Team Balance
#1
I posted in the match Fred a few times about this but thought it was worth its own Fred. 

The balance of our team is so far off, and it's what is putting us under pressure. I am disregarding formations and shape, as that's not the issue.

Today's XI:

Palmer (Defensive)
Furlong (Defensive)
Ajayi (Defensive)
Kipre (Defensive)
Pieters (Defensive)
Phillips (Transitional/Attacking) 
Okay (Defensive)
Molumby (Transitional)
Swift (Transitional/Attacking)
Wallace (Attacking)
BTA (Attacking) 

So I make it, primarily (with Swift and Phillips being abit of both);
Defensive - 6
Transitional - 3
Attacking - 2

After the subs:

Palmer (Defensive)
Furlong (Defensive)
Ajayi (Defensive)
Kipre (Defensive)
Pieters (Defensive)
Townsend (Defensive)
Mowatt (Transitional)
Okay (Defensive)
Chalobah (Defensive/Transitional)
Sarmiento (Attacking)
BTS (Attacking)

So, primarily, we ended with;
Defensive - 8
Transitional - 1
Attacking - 2

Now for me you should never have more than 5 defensive players on the pitch. 5 should be when holding onto a game. On any normal occasion 4 is about right. The main change should be between the numbers of transitional and attacking players. 

We are getting the balance wrong. Full stop.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#2
I'm not sure it's that simple. Or right, you missed Townsend off! In those conditions we were wise not to overplay at the back and not to over commit going forward. We gave them a game, I thought.
Reply
#3
(09-20-2023, 09:15 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I'm not sure it's that simple. Or right, you missed Townsend off!  In those conditions we were wise not to overplay at the back and not to over commit going forward. We gave them a game, I thought.

I noticed so added him on. It makes it worse though  Big Grin

No it is more nuanced in reality. But simply speaking it explains why we struggle to move the ball through the pitch whilst getting enough runners into advanced positions. 

It ay rocket science.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#4
(09-20-2023, 09:16 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(09-20-2023, 09:15 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I'm not sure it's that simple. Or right, you missed Townsend off!  In those conditions we were wise not to overplay at the back and not to over commit going forward. We gave them a game, I thought.

I noticed so added him on. It makes it worse though  Big Grin

No it is more nuanced in reality. But simply speaking it explains why we struggle to move the ball through the pitch whilst getting enough runners into advanced positions. 

It ay rocket science.
In those conditions, sounded biblical at times give the players some credit. ?
Reply
#5
(09-20-2023, 09:11 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Now for me you should never have more than 5 defensive players on the pitch. 5 should be when holding onto a game. On any normal occasion 4 is about right. The main change should be between the numbers of transitional and attacking players. 

We are getting the balance wrong. Full stop.

As you include the goalkeeper as one of your defensive players, 4 as normal may be a bit light! Also Townsend played in exactly the same position as Phillips and offered more going forward. That switch did not make us more defensive - just more effective.
Reply
#6
(09-20-2023, 09:16 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(09-20-2023, 09:15 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I'm not sure it's that simple. Or right, you missed Townsend off!  In those conditions we were wise not to overplay at the back and not to over commit going forward. We gave them a game, I thought.

I noticed so added him on. It makes it worse though  Big Grin

No it is more nuanced in reality. But simply speaking it explains why we struggle to move the ball through the pitch whilst getting enough runners into advanced positions. 

It ay rocket science.

It sure isn’t rocket science because by and large that has far fewer variables than 11 human beings. The very fact that so many of our players are labelled useless one minute only to do something to completely contradict the notion a few moments later (I.e.Wallace’s goal) is testament to that fact. Our problem is not playing formations or positions but massive inconsistencies in performance. In reality none of us have a clue which of this team will turn up with very few exceptions. Luckily we have a coach that seems to be able to drag some kind of results so far when everything else about the club appears to be going to shit. Losing Maja is a … er Maja blow. CC possibly could have fought harder to find another forward but sadly the club was always going to depend on freebies and loans. So far I think results if not necessarily performances have been miraculous.
Reply
#7
(09-20-2023, 09:16 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(09-20-2023, 09:15 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I'm not sure it's that simple. Or right, you missed Townsend off!  In those conditions we were wise not to overplay at the back and not to over commit going forward. We gave them a game, I thought.

I noticed so added him on. It makes it worse though  Big Grin

No it is more nuanced in reality. But simply speaking it explains why we struggle to move the ball through the pitch whilst getting enough runners into advanced positions. 

It ay rocket science.

No but by those definitions, Townsend was transitional, as was Chalobah. I think with a tiring BTA and Jeremy in a seemingly free attacking role, we had to be switched on and aware of their attack. If we had a big old fashioned no.9 I think it would be a different story but without someone planted in their half dragging play 20 yards upfield, we have to beware of getting caught out at the back.
Reply
#8
(09-20-2023, 09:28 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(09-20-2023, 09:16 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(09-20-2023, 09:15 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I'm not sure it's that simple. Or right, you missed Townsend off!  In those conditions we were wise not to overplay at the back and not to over commit going forward. We gave them a game, I thought.

I noticed so added him on. It makes it worse though  Big Grin

No it is more nuanced in reality. But simply speaking it explains why we struggle to move the ball through the pitch whilst getting enough runners into advanced positions. 

It ay rocket science.

No but by those definitions, Townsend was transitional, as was Chalobah. I think with a tiring BTA and Jeremy in a seemingly free attacking role, we had to be switched on and aware of their attack. If we had a big old fashioned no.9 I think it would be a different story but without someone planted in their half dragging play 20 yards upfield, we have to beware of getting caught out at the back.

Townsend was brought on the sure up the left hand side to allow Sarmiento to roam. He was a defensive sub. He only started pushing on when Chalobah came on to add more bite to the midfield. 

So either way we never got the attacking balance right. 

At no point during the game did we have enough of a goal threat, we didn't cause them any concerns in terms of 3rd man, attacking runs. 

It shows in the stats. We have very few shots, very few dribbles and low xG. It all points towards not committing enough men forward or dominating the ball enough on transition.

(09-20-2023, 09:25 PM)Everything Zin Wrote:
(09-20-2023, 09:11 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Now for me you should never have more than 5 defensive players on the pitch. 5 should be when holding onto a game. On any normal occasion 4 is about right. The main change should be between the numbers of transitional and attacking players. 

We are getting the balance wrong. Full stop.

As you include the goalkeeper as one of your defensive players, 4 as normal may be a bit light! Also Townsend played in exactly the same position as Phillips and offered more going forward. That switch did not make us more defensive - just more effective.

I don't think it is. Traditionally you had a GK, 2 CBs and a holding midfielder. Yes now it's more nuanced. As we have more fluidity in the game which is grand. So CBs can be Transitional players, Wingers can be defensive. Full backs can be attacking. Jesus, even GKs are now being discussed in tactical discussions. 

But across the board we have too many players with defensive characteristics. And it shows.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#9
(09-20-2023, 09:36 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(09-20-2023, 09:28 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(09-20-2023, 09:16 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(09-20-2023, 09:15 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I'm not sure it's that simple. Or right, you missed Townsend off!  In those conditions we were wise not to overplay at the back and not to over commit going forward. We gave them a game, I thought.

I noticed so added him on. It makes it worse though  Big Grin

No it is more nuanced in reality. But simply speaking it explains why we struggle to move the ball through the pitch whilst getting enough runners into advanced positions. 

It ay rocket science.

No but by those definitions, Townsend was transitional, as was Chalobah. I think with a tiring BTA and Jeremy in a seemingly free attacking role, we had to be switched on and aware of their attack. If we had a big old fashioned no.9 I think it would be a different story but without someone planted in their half dragging play 20 yards upfield, we have to beware of getting caught out at the back.

Townsend was brought on the sure up the left hand side to allow Sarmiento to roam. He was a defensive sub. He only started pushing on when Chalobah came on to add more bite to the midfield. 

So either way we never got the attacking balance right. 

At no point during the game did we have enough of a goal threat, we didn't cause them any concerns in terms of 3rd man, attacking runs. 

It shows in the stats. We have very few shots, very few dribbles and low xG. It all points towards not committing enough men forward or dominating the ball enough on transition.

(09-20-2023, 09:25 PM)Everything Zin Wrote:
(09-20-2023, 09:11 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Now for me you should never have more than 5 defensive players on the pitch. 5 should be when holding onto a game. On any normal occasion 4 is about right. The main change should be between the numbers of transitional and attacking players. 

We are getting the balance wrong. Full stop.

As you include the goalkeeper as one of your defensive players, 4 as normal may be a bit light! Also Townsend played in exactly the same position as Phillips and offered more going forward. That switch did not make us more defensive - just more effective.

I don't think it is. Traditionally you had a GK, 2 CBs and a holding midfielder. Yes now it's more nuanced. As we have more fluidity in the game which is grand. So CBs can be Transitional players, Wingers can be defensive. Full backs can be attacking. Jesus, even GKs are now being discussed in tactical discussions. 

But across the board we have too many players with defensive characteristics. And it shows.
Remember, we only have one fit no.9.
Reply
#10
(09-20-2023, 09:45 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Remember, we only have one fit no.9.

It's not about strikers. It's about the characteristics of players throughout the team.

For example;

Palmer
Furlong Kipre Ajayi
Pipa Molumby Mowatt Phillips
Grady Swift Sarmiento

Is much more offensive without a striker (D4, T3, A4) than...

Palmer
Ajayi Kipre Pieters
Furlong Molumby Okay Phillips
Wallace BTA Swift

(D6, T2, A3)
"IMO of course..."
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: