England v India Test Series!!..
(08-04-2025, 11:32 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 11:31 AM)richbaggie Wrote: It often feels like Southgate and England on here. Unless we beat everyone, we are failures, whether we've got the best players in the world or not.

Yep.

Perspective is seemingly not a thing in sport any more. Outrage and short sighted moaning is the order of the day.

Ignorance is bliss mate.
Reply
(08-04-2025, 11:27 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 11:26 AM)Old Fart Wrote: Despite his century, Brook decided to showboat. 

 The way he was playing he could have seen the game out just by knocking the ball about on the ground and taking singles and twos. 

Unprofessional behaviour with a touch of arrogance and lack of clear instruction from the team manager, unless he told him to act like a twat.

You've managed to win the award for stupidest post on this thread, and that takes some doing.

Jesus fucking christ.

Thanks.  I shall wear the badge with honour.
Reply
(08-04-2025, 11:28 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 11:27 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: [quote="Old Fart" pid="790465" dateline="1754306771"]
Despite his century, Brook decided to showboat. 

 The way he was playing he could have seen the game out just by knocking the ball about on the ground and taking singles and twos. 

Unprofessional behaviour with a touch of arrogance and lack of clear instruction from the team manager, unless he told him to act like a twat.

You've managed to win the award for stupidest post on this thread, and that takes some doing.

Jesus fucking christ.
Are you seriously suggesting that England's pool of cricket talent is well below that of Australia, India, New Zealand, Pakistan and South Africa? The top cricket nations.

You're not, are you?


Top level talent? Yes.

You widely critisie the likes of Crawley, Pope in the batting line up, and completely denigrate our bowling attack a lot. Poo poo the selections of Overton and Bethell. None of these criticisms are unfair, if slightly overblown.

But how can you sit there and criticise the team so much, yet claim we have as much talent as the other top nations? It's hypocrisy.
Reply
I've no issue with losing when you're beaten by someone doing something special, or simply being better in all elements of the game.

I've cited our last three big series and moments in each that have turned the tide away from England not through good play from the opponent, but through our own stupidity, approach and decision making at key times. That's what's hard to take.
Reply
Brook did what Brook does, is all. I'd point to 38 extras 1st knock (India's 2nd top score) and 6 dropped catches 2nd innings. All the rest are ifs and maybes.
Great game and a fair end to an amazing series.
Reply
Gutting as that was, 2-2 is a fair refection of a very good series.
Reply
(08-04-2025, 11:31 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: The style of cricket has got us back winning games but it is totally valid to express frustration at constantly throwing it away in key moments in series.

This is the correct view. 

I believe the criticism of Brook in the second innings is very harsh. He got a century and put us in a winning position FFS. 

However, we were cantering to victory with Brook and Root at the crease, needing 70 odd at that point. There was absolutely no need to do anything stupid or overly aggressive. I can understand why people are frustrated at Brook, as he did gift his wicket away, and it did start the collapse. I believe that's very harsh to criticise him, but I can understand the view point. 

Aggressive batting has its place, and this leadership regime has been beneficial and has improved us from the Root era of captaincy, but the idea that we can't criticise poor results and have to just accept it as a consequence of how we place is nonsnese. 

Test matches are a long grind. There's plenty of time to be positive and aggressive, and there's also time and situations where you need to bat within yourself and sensibly. You don't have to play with the same mentality all the time. You can read the situation and play accordingly, which we do better nowadays, than when old Baz took over, and it has improved, but there's still elements of arrogance, stupidity, aggression, whatever you want to label it, that is often needless and it does cost us. 

There's absolutely no reason why you can't appreciate the positives the style brings, but also question it when it doesn't work, especially when the reason it hasn't work has been avoidable, like in this Test. Yes, it's brought success and wonderful occasions, but it's also led to us throwing away Tests from winnable positions.
Reply
India thoroughly deserved a draw in the series but England should have won given the base that Root and Brook built.

I have no issue with the approach but I do with selection. Dawson over Rehan FFS. Overton??
Reply
This series has been brilliant, not just as a spectacle, but for the game in general.
Test cricket had become stale and boring, for many, with the result being the only thing that mattered, by any means necessary, whereas here we had two fantastic teams going toe to toe for the entirety of the series. It was like a classic boxing match of old!
Sometimes you've just got to be glad you were able to see it and applaud all those involved.
Reply
I don't think the Southgate comparison is fair - no one has said this England team are failures or that they should be beating everyone. Expressing fruststration at going from 300-4 to 367 all out is perfectly valid. There doesn't have to be a binary "they're great/shit" we can love a lot about the side while wanting them to be better.

Having said that, Siraj deserved a draw on his own.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)