Posts: 1,238
Threads: 76
Joined: Feb 2025
Reputation:
4
(10-30-2026, 11:04 AM)BertieTheBaggie Wrote: Over the years I've been increasingly bewildered by the lack of help in this country to help decent families, by decent I mean ones where the parents want to add to society.
Most parents of schoolkids I know have a mixture of unbelievable stress or unbelievable debt, or both pushing them to breaking point.
It's a topic seldom mentioned, but it's little wonder that birthrate is at an all time low and broken families at an all time high.
The cost of raising two kids, mine are young adults out of education now, has been exhorbitant. They reckon it's £200k or so per kid. I get it.
This article, if you can get through the firewall, is one of the first to address the issue I've read in a long time. https://www.thetimes.com/comment/columni...-0vqhtqqxh
The cost for me of having two kids has been I will probably certainly work to 67, if AI allows me to work, I will probably have to downsize to something a lot more modest than my current 3 bedroom semi, and I'm doing my upmost to scramble some kind of pension pot together.
My factory worker dad bought a house on his wage in 1970 now worth about £350k. That couldn't be done now.
Most people I know, honest about their finances in a similar position to me, have spoken to me of crippling debt. At one point we had £25k on credit, which we've now paid off. It wasn't for fancy holidays or leased cars either. It was just to keep a roof over our head. I do just wonder why this massive crisis is so underspoken about.
People without kids have absolutely no idea whatsoever how difficult it is. They really don't! In fact I find it hard to relate to those who haven't gone through this, whilst certainly not making judgement on them.
Interested to hear thoughts of others on here.
I'm 68 next month and don't have kids. Never wanted them. Married twice and neither was able to have kids so it balanced. I do wonder how most folk manage financially but not too much as it's what I avoided! Good luck.
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
Again BB, your opening statement is simply untrue. You are very confident of a stranger on the internet's knowledge on a subject if it doesn't agree with yours. I am fully aware of modern housing costs, two kids with mortgages give me a pretty good indicator of what it costs and how hard they have to work to afford them. When we moved to our current house in 2001 as an under 40 year old my share of the mortgage was over £500 on an income of less than £1,500 (i'd have to look but it was probably a lot less than that actually) so between a third and a half of post tax income - that is nothing new.
You appear ignorant of a lot of what was going on and rely on partially collated stats to justify your points. As an example, we couldn't afford to buy a house near my wife's parents so we moved to where we could and on a daily basis my wife would get up early to get the bus from Cov, get off in Sheldon to drop my eldest off, and then get back on another bus to go to her full time job in Brum and do the same for the return journey. What you have given examples of are choices, I know plenty of people that made choices to work in London back in the day but moved back to having children when they were older.
Now, having said all that we do need to address the cost of childcare to help, but don't place all of the parent age problems at the alter of modern day unaffordability - that was always the case. There are many choices that are taken these days that will add years to the starting point of parenthood, education, travel, wanting to live life, and work, but they are choices.
Posts: 6,717
Threads: 354
Joined: Mar 2024
Reputation:
40
I have been saying all my life "build more affordable housing"
Each government has ignored this, to their utter shame. And yet, here we are.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
10-30-2026, 02:12 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-30-2026, 02:12 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
(10-30-2026, 01:42 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Again BB, your opening statement is simply untrue. You are very confident of a stranger on the internet's knowledge on a subject if it doesn't agree with yours. I am fully aware of modern housing costs, two kids with mortgages give me a pretty good indicator of what it costs and how hard they have to work to afford them. When we moved to our current house in 2001 as an under 40 year old my share of the mortgage was over £500 on an income of less than £1,500 (i'd have to look but it was probably a lot less than that actually) so between a third and a half of post tax income - that is nothing new.
You appear ignorant of a lot of what was going on and rely on partially collated stats to justify your points. As an example, we couldn't afford to buy a house near my wife's parents so we moved to where we could and on a daily basis my wife would get up early to get the bus from Cov, get off in Sheldon to drop my eldest off, and then get back on another bus to go to her full time job in Brum and do the same for the return journey. What you have given examples of are choices, I know plenty of people that made choices to work in London back in the day but moved back to having children when they were older.
Now, having said all that we do need to address the cost of childcare to help, but don't place all of the parent age problems at the alter of modern day unaffordability - that was always the case. There are many choices that are taken these days that will add years to the starting point of parenthood, education, travel, wanting to live life, and work, but they are choices.
If you want to work on anecdotes, to afford the house I grew up in (that had damp issues that weren't resolved until my teens and gave me childhood asthma) to meet the mortgage requirements we need a combined income of £110k with a 10% deposit. My parents worked in manual jobs and still do work below the median wage at the time. This is not in London. There's a reason why I gave data instead of rely on ancdotes, because they are unreliable and emotional. The fact is that housing costs are signiicantly higher these days than they have been with the exception of right before the 2008 financial crash. To suggest that your personal circumstances discredit wider data trends is completely ignorant of the situation. There's a reason why more young people live with their parents well into their 20s and 30s than at any point after WWI, there's a reason why the average first time buyer trend has edged up and up to the mid-30s and there's a reason why housing costs have risen to between a third and 50% of post tax income now than 10% 55 years ago.
There's also no bus to easily drop off a hypothetical child to my partners parents house over an hour and half drive to one way. This is all why we deferred having children, the costs do not add up logistically without one or both of us taking significant time off which causes significant cost issues and we are both in decent positions for income relative to most of the country and don't live in London. And my mates in London are thinking of moving back now or to the peripheries, it's only hybrid working arrangements that have made that feasible as their jobs don't exist at any sort of scale outside of London because of how centralised our economy is these days.
The cost of food and white goods being lower than ever before doesn't negate the issues faced on providing the fundamental basics of a stable house and ensuring your hypothetical child is looked after in their early life 24/7. If you want to look at the fertility rates yes people are having fewer children but the trend is also shifting rightwards so the peak fertility age is getting later and later because of economic circumstances being more hostile to getting basic security before choosing to have children. I'm in a much stronger position to buy a car or a pram or baby food or whatever but that is irrelevant until I can afford a stable living situation and childcare.
Posts: 6,717
Threads: 354
Joined: Mar 2024
Reputation:
40
(10-30-2026, 01:29 PM)Hudds2 Wrote: (10-30-2026, 11:04 AM)BertieTheBaggie Wrote: Over the years I've been increasingly bewildered by the lack of help in this country to help decent families, by decent I mean ones where the parents want to add to society.
Most parents of schoolkids I know have a mixture of unbelievable stress or unbelievable debt, or both pushing them to breaking point.
It's a topic seldom mentioned, but it's little wonder that birthrate is at an all time low and broken families at an all time high.
The cost of raising two kids, mine are young adults out of education now, has been exhorbitant. They reckon it's £200k or so per kid. I get it.
This article, if you can get through the firewall, is one of the first to address the issue I've read in a long time. https://www.thetimes.com/comment/columni...-0vqhtqqxh
The cost for me of having two kids has been I will probably certainly work to 67, if AI allows me to work, I will probably have to downsize to something a lot more modest than my current 3 bedroom semi, and I'm doing my upmost to scramble some kind of pension pot together.
My factory worker dad bought a house on his wage in 1970 now worth about £350k. That couldn't be done now.
Most people I know, honest about their finances in a similar position to me, have spoken to me of crippling debt. At one point we had £25k on credit, which we've now paid off. It wasn't for fancy holidays or leased cars either. It was just to keep a roof over our head. I do just wonder why this massive crisis is so underspoken about.
People without kids have absolutely no idea whatsoever how difficult it is. They really don't! In fact I find it hard to relate to those who haven't gone through this, whilst certainly not making judgement on them.
Interested to hear thoughts of others on here.
I'm 68 next month and don't have kids. Never wanted them. Married twice and neither was able to have kids so it balanced. I do wonder how most folk manage financially but not too much as it's what I avoided! Good luck.
Ah Hudds, you may not realise it but I am your second cousin, once removed. Just so as you know when it comes to will writing time.
I prefer my settlements in Putney pounds rather than zlotys, C/O Coutts, 440 The Strand.
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(10-30-2026, 02:12 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (10-30-2026, 01:42 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Again BB, your opening statement is simply untrue. You are very confident of a stranger on the internet's knowledge on a subject if it doesn't agree with yours. I am fully aware of modern housing costs, two kids with mortgages give me a pretty good indicator of what it costs and how hard they have to work to afford them. When we moved to our current house in 2001 as an under 40 year old my share of the mortgage was over £500 on an income of less than £1,500 (i'd have to look but it was probably a lot less than that actually) so between a third and a half of post tax income - that is nothing new.
You appear ignorant of a lot of what was going on and rely on partially collated stats to justify your points. As an example, we couldn't afford to buy a house near my wife's parents so we moved to where we could and on a daily basis my wife would get up early to get the bus from Cov, get off in Sheldon to drop my eldest off, and then get back on another bus to go to her full time job in Brum and do the same for the return journey. What you have given examples of are choices, I know plenty of people that made choices to work in London back in the day but moved back to having children when they were older.
Now, having said all that we do need to address the cost of childcare to help, but don't place all of the parent age problems at the alter of modern day unaffordability - that was always the case. There are many choices that are taken these days that will add years to the starting point of parenthood, education, travel, wanting to live life, and work, but they are choices.
If you want to work on anecdotes, to afford the house I grew up in (that had damp issues that weren't resolved until my teens and gave me childhood asthma) to meet the mortgage requirements we need a combined income of £110k with a 10% deposit. My parents worked in manual jobs and still do work below the median wage at the time. This is not in London. There's a reason why I gave data instead of rely on ancdotes, because they are unreliable and emotional. The fact is that housing costs are signiicantly higher these days than they have been with the exception of right before the 2008 financial crash. To suggest that your personal circumstances discredit wider data trends is completely ignorant of the situation. There's a reason why more young people live with their parents well into their 20s and 30s than at any point after WWI, there's a reason why the average first time buyer trend has edged up and up to the mid-30s and there's a reason why housing costs have risen to between a third and 50% of post tax income now than 10% 55 years ago.
There's also no bus to easily drop off a hypothetical child to my partners parents house over an hour and half drive to one way. This is all why we deferred having children, the costs do not add up logistically without one or both of us taking significant time off which causes significant cost issues and we are both in decent positions for income relative to most of the country and don't live in London. And my mates in London are thinking of moving back now or to the peripheries, it's only hybrid working arrangements that have made that feasible as their jobs don't exist at any sort of scale outside of London because of how centralised our economy is these days.
The cost of food and white goods being lower than ever before doesn't negate the issues faced on providing the fundamental basics of a stable house and ensuring your hypothetical child is looked after in their early life 24/7. If you want to look at the fertility rates yes people are having fewer children but the trend is also shifting rightwards so the peak fertility age is getting later and later because of economic circumstances being more hostile to getting basic security before choosing to have children. I'm in a much stronger position to buy a car or a pram or baby food or whatever but that is irrelevant until I can afford a stable living situation and childcare.
I'm not certain why you are comparing 55 years ago to today, that was an entirely different world. Ownership of property was lower then than it is today.
I'm also not certain why you are making such a simple argument to such a complex problem. People delay having kids for more than A reason these days because there are many other reasons to cause that delay, be that education, travel, living life, societal changes (people got married earlier as an example) and cost of living. I'm not disputing it is a factor, it isn't the only factor though as you are portraying it.
I also believe that we should be building far more houses but as a nation we need to stop shooting ourselves in the foot through nimbyism and restricting labour through things such as Brexit, but that is easier said than done. I would love to have more free childcare but until that becomes state driven it won't happen, state funding appears to just put the costs for providers up at the same time.
None of that takes away you portraying choices as just that, choices. Why didn't you have kids at 18, because you choose better education to provide yourself, and any future kids, a better life, so that moved the dial to 24 or 25. You then chose to get a decent job and moved to where you could achieve that and by doing so give yourself, and again your future kids, a better life. Add to that the need for a number of people to have a year off and travel, not saying everyone, but that moves the dial again. Before you know it after dating a few you are pushing 30 and wondering why the age of parents is a lot older than 40 years ago. A lot of us didn't go to uni, we didn't have the option of travelling elsewhere for jobs, and there is a good chance that a lot of us were too young to have kids. Throughout that there is one theme - choice.
Posts: 27,980
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
As a father of three, all under the age of nine, I can confirm that having kids is an absolute ballache financially!
Posts: 7,862
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
13
10-30-2026, 02:54 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-30-2026, 02:54 PM by Midget In A Pinstripe Suit.)
(10-30-2026, 02:47 PM)Duffers Wrote: As a father of three, all under the age of nine, I can confirm that having kids is an absolute ballache financially!
Don’t k is how you do it in a London flat, we have friends in a 2 bed in Woolwich with 3 under 5 and they are desperate to join us out East outside the M25.
In the form of his life.
Posts: 3,903
Threads: 18
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(10-30-2026, 11:42 AM)baggy1 Wrote: When you talk about cost Bertie you appear to be equating kids to an expense, something that will drain you of your funds with no return. Would it be better if you looked on the money spent on your kids as an investment with a non-financial return. I'm approaching 60 now and had kids young and there were times when we had nothing left at the end of a pay check, these were the days before the costs of phones or TV subscription or app subscriptions. I'm not complaining by the way, different generations have different struggles. I can tell you without any doubt that the joy I get from having kids and grandkids is greater than any return on investment seen in the traditional sense.
Then there is another angle, at some point in the future you will leave work and retire, and then what? You'll travel the world and do things as a couple - great, a worthy way of seeing out your days, something deserved and earned. However at some point one of you will pass and then without that family, without the kids and grandkids (and great grandkids) life will be lonely.
Family is everything, gather the biggest one around you that you can - it pays off in the end. And as for todays expense, you'll find a way. Couldn't agree more Baggie im 62 with 3 grandkids the pleasure i get with interaction with them is priceless.Dont get me wrong its been tough extremely tough at times we've been together 48yrs and i cant recall a time that we wernt in debt for something and thats not including the mortgage which is almost done, i desperately trying to get my pension pot in some sort of order but pretty sure im going to have to work beyond 67 in some capacity probaly part time to be comfortable, but the pleasure of watching my girls grow up and then grandkids somehow makes it all worth while.
Posts: 7,711
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
Not tonight dear, the price of childcare is through the roof.
|