England v India Test Series!!..
(07-06-2025, 03:57 PM)Jacko Wrote: We shouldn't have lost 20 wickets on this pitch against an India attack bereft of Bumrah irrespective of approach.

Zac Crawley, Chris Woakes and maybe the spinner must come under consideration for their places.

India now have 3 frontline quicks. Bonus.
Reply
Crawley, Woakes and Bashir should be nowhere near future considerations.
Reply
Stokes had a pop at the pitch…
I blame the BCCI & Gill myself.??‍♂️??
We can’t produce a pitch for an England team in England quite unbelievable???
Reply
Arrogance to blame anyone but yourself. This England team really do make themselves unlikeable.

We didn’t expect that the wicket would play quite as it did and hence we probably got it slightly wrong - quote from Old Baz.

What the hell was he expecting from the Edgbaston pitch, which has been as flat as a witches tit for a number of seasons now. That's a strange old quote.
Reply
(07-06-2025, 05:19 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Arrogance to blame anyone but yourself. This England team really do make themselves unlikeable.
They play a certain way more times they win sometimes they lose, it won’t change and I don’t won’t it to.
Yes a couple of changes, Bethel, Atkinson and Archer should be playing. 
Must admit Crawley has had to many chances. But for me it’s not arrogance it’s just the way we play.
Reply
(07-05-2025, 04:39 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: Jaffa from Deep, he's bowled very very well, along with Siraj.

India are winning this match by 300-400 runs.

Called it.

Agree with Josh, Bashir should be nowhere this team. Playing Woakes after we binned Jimmy off is criminal.
Crawley and Duckett seem to have a good partnership, so i'd be hesitant to get rid, but he's been poor.
Reply
(07-06-2025, 05:27 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(07-06-2025, 05:19 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Arrogance to blame anyone but yourself. This England team really do make themselves unlikeable.
They play a certain way more times they win sometimes they lose, it won’t change and I don’t won’t it to.
Yes a couple of changes, Bethel, Atkinson and Archer should be playing. 
Must admit Crawley has had to many chances. But for me it’s not arrogance it’s just the way we play.

They play a lot of poor test teams that’s why we get the impression they are doing well.
Against India & Australia there record woeful Angry
Reply
Dom Sibley deserves another chance at opening. He's far better than Crawley. But his style doesn't fit, so that doesn't stand a chance. Although, he does seem to have become slightly more aggressive and scores quicker than he did when with the Bears. But he's still a steady opener, that doesn't fit the England mould.

Bethell to come in in place of Bashir as the spin option, although I don't know how his bowling is nowadays after a long standing back issue. But our spin bowling options are so thin, so whoever we pick won't be good enough. Dom Bess, maybe?

In terms of pace bowling. Dare I suggest calling Jimmy back up, and getting him out of retirement? He can't be any worse than Woakes and Tongue. Surely.

(07-06-2025, 05:36 PM)pindgill Wrote:
(07-06-2025, 05:27 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(07-06-2025, 05:19 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Arrogance to blame anyone but yourself. This England team really do make themselves unlikeable.
They play a certain way more times they win sometimes they lose, it won’t change and I don’t won’t it to.
Yes a couple of changes, Bethel, Atkinson and Archer should be playing. 
Must admit Crawley has had to many chances. But for me it’s not arrogance it’s just the way we play.

They play a lot of poor test teams that’s why we get the impression they are doing well.
Against India & Australia there record woeful Angry

Don't come on here spouting facts, lad. That won't get you nowhere.
Reply
(07-06-2025, 05:37 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Dom Sibley deserves another chance at opening. He's far better than Crawley. But his style doesn't fit, so that doesn't stand a chance. Although, he does seem to have become slightly more aggressive and scores quicker than he did when with the Bears. But he's still a steady opener, that doesn't fit the England mould.

Bethell to come in in place of Bashir as the spin option, although I don't know how his bowling is nowadays after a long standing back issue. But our spin bowling options are so thin, so whoever we pick won't be good enough. Dom Bess, maybe?

In terms of pace bowling. Dare I suggest calling Jimmy back up, and getting him out of retirement? He can't be any worse than Woakes and Tongue. Surely.

(07-06-2025, 05:36 PM)pindgill Wrote:
(07-06-2025, 05:27 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(07-06-2025, 05:19 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Arrogance to blame anyone but yourself. This England team really do make themselves unlikeable.
They play a certain way more times they win sometimes they lose, it won’t change and I don’t won’t it to.
Yes a couple of changes, Bethel, Atkinson and Archer should be playing. 
Must admit Crawley has had to many chances. But for me it’s not arrogance it’s just the way we play.

They play a lot of poor test teams that’s why we get the impression they are doing well.
Against India & Australia there record woeful Angry

Don't come on here spouting facts, lad. That won't get you nowhere.
Hasib has had a fruitful summer. But his style is not going to sit well with Baz and Stokes.
Jimmy recall should not be an option in any way.
Bashir is absolutely NOT a spin bowler of any quality, maybe never will be.
There appears to be a bit of a closed shop within the hierarchy and if your face don't fit you will always be on the outside looking in.

But aside from England's issues it was a superb performance by an Indian team ... and a deserved win to somewhat atone for throwing away the first test.
Reply
The attitude is fine, attacking, trying to win etc. Today they made a decent effort to bat through to a draw, which is new. But there are so many examples of how they make life harder for themselves.

Crawley is there because his dad is Rob Key's mate. For every match he wins there's another where he puts pressure on his team mates by not doing his job seeing off the new ball. No wonder Joe Root looks angry strolling out to bat 20 overs too soon.

Can't see what the plan is with Bashir. Spin bowling is an art form that needs to be learned. There are better spinners available to England. Bashir needs to learn his game at a lower level.

I'm a big fan of Woakes, he's been unlucky to coincide with Broad and Anderson. But he went into this series on the back of another injury with very little game time behind him. No wonder he was "tired". Shouldn't Sam Cook have been given another shot?

Stokes is the best of the seam bowlers on recent form - but he obviously can't do the number of overs he needs. He isn't contributing with the bat either. Difficult one because he's the inspiration.

Turning every match into a fourth innings run chase is too simplistic. India negated that by making the match unwinnable for England.

"Waiting for Jofra" has pretty much been England's plan for 5 years. Add Mark Wood to that as well. Does anyone think those tow are going to see us through a tough series Down Under? Is there a plan B?

And finally, for home Tests at least, we need a proper old-fashioned bits and pieces all rounder. Sam Curran would have added some variety to the bowling and some backbone to a team trying to grind out a draw.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)