England v India Test Series!!..
(08-04-2025, 09:55 PM)Albionmad Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 08:09 PM)Old Fart Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 11:34 AM)Old Fart Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 11:27 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 11:26 AM)Old Fart Wrote: Despite his century, Brook decided to showboat. 

 The way he was playing he could have seen the game out just by knocking the ball about on the ground and taking singles and twos. 

Unprofessional behaviour with a touch of arrogance and lack of clear instruction from the team manager, unless he told him to act like a twat.

You've managed to win the award for stupidest post on this thread, and that takes some doing.

Jesus fucking christ.

Thanks.  I shall wear the badge with honour.

From Jonathan Agnew BBC Sport

If you go back to key moments in this match, particularly with 73 runs needed with seven wickets in hand, England should be winning from there. 
There will be comments about Harry Brook's dismissal and I'll be one who says, really, was that necessary? With the game just within your grasp, the really hard-nosed professional attitude is that you win the game.
Joe Root and Brook had just snatched the game away from them with such an incredible 195-run partnership.
But if you speak to Michael Vaughan and Sir Alastair Cook, people who have scored far many more Test runs than I have, they'll say they're OK with it, so an old-timer shrugs his shoulders and says 'fair enough'.
But Brook was the only one who could have seized the game in the manner that he did because Root just played in his quiet, professional way.
He has since said he regretted the shot got that him out and fair enough to him, it's big of him to say that. You just hope that next time, in Sydney when they're 2-1 up to win the Ashes, he'll see England home!

Maybe not the most stupid post of the day? 
The argument is that without Brook's innings England wouldn't have got close to winning the game. That's very true. 

However, once he'd got England to the cusp of victory, he should have reigned in his attacking instincts and taken 1s & 2s as he was doing until that kamikaze shot. Did Joe Root tell him to calm down and nurdle the runs?

 India were a spent force. The bowlers were serving up easy meat.

All credit to India for getting off the floor and turning the tables so they were the side exerting pressure which England couldn't deal with.

Down under England will face a team that gives no quarter. Once they have their foot on your throat they rarely give you any respite.
This could back to bite me in the bum, but we will win in Australia.
Reply
We're more than capable. I don't think we will. It's such a tough ask to win a series down under. If we can get, and keep, Archer and Wood fit then we stand a reasonable chance.
Reply
Fun fact about the golden era of Baz'n'Ben is that this team has never (yet) won a 5 match series. So that means they've never (yet) won against Oz or India, because they're the only sides that play 5 match series.

I'm not on board with the notion that we are "over-achieving". I think that's an effort to justify our failings when we look so good, then sometimes fall short when the pressure's on. We should be able to produce a winning team with our cricket infrastructure in the UK. Part of winning is mentality, and McCullum and Stokes have certainly brought that to the fore. We've discovered some huge talents, but there are still a few strange decisions being made on field and in terms of selection.

Following on from Chris Silverwood was an easy gig. Those were dark days. Joe Root was very ill-served by some of his senior players, bowling for their legacy rather than trying to take wickets, hiding on the boundary when the ball was flying off the bat. His batters went out there full of fear rather than hope. I'm pleased Joe has stayed in the fold and gone on to become the greatest ever - his later years as captain of a failing side could have derailed that.
Reply
(08-05-2025, 07:47 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Fun fact about the golden era of Baz'n'Ben is that this team has never (yet) won a 5 match series. So that means they've never (yet) won against Oz or India, because they're the only sides that play 5 match series.

I'm not on board with the notion that we are "over-achieving". I think that's an effort to justify our failings when we look so good, then sometimes fall short when the pressure's on. We should be able to produce a winning team with our cricket infrastructure in the UK. Part of winning is mentality, and McCullum and Stokes have certainly brought that to the fore. We've discovered some huge talents, but there are still a few strange decisions being made on field and in terms of selection.

Following on from Chris Silverwood was an easy gig. Those were dark days. Joe Root was very ill-served by some of his senior players, bowling for their legacy rather than trying to take wickets, hiding on the boundary when the ball was flying off the bat. His batters went out there full of fear rather than hope. I'm pleased Joe has stayed in the fold and gone on to become the greatest ever - his later years as captain of a failing side could have derailed that.

Excellent post. Agree with all of it.
Reply
(08-05-2025, 07:49 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(08-05-2025, 07:47 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Fun fact about the golden era of Baz'n'Ben is that this team has never (yet) won a 5 match series. So that means they've never (yet) won against Oz or India, because they're the only sides that play 5 match series.

I'm not on board with the notion that we are "over-achieving". I think that's an effort to justify our failings when we look so good, then sometimes fall short when the pressure's on. We should be able to produce a winning team with our cricket infrastructure in the UK. Part of winning is mentality, and McCullum and Stokes have certainly brought that to the fore. We've discovered some huge talents, but there are still a few strange decisions being made on field and in terms of selection.

Following on from Chris Silverwood was an easy gig. Those were dark days. Joe Root was very ill-served by some of his senior players, bowling for their legacy rather than trying to take wickets, hiding on the boundary when the ball was flying off the bat. His batters went out there full of fear rather than hope. I'm pleased Joe has stayed in the fold and gone on to become the greatest ever - his later years as captain of a failing side could have derailed that.

Excellent post. Agree with all of it.

You are never going to compete in a 5 test series if you disrespect the tour by arriving in the country less than 48hrs to the first test & as in this winters ashes tour not playing as single warm up match!!..
This kind of planning and management by the coaches will inevitably lead to heavy series losses.
Reply
Harry Brook himself agrees with me in that he regrets playing the shot. Nice to see an ounce of reflection for once, perhaps a very valuable learning experience for someone who is a fine young player. Learning from situations like this will only make him better.
Reply
(08-05-2025, 08:08 AM)pindgill Wrote:
(08-05-2025, 07:49 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(08-05-2025, 07:47 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Fun fact about the golden era of Baz'n'Ben is that this team has never (yet) won a 5 match series. So that means they've never (yet) won against Oz or India, because they're the only sides that play 5 match series.

I'm not on board with the notion that we are "over-achieving". I think that's an effort to justify our failings when we look so good, then sometimes fall short when the pressure's on. We should be able to produce a winning team with our cricket infrastructure in the UK. Part of winning is mentality, and McCullum and Stokes have certainly brought that to the fore. We've discovered some huge talents, but there are still a few strange decisions being made on field and in terms of selection.

Following on from Chris Silverwood was an easy gig. Those were dark days. Joe Root was very ill-served by some of his senior players, bowling for their legacy rather than trying to take wickets, hiding on the boundary when the ball was flying off the bat. His batters went out there full of fear rather than hope. I'm pleased Joe has stayed in the fold and gone on to become the greatest ever - his later years as captain of a failing side could have derailed that.

Excellent post. Agree with all of it.

You are never going to compete in a 5 test series if you disrespect the tour by arriving in the country less than 48hrs to the first test & as in this winters ashes tour not playing as single warm up match!!..
This kind of planning and management by the coaches will inevitably lead to heavy series losses.

India 23/24. England won the first test.

This is the only 5 match tour the McCullum/Stokes regime have been on.
Reply
(08-05-2025, 08:51 AM)Jacko Wrote:
(08-05-2025, 08:08 AM)pindgill Wrote:
(08-05-2025, 07:49 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(08-05-2025, 07:47 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Fun fact about the golden era of Baz'n'Ben is that this team has never (yet) won a 5 match series. So that means they've never (yet) won against Oz or India, because they're the only sides that play 5 match series.

I'm not on board with the notion that we are "over-achieving". I think that's an effort to justify our failings when we look so good, then sometimes fall short when the pressure's on. We should be able to produce a winning team with our cricket infrastructure in the UK. Part of winning is mentality, and McCullum and Stokes have certainly brought that to the fore. We've discovered some huge talents, but there are still a few strange decisions being made on field and in terms of selection.

Following on from Chris Silverwood was an easy gig. Those were dark days. Joe Root was very ill-served by some of his senior players, bowling for their legacy rather than trying to take wickets, hiding on the boundary when the ball was flying off the bat. His batters went out there full of fear rather than hope. I'm pleased Joe has stayed in the fold and gone on to become the greatest ever - his later years as captain of a failing side could have derailed that.

Excellent post. Agree with all of it.

You are never going to compete in a 5 test series if you disrespect the tour by arriving in the country less than 48hrs to the first test & as in this winters ashes tour not playing as single warm up match!!..
This kind of planning and management by the coaches will inevitably lead to heavy series losses.

India 23/24. England won the first test.

This is the only 5 match tour the McCullum/Stokes regime have been on.

They lost the next 4 tests badly  Huh
Reply
(08-05-2025, 08:08 AM)pindgill Wrote:
(08-05-2025, 07:49 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(08-05-2025, 07:47 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Fun fact about the golden era of Baz'n'Ben is that this team has never (yet) won a 5 match series. So that means they've never (yet) won against Oz or India, because they're the only sides that play 5 match series.

I'm not on board with the notion that we are "over-achieving". I think that's an effort to justify our failings when we look so good, then sometimes fall short when the pressure's on. We should be able to produce a winning team with our cricket infrastructure in the UK. Part of winning is mentality, and McCullum and Stokes have certainly brought that to the fore. We've discovered some huge talents, but there are still a few strange decisions being made on field and in terms of selection.

Following on from Chris Silverwood was an easy gig. Those were dark days. Joe Root was very ill-served by some of his senior players, bowling for their legacy rather than trying to take wickets, hiding on the boundary when the ball was flying off the bat. His batters went out there full of fear rather than hope. I'm pleased Joe has stayed in the fold and gone on to become the greatest ever - his later years as captain of a failing side could have derailed that.

Excellent post. Agree with all of it.

You are never going to compete in a 5 test series if you disrespect the tour by arriving in the country less than 48hrs to the first test & as in this winters ashes tour not playing as single warm up match!!..
This kind of planning and management by the coaches will inevitably lead to heavy series losses.

You don't need to do any prep if you are arrogant.

(08-05-2025, 10:48 AM)pindgill Wrote:
(08-05-2025, 08:51 AM)Jacko Wrote:
(08-05-2025, 08:08 AM)pindgill Wrote:
(08-05-2025, 07:49 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(08-05-2025, 07:47 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Fun fact about the golden era of Baz'n'Ben is that this team has never (yet) won a 5 match series. So that means they've never (yet) won against Oz or India, because they're the only sides that play 5 match series.

I'm not on board with the notion that we are "over-achieving". I think that's an effort to justify our failings when we look so good, then sometimes fall short when the pressure's on. We should be able to produce a winning team with our cricket infrastructure in the UK. Part of winning is mentality, and McCullum and Stokes have certainly brought that to the fore. We've discovered some huge talents, but there are still a few strange decisions being made on field and in terms of selection.

Following on from Chris Silverwood was an easy gig. Those were dark days. Joe Root was very ill-served by some of his senior players, bowling for their legacy rather than trying to take wickets, hiding on the boundary when the ball was flying off the bat. His batters went out there full of fear rather than hope. I'm pleased Joe has stayed in the fold and gone on to become the greatest ever - his later years as captain of a failing side could have derailed that.

Excellent post. Agree with all of it.

You are never going to compete in a 5 test series if you disrespect the tour by arriving in the country less than 48hrs to the first test & as in this winters ashes tour not playing as single warm up match!!..
This kind of planning and management by the coaches will inevitably lead to heavy series losses.

India 23/24. England won the first test.

This is the only 5 match tour the McCullum/Stokes regime have been on.

They lost the next 4 tests badly  Huh

Yes, but but but the plucky underdogs did ever so well to win that single Test.
Reply
(08-05-2025, 10:48 AM)pindgill Wrote:
(08-05-2025, 08:51 AM)Jacko Wrote:
(08-05-2025, 08:08 AM)pindgill Wrote:
(08-05-2025, 07:49 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(08-05-2025, 07:47 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Fun fact about the golden era of Baz'n'Ben is that this team has never (yet) won a 5 match series. So that means they've never (yet) won against Oz or India, because they're the only sides that play 5 match series.

I'm not on board with the notion that we are "over-achieving". I think that's an effort to justify our failings when we look so good, then sometimes fall short when the pressure's on. We should be able to produce a winning team with our cricket infrastructure in the UK. Part of winning is mentality, and McCullum and Stokes have certainly brought that to the fore. We've discovered some huge talents, but there are still a few strange decisions being made on field and in terms of selection.

Following on from Chris Silverwood was an easy gig. Those were dark days. Joe Root was very ill-served by some of his senior players, bowling for their legacy rather than trying to take wickets, hiding on the boundary when the ball was flying off the bat. His batters went out there full of fear rather than hope. I'm pleased Joe has stayed in the fold and gone on to become the greatest ever - his later years as captain of a failing side could have derailed that.

Excellent post. Agree with all of it.

You are never going to compete in a 5 test series if you disrespect the tour by arriving in the country less than 48hrs to the first test & as in this winters ashes tour not playing as single warm up match!!..
This kind of planning and management by the coaches will inevitably lead to heavy series losses.

India 23/24. England won the first test.

This is the only 5 match tour the McCullum/Stokes regime have been on.

They lost the next 4 tests badly  Huh

How can it be a preparation issue if they win the first game ffs.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)