEO or CFO of a large, multinational logistics company in charge of a large transport infrastructure development company as an example. We've seen with Boeing how financial nous doesn't translate to being an appropriate fit as leader of an engineering company.
Reply
#13
It's an arrogance of people, akin to the historical view that poor people shouldn't vote because they don't understand what is good for them, that have been in business to think that only certain aspects of humanity should be taken into account when choosing someone to lead a nation. Imagine considering that someone who understands figures alone and has, as mentioned, borrowed to pay bills and provide a salary for staff, should lead a country whilst potentially devoid of the human qualities such as compassion and empathy.

There are plenty of decisions that on paper look correct to cut losses or save money that take no account of the human impact of such decisions. We don't need a business leader to run the country, or a social worker come to that - we need someone that has a wider view and can listen to experts.
Reply
#14
Doesn't change the fundamental fact that if we want the best leaders and decision makers to go into politics we have to pay them a wage that will tempt them away from the jobs they're currently in. £80-90k a year to these type of people is peanuts.
Reply
#15
(07-22-2026, 10:10 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I don't understand why being a business leader automatically means anything? I wouldn't think it wise to put the CEO or CFO of a large, multinational logistics company in charge of a large transport infrastructure development company as an example. We've seen with Boeing how financial nous doesn't translate to being an appropriate fit as leader of an engineering company.

Of course it doesn't, BB. But the logic of "anyone with a brain can do it" is probably a less-favourable route to take, I would suggest. The straitjacket is obviously tighter in a public sector position but experience of productivity gains coupled with improving customer experience would be of great benefit.

(07-22-2026, 10:20 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Doesn't change the fundamental fact that if we want the best leaders and decision makers to go into politics we have to pay them a wage that will tempt them away from the jobs they're currently in. £80-90k a year to these type of people is peanuts.

+1.
Reply
#16
(07-22-2026, 10:25 AM)Fido Wrote:
(07-22-2026, 10:10 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I don't understand why being a business leader automatically means anything? I wouldn't think it wise to put the CEO or CFO of a large, multinational logistics company in charge of a large transport infrastructure development company as an example. We've seen with Boeing how financial nous doesn't translate to being an appropriate fit as leader of an engineering company.

Of course it doesn't, BB. But the logic of "anyone with a brain can do it" is probably a less-favourable route to take, I would suggest. The straitjacket is obviously tighter in a public sector position but experience of productivity gains coupled with improving customer experience would be of great benefit.


So would someone with experience being involved in designing and delivering large infrastructure projects, or someone who is involved in producing key research outputs but you don't see the same clamour for engineering managers or research scientists to get into government in the same view as you do the vague "business leader" trope from sections of the right. It just seems like a lazy criticism to me.
Reply
#17
(07-22-2026, 10:20 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Doesn't change the fundamental fact that if we want the best leaders and decision makers to go into politics we have to pay them a wage that will tempt them away from the jobs they're currently in. £80-90k a year to these type of people is peanuts.

Absolutely correct. 

One of the greatest issues with the current PLP is that for the vast majority of them this is the best paid job they will ever have had, and will ever have. The quality of the 2025 intake is dire and drawn from an exceptionally narrow section of the community.

(07-22-2026, 10:31 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-22-2026, 10:25 AM)Fido Wrote:
(07-22-2026, 10:10 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I don't understand why being a business leader automatically means anything? I wouldn't think it wise to put the CEO or CFO of a large, multinational logistics company in charge of a large transport infrastructure development company as an example. We've seen with Boeing how financial nous doesn't translate to being an appropriate fit as leader of an engineering company.

Of course it doesn't, BB. But the logic of "anyone with a brain can do it" is probably a less-favourable route to take, I would suggest. The straitjacket is obviously tighter in a public sector position but experience of productivity gains coupled with improving customer experience would be of great benefit.


So would someone with experience being involved in designing and delivering large infrastructure projects, or someone who is involved in producing key research outputs but you don't see the same clamour for engineering managers or research scientists to get into government in the same view as you do the vague "business leader" trope from sections of the right. It just seems like a lazy criticism to me.

Don't you? I think that's exactly what we need.

(07-22-2026, 10:20 AM)baggy1 Wrote: It's an arrogance of people, akin to the historical view that poor people shouldn't vote because they don't understand what is good for them, that have been in business to think that only certain aspects of humanity should be taken into account when choosing someone to lead a nation. Imagine considering that someone who understands figures alone and has, as mentioned, borrowed to pay bills and provide a salary for staff, should lead a country whilst potentially devoid of the human qualities such as compassion and empathy.

There are plenty of decisions that on paper look correct to cut losses or save money that take no account of the human impact of such decisions. We don't need a business leader to run the country, or a social worker come to that - we need someone that has a wider view and can listen to experts.

Ignoring the cheap and lazy dig in your first paragraph, I'm sure Rachel Reeves listened to experts in the Treasury. Why wouldn't she? She was cut from exactly the same cloth. You talk about human impact, you also need to consider behavioural impact. If the Treasury has an expert in that then they've been hiding very well.
Reply
#18
I still haven't managed to understand Proth's square circle of Maggie being his most revered politician with next to no experience outside of politics
Reply
#19
(07-22-2026, 10:02 AM)Fido Wrote:
(07-22-2026, 09:52 AM)Logic1 Wrote:
(07-22-2026, 09:08 AM)Fido Wrote:
(07-22-2026, 08:18 AM)Logic1 Wrote:
(07-22-2026, 12:44 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Not one person in the cabinet. Zero.Zilch. The Business Secretary even lied about being a solicitor FFS.

I would imagine Boris Johnson's government had many former business people in it and links with business people e.g. Michelle Mone. Yet it was one of the most clueless, inept governments on record.

The basic idea that just because someone has run a business, they have magical powers relative to other people is just simple lunacy and makes absolutely no sense. All humans are generally made of the same stuff, our brains have similar architecture so there is no reason to suppose that someone who has run a business would be better at being Chancellor than someone who was a journalist or worked for a trade union.

So if you were recruiting a new CFO for a company would you tend to look for candidates that had strong financial experience or someone with none whatsoever? Surely the situation is similar?

I think the question is whether how we should attract people with the right qualities and experience to leadership roles in government instead of picking from a small group of what are essentially just acolytes.
If I was appointing a CFO, I would expect them to have business experience in the context of the job. If I was appointing the head of nursing for a hospital likewise etc. We elect politicians from a diversity of backgrounds. They make decisions based on policy put to the electorate. The civil servants, who are experts then deliver that policy. Unless you believe in some mythical deep state conspricay theory.

If you want to change the composition of people who are elected to parliament, join a political party and take part in the selection process. 

Nevertheless, my premise is certainly correct, you do not need to have expertise in business in order to be a successful politician/minister. The key is strong political awareness. Rachel Reeves is a trained economist, yet her political awareness (likewise Keir Staremer) meant she failed.

Well if you're that sure of yourself then no point in continuing the debate, FFS sake. Bear in mind though we are talking about decision-making heads within the cabinet with enormous budgets for things that affect the whole country.

But herein lies the truth of this whole thing in bold. That people want what's good for them as opposed to what should be the right direction for the country. Being a good politician should be about taking better courses of action but bringing the electorate along in terms of the final goal. Strong leaders of large businesses know this. Not sure why it should be too different in a governmental situation.
So do pediatric consultants who run departments dealing with life and death decisions. No profit motive there. I think driven business leaders should stick to what they do best... Run businesses. Not bleat that there is a lack of business in government.
Reply
#20
(07-22-2026, 09:41 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Feels a bit like the outdated claims that you need to have played the game at the highest level to be a good manager

I am finding it an argument that is rather detached from reality. Ministers are figureheads and leaders making the decisions. The govt dept heads and civil servants will be the people with the experience and skills of budget management etc. 

It is a bit of another Daily Mail dog whistle argument imo. Becoming par for the course 

Javid and Sunak were bankers (no typo on the b). 

I rest my case your honour.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)