England v India Test Series!!..
(07-23-2025, 04:57 PM)Jacko Wrote: Can only assume you've never played the game. Having a substitute wicketkeeper on the field for the entirety of both innings is a massive advantage, if the injured party is still allowed to bat with no penalty for time off the field.

You assume too much. I would rather have a fit Pant keeping wicket and batting.

The 12 v 13 was as nonsensical as your 11 v 12.
If an England player had the same misfortune I don't think you would be so flippant about a sub keeper.
Reply
(07-23-2025, 04:57 PM)Jacko Wrote: Can only assume you've never played the game. Having a substitute wicketkeeper on the field for the entirety of both innings is a massive advantage, if the injured party is still allowed to bat with no penalty for time off the field.

I know you're keen to be RSB's new Cuzer, Jacko, but you're coming across as a bit of a twat here. Pant was hit full on the foot by an 80+mph delivery. You could see the swelling from miles away as he was karted off. No cheating intended. The anomalies in the injury sub rules are being debated at length by the pundits - you can replace a wicket keeper, you can have a concussion sub, but you can't replace a player who's broken a bone or suffered a severe soft tissue injury and you can't have a runner. If he can't walk, he can't bat. No advantage for India in that.

Have we added cricket to football and financial advising - if you haven't done it at a high enough level you can't have an opinion???
Reply
(07-23-2025, 05:05 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(07-23-2025, 04:57 PM)Jacko Wrote: Can only assume you've never played the game. Having a substitute wicketkeeper on the field for the entirety of both innings is a massive advantage, if the injured party is still allowed to bat with no penalty for time off the field.

You assume too much. I would rather have a fit Pant keeping wicket and batting.

The 12 v 13 was as nonsensical as your 11 v 12.
If an England player had the same misfortune I don't think you would be so flippant about a sub keeper.

We should start doing it. Get Smith to wear one on the wrist on the first morning of the test and have Foakes as a named 12th man. Job done. It's a joke and one of the laws that needs looking at.

Jurel is fundamentally a better wicketkeeper. The fatigue of keeping wicket and also batting long innings should not be understated.
Reply
(07-23-2025, 05:18 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(07-23-2025, 05:05 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(07-23-2025, 04:57 PM)Jacko Wrote: Can only assume you've never played the game. Having a substitute wicketkeeper on the field for the entirety of both innings is a massive advantage, if the injured party is still allowed to bat with no penalty for time off the field.

You assume too much. I would rather have a fit Pant keeping wicket and batting.

The 12 v 13 was as nonsensical as your 11 v 12.
If an England player had the same misfortune I don't think you would be so flippant about a sub keeper.

We should start doing it. Get Smith to wear one on the wrist on the first morning of the test and have Foakes as a named 12th man. Job done. It's a joke and one of the laws that needs looking at.

Jurel is fundamentally a better wicketkeeper. The fatigue of keeping wicket and also batting long innings should not be understated.

It’s all a cunning plan by the Indians Big Grin
Jacko is cuzers papa
Reply
(07-23-2025, 05:18 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(07-23-2025, 05:05 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(07-23-2025, 04:57 PM)Jacko Wrote: Can only assume you've never played the game. Having a substitute wicketkeeper on the field for the entirety of both innings is a massive advantage, if the injured party is still allowed to bat with no penalty for time off the field.

You assume too much. I would rather have a fit Pant keeping wicket and batting.

The 12 v 13 was as nonsensical as your 11 v 12.
If an England player had the same misfortune I don't think you would be so flippant about a sub keeper.

We should start doing it. Get Smith to wear one on the wrist on the first morning of the test and have Foakes as a named 12th man. Job done. It's a joke and one of the laws that needs looking at.

Jurel is fundamentally a better wicketkeeper. The fatigue of keeping wicket and also batting long innings should not be understated.

So you would ask a player to deliberately injure themselves to gain what you perceive as an advantage.

Well that's one of your best. Stunner.
Reply
And there we have it instead of playing spinners and not taking the new ball Englands captain stops play by taking the new ball and the umpires call end of play due to bad light!!!..
Lamentable I hope all barracking the Indian captain for time wasting last test will now pipe up too!!…
Reply
Even day. 
If Pant can't bat then maybe England the happier of the two.
Reply
(07-23-2025, 05:15 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(07-23-2025, 04:57 PM)Jacko Wrote: Can only assume you've never played the game. Having a substitute wicketkeeper on the field for the entirety of both innings is a massive advantage, if the injured party is still allowed to bat with no penalty for time off the field.

I know you're keen to be RSB's new Cuzer, Jacko, but you're coming across as a bit of a twat here. Pant was hit full on the foot by an 80+mph delivery. You could see the swelling from miles away as he was karted off. No cheating intended. The anomalies in the injury sub rules are being debated at length by the pundits - you can replace a wicket keeper, you can have a concussion sub, but you can't replace a player who's broken a bone or suffered a severe soft tissue injury and you can't have a runner. If he can't walk, he can't bat. No advantage for India in that.

Have we added cricket to football and financial advising - if you haven't done it at a high enough level you can't have an opinion???

Cheers CEB, in the office so haven't seen it. If the poor mite doesn't come back out to bat I'll give a full retraction. Not holding my breath though...

(07-23-2025, 05:23 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(07-23-2025, 05:18 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(07-23-2025, 05:05 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(07-23-2025, 04:57 PM)Jacko Wrote: Can only assume you've never played the game. Having a substitute wicketkeeper on the field for the entirety of both innings is a massive advantage, if the injured party is still allowed to bat with no penalty for time off the field.

You assume too much. I would rather have a fit Pant keeping wicket and batting.

The 12 v 13 was as nonsensical as your 11 v 12.
If an England player had the same misfortune I don't think you would be so flippant about a sub keeper.

We should start doing it. Get Smith to wear one on the wrist on the first morning of the test and have Foakes as a named 12th man. Job done. It's a joke and one of the laws that needs looking at.

Jurel is fundamentally a better wicketkeeper. The fatigue of keeping wicket and also batting long innings should not be understated.

So you would ask a player to deliberately injure themselves to gain what you perceive as an advantage.

Well that's one of your best. Stunner.

No, are you hard of thinking? I would have them feign an injury or the severity of an injury to gain the obvious advantage of having the best wicketkeeper while retaining the best six or seven different batters.
Reply
(07-23-2025, 05:31 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(07-23-2025, 05:15 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(07-23-2025, 04:57 PM)Jacko Wrote: Can only assume you've never played the game. Having a substitute wicketkeeper on the field for the entirety of both innings is a massive advantage, if the injured party is still allowed to bat with no penalty for time off the field.

I know you're keen to be RSB's new Cuzer, Jacko, but you're coming across as a bit of a twat here. Pant was hit full on the foot by an 80+mph delivery. You could see the swelling from miles away as he was karted off. No cheating intended. The anomalies in the injury sub rules are being debated at length by the pundits - you can replace a wicket keeper, you can have a concussion sub, but you can't replace a player who's broken a bone or suffered a severe soft tissue injury and you can't have a runner. If he can't walk, he can't bat. No advantage for India in that.

Have we added cricket to football and financial advising - if you haven't done it at a high enough level you can't have an opinion???

Cheers CEB, in the office so haven't seen it. If the poor mite doesn't come back out to bat I'll give a full retraction. Not holding my breath though...

(07-23-2025, 05:23 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(07-23-2025, 05:18 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(07-23-2025, 05:05 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(07-23-2025, 04:57 PM)Jacko Wrote: Can only assume you've never played the game. Having a substitute wicketkeeper on the field for the entirety of both innings is a massive advantage, if the injured party is still allowed to bat with no penalty for time off the field.

You assume too much. I would rather have a fit Pant keeping wicket and batting.

The 12 v 13 was as nonsensical as your 11 v 12.
If an England player had the same misfortune I don't think you would be so flippant about a sub keeper.

We should start doing it. Get Smith to wear one on the wrist on the first morning of the test and have Foakes as a named 12th man. Job done. It's a joke and one of the laws that needs looking at.

Jurel is fundamentally a better wicketkeeper. The fatigue of keeping wicket and also batting long innings should not be understated.

So you would ask a player to deliberately injure themselves to gain what you perceive as an advantage.

Well that's one of your best. Stunner.

No, are you hard of thinking? I would have them feign an injury or the severity of an injury to gain the obvious advantage of having the best wicketkeeper while retaining the best six or seven different batters.

But Pant is injured and will have to bat injured too!!..
There’s absolute no benefit!!..
Reply
(07-23-2025, 05:44 PM)pindgill Wrote:
(07-23-2025, 05:31 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(07-23-2025, 05:15 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(07-23-2025, 04:57 PM)Jacko Wrote: Can only assume you've never played the game. Having a substitute wicketkeeper on the field for the entirety of both innings is a massive advantage, if the injured party is still allowed to bat with no penalty for time off the field.

I know you're keen to be RSB's new Cuzer, Jacko, but you're coming across as a bit of a twat here. Pant was hit full on the foot by an 80+mph delivery. You could see the swelling from miles away as he was karted off. No cheating intended. The anomalies in the injury sub rules are being debated at length by the pundits - you can replace a wicket keeper, you can have a concussion sub, but you can't replace a player who's broken a bone or suffered a severe soft tissue injury and you can't have a runner. If he can't walk, he can't bat. No advantage for India in that.

Have we added cricket to football and financial advising - if you haven't done it at a high enough level you can't have an opinion???

Cheers CEB, in the office so haven't seen it. If the poor mite doesn't come back out to bat I'll give a full retraction. Not holding my breath though...

(07-23-2025, 05:23 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(07-23-2025, 05:18 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(07-23-2025, 05:05 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: You assume too much. I would rather have a fit Pant keeping wicket and batting.

The 12 v 13 was as nonsensical as your 11 v 12.
If an England player had the same misfortune I don't think you would be so flippant about a sub keeper.

We should start doing it. Get Smith to wear one on the wrist on the first morning of the test and have Foakes as a named 12th man. Job done. It's a joke and one of the laws that needs looking at.

Jurel is fundamentally a better wicketkeeper. The fatigue of keeping wicket and also batting long innings should not be understated.

So you would ask a player to deliberately injure themselves to gain what you perceive as an advantage.

Well that's one of your best. Stunner.

No, are you hard of thinking? I would have them feign an injury or the severity of an injury to gain the obvious advantage of having the best wicketkeeper while retaining the best six or seven different batters.

But Pant is injured and will have to bat injured too!!..
There’s absolute no benefit!!..
Two short planks.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: