England v India Test Series!!..
(07-07-2025, 06:59 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I did have a really long and reasoned post lined up but I can't be arsed so I'll just say that it's crap and unlikeable. Even when they win they come across as dicks.

They're asking for flat decks so they can slap it around and we don't have the bowlers to take wickets. Much improvement needed for Lords and I'm hoping for a pitch closer to what we saw in the WTC.

Crawley should have gone years ago. There are now real questions about Pope and his 4th innings record where he averages less than 20. Bashir isn't it but gets zero help from his captain and the pitches. Retiring Anderson and replacing him with Wakes, go figure?

Big one for me is Stokes. It's nice to see him bowl again but he hasn't scored a run for ages and his captaincy has got bizarre. It won't happen but I'd be giving serious thought to dropping him and bringing Dawson in as the all-rounder and spin option, also gives us space to get another quick in the team.

Expect minimal changes for the next game, I can see us bringing Archer in, asking him to bowl 20 overs of bouncers and then him having to retire immediately after the game.

This keeps coming up. Woakes is fine if he's fit (which he obviously isn't at the moment). Jimmy is 6 years older. 3 games in the County Championship Div 2 (only bowled in 5 innings though), his figures are good as you'd expect, 11 for 273 at a decent strike rate. Does this mean he's fit for a 5 day Test. I'd say no.

Looking at the Championship stats, the two unlucky losers are Jack Leach and Ollie Robinson, both taking wickets economically and regularly in Div 1. But Bazball isn't about picking players in form, it's about - - - well wtf is it all about? I'm with Ted on this, I just don't like Baz'n'Ben. They come across as arrogant. Winning well often, then getting hammered on a fairly regular basis isn't a crowd-pleasing formula for the long term.
Reply
(07-07-2025, 08:56 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(07-07-2025, 06:59 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I did have a really long and reasoned post lined up but I can't be arsed so I'll just say that it's crap and unlikeable. Even when they win they come across as dicks.

They're asking for flat decks so they can slap it around and we don't have the bowlers to take wickets. Much improvement needed for Lords and I'm hoping for a pitch closer to what we saw in the WTC.

Crawley should have gone years ago. There are now real questions about Pope and his 4th innings record where he averages less than 20. Bashir isn't it but gets zero help from his captain and the pitches. Retiring Anderson and replacing him with Wakes, go figure?

Big one for me is Stokes. It's nice to see him bowl again but he hasn't scored a run for ages and his captaincy has got bizarre. It won't happen but I'd be giving serious thought to dropping him and bringing Dawson in as the all-rounder and spin option, also gives us space to get another quick in the team.

Expect minimal changes for the next game, I can see us bringing Archer in, asking him to bowl 20 overs of bouncers and then him having to retire immediately after the game.

This keeps coming up. Woakes is fine if he's fit (which he obviously isn't at the moment). Jimmy is 6 years older. 3 games in the County Championship Div 2 (only bowled in 5 innings though), his figures are good as you'd expect, 11 for 273 at a decent strike rate. Does this mean he's fit for a 5 day Test. I'd say no.

Looking at the Championship stats, the two unlucky losers are Jack Leach and Ollie Robinson, both taking wickets economically and regularly in Div 1. But Bazball isn't about picking players in form, it's about - - - well wtf is it all about? I'm with Ted on this, I just don't like Baz'n'Ben. They come across as arrogant. Winning well often, then getting hammered on a fairly regular basis isn't a crowd-pleasing formula for the long term.

Then you don’t like winning cricket. The best win percentage in England cricket history, the 4th best in history across all test playing countries
Being brutally honest 
Reply
No time for a huge inquest as the 3rd test is already upon us. It was a huge mistake putting India in, there was good reason everyone called it the other way. Also what hasn't been mentioned is the damage India did with the new ball. After rattling through England's top order (1st knock), Smith and Brook batted the ball aots until the 2nd new ball arrived when we were promptly dismissed in half an hour.
The captain and coach might be unfortunate in that we have a plethora of average bowlers, but they shouldn't ignore the fine margins which every coach in every sport everywhere drums home.
That said, don't let's lose sight that every ticket was sold at Edgbaston and we'll have 3 more full grounds this series. It's some of the most enthralling cricket I've watched and credit to them for making it so.
Reply
I'm not a fan of the McCullum/Stokes leadership, either. I don't think they're likeable. I don't like the 'our way or the highway' attitude. The arrogance they show in interviews is deplorable. But I will concede that they have improved the Test playing fortunes, although, we couldn't have gotten worse. We were so low when they took over. They have given us some great occasions and memories. Particularly the Headingly Test, and some of the chases have been remarkable. You also feel we can still win a Test from any position. There has definitely been a positive impact. I can see that. 

But as a general rule, I just don't like how we're going about applying ourselves in games. It's not the cricket I enjoy watching, it's not how I believe Test cricket should be approached, and in all honesty I don't enjoy watching this England team in general, despite some glorious moments. Seeing ultra aggressive batting on flat pitches just doesn't entertain me. If I want to see games dominated by the bat, I'll go and watch the T20 for a few hours.
Reply
What are pitches generally like in first class county cricket.

The reason why the Indian quickies did better with the ball than our bowlers did might be due to having more experience on pitches like the one served up at Edgbaston.
Reply
(07-07-2025, 09:48 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: What are pitches generally like in first class county cricket.

The Edgbaston pitch has been exactly like the wicket we had for the Test match for at least two seasons now. Which is why I found McCullam's comments about not knowing what the pitch would do to be ridiculous, and highlights the blind arrogance of our set up. 

I'm sure it's not the case, and I'm sure plenty of analysis is done across many areas before a Test Match, but that really does give the impression of 'we'll just turn up and play how we play, it doesn't matter about the opposition or the type of wicket we play on'. Like I say, I'm sure that's not the case, but that's how we're coming across. And it's an attitude I find to be unlikeable.
Reply
(07-07-2025, 07:44 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(07-07-2025, 06:44 AM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
(07-06-2025, 05:36 PM)pindgill Wrote:
(07-06-2025, 05:27 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(07-06-2025, 05:19 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Arrogance to blame anyone but yourself. This England team really do make themselves unlikeable.
They play a certain way more times they win sometimes they lose, it won’t change and I don’t won’t it to.
Yes a couple of changes, Bethel, Atkinson and Archer should be playing. 
Must admit Crawley has had to many chances. But for me it’s not arrogance it’s just the way we play.

They play a lot of poor test teams that’s why we get the impression they are doing well.
Against India & Australia there record woeful Angry

Play a lot of poor test teams? What you mean like our last series, against NZ? Who beat India 3-0 but we beat 2-1?
Woeful record against Aus & India? Stokes has captained in 5 tests v Aus, won 2 lost 2. He’s captained in 8 v India, won 3 lost 5, but then 5 of those were in India. I don’t think that’s woeful

Those pesky facts eh?

Easy sum up for me. We got mullered by a team that performed much better than us.
Wrong call made at the toss, as BM admitted, and bar the Brook/Smith partnership, we played poorly against a very good side.

I haven't seen this arrogance that some see in the squad this summer. When you hear what BM said about the reasons for batting 1st, they were based on logic around weather and the pitch, not an arrogant belief that they can chase anything down. They just got it wrong.

I don't see petulance or poor behaviour on the pitch. 

What I see is a team that is being coached in being positive and aggressive in their cricket. Pretty much how the Aussies have approached it for 30 years. It's a very English trait to not like this confidence, we are far too polite.

I can see us bouncing back and it being a much more even test at Lords, as long as we are bold with a couple of changes. Bethel for Pope,  Atkinson and Archer for Tongue and Woakes. Add in simply batting better and we can reverse what we've seen at Edgbaston.

This about sums up where I am too. Our seam bowling (thanks to injuries we always seem to have) is average at best currently. India's batters are far too good for our bowlers. A trio of Atkinson, Wood and Archer/Carse would be much improved, with Stokes as the fourth option.

Spin - Bashir, although not his fault, is barely even a County level spinner. He should be nowhere near the Test team. We have Leach, Dawson (who can bat very well), Bess as fine, average options. If you want to go for a younger project, where's Rehan Ahmed, or maybe even his younger brother? Or, as others have suggested, get Bethell into the team as a bat at 6, and you can combo his spin with Root for a serviceable option. Root's spin is bloody good.

Regards Pope. His poor record isn't just limited to 4th innings, it's any second innings. It is a staggering split. He just can't bat in a 2nd innings. Yet his 1st innings stats are more than decent. Baffling conundrum. His stats:

1st Team Innings - 58 innings, 2618 runs, 46.75 average, 66 SR, 8 100s, 13 50s.
2nd Team Innings - 44 innings, 821 runs, 20.02 average, 62 SR, 1 100, 2 50s.

Crawley - he obviously isn't playing well enough and his flaws are there for all to see. However, his partnership with Duckett is excellent, and he seems to enable Duckett to be great. With all the other issues with the line up, I'd be hesitant to mess that partnership up

The (almost) realistic team line up I'd like to see:

Crawley
Duckett
Pope
Root
Brook
Bethell
Smith
Stokes
Atkinson
Wood
Archer/Carse/another Seamer who isn't injured
Reply
(07-07-2025, 09:36 AM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
(07-07-2025, 08:56 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(07-07-2025, 06:59 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I did have a really long and reasoned post lined up but I can't be arsed so I'll just say that it's crap and unlikeable. Even when they win they come across as dicks.

They're asking for flat decks so they can slap it around and we don't have the bowlers to take wickets. Much improvement needed for Lords and I'm hoping for a pitch closer to what we saw in the WTC.

Crawley should have gone years ago. There are now real questions about Pope and his 4th innings record where he averages less than 20. Bashir isn't it but gets zero help from his captain and the pitches. Retiring Anderson and replacing him with Wakes, go figure?

Big one for me is Stokes. It's nice to see him bowl again but he hasn't scored a run for ages and his captaincy has got bizarre. It won't happen but I'd be giving serious thought to dropping him and bringing Dawson in as the all-rounder and spin option, also gives us space to get another quick in the team.

Expect minimal changes for the next game, I can see us bringing Archer in, asking him to bowl 20 overs of bouncers and then him having to retire immediately after the game.

This keeps coming up. Woakes is fine if he's fit (which he obviously isn't at the moment). Jimmy is 6 years older. 3 games in the County Championship Div 2 (only bowled in 5 innings though), his figures are good as you'd expect, 11 for 273 at a decent strike rate. Does this mean he's fit for a 5 day Test. I'd say no.

Looking at the Championship stats, the two unlucky losers are Jack Leach and Ollie Robinson, both taking wickets economically and regularly in Div 1. But Bazball isn't about picking players in form, it's about - - - well wtf is it all about? I'm with Ted on this, I just don't like Baz'n'Ben. They come across as arrogant. Winning well often, then getting hammered on a fairly regular basis isn't a crowd-pleasing formula for the long term.

Then you don’t like winning cricket. The best win percentage in England cricket history, the 4th best in history across all test playing countries

That's a bit like the old debate about CC's winning start. England won 9 and drew 1 of their Tests in 2022. Since then the record is (I think) won 12 of 24 with Stokes as captain. Still a very solid percentage, but we regularly get hammered, generally at least one match per series. You don't get to be world number one that way and you don't beat India or Oz in a series.

Stats don't tell the whole story. Joe Root had a win percentage of 54% at the beginning of the 2020/21 tour of India. Two years later he was gone, with his record reduced to (a still very impressive) 42%.

I like winning cricket. If you pick the right players, make the right decision at the toss, bat sensibly and manage your fielding side well, you tend to win. Stokes got all four aspects wrong last weekend.
Reply
Team announced for next Test:

Crawley
Duckett
Pope
Root
Brook
Stokes
Smith
Woakes
Carse
Archer (!!)
Bashir
Reply
Archer a big gamble 5 hot days!!!...
Cuzer will be keeping his fingers crossed.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: