Team Balance
#11
I think some of the players coming on are meant to step into transitional or attacking roles, but we simply don't have that many players like that, so many of our squad are defensive by nature.
Reply
#12
(09-20-2023, 10:00 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I think some of the players coming on are meant to step into transitional or attacking roles, but we simply don't have that many players like that, so many of our squad are defensive by nature.

I dunno Birdy. If he wanted to add more transition or offensive players today he could have. 

As stated, his original 3 subs made us more compact and Defensive as a unit, obviously trying to protect Sarmiento and hoping he did something brilliant. 

Then he settled for the point by further tightening up the midfield with the Chalobah Sub.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#13
(09-20-2023, 09:45 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(09-20-2023, 09:36 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(09-20-2023, 09:28 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(09-20-2023, 09:16 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(09-20-2023, 09:15 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I'm not sure it's that simple. Or right, you missed Townsend off!  In those conditions we were wise not to overplay at the back and not to over commit going forward. We gave them a game, I thought.

I noticed so added him on. It makes it worse though  Big Grin

No it is more nuanced in reality. But simply speaking it explains why we struggle to move the ball through the pitch whilst getting enough runners into advanced positions. 

It ay rocket science.

No but by those definitions, Townsend was transitional, as was Chalobah. I think with a tiring BTA and Jeremy in a seemingly free attacking role, we had to be switched on and aware of their attack. If we had a big old fashioned no.9 I think it would be a different story but without someone planted in their half dragging play 20 yards upfield, we have to beware of getting caught out at the back.

Townsend was brought on the sure up the left hand side to allow Sarmiento to roam. He was a defensive sub. He only started pushing on when Chalobah came on to add more bite to the midfield. 

So either way we never got the attacking balance right. 

At no point during the game did we have enough of a goal threat, we didn't cause them any concerns in terms of 3rd man, attacking runs. 

It shows in the stats. We have very few shots, very few dribbles and low xG. It all points towards not committing enough men forward or dominating the ball enough on transition.

(09-20-2023, 09:25 PM)Everything Zin Wrote:
(09-20-2023, 09:11 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Now for me you should never have more than 5 defensive players on the pitch. 5 should be when holding onto a game. On any normal occasion 4 is about right. The main change should be between the numbers of transitional and attacking players. 

We are getting the balance wrong. Full stop.

As you include the goalkeeper as one of your defensive players, 4 as normal may be a bit light! Also Townsend played in exactly the same position as Phillips and offered more going forward. That switch did not make us more defensive - just more effective.

I don't think it is. Traditionally you had a GK, 2 CBs and a holding midfielder. Yes now it's more nuanced. As we have more fluidity in the game which is grand. So CBs can be Transitional players, Wingers can be defensive. Full backs can be attacking. Jesus, even GKs are now being discussed in tactical discussions. 

But across the board we have too many players with defensive characteristics. And it shows.
Remember, we only have one fit no.9.

This +.  We saw the difference Maja made at Brizzle in that last twenty minutes. How he was able to take us up the pitch and link play. This was a view of how CC wants to set up.   I think one of the biggest flaws in this manager is that he doesnt moan and whinge about his squad or injuries, he just seems to crack on.
Reply
#14
I thought the subs were too negative, especially Chalobah for Wallace. Watford looked poor at the back and thought we could’ve nicked it. We made a positive change in giving Sarmiento 30+ minutes but then proceeded to take off the attacking players around him. A good point in isolation but the away record in general is very poor
Reply
#15
(09-21-2023, 07:02 AM)wbamitch Wrote: I thought the subs were too negative, especially Chalobah for Wallace. Watford looked poor at the back and thought we could’ve nicked it. We made a positive change in giving Sarmiento 30+ minutes but then proceeded to take off the attacking players around him. A good point in isolation but the away record in general is very poor

And yet I thought we were the team in the last 20 mins, more likely to win it.
Reply
#16
Carlos is cautious but negative is unfair IMO. He is restricted by the players that are available. Our performances are strongly linked to how the opposition are set up. Ignoring this when deciding if we are negative is a mistake. 
We would all love to see us steam forward and smash the opposition every game, but so would everyone.
Reply
#17
Let us not forget that we have lost one of the best defenders in the Champ in Dara. I had a look at last season a few weeks back (and posted it somewhere) that showed a massive difference in goals conceded with and without Dara. Not being able to sign a replacement has hamstrung Carlos a bit, and i reckon he's just being cautious. We concede enough as it is, imagine having one less defensive player on the pitch? It would be carnage.
Reply
#18
This whole thread is just to show we know just as much about tactics as those Watford forum bastards isn't it?
Reply
#19
(09-21-2023, 07:02 AM)wbamitch Wrote: I thought the subs were too negative, especially Chalobah for Wallace. Watford looked poor at the back and thought we could’ve nicked it. We made a positive change in giving Sarmiento 30+ minutes but then proceeded to take off the attacking players around him. A good point in isolation but the away record in general is very poor

Have you seen our defense? If we'd gone attacking for the win, it could've ended up a 5-5 pinball game. Both teams still had two good chances to win it.
Reply
#20
(09-21-2023, 07:58 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: This whole thread is just to show we know just as much about tactics as those Watford forum bastards isn't it?

Dunno how we're meant to keep up, Arteta said after a game the other week that he used 35 formations in 90 minutes.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: