Rachel wants to fiddle the figures
#81
(10-27-2024, 05:19 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The cost of universal free school meals (breakfast and lunch) is fuck all compared to the upsides, the benefits massively outweigh the costs (attention in schools, free childcare support with breakfast clubs, better take up due to universalism, guaranteed nutrition linking to better health outcomes for physical and mental development). I don't even have children and I'm perfectly content for my tax contributions to pay for that. In terms of the social benefit to cost ratio it is massively in favour of the social benefit outcome, a suitable eligibility threshold would already need to cover between 50-70% of all children between the ages for 4 and 16 and at the point you may as well just make it universal as it's going to cost significantly less than making it targeted purely due to the bureaucracy and red tape.

There is objective evidence pointing to the success of schemes in Finland, Sweden and Japan for this.

The cost of universal free school meals is astronomical, because there is nowhere to cook them. It's a massive infrastructure cost - I know my wife works in the school meals industry.

Yet another piece of idealism that hasn't been thought through. Give benefit claimants an extra £5 a week, and tell them to make little Johnny a sandwich.
Reply
#82
Is her name Olive?
Reply
#83
(10-28-2024, 03:29 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Is her name Olive?

And why would that be?
Reply
#84
(10-28-2024, 12:49 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-27-2024, 05:19 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The cost of universal free school meals (breakfast and lunch) is fuck all compared to the upsides, the benefits massively outweigh the costs (attention in schools, free childcare support with breakfast clubs, better take up due to universalism, guaranteed nutrition linking to better health outcomes for physical and mental development). I don't even have children and I'm perfectly content for my tax contributions to pay for that. In terms of the social benefit to cost ratio it is massively in favour of the social benefit outcome, a suitable eligibility threshold would already need to cover between 50-70% of all children between the ages for 4 and 16 and at the point you may as well just make it universal as it's going to cost significantly less than making it targeted purely due to the bureaucracy and red tape.

There is objective evidence pointing to the success of schemes in Finland, Sweden and Japan for this.

In my world parents feed their kids, not the state. 

No wonder the country is so fucked. Like I said, no wonder kids are turning up at reception not having been toilet trained, or taught to eat with a knife and fork. You know, the basics of parenting.

Your world isn't the real world, comparing universal free school meals with teaching kids how to use a knife and fork or toilet train them is honestly kind of pathetic when schools already serve hot dinners and run breakfast clubs. Your entire argument on this is the same argument dickheads 150 years ago were making in opposition to universal education. Did you know kids were the group with the highest rates of absolute poverty at 25% in the UK (1-in-4)? Are you aware that the eligibility criteria hasn't changed in 14 years? You whingeing about "parental responsibility" isn't a refute of the social problem that needs to be solved, nor is it a refute of the benefits from implementing it and the empirical and rational analyses that outline those benefits.

(10-28-2024, 01:25 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: The cost of universal free school meals is astronomical, because there is nowhere to cook them. It's a massive infrastructure cost - I know my wife works in the school meals industry.

Yet another piece of idealism that hasn't been thought through. Give benefit claimants an extra £5 a week, and tell them to make little Johnny a sandwich.

If Japan, Finland and Sweden can manage it I'm sure we will be able to find a way - especially when 1 cost-benefit analysis for universal free school meals (PwC) pointed to a £25bn net benefit over 20 years (which is over double the Implementation cost, a 200% return on investment over 20 years). It's not exactly trying to demonstrate cold fusion, is it?
Reply
#85
(10-28-2024, 03:39 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-28-2024, 12:49 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-27-2024, 05:19 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The cost of universal free school meals (breakfast and lunch) is fuck all compared to the upsides, the benefits massively outweigh the costs (attention in schools, free childcare support with breakfast clubs, better take up due to universalism, guaranteed nutrition linking to better health outcomes for physical and mental development). I don't even have children and I'm perfectly content for my tax contributions to pay for that. In terms of the social benefit to cost ratio it is massively in favour of the social benefit outcome, a suitable eligibility threshold would already need to cover between 50-70% of all children between the ages for 4 and 16 and at the point you may as well just make it universal as it's going to cost significantly less than making it targeted purely due to the bureaucracy and red tape.

There is objective evidence pointing to the success of schemes in Finland, Sweden and Japan for this.

In my world parents feed their kids, not the state. 

No wonder the country is so fucked. Like I said, no wonder kids are turning up at reception not having been toilet trained, or taught to eat with a knife and fork. You know, the basics of parenting.

Your world isn't the real world, comparing universal free school meals with teaching kids how to use a knife and fork or toilet train them is honestly kind of pathetic when schools already serve hot dinners and run breakfast clubs. Your entire argument on this is the same argument dickheads 150 years ago were making in opposition to universal education. Did you know kids were the group with the highest rates of absolute poverty at 25% in the UK (1-in-4)? Are you aware that the eligibility criteria hasn't changed in 14 years? You whingeing about "parental responsibility" isn't a refute of the social problem that needs to be solved, nor is it a refute of the benefits from implementing it and the empirical and rational analyses that outline those benefits.

(10-28-2024, 01:25 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: The cost of universal free school meals is astronomical, because there is nowhere to cook them. It's a massive infrastructure cost - I know my wife works in the school meals industry.

Yet another piece of idealism that hasn't been thought through. Give benefit claimants an extra £5 a week, and tell them to make little Johnny a sandwich.

If Japan, Finland and Sweden can manage it I'm sure we will be able to find a way - especially when 1 cost-benefit analysis for universal free school meals (PwC) pointed to a £25bn net benefit over 20 years (which is over double the Implementation cost, a 200% return on investment over 20 years). It's not exactly trying to demonstrate cold fusion, is it?

Here we go again. A 20 year cost benefit analysis. You don't understand the difference between profit and cash. The amount of cash it would cost to implement this infrastructure would be astronomical - and as people keep pointing out there are plenty of projects that need cash investment at the moment, some of which might just lead to economic growth. Free school meals won't. Free school meals will not generate cash, but PwC say it will give a return on Core Benefits. It's all "Wooden Dollars".

It's a bit like Putin announcing an increase in GDP in his war economy, as his newly built tanks are blown up.
Reply
#86
(10-28-2024, 03:39 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Your world isn't the real world, comparing universal free school meals with teaching kids how to use a knife and fork or toilet train them is honestly kind of pathetic when schools already serve hot dinners and run breakfast clubs. Your entire argument on this is the same argument dickheads 150 years ago were making in opposition to universal education. Did you know kids were the group with the highest rates of absolute poverty at 25% in the UK (1-in-4)? Are you aware that the eligibility criteria hasn't changed in 14 years? You whingeing about "parental responsibility" isn't a refute of the social problem that needs to be solved, nor is it a refute of the benefits from implementing it and the empirical and rational analyses that outline those benefits.

Of course it's the same. Targeted early years intervention would be much more valuable than free sausage and chips in so many ways.

Labour could've done this with Sure Start had it not become a hub for self selecting middle class white women. Multi agency targeted early years intervention is hard, the state isn't prepared to do it. Easier to bung even more freebies to people who don't need them.
Reply
#87
(10-28-2024, 03:39 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-28-2024, 03:29 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Is her name Olive?

And why would that be?

It’s a food name and the cook from the Bash Street Kids so seemed likely
Reply
#88
(10-28-2024, 03:44 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-28-2024, 01:25 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: The cost of universal free school meals is astronomical, because there is nowhere to cook them. It's a massive infrastructure cost - I know my wife works in the school meals industry.

Yet another piece of idealism that hasn't been thought through. Give benefit claimants an extra £5 a week, and tell them to make little Johnny a sandwich.

If Japan, Finland and Sweden can manage it I'm sure we will be able to find a way - especially when 1 cost-benefit analysis for universal free school meals (PwC) pointed to a £25bn net benefit over 20 years (which is over double the Implementation cost, a 200% return on investment over 20 years). It's not exactly trying to demonstrate cold fusion, is it?


Here we go again. A 20 year cost benefit analysis. You don't understand the difference between profit and cash. The amount of cash it would cost to implement this infrastructure would be astronomical - and as people keep pointing out there are plenty of projects that need cash investment at the moment, some of which might just lead to economic growth. Free school meals won't. Free school meals will not generate cash, but PwC say it will give a return on Core Benefits. It's all "Wooden Dollars".

It's a bit like Putin announcing an increase in GDP in his war economy, as his newly built tanks are blown up.

It's not about "generating cash", it's about economic returns through better learning outcomes at school leading to greater lifetime contributions and reduced spending on healthcare due to better nutritional care.

I hate the immediate-termist outlook that you are repeating, all it does is multiply problems.
Reply
#89
Odd that people that think we need to increase attendance wouldn’t see the benefit of better nutrition reducing sickness absence. I guess that’s the limitation of thinking in quantitative terms only.

I always feel sorry for people that have such limited linear thought processes.
Reply
#90
(10-28-2024, 05:02 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-28-2024, 03:39 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Your world isn't the real world, comparing universal free school meals with teaching kids how to use a knife and fork or toilet train them is honestly kind of pathetic when schools already serve hot dinners and run breakfast clubs. Your entire argument on this is the same argument dickheads 150 years ago were making in opposition to universal education. Did you know kids were the group with the highest rates of absolute poverty at 25% in the UK (1-in-4)? Are you aware that the eligibility criteria hasn't changed in 14 years? You whingeing about "parental responsibility" isn't a refute of the social problem that needs to be solved, nor is it a refute of the benefits from implementing it and the empirical and rational analyses that outline those benefits.

Of course it's the same. Targeted early years intervention would be much more valuable than free sausage and chips in so many ways.

Labour could've done this with Sure Start had it not become a hub for self selecting middle class white women. Multi agency targeted early years intervention is hard, the state isn't prepared to do it. Easier to bung even more freebies to people who don't need them.

Sausage and chips? You are deliberately misconstruing the point. It isn't the 1950s anymore, nutritional standards are better than meat, two veg and chocolate concrete. I suggest you look at what they actually serve the kids in the countries with universal free school meals.

Targeted early-years intervention to help support parents is completely unrelated, yet again you have decided to completely avoid refuting any of the benefits so you can talk about something that has nowt to do with free school meals. Free school meals is completely unrelated to supporting parents to help teach kids crucial life skills at key times in their children's developments.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 5 Guest(s)