The what we learnt tonight thread
#51
(10-02-2019, 01:12 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Did we really learn anything?

We came away to a very good team, who beat us. It really is that simple. Let's move on to Cardiff, a game we should win.

(10-02-2019, 08:33 AM)brada_wba Wrote: HRK is awful. Just play Austin until he hits the goals. He's proven.

 
I'm risking having 'tedious idiot' childishly brandished against me again here, but HRK’s performance was no better or worse (HRK was poor, don’t get me wrong) than Austin's performance against QPR.

It’s amazing the amount of stick HRK gets, usually he improves us as a team, has put in some great performances for us (Leeds at home last year, particularly) and works his nuts off. Yes he lacks quality a lot of the time, and is obviously limited, but there does seem to be an agenda against him, when other players are just as bad at times, if not worse.

I'd personally give Zohore a run in the side, he looks like a good hold up player to me, who will cause problems. Or even give Edwards a try. Hopefully Austin finds fitness ASAP, but he looks a long way off being fully fit, to me.

HRK is seemingly better as an impact sub, to give us renewed energy up front. I don’t think he should be starting games.

But there is not 'agenda' against him, it's based on empirical evidence and observation.  His performances have been consistently poor since his arrival and the statistics back that up.

9 goals in 74 for us and 5 in 44 for Wales.  That really isn't good enough, regardless of what anyone thinks of his work ethic or hold up play (which in my opinion is substandard).
Reply
#52
(10-02-2019, 01:36 PM)WWHO Wrote:
(10-02-2019, 01:12 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Did we really learn anything?

We came away to a very good team, who beat us. It really is that simple. Let's move on to Cardiff, a game we should win.

(10-02-2019, 08:33 AM)brada_wba Wrote: HRK is awful. Just play Austin until he hits the goals. He's proven.

 
I'm risking having 'tedious idiot' childishly brandished against me again here, but HRK’s performance was no better or worse (HRK was poor, don’t get me wrong) than Austin's performance against QPR.

It’s amazing the amount of stick HRK gets, usually he improves us as a team, has put in some great performances for us (Leeds at home last year, particularly) and works his nuts off. Yes he lacks quality a lot of the time, and is obviously limited, but there does seem to be an agenda against him, when other players are just as bad at times, if not worse.

I'd personally give Zohore a run in the side, he looks like a good hold up player to me, who will cause problems. Or even give Edwards a try. Hopefully Austin finds fitness ASAP, but he looks a long way off being fully fit, to me.

HRK is seemingly better as an impact sub, to give us renewed energy up front. I don’t think he should be starting games.

But there is not 'agenda' against him, it's based on empirical evidence and observation.  His performances have been consistently poor since his arrival and the statistics back that up.

9 goals in 74 for us and 5 in 44 for Wales.  That really isn't good enough, regardless of what anyone thinks of his work ethic or hold up play (which in my opinion is substandard).

Hallelujah - common sense. He runs around a lot, sometimes works 'aard and can "plough the channels". Fact is he's a striker that doesn't score. I'd rather play one of the young 'uns than ever play him again. Waste of total space.
Reply
#53
As with everything, it's not black and white. HRK has a good work rate, charges around a lot and appears in positions where you wouldn't necessarily expect him to initially. For a fresh defence this isn't too difficult to deal with usually because he lacks that spark, and is still (which people forget) a naturally wide player trying to do the job of a centre forward. Defenders have to keep an eye on him but if you can do that then there's rarely much threat.

However, for a defence that's tiring both mentally and physically this can be a nightmare as we saw against QPR. The way HRK plays at this level lends itself to him being a better impact player than a starter, however he still has something to offer.

Our results have been good recently with Austin in the team. IMO he has to start (maybe with the exception of this weekend, as Zohore v his old club). Generally we should be bringing on HRK or Zohore as impact subs. I'm willing to not put too much emphasis on the fact that Zohore's performance yesterday was absolutely abysmal.
Reply
#54
Save Robson-Kanu for the odd cameo role as sub when he does ok. Time and time again he's started games and not been good enough.
Reply
#55
I think this loss was a good thing, gets the everyone focused on improving play rather than reading their press clippings.

As for the squad, remember this is a new team. I think Bits now clear to Bilic who is best 11 is. Moving forward the side needs to always have Diangana, Pereira, Phillips, Austin, Sawyers, and the 4 defenders. Krovinovic, HRK, Zohore, and Townsend are impact subs to be used where needed. For those slagging Austin give him time. Even when not scoring he offers much more than the others. With him out there as another top threat, we are much more potent as everyone can see. Even if not scoring he is causing the defenders to match up with him, opening spaces for others. His goals will come, they always do.

After yesterday I'm even more convinced this team will get the automatic promotion. To play "just ok" and basically tie the other best squad at their place is a very good sign.
Reply
#56
(10-02-2019, 07:02 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-02-2019, 06:58 AM)John Osborne’s Knuckle Wrote:
(10-02-2019, 06:39 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:


Pfft the Baby Boom generation will go down as the most selfish, wasteful and self indulgent UK society in generations.
Not going to inflict your continuing spat with me on the readers of the main bored. So will just say this. You are a tit. What has a your assertion got to do with whinging about  football? 

See the Politics bored for your answer.

You brought nonsense about age and different generations into it. We got narrowly beat by a promotion rival... that’s what we learnt whatever generation you’re from.
Clearly, reading comprehension is not your strong suit. I think you will find I referred to the previous post which mentioned the age of moaners. So if there was any nonsense I didn’t bring it up.
Reply
#57
(10-02-2019, 02:22 PM)scotbaggie Wrote: I think this loss was a good thing, gets the everyone focused on improving play rather than reading their press clippings.

As for the squad, remember this is a new team. I think Bits now clear to Bilic who is best 11 is. Moving forward the side needs to always have Diangana, Pereira, Phillips, Austin, Sawyers, and the 4 defenders. Krovinovic, HRK, Zohore, and Townsend are impact subs to be used where needed. For those slagging Austin give him time. Even when not scoring he offers much more than the others. With him out there as another top threat, we are much more potent as everyone can see. Even if not scoring he is causing the defenders to match up with him, opening spaces for others. His goals will come, they always do.

After yesterday I'm even more convinced this team will get the automatic promotion. To play "just ok" and basically tie the other best squad at their place is a very good sign.

Bilic talks about his 16 "first team" players which I think are as follows;

Johnstone, Ferguson, Furlong, Ajayi, Bartley, O'Shea, Gibbs, Livermore, Sawyers, Phillips, Pereira, Diangana, Edwards, Austin, HRK, Zohore.

Added to this will be Hegazi & Barry.

I think Harper, Brunt, Townsend and Willock will be cover for injuries.
Reply
#58
(10-02-2019, 11:39 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(10-02-2019, 08:43 AM)74bus Wrote:
(10-01-2019, 09:08 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: A defeat was due, and that is the best way to get one. 
Pace, movement and attacking intent, this team is truly something.
The grumpy old gitts will whine on about the strength up front, but personally I think Diangana and Pereira both hesitated in shots on occasions tonight. 
Other days like this we will have 3 or 4.
Johnson a fine keeper- let it be known. 
Take tonight in your stride- there won’t be many defeats.

Unless we have an awful spate of injuries, HRK should never start another game.
In terms of pure footballing skill, Pereira is the best player to wear an Albion shirt in a very long time. If we can get him for 9 million, we should bite their hands off. After all, Kenneth reportedly cost almost that......
Surely by now, Johnstone has done more than enough to silence the moronic boo boys - but I won't hold my breath.
I can't wait for the Ajayi/Hegazi partnership at the back - will be awesome, because Semi is some player.

Are you turning blue yet?? 

The "moronic boo boys" which I assume refers to me, will acknowledge when he plays well. He played well last night. 

His limitations are there for all fair minded fans to see. He is beaten too easily from distance, and doesn't command his area. Teams that attack those weaknesses do well against us. Leeds played more like a Prem team last night, and SJ dealt with their threats admirably. He may well be better suited to Prem league, where it is more about reflexes, rather than movement of feet, or commanding your area.

He had a good game last night. Let's see how he deals with the directness of Cardiff on Saturday.
I have absolutely no idea whether you boo one of our own players during a game.
Some people around me in the BRE take great pleasure in booing and heckling Johnstone at every perceived mistake.
I was referring to them. If you're one of them, please feel included.
Reply
#59
The best thing about HRK is his song.
Reply
#60
What we learnt from last night is that Johnstone is a bloody good keeper, Ajayi is one of the bargains of the season,Peirera is possibly the best player in the championship, badly need Austin to find his shooting boots but all in all we have a bloody good side who in my opinion will go up as champions .
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: