Rachel wants to fiddle the figures
(10-29-2024, 04:29 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-28-2024, 09:38 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-28-2024, 09:32 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-28-2024, 05:20 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-28-2024, 03:44 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:

If Japan, Finland and Sweden can manage it I'm sure we will be able to find a way - especially when 1 cost-benefit analysis for universal free school meals (PwC) pointed to a £25bn net benefit over 20 years (which is over double the Implementation cost, a 200% return on investment over 20 years). It's not exactly trying to demonstrate cold fusion, is it?


Here we go again. A 20 year cost benefit analysis. You don't understand the difference between profit and cash. The amount of cash it would cost to implement this infrastructure would be astronomical - and as people keep pointing out there are plenty of projects that need cash investment at the moment, some of which might just lead to economic growth. Free school meals won't. Free school meals will not generate cash, but PwC say it will give a return on Core Benefits. It's all "Wooden Dollars".

It's a bit like Putin announcing an increase in GDP in his war economy, as his newly built tanks are blown up.

It's not about "generating cash", it's about economic returns through better learning outcomes at school leading to greater lifetime contributions and reduced spending on healthcare due to better nutritional care.

I hate the immediate-termist outlook that you are repeating, all it does is multiply problems.

Oh I see. Spunk billions today for intangible benefits in a decade or two.

How exactly are increased lifetime contributions as a result of better educational attainment and reduced spending on healthcare due to better childhood nutrition intangible?

And two decades is really not that long in the future, it's the exact sort of timeframe this country should be focusing policy outcomes on instead of the moronic short-termist attitude that has resulted in stagnant productivity and half the country earning less than they would in Slovenia.

Because improvement costs cash now, and the gilt market that funds it is trembling at the knees, look at the front page of Tuesday's FT.

You simply can't just chuck cash into a project and amortise the cost over 20 years citing "benefits".

The cash is now, the cost is now. It is costing the UK to invest, and Gilts will reflect this. The markets are driven by pure profit, not idealism.

That is the exact short-termist attitude that has led to shit growth, stagnant productivity and median wages falling below Slovenia.

If you want things to get better, you need to actually plan for them to get better. If a policy is going to have great economic impact over the medium term you need to look at plans to fund it instead of dismissing it out of hand, and if something is mooted to lead to a 200% return in 20 years it needs to be looked at properly instead of dismissed out hand because you're looking at £25bn in savings over 20 years - whether that be more graduated or whatever like graduating it in over time as was already started in 2014 by making it universal for reception to year 2. Our healthcare services can barely function as it is now, how do you expect them to function 20 years down the line with a much older and fatter population and with more people suffering from the effects of childhood malnutrition? Who is going to fund that? This happens to every policy decision in this country. Can't build new interconnectors or grid upgrades because "too expensive". Can't build new reservoirs because "too expensive". Can't build new nuclear because "too expensive". Can't build new train lines because "too expensive". Can't build new roads because "too expensive". Then all the spending liabilities that those policies were designed to mitigate against come home to roost and everything goes to pot. Who is going to fund those liabilities twenty years down the line if they're not addressed?
Reply
(10-29-2024, 11:55 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-29-2024, 04:29 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-28-2024, 09:38 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-28-2024, 09:32 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-28-2024, 05:20 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: It's not about "generating cash", it's about economic returns through better learning outcomes at school leading to greater lifetime contributions and reduced spending on healthcare due to better nutritional care.

I hate the immediate-termist outlook that you are repeating, all it does is multiply problems.

Oh I see. Spunk billions today for intangible benefits in a decade or two.

How exactly are increased lifetime contributions as a result of better educational attainment and reduced spending on healthcare due to better childhood nutrition intangible?

And two decades is really not that long in the future, it's the exact sort of timeframe this country should be focusing policy outcomes on instead of the moronic short-termist attitude that has resulted in stagnant productivity and half the country earning less than they would in Slovenia.

Because improvement costs cash now, and the gilt market that funds it is trembling at the knees, look at the front page of Tuesday's FT.

You simply can't just chuck cash into a project and amortise the cost over 20 years citing "benefits".

The cash is now, the cost is now. It is costing the UK to invest, and Gilts will reflect this. The markets are driven by pure profit, not idealism.

That is the exact short-termist attitude that has led to shit growth, stagnant productivity and median wages falling below Slovenia.

If you want things to get better, you need to actually plan for them to get better. If a policy is going to have great economic impact over the medium term you need to look at plans to fund it instead of dismissing it out of hand, and if something is mooted to lead to a 200% return in 20 years it needs to be looked at properly instead of dismissed out hand because you're looking at £25bn in savings over 20 years - whether that be more graduated or whatever like graduating it in over time as was already started in 2014 by making it universal for reception to year 2. Our healthcare services can barely function as it is now, how do you expect them to function 20 years down the line with a much older and fatter population and with more people suffering from the effects of childhood malnutrition? Who is going to fund that? This happens to every policy decision in this country. Can't build new interconnectors or grid upgrades because "too expensive". Can't build new reservoirs because "too expensive". Can't build new nuclear because "too expensive". Can't build new train lines because "too expensive". Can't build new roads because "too expensive". Then all the spending liabilities that those policies were designed to mitigate against come home to roost and everything goes to pot. Who is going to fund those liabilities twenty years down the line if they're not addressed?

Build a nuclear power plant, improve rail lines, build new roads. I can see it. Some of these industries should not have been privatised in the first place.

Spunk cash on school meals, give pay rises without strings for working reform. and throw even more cash into the NHS without a real reform policy, whilst increasing indirect taxes on working people and burdening tax on SMEs isn't going to give growth, in my opinion.

Time will tell.
Reply
(10-29-2024, 12:02 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-29-2024, 11:55 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-29-2024, 04:29 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-28-2024, 09:38 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-28-2024, 09:32 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Oh I see. Spunk billions today for intangible benefits in a decade or two.

How exactly are increased lifetime contributions as a result of better educational attainment and reduced spending on healthcare due to better childhood nutrition intangible?

And two decades is really not that long in the future, it's the exact sort of timeframe this country should be focusing policy outcomes on instead of the moronic short-termist attitude that has resulted in stagnant productivity and half the country earning less than they would in Slovenia.

Because improvement costs cash now, and the gilt market that funds it is trembling at the knees, look at the front page of Tuesday's FT.

You simply can't just chuck cash into a project and amortise the cost over 20 years citing "benefits".

The cash is now, the cost is now. It is costing the UK to invest, and Gilts will reflect this. The markets are driven by pure profit, not idealism.

That is the exact short-termist attitude that has led to shit growth, stagnant productivity and median wages falling below Slovenia.

If you want things to get better, you need to actually plan for them to get better. If a policy is going to have great economic impact over the medium term you need to look at plans to fund it instead of dismissing it out of hand, and if something is mooted to lead to a 200% return in 20 years it needs to be looked at properly instead of dismissed out hand because you're looking at £25bn in savings over 20 years - whether that be more graduated or whatever like graduating it in over time as was already started in 2014 by making it universal for reception to year 2. Our healthcare services can barely function as it is now, how do you expect them to function 20 years down the line with a much older and fatter population and with more people suffering from the effects of childhood malnutrition? Who is going to fund that? This happens to every policy decision in this country. Can't build new interconnectors or grid upgrades because "too expensive". Can't build new reservoirs because "too expensive". Can't build new nuclear because "too expensive". Can't build new train lines because "too expensive". Can't build new roads because "too expensive". Then all the spending liabilities that those policies were designed to mitigate against come home to roost and everything goes to pot. Who is going to fund those liabilities twenty years down the line if they're not addressed?

Build a nuclear power plant, improve rail lines, build new roads. I can see it. Some of these industries should not have been privatised in the first place.

Spunk cash on school meals, give pay rises without strings for working reform. and throw even more cash into the NHS without a real reform policy, whilst increasing indirect taxes on working people and burdening tax on SMEs isn't going to give growth, in my opinion.

Time will tell.

And what is "real reform" on healthcare policy? Because more forward thinking preventative healthcare positions - which universal free school meals come under due to reduced childhood malnutrition meaning the knock-on effects are mitigated against over the medium-term - in order to reduce the spending liabilities on easily preventable problems instead of letting problems fester, multiple and take up more hospital resources is what I would class as "real reform", without even mentioning the economic benefits of a better educated and healthier population with a better quality of life (and therefore from that more money to the Exchequer).

If you want to reduce the indirect and direct taxes on working people then you need to look medium-term and long-term as that is how you actually base returns, otherwise the tax burden will continue to go up and up and up without public services being improved to account for that - as has been happening - as you are not trying to fix the actual problems because doing so requires thinking further ahead than 5 years in the future. If something is mooted as saving the taxpayer the sums that universal free school meals are over the medium term then it's short-termist outlooks are an insane reason to block looking it into it or even offering tentative support.
Reply
(10-29-2024, 12:16 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-29-2024, 12:02 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-29-2024, 11:55 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-29-2024, 04:29 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-28-2024, 09:38 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: How exactly are increased lifetime contributions as a result of better educational attainment and reduced spending on healthcare due to better childhood nutrition intangible?

And two decades is really not that long in the future, it's the exact sort of timeframe this country should be focusing policy outcomes on instead of the moronic short-termist attitude that has resulted in stagnant productivity and half the country earning less than they would in Slovenia.

Because improvement costs cash now, and the gilt market that funds it is trembling at the knees, look at the front page of Tuesday's FT.

You simply can't just chuck cash into a project and amortise the cost over 20 years citing "benefits".

The cash is now, the cost is now. It is costing the UK to invest, and Gilts will reflect this. The markets are driven by pure profit, not idealism.

That is the exact short-termist attitude that has led to shit growth, stagnant productivity and median wages falling below Slovenia.

If you want things to get better, you need to actually plan for them to get better. If a policy is going to have great economic impact over the medium term you need to look at plans to fund it instead of dismissing it out of hand, and if something is mooted to lead to a 200% return in 20 years it needs to be looked at properly instead of dismissed out hand because you're looking at £25bn in savings over 20 years - whether that be more graduated or whatever like graduating it in over time as was already started in 2014 by making it universal for reception to year 2. Our healthcare services can barely function as it is now, how do you expect them to function 20 years down the line with a much older and fatter population and with more people suffering from the effects of childhood malnutrition? Who is going to fund that? This happens to every policy decision in this country. Can't build new interconnectors or grid upgrades because "too expensive". Can't build new reservoirs because "too expensive". Can't build new nuclear because "too expensive". Can't build new train lines because "too expensive". Can't build new roads because "too expensive". Then all the spending liabilities that those policies were designed to mitigate against come home to roost and everything goes to pot. Who is going to fund those liabilities twenty years down the line if they're not addressed?

Build a nuclear power plant, improve rail lines, build new roads. I can see it. Some of these industries should not have been privatised in the first place.

Spunk cash on school meals, give pay rises without strings for working reform. and throw even more cash into the NHS without a real reform policy, whilst increasing indirect taxes on working people and burdening tax on SMEs isn't going to give growth, in my opinion.

Time will tell.

And what is "real reform" on healthcare policy? Because more forward thinking preventative healthcare positions - which universal free school meals come under due to reduced childhood malnutrition meaning the knock-on effects are mitigated against over the medium-term - in order to reduce the spending liabilities on easily preventable problems instead of letting problems fester, multiple and take up more hospital resources is what I would class as "real reform", without even mentioning the economic benefits of a better educated and healthier population with a better quality of life (and therefore from that more money to the Exchequer).

If you want to reduce the indirect and direct taxes on working people then you need to look medium-term and long-term as that is how you actually base returns, otherwise the tax burden will continue to go up and up and up without public services being improved to account for that - as has been happening - as you are not trying to fix the actual problems because doing so requires thinking further ahead than 5 years in the future. If something is mooted as saving the taxpayer the sums that universal free school meals are over the medium term then it's short-termist outlooks are an insane reason to block looking it into it or even offering tentative support.

Real world polices for the real world, for real people.

Not hypothetical stuff that takes 20 years to deliver (or not).

Let's start by halving the numbers of managers in the NHS, and improving productivity in the Public Sector, which has flatlined since 2008.

The private sector has embraced technology, modern working practices and become leaner. The public sector has not. Why should my taxes increase, if they can't bring themselves into the modern world? Asking Little Jimmy to eat grass and kernel nuts ain't going to improve an institution that is no longer fit for purpose. Neither is tossing off even more cash at it - without reform.
Reply
"Let's start by halving the numbers of managers in the NHS"

Wow. The sheer ignorance of this line. KKC, you are a walking, talking, daily mail. And no, I don't work in the NHS.
Reply
(10-29-2024, 12:24 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-29-2024, 12:16 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-29-2024, 12:02 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-29-2024, 11:55 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-29-2024, 04:29 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Because improvement costs cash now, and the gilt market that funds it is trembling at the knees, look at the front page of Tuesday's FT.

You simply can't just chuck cash into a project and amortise the cost over 20 years citing "benefits".

The cash is now, the cost is now. It is costing the UK to invest, and Gilts will reflect this. The markets are driven by pure profit, not idealism.

That is the exact short-termist attitude that has led to shit growth, stagnant productivity and median wages falling below Slovenia.

If you want things to get better, you need to actually plan for them to get better. If a policy is going to have great economic impact over the medium term you need to look at plans to fund it instead of dismissing it out of hand, and if something is mooted to lead to a 200% return in 20 years it needs to be looked at properly instead of dismissed out hand because you're looking at £25bn in savings over 20 years - whether that be more graduated or whatever like graduating it in over time as was already started in 2014 by making it universal for reception to year 2. Our healthcare services can barely function as it is now, how do you expect them to function 20 years down the line with a much older and fatter population and with more people suffering from the effects of childhood malnutrition? Who is going to fund that? This happens to every policy decision in this country. Can't build new interconnectors or grid upgrades because "too expensive". Can't build new reservoirs because "too expensive". Can't build new nuclear because "too expensive". Can't build new train lines because "too expensive". Can't build new roads because "too expensive". Then all the spending liabilities that those policies were designed to mitigate against come home to roost and everything goes to pot. Who is going to fund those liabilities twenty years down the line if they're not addressed?

Build a nuclear power plant, improve rail lines, build new roads. I can see it. Some of these industries should not have been privatised in the first place.

Spunk cash on school meals, give pay rises without strings for working reform. and throw even more cash into the NHS without a real reform policy, whilst increasing indirect taxes on working people and burdening tax on SMEs isn't going to give growth, in my opinion.

Time will tell.

And what is "real reform" on healthcare policy? Because more forward thinking preventative healthcare positions - which universal free school meals come under due to reduced childhood malnutrition meaning the knock-on effects are mitigated against over the medium-term - in order to reduce the spending liabilities on easily preventable problems instead of letting problems fester, multiple and take up more hospital resources is what I would class as "real reform", without even mentioning the economic benefits of a better educated and healthier population with a better quality of life (and therefore from that more money to the Exchequer).

If you want to reduce the indirect and direct taxes on working people then you need to look medium-term and long-term as that is how you actually base returns, otherwise the tax burden will continue to go up and up and up without public services being improved to account for that - as has been happening - as you are not trying to fix the actual problems because doing so requires thinking further ahead than 5 years in the future. If something is mooted as saving the taxpayer the sums that universal free school meals are over the medium term then it's short-termist outlooks are an insane reason to block looking it into it or even offering tentative support.

Real world polices for the real world, for real people.

Not hypothetical stuff that takes 20 years to deliver (or not).

Let's start by halving the numbers of managers in the NHS, and improving productivity in the Public Sector, which has flatlined since 2008.

The private sector has embraced technology, modern working practices and become leaner. The public sector has not. Why should my taxes increase, if they can't bring themselves into the modern world? Asking Little Jimmy to eat grass and kernel nuts ain't going to improve an institution that is no longer fit for purpose. Neither is tossing off even more cash at it - without reform.

The real world is that the UK has shit economic growth, stagnant productivity, an increasing tax burden, inadequate public services, indefinite fiscal drag, an aging population and median wages below Slovenia.

You talk about "halving managers" yet we spend less on managers and employ fewer managers already than other European countries - both other Beveridge model countries and Bismarck model countries like Germany - so where is the evidence base that will actually lead to better healthcare outcomes? If anything it suggests the opposite at a cursory glance, and if anything hospital care in this country (the core function of the NHS, social care and primary care are predominantly run as de-facto social insurance systems by private healthcare providers and they both have worse productivity than in hospital care, ironically) is extremely lean compared to healthcare in every other country because medical staff and managers do more within their remit than in other countries who employ more people to do gruntwork. The core way that the NHS needs to be reformed is obvious as it has been pointed out time and time and time again, improve primary care and social care provisions - technology has significantly limited returns compared to stopping people who don't need to go to a hospital from going to a hospital and making sure people that do not need hospital care are able to be discharged to social care, freeing up the time doctors and nurses can spend on actually treating people in hospitals. Preventing the knock-on effects of poor childhood nutrition is key to that as it stops them needing hospital care in the future for something that could have been prevented if we had the foresight to look past the end of our nose. And if you do that you end up having to throw more money at the NHS to stand still, which is the problem we have that needs to be addressed.

You talk about public sector productivity but one of the biggest issues in the energy sector is that the public sector is entirely reliant on high-paid consultancies and consultants to cover gaps in civil service capabilities due to public sector churn and poor wages making being a civil servant unattractive, as well as a dearth of technical expertise because anyone with any technical knowledge on energy systems can get paid significantly more in the private sector or in other countries. Result is any output gains there are swallowed up by increased expenditure on outside expertise - there is essentially zero public sector expertise on how to build a new nuclear plant for example. How does technology magically fix that? And if you don't fix it the private sector is constrained by stupid systems that it has to navigate, whether directly or - in the case of energy as basically everything we do requires power - indirectly.

This is all due to the short-termist attitude that this country is obsessed over. You halve the management staff, forcing hospital staff to cover more functions and spend less time treating people, then what? Doesn't seem like that will actually help healthcare outcomes to me.

As for your assertion that private sector productivity in this country has improved, aside from Covid it has actually tracked with public sector productivity since 2010. That is also shit:

[Image: 20231125_BRC481.png]

Compare the gradient of the lines between 2010 and 2019 for both the private sector and public sector, they're almost identical. The private sector has not carried anywhere near the level of growth that it needs to do, that's why the tax burden is going up. Productivity is also linked to wages, and that's why real wages are flat and why the median income is now below Slovenia, for comparison Slovenia's as a whole was up 17 points from Q1 2010 to Q4 2019 vs the UK's going up by 5 points in that same timeframe:

We simply cannot continue this stupid, short-termist attitude as it is strangling growth and is the core reason the tax burden is going up despite public services not improving. And this myth that the private sector has been carrying growth hasn't tracked since the GFC (at some point you need to admit that something is structurally wrong with how the country is doing stuff, this isn't the 1990s anymore).
Reply
(10-29-2024, 01:03 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: "Let's start by halving the numbers of managers in the NHS"

Wow. The sheer ignorance of this line. KKC, you  are a walking, talking, daily mail. And no, I don't work in the NHS.

Go on then. Explain to me why the NHS has flat lined on productivity in the last 16 years (which included a Labour Government), and tell how you would change and improve it.

Don't give me rhetoric, give me some positive solutions.

(10-29-2024, 01:05 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-29-2024, 12:24 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-29-2024, 12:16 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-29-2024, 12:02 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-29-2024, 11:55 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: That is the exact short-termist attitude that has led to shit growth, stagnant productivity and median wages falling below Slovenia.

If you want things to get better, you need to actually plan for them to get better. If a policy is going to have great economic impact over the medium term you need to look at plans to fund it instead of dismissing it out of hand, and if something is mooted to lead to a 200% return in 20 years it needs to be looked at properly instead of dismissed out hand because you're looking at £25bn in savings over 20 years - whether that be more graduated or whatever like graduating it in over time as was already started in 2014 by making it universal for reception to year 2. Our healthcare services can barely function as it is now, how do you expect them to function 20 years down the line with a much older and fatter population and with more people suffering from the effects of childhood malnutrition? Who is going to fund that? This happens to every policy decision in this country. Can't build new interconnectors or grid upgrades because "too expensive". Can't build new reservoirs because "too expensive". Can't build new nuclear because "too expensive". Can't build new train lines because "too expensive". Can't build new roads because "too expensive". Then all the spending liabilities that those policies were designed to mitigate against come home to roost and everything goes to pot. Who is going to fund those liabilities twenty years down the line if they're not addressed?

Build a nuclear power plant, improve rail lines, build new roads. I can see it. Some of these industries should not have been privatised in the first place.

Spunk cash on school meals, give pay rises without strings for working reform. and throw even more cash into the NHS without a real reform policy, whilst increasing indirect taxes on working people and burdening tax on SMEs isn't going to give growth, in my opinion.

Time will tell.

And what is "real reform" on healthcare policy? Because more forward thinking preventative healthcare positions - which universal free school meals come under due to reduced childhood malnutrition meaning the knock-on effects are mitigated against over the medium-term - in order to reduce the spending liabilities on easily preventable problems instead of letting problems fester, multiple and take up more hospital resources is what I would class as "real reform", without even mentioning the economic benefits of a better educated and healthier population with a better quality of life (and therefore from that more money to the Exchequer).

If you want to reduce the indirect and direct taxes on working people then you need to look medium-term and long-term as that is how you actually base returns, otherwise the tax burden will continue to go up and up and up without public services being improved to account for that - as has been happening - as you are not trying to fix the actual problems because doing so requires thinking further ahead than 5 years in the future. If something is mooted as saving the taxpayer the sums that universal free school meals are over the medium term then it's short-termist outlooks are an insane reason to block looking it into it or even offering tentative support.

Real world polices for the real world, for real people.

Not hypothetical stuff that takes 20 years to deliver (or not).

Let's start by halving the numbers of managers in the NHS, and improving productivity in the Public Sector, which has flatlined since 2008.

The private sector has embraced technology, modern working practices and become leaner. The public sector has not. Why should my taxes increase, if they can't bring themselves into the modern world? Asking Little Jimmy to eat grass and kernel nuts ain't going to improve an institution that is no longer fit for purpose. Neither is tossing off even more cash at it - without reform.

The real world is that the UK has shit economic growth, stagnant productivity, an increasing tax burden, inadequate public services, indefinite fiscal drag, an aging population and median wages below Slovenia.

You talk about "halving managers" yet we spend less on managers and employ fewer managers already than other European countries - both other Beveridge model countries and Bismarck model countries like Germany - so where is the evidence base that will actually lead to better healthcare outcomes? If anything it suggests the opposite at a cursory glance, and if anything hospital care in this country (the core function of the NHS, social care and primary care are predominantly run as de-facto social insurance systems by private healthcare providers and they both have worse productivity than in hospital care, ironically) is extremely lean compared to healthcare in every other country because medical staff and managers do more within their remit than in other countries who employ more people to do gruntwork. The core way that the NHS needs to be reformed is obvious as it has been pointed out time and time and time again, improve primary care and social care provisions - technology has significantly limited returns compared to stopping people who don't need to go to a hospital from going to a hospital and making sure people that do not need hospital care are able to be discharged to social care, freeing up the time doctors and nurses can spend on actually treating people in hospitals. Preventing the knock-on effects of poor childhood nutrition is key to that as it stops them needing hospital care in the future for something that could have been prevented if we had the foresight to look past the end of our nose. And if you do that you end up having to throw more money at the NHS to stand still, which is the problem we have that needs to be addressed.

You talk about public sector productivity but one of the biggest issues in the energy sector is that the public sector is entirely reliant on high-paid consultancies and consultants to cover gaps in civil service capabilities due to public sector churn and poor wages making being a civil servant unattractive, as well as a dearth of technical expertise because anyone with any technical knowledge on energy systems can get paid significantly more in the private sector or in other countries. Result is any output gains there are swallowed up by increased expenditure on outside expertise - there is essentially zero public sector expertise on how to build a new nuclear plant for example. How does technology magically fix that? And if you don't fix it the private sector is constrained by stupid systems that it has to navigate, whether directly or - in the case of energy as basically everything we do requires power - indirectly.

This is all due to the short-termist attitude that this country is obsessed over. You halve the management staff, forcing hospital staff to cover more functions and spend less time treating people, then what? Doesn't seem like that will actually help healthcare outcomes to me.

As for your assertion that private sector productivity in this country has improved, aside from Covid it has actually tracked with public sector productivity since 2010. That is also shit:

[Image: 20231125_BRC481.png]

Compare the gradient of the lines between 2010 and 2019 for both the private sector and public sector, they're almost identical. The private sector has not carried anywhere near the level of growth that it needs to do, that's why the tax burden is going up. Productivity is also linked to wages, and that's why real wages are flat and why the median income is now below Slovenia, for comparison Slovenia's as a whole was up 17 points from Q1 2010 to Q4 2019 vs the UK's going up by 5 points in that same timeframe:

We simply cannot continue this stupid, short-termist attitude as it is strangling growth and is the core reason the tax burden is going up despite public services not improving. And this myth that the private sector has been carrying growth hasn't tracked since the GFC (at some point you need to admit that something is structurally wrong with how the country is doing stuff, this isn't the 1990s anymore).

Why do they call you "Borin"?

Cut it down to a couple of paragraphs and I'll reply.
Reply
It's not even 1k words and the core point in every one of those paragraphs is contained in the first sentence, with everything else afterwards justifying the first sentence.

Hilariously, you have just asked to "explain why NHS productivity has flatlined" to one person while choosing to ignore me explaining it and what we should do to actually improve productive output (have hospital staff in charge of healthcare spend more time doing their jobs instead of covering management functions and poor service provisions in primary care and social care).
Reply
(10-29-2024, 01:16 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: It's not even 1k words and the core point in every one of those paragraphs is contained in the first sentence, with everything else afterwards justifying the first sentence.

Hilariously, you have just asked to "explain why NHS productivity has flatlined" to one person while choosing to ignore me explaining it and what we should do to actually improve productive output (have hospital staff in charge of healthcare spend more time doing their jobs instead of covering management functions and poor service provisions in primary care and social care).

It's because your posts are way too long. 

Keep It Simple, Stupid.
Reply
(10-29-2024, 01:21 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-29-2024, 01:16 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: It's not even 1k words and the core point in every one of those paragraphs is contained in the first sentence, with everything else afterwards justifying the first sentence.

Hilariously, you have just asked to "explain why NHS productivity has flatlined" to one person while choosing to ignore me explaining it and what we should do to actually improve productive output (have hospital staff in charge of healthcare spend more time doing their jobs instead of covering management functions and poor service provisions in primary care and social care).

It's because your posts are way too long. 

Keep It Simple, Stupid.

Explaining things requires writing more than just asserting stuff with zero evidence for that assertion? You don't say.

It's not a novel, I'm sure you can manage to read that quickly.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 7 Guest(s)