England v India Test Series!!..
(07-23-2025, 05:18 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(07-23-2025, 05:05 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(07-23-2025, 04:57 PM)Jacko Wrote: Can only assume you've never played the game. Having a substitute wicketkeeper on the field for the entirety of both innings is a massive advantage, if the injured party is still allowed to bat with no penalty for time off the field.

You assume too much. I would rather have a fit Pant keeping wicket and batting.

The 12 v 13 was as nonsensical as your 11 v 12.
If an England player had the same misfortune I don't think you would be so flippant about a sub keeper.

We should start doing it. Get Smith to wear one on the wrist on the first morning of the test and have Foakes as a named 12th man. Job done. It's a joke and one of the laws that needs looking at.

Jurel is fundamentally a better wicketkeeper. The fatigue of keeping wicket and also batting long innings should not be understated.

Jacko, the guy couldn't even walk off the pitch. He had to retire hurt when his team needed him out in the middle and may not be able to bat for the rest of the match. I can't see how you interpret this as some sort of sneaky plan to gain an advantage.
Reply
(07-23-2025, 06:13 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(07-23-2025, 05:18 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(07-23-2025, 05:05 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(07-23-2025, 04:57 PM)Jacko Wrote: Can only assume you've never played the game. Having a substitute wicketkeeper on the field for the entirety of both innings is a massive advantage, if the injured party is still allowed to bat with no penalty for time off the field.

You assume too much. I would rather have a fit Pant keeping wicket and batting.

The 12 v 13 was as nonsensical as your 11 v 12.
If an England player had the same misfortune I don't think you would be so flippant about a sub keeper.

We should start doing it. Get Smith to wear one on the wrist on the first morning of the test and have Foakes as a named 12th man. Job done. It's a joke and one of the laws that needs looking at.

Jurel is fundamentally a better wicketkeeper. The fatigue of keeping wicket and also batting long innings should not be understated.

Jacko, the guy couldn't even walk off the pitch. He had to retire hurt when his team needed him out in the middle and may not be able to bat for the rest of the match. I can't see how you interpret this as some sort of sneaky plan to gain an advantage.

I don't think it's a sneaky plan, but now that it has happened colour me cynical if I happen to think the lad will bat in both innings but somehow won't be fit enough to keep wicket, ala 10 days ago.
Reply
(07-23-2025, 04:39 PM)Jacko Wrote: Pant can bat. After getting his feet up for as long as he wants in the rest of this innings and the entirety of England's two innings.

He could bat but there is a possibility he might not, a probability if his foot is broken as has been speculated.
Reply
(07-23-2025, 06:45 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(07-23-2025, 04:39 PM)Jacko Wrote: Pant can bat. After getting his feet up for as long as he wants in the rest of this innings and the entirety of England's two innings.

He could bat but there is a possibility he might not, a probability if his foot is broken as has been speculated.

Doesn’t look good

Eng slight favourites as it stands
Reply
His foot is quite clearly broken. Fair play if he comes back out to bat but I don't see it.

Jacko's point about Durel in the previous test is valid. I think if you've gone off the field like this then you're relegated to number 11. There's no way at Lords after not fielding Pant should have been able to come out and bat 5-6.
Reply
I think India abused the situation at Lords and the world moves in mysterious ways that potentially Pant has now got a genuine injury that could keep him out from not just fielding but batting too. I think they call it karma, although that sounds a little harsh.

Pant wouldn’t be the guy I’d want this to happen to, after his time out it would be a low for him personally, but also the way he plays makes him an entertainer. Good for England, not so good for the game.

Wherever they’ve sent him must be the slowest A&E dept. In the world to not have the results yet! Back to the gamesmanship…
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
The problem here is the rule that allowed Pant to bat as normal, but not field in the Lords Test. India just took advantage of it, like England absolutely would have done as well.
Reply
https://x.com/mufaddal_vohra/status/1948282161410580550

Various Indian journalists now sharing that Pant is out for 6 weeks with a broken foot. Ishan Kishan added to the squad.
Reply
Quite a bit of Pant wetting on here
Reply
(07-24-2025, 08:05 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: https://x.com/mufaddal_vohra/status/1948282161410580550

Various Indian journalists now sharing that Pant is out for 6 weeks with a broken foot. Ishan Kishan added to the squad.

Jacko will be gutted  Big Grin

(07-24-2025, 07:12 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: I think India abused the situation at Lords and the world moves in mysterious ways that potentially Pant has now got a genuine injury that could keep him out from not just fielding but batting too. I think they call it karma, although that sounds a little harsh. 

Pant wouldn’t be the guy I’d want this to happen to, after his time out it would be a low for him personally, but also the way he plays makes him an entertainer.  Good for England, not so good for the game.

Wherever they’ve sent him must be the slowest A&E dept. In the world to not have the results yet! Back to the gamesmanship…
Why is it gamesmanship?
We now know he's out for the series.  But how is not having an official confirmation change anything?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)