Team Balance
#21
I'm not a stats dude, so this is just my perception, but it seems to me, we concede far more when taking a cautious approach than we do when being more adventurous.
The more we try to defend and contain, the worse we become in terms of passing, tackling, winning headers etc. and the errors creep in.

Yesterday was a prime example. I have no doubt that the last message in the players ears before stepping onto the pitch was keep it tight and contain for the first 15. Well that worked well, we were literally, all over the shop from the first whistle.

Second half, we came out with intent and, guess what, didn't concede.

I think Carlos needs to back the players a bit more and resort to a new strategy.......

Attack, attack, attack attack attack  Smile
Reply
#22
(09-21-2023, 08:41 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(09-21-2023, 07:02 AM)wbamitch Wrote: I thought the subs were too negative, especially Chalobah for Wallace. Watford looked poor at the back and thought we could’ve nicked it. We made a positive change in giving Sarmiento 30+ minutes but then proceeded to take off the attacking players around him. A good point in isolation but the away record in general is very poor

Have you seen our defense? If we'd gone attacking for the win, it could've ended up a 5-5 pinball game. Both teams still had two good chances to win it.

I wasn’t suggesting taking defenders off for attackers but I don’t think Chalobah for Wallace was needed. We finished the game with a back 5 and 3 DMs
Reply
#23
(09-21-2023, 08:48 AM)wbamitch Wrote:
(09-21-2023, 08:41 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(09-21-2023, 07:02 AM)wbamitch Wrote: I thought the subs were too negative, especially Chalobah for Wallace. Watford looked poor at the back and thought we could’ve nicked it. We made a positive change in giving Sarmiento 30+ minutes but then proceeded to take off the attacking players around him. A good point in isolation but the away record in general is very poor

Have you seen our defense? If we'd gone attacking for the win, it could've ended up a 5-5 pinball game. Both teams still had two good chances to win it.

I wasn’t suggesting taking defenders off for attackers but I don’t think Chalobah for Wallace was needed. We finished the game with a back 5 and 3 DMs

That's fair. I was also surprised by the sub, but thought it was at least okay. Chucking Grady on instead my have worked, hopefully we see it soon against other opposition.
Reply
#24
(09-21-2023, 08:46 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: I'm not a stats dude, so this is just my perception, but it seems to me, we concede far more when taking a cautious approach than we do when being more adventurous.
The more we try to defend and contain, the worse we become in terms of passing, tackling, winning headers etc. and the errors creep in.

Yesterday was a prime example. I have no doubt that the last message in the players ears before stepping onto the pitch was keep it tight and contain for the first 15. Well that worked well, we were literally, all over the shop from the first whistle.

Second half, we came out with intent and, guess what, didn't concede.

I think Carlos needs to back the players a bit more and resort to a new strategy.......

Attack, attack, attack attack attack  Smile

Don't know what he said to them before the game last night or at Bristol but after the Bristol match he pretty much said attack is the best form of defence
Reply
#25
(09-21-2023, 09:06 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(09-21-2023, 08:48 AM)wbamitch Wrote:
(09-21-2023, 08:41 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(09-21-2023, 07:02 AM)wbamitch Wrote: I thought the subs were too negative, especially Chalobah for Wallace. Watford looked poor at the back and thought we could’ve nicked it. We made a positive change in giving Sarmiento 30+ minutes but then proceeded to take off the attacking players around him. A good point in isolation but the away record in general is very poor

Have you seen our defense? If we'd gone attacking for the win, it could've ended up a 5-5 pinball game. Both teams still had two good chances to win it.

I wasn’t suggesting taking defenders off for attackers but I don’t think Chalobah for Wallace was needed. We finished the game with a back 5 and 3 DMs

That's fair. I was also surprised by the sub, but thought it was at least okay. Chucking Grady on instead my have worked, hopefully we see it soon against other opposition.

I agree with you AnelkasBeard and wbamitch. 

We were getting hammered down the left so bringing on Townsend made sense, to me at least. In hindsight he should/could have subbed Wallace for Grady to keep the attacking threat, but at 75 mins its 'ommering it down with rain, the way the first 25 mins went, 1 point away looks good and is enticing, bringing on Chalobah to break up play and come home with a point also makes sense.
Reply
#26
(09-21-2023, 08:44 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(09-21-2023, 07:58 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: This whole thread is just to show we know just as much about tactics as those Watford forum bastards isn't it?

Dunno how we're meant to keep up, Arteta said after a game the other week that he used 35 formations in 90 minutes.

That made me laugh as I distinctly remember somebody on here saying no manager has a Plan B
Reply
#27
(09-21-2023, 08:30 PM)Brandywell Wrote:
(09-21-2023, 08:44 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(09-21-2023, 07:58 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: This whole thread is just to show we know just as much about tactics as those Watford forum bastards isn't it?

Dunno how we're meant to keep up, Arteta said after a game the other week that he used 35 formations in 90 minutes.

That made me laugh as I distinctly remember somebody on here saying no manager has a Plan B

Noone said that.

A few mentioned how some managers just don't, and even more so recently. Klopp never has for example, Plan B is Plan A with different players.

I think we know already CC isn't one of these managers.
Reply
#28
(09-20-2023, 09:11 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I posted in the match Fred a few times about this but thought it was worth its own Fred. 

The balance of our team is so far off, and it's what is putting us under pressure. I am disregarding formations and shape, as that's not the issue.

Today's XI:

Palmer (Defensive)
Furlong (Defensive)
Ajayi (Defensive)
Kipre (Defensive)
Pieters (Defensive)
Phillips (Transitional/Attacking) 
Okay (Defensive)
Molumby (Transitional)
Swift (Transitional/Attacking)
Wallace (Attacking)
BTA (Attacking) 

So I make it, primarily (with Swift and Phillips being abit of both);
Defensive - 6
Transitional - 3
Attacking - 2

After the subs:

Palmer (Defensive)
Furlong (Defensive)
Ajayi (Defensive)
Kipre (Defensive)
Pieters (Defensive)
Townsend (Defensive)
Mowatt (Transitional)
Okay (Defensive)
Chalobah (Defensive/Transitional)
Sarmiento (Attacking)
BTS (Attacking)

So, primarily, we ended with;
Defensive - 8
Transitional - 1
Attacking - 2

Now for me you should never have more than 5 defensive players on the pitch. 5 should be when holding onto a game. On any normal occasion 4 is about right. The main change should be between the numbers of transitional and attacking players. 

We are getting the balance wrong. Full stop.

I’m just amazed Phillips, Moulumby, Swift, Mowatt and Chalobah had all been to the Tavistock Clinic and this is the first I’m reading about it.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: