Rachel wants to fiddle the figures
(10-28-2024, 09:32 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-28-2024, 05:20 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-28-2024, 03:44 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-28-2024, 01:25 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: The cost of universal free school meals is astronomical, because there is nowhere to cook them. It's a massive infrastructure cost - I know my wife works in the school meals industry.

Yet another piece of idealism that hasn't been thought through. Give benefit claimants an extra £5 a week, and tell them to make little Johnny a sandwich.

If Japan, Finland and Sweden can manage it I'm sure we will be able to find a way - especially when 1 cost-benefit analysis for universal free school meals (PwC) pointed to a £25bn net benefit over 20 years (which is over double the Implementation cost, a 200% return on investment over 20 years). It's not exactly trying to demonstrate cold fusion, is it?


Here we go again. A 20 year cost benefit analysis. You don't understand the difference between profit and cash. The amount of cash it would cost to implement this infrastructure would be astronomical - and as people keep pointing out there are plenty of projects that need cash investment at the moment, some of which might just lead to economic growth. Free school meals won't. Free school meals will not generate cash, but PwC say it will give a return on Core Benefits. It's all "Wooden Dollars".

It's a bit like Putin announcing an increase in GDP in his war economy, as his newly built tanks are blown up.

It's not about "generating cash", it's about economic returns through better learning outcomes at school leading to greater lifetime contributions and reduced spending on healthcare due to better nutritional care.

I hate the immediate-termist outlook that you are repeating, all it does is multiply problems.

Oh I see. Spunk billions today for intangible benefits in a decade or two.

How exactly are increased lifetime contributions as a result of better educational attainment and reduced spending on healthcare due to better childhood nutrition intangible?

And two decades is really not that long in the future, it's the exact sort of timeframe this country should be focusing policy outcomes on instead of the moronic short-termist attitude that has resulted in stagnant productivity and half the country earning less than they would in Slovenia.
Reply
“Intangible”

See previous point about those that can only think in straight lines
Reply
[Image: GbAgv4HXQAAyXxh?format=jpg&name=small]

OK, this is pretty funny
Reply
(10-28-2024, 09:38 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-28-2024, 09:32 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-28-2024, 05:20 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-28-2024, 03:44 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-28-2024, 01:25 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: The cost of universal free school meals is astronomical, because there is nowhere to cook them. It's a massive infrastructure cost - I know my wife works in the school meals industry.

Yet another piece of idealism that hasn't been thought through. Give benefit claimants an extra £5 a week, and tell them to make little Johnny a sandwich.

If Japan, Finland and Sweden can manage it I'm sure we will be able to find a way - especially when 1 cost-benefit analysis for universal free school meals (PwC) pointed to a £25bn net benefit over 20 years (which is over double the Implementation cost, a 200% return on investment over 20 years). It's not exactly trying to demonstrate cold fusion, is it?


Here we go again. A 20 year cost benefit analysis. You don't understand the difference between profit and cash. The amount of cash it would cost to implement this infrastructure would be astronomical - and as people keep pointing out there are plenty of projects that need cash investment at the moment, some of which might just lead to economic growth. Free school meals won't. Free school meals will not generate cash, but PwC say it will give a return on Core Benefits. It's all "Wooden Dollars".

It's a bit like Putin announcing an increase in GDP in his war economy, as his newly built tanks are blown up.

It's not about "generating cash", it's about economic returns through better learning outcomes at school leading to greater lifetime contributions and reduced spending on healthcare due to better nutritional care.

I hate the immediate-termist outlook that you are repeating, all it does is multiply problems.

Oh I see. Spunk billions today for intangible benefits in a decade or two.

How exactly are increased lifetime contributions as a result of better educational attainment and reduced spending on healthcare due to better childhood nutrition intangible?

And two decades is really not that long in the future, it's the exact sort of timeframe this country should be focusing policy outcomes on instead of the moronic short-termist attitude that has resulted in stagnant productivity and half the country earning less than they would in Slovenia.

Because improvement costs cash now, and the gilt market that funds it is trembling at the knees, look at the front page of Tuesday's FT.

You simply can't just chuck cash into a project and amortise the cost over 20 years citing "benefits".

The cash is now, the cost is now. It is costing the UK to invest, and Gilts will reflect this. The markets are driven by pure profit, not idealism.
Reply
The 10y gilt market lo9ks, to me, to be with standard deviation. I've looked at it over a 1 month and 1 year period and that's my conclusion. I'll ask again, what markets are spooked? Will they stop being spooked on the 31st and will it be fireworks afterwards?

https://markets.ft.com/data/bonds/tearsh...y?s=UK10YG
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
(10-28-2024, 08:49 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Nope. It improves attendance, well-being, focus, health and provides a steady foundation for children of one of the worlds wealthiest countries to access a basic right. Food.

You’re getting angry over kids being fed.

No, I’m not. I’m getting angry about the idea that feeding kids is not basic fucking parenting.
Reply
What’s the issue with a back up plan in life?

Do you live in some sort of ideological utopia?

Mind you, when I think of your conviction of how Brexit would play out….
Reply
I think you have to acknowledge there are some awful parents, some parents that struggle and some that muddle through. At some point they all need help from the state, how much or how little can depend very much on circumstances. Is it worth trying to set up another layer of bureaucracy to deal with arbitrary means testing for warm meals for children?

I resent your larger than life mate and others Proth having subsidised meals and drinks in the House of Commons, let’s start with the easy wins like taking those away rather than meals for kids.

Btw making excuses for kids not being able to go to the toilet, brush teeth, form sentences by the time they get to school is abdicating the responsibility of the parents and should not be meekly accepted or tolerated, but you can’t punish the kids for the failures of their parents.
Reply
I will soon find out whether I am a fat cat or a hard worker.
Reply
(10-29-2024, 05:06 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: The 10y gilt market lo9ks, to me, to be with standard deviation. I've looked at it over a 1 month and 1 year period and that's my conclusion. I'll ask again, what markets are spooked? Will they stop being spooked on the 31st and will it be fireworks afterwards?

https://markets.ft.com/data/bonds/tearsh...y?s=UK10YG


Early Sept it dropped to c3.80% on the back of better economic data, and expectations of interest rate cuts. Since then the rise has been upwards by c50bps, based on market fears of the budget (despite better than expected inflation figures and possible Base rate reductions in November and December). This is whilst USA and European markets reduce further. If the budget is badly received 10 year and 5 year gilts will rise. This is a massive gamble, and the much vaunted investment has to work and deliver results.

Summarised in the FT https://www.ft.com/content/432166d7-d0c4...dc40021c4f
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 12 Guest(s)