The near impossible task of the finances to have a family
#31
(10-30-2026, 03:21 PM)Jacko Wrote: Not tonight dear, the price of childcare is through the roof.  Big Grin

Ay it, it was the lack of any money to spend on anything that got me into the bother in the 1st place  Big Grin

What's on the 4 channels tonight love? Early night then  Cool
Reply
#32
(10-30-2026, 02:46 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-30-2026, 02:12 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-30-2026, 01:42 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Again BB, your opening statement is simply untrue. You are very confident of a stranger on the internet's knowledge on a subject if it doesn't agree with yours. I am fully aware of modern housing costs, two kids with mortgages give me a pretty good indicator of what it costs and how hard they have to work to afford them. When we moved to our current house in 2001 as an under 40 year old my share of the mortgage was over £500 on an income of less than £1,500 (i'd have to look but it was probably a lot less than that actually) so between a third and a half of post tax income - that is nothing new.

You appear ignorant of a lot of what was going on and rely on partially collated stats to justify your points. As an example, we couldn't afford to buy a house near my wife's parents so we moved to where we could and on a daily basis my wife would get up early to get the bus from Cov, get off in Sheldon to drop my eldest off, and then get back on another bus to go to her full time job in Brum and do the same for the return journey. What you have given examples of are choices, I know plenty of people that made choices to work in London back in the day but moved back to having children when they were older.

Now, having said all that we do need to address the cost of childcare to help, but don't place all of the parent age problems at the alter of modern day unaffordability - that was always the case. There are many choices that are taken these days that will add years to the starting point of parenthood, education, travel, wanting to live life, and work, but they are choices.

If you want to work on anecdotes, to afford the house I grew up in (that had damp issues that weren't resolved until my teens and gave me childhood asthma) to meet the mortgage requirements we need a combined income of £110k with a 10% deposit. My parents worked in manual jobs and still do work below the median wage at the time. This is not in London. There's a reason why I gave data instead of rely on ancdotes, because they are unreliable and emotional. The fact is that housing costs are signiicantly higher these days than they have been with the exception of right before the 2008 financial crash. To suggest that your personal circumstances discredit wider data trends is completely ignorant of the situation. There's a reason why more young people live with their parents well into their 20s and 30s than at any point after WWI, there's a reason why the average first time buyer trend has edged up and up to the mid-30s and there's a reason why housing costs have risen to between a third and 50% of post tax income now than 10% 55 years ago.

There's also no bus to easily drop off a hypothetical child to my partners parents house over an hour and half drive to one way. This is all why we deferred having children, the costs do not add up logistically without one or both of us taking significant time off which causes significant cost issues and we are both in decent positions for income relative to most of the country and don't live in London. And my mates in London are thinking of moving back now or to the peripheries, it's only hybrid working arrangements that have made that feasible as their jobs don't exist at any sort of scale outside of London because of how centralised our economy is these days.

The cost of food and white goods being lower than ever before doesn't negate the issues faced on providing the fundamental basics of a stable house and ensuring your hypothetical child is looked after in their early life 24/7. If you want to look at the fertility rates yes people are having fewer children but the trend is also shifting rightwards so the peak fertility age is getting later and later because of economic circumstances being more hostile to getting basic security before choosing to have children. I'm in a much stronger position to buy a car or a pram or baby food or whatever but that is irrelevant until I can afford a stable living situation and childcare.

I'm not certain why you are comparing 55 years ago to today, that was an entirely different world. Ownership of property was lower then than it is today. 

I'm also not certain why you are making such a simple argument to such a complex problem. People delay having kids for more than A reason these days because there are many other reasons to cause that delay, be that education, travel, living life, societal changes (people got married earlier as an example) and cost of living. I'm not disputing it is a factor, it isn't the only factor though as you are portraying it.

I also believe that we should be building far more houses but as a nation we need to stop shooting ourselves in the foot through nimbyism and restricting labour through things such as Brexit, but that is easier said than done. I would love to have more free childcare but until that becomes state driven it won't happen, state funding appears to just put the costs for providers up at the same time.

None of that takes away you portraying choices as just that, choices. Why didn't you have kids at 18, because you choose better education to provide yourself, and any future kids, a better life, so that moved the dial to 24 or 25. You then chose to get a decent job and moved to where you could achieve that and by doing so give yourself, and again your future kids, a better life. Add to that the need for a number of people to have a year off and travel, not saying everyone, but that moves the dial again. Before you know it after dating a few you are pushing 30 and wondering why the age of parents is a lot older than 40 years ago. A lot of us didn't go to uni, we didn't have the option of travelling elsewhere for jobs, and there is a good chance that a lot of us were too young to have kids. Throughout that there is one theme - choice.

I am aware people are choosing to have kids later, I am one of them. Two of the biggest reasons for that are housing costs and stability and childcare access and costs are higher and more difficult now. Childcare isn't just about expanding free childcare, it's about relative demand especially pertinent given the centralisation of our economy as we've shifted towards services a.k.a. where the productive jobs are and legislation like maximum children per childcare worker being much more stringent in the UK than they used to be and are currently on the continent driving up costs because it should not be four times more expensive in the UK than a richer country like Denmark.

And housing costs are not just mortgage costs. Rent is a housing cost.
Reply
#33
I agree that we desperately need to build more housing. As I've lamented previously, I drive past a ludicrous number of boarded-up buildings around Birmingham (particularly Hagley Road/Fiveways) which could and should all be converted into housing. Yet instead, there seems to be a glut of student accommodation being built, despite student numbers, particularly international student numbers, falling.

However, the other point I wanted to make is this: I'm presuming quite a few posting on here are men, and you do indeed have all the time in the world to wait to have children. Your partners don't, and IVF is very expensive and physically and emotionally arduous. The average success rate in the UK is 31% and that's including all age groups; it drops sharply after the age of 35*. I have school-aged children, we had to pay for childcare; no family nearby, but we managed. There will be people on far lower incomes than anyone on this board having children and they manage too. If you want to have children, have children asap, because you never know what is around the corner.


*Before anyone says, "I'll just adopt", UK adoption is a very gruelling process and often the children available for adoption have significant additional problems. It has to be something that you very specifically wish to do, as opposed to a backup plan for infertility.
Reply
#34
(10-30-2026, 03:44 PM)Squid Wrote: I agree that we desperately need to build more housing. As I've lamented previously, I drive past a ludicrous number of boarded-up buildings around Birmingham (particularly Hagley Road/Fiveways) which could and should all be converted into housing. Yet instead, there seems to be a glut of student accommodation being built, despite student numbers, particularly international student numbers, falling.

However, the other point I wanted to make is this: I'm presuming quite a few posting on here are men, and you do indeed have all the time in the world to wait to have children. Your partners don't, and IVF is very expensive and physically and emotionally arduous. The average success rate in the UK is 31% and that's including all age groups; it drops sharply after the age of 35*. I have school-aged children, we had to pay for childcare; no family nearby, but we managed. There will be people on far lower incomes than anyone on this board having children and they manage too. If you want to have children, have children asap, because you never know what is around the corner.


*Before anyone says, "I'll just adopt", UK adoption is a very gruelling process and often the children available for adoption have significant additional problems. It has to be something that you very specifically wish to do, as opposed to a backup plan for infertility.

Also the risk of birth defects or chromosomal abnormalities are higher due to the eggs being older
Reply
#35
(10-30-2026, 03:44 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I am aware people are choosing to have kids later, I am one of them. Two of the biggest reasons for that are housing costs and stability and childcare access and costs are higher and more difficult now. Childcare isn't just about expanding free childcare, it's about relative demand especially pertinent given the centralisation of our economy as we've shifted towards services a.k.a. where the productive jobs are and legislation like maximum children per childcare worker being much more stringent in the UK than they used to be and are currently on the continent driving up costs because it should not be four times more expensive in the UK than a richer country like Denmark.

And housing costs are not just mortgage costs. Rent is a housing cost.

Your argument is that the average age of people having kids has gone up over the last 50 years. We agree on that.

You put all of that down to housing costs and stability and childcare access and costs - all of those have always been an issue, that isn't saying they aren't more of an issue now, but they have always been an issue.

I have pointed out that lifestyle / education choices will push that average age higher from being more available these days. You seem to brush that aside.

I'd also say you worry too much about affording things now, bringing a child into this world with everything going on, and can you give them what they need. As someone who is at the other end of those worries, I'd say do it, take the hit, make the changes, fuck the cost, it'll work out, you make sacrifices that you didn't know you could, you will find ways of earning more money and the pay off will be greater than anything else you could have invested in.

If I told you that you had to put every spare penny you had into a scheme for 20 years that would reward you with the greatest adventure you will ever have for the rest of your days, for me that would be a no brainer and the sooner started the better. None of us could afford it at the time but we did and found out we could.
Reply
#36
(10-30-2026, 03:57 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-30-2026, 03:44 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I am aware people are choosing to have kids later, I am one of them. Two of the biggest reasons for that are housing costs and stability and childcare access and costs are higher and more difficult now. Childcare isn't just about expanding free childcare, it's about relative demand especially pertinent given the centralisation of our economy as we've shifted towards services a.k.a. where the productive jobs are and legislation like maximum children per childcare worker being much more stringent in the UK than they used to be and are currently on the continent driving up costs because it should not be four times more expensive in the UK than a richer country like Denmark.

And housing costs are not just mortgage costs. Rent is a housing cost.

Your argument is that the average age of people having kids has gone up over the last 50 years. We agree on that.

You put all of that down to housing costs and stability and childcare access and costs - all of those have always been an issue, that isn't saying they aren't more of an issue now, but they have always been an issue.

I have pointed out that lifestyle / education choices will push that average age higher from being more available these days. You seem to brush that aside.

I'd also say you worry too much about affording things now, bringing a child into this world with everything going on, and can you give them what they need. As someone who is at the other end of those worries, I'd say do it, take the hit, make the changes, fuck the cost, it'll work out, you make sacrifices that you didn't know you could, you will find ways of earning more money and the pay off will be greater than anything else you could have invested in.

If I told you that you had to put every spare penny you had into a scheme for 20 years that would reward you with the greatest adventure you will ever have for the rest of your days, for me that would be a no brainer and the sooner started the better. None of us could afford it at the time but we did and found out we could.

No, I said that you didn't understand the extent of how much higher housing costs and childcare costs are now than they historically have been and you're still denying that even erstwhile saying we need to build more houses. Doing a masters degree and 3 years of work post graduation puts you at 24, peak fertility age i.e. the modal age that people are having kids is now in the mid-30s, do you think that it being close to the now average first time buyer age is a coincidence? The steady financial situation that people generally want before starting a family is not shifting into the mid-30s because everyone is doing a PhD, is it? I'm perfectly cognizant of needing to make sacrifices and that earning potential will likely grow into my late 40s but that still doesn't detract from the need for stability from housing or making sure a young child is able to be looked after 24/7 to start a family.
Reply
#37
Fucks sake - I give up. You appear to be waiting for the perfect time to afford kids, I wish you all the best for that. One of my granddaughters has just come over, I'm glad that even though I couldn't really afford it I had my kids early, if I'd have thought about it logically like you have they'd still have been in school I reckon.

And no, i didn't say that it was just education that delayed things, but why wouldn't you misquote me to win a point, eh?
Reply
#38
Do you not think it's selfish to plan to have kids if you know you can't afford/aren't in a good financial position?

Although, I guess there's always a way to make things work, if you want something badly enough.

Interesting debate.
Reply
#39
(10-30-2026, 04:20 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Fucks sake - I give up. You appear to be waiting for the perfect time to afford kids, I wish you all the best for that. One of my granddaughters has just come over, I'm glad that even though I couldn't really afford it I had my kids early, if I'd have thought about it logically like you have they'd still have been in school I reckon.

And no, i didn't say that it was just education that delayed things, but why wouldn't you misquote me to win a point, eh?

The perfect time being able to ensure they can be looked after 24/7 and have a stable living situation? I'd say that's just trying to get the basics in place to be a responsible parent. Hardly looking at pre-prep through to 18 years old at private school with £4k a year in their JISAs, is it? And sorry for not entertaining the quite frankly bizarre notion you presented that people aren't able to get into a settled relationship until their mid-30s as though people don't date at uni or start long term relationships in their early 20s anymore.
Reply
#40
We made sacrifices to ensure that they had childcare and part of that was moving away from our workplace to be nearer family at a cost. We paid for childcare when we couldn't get that cover. We shifted our work patterns so that we could minimise the costs. You find a way and you are going to be mightily disappointed if you think you can only have kids in a stable living situation.

I didn't have either a stable living situation or 24/7 childcare, or a proper job come to that, when my lad was conceived, but we scrambled through. They were both given enough love through all the stresses that life threw at us to enable them both to be decent people who work in well paid jobs and now great parents. You trying to have the perfect start is delaying the point you realise you will have to throw the spreadsheet out the window.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)