Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
You can't prevent people from killing themselves outside the law or going to Dignitas. You can stop the state from issuing the death sentence. The notion that the morals are anyway equivalent is absolutely bizarre.
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
Assisted dying at the request of a patient is not the same as state murder/revenge.
And assisted dying is with us now, just in a slow painful way. I've recently lost a relative where the decision was made to not only withdraw treatment but also all food and fluids as they were causing some of the symptoms. This choice was made in agreement with doctors and remaining relatives (including myself) which in effect means we chose to end his life. He lived for almost 5 days, sedated for the pain, in a pointless existence to just drag out the inevitable. The decision to "kill him" was made 5 days before he passed and yet we don't have a system to control this.
Jacko, if you look through a skewed lens then you can make an argument that the state would be allowing the sick and elderly to die whilst protecting the lives of murderers. But that is completely failing to understand the nuance of the reality and a false equivalent.
Having had that recent experience my belief in assisted dying had actually been shaken by the finality of it all, not helped by the patient being unable to make his own decisions. But in the couple of weeks since I've reconciled that the pain and suffering is worse as his death was inevitable and all it did was make us as a family feel even worse in agreeing/deciding on that course of action.
State murder is somewhat different and is certainly motivated by revenge not justice. I'm happy to lock someone in a dark room and just enough room to lie on a hard cold floor with the most basic of sustenance. If you want to hold up a mirror on decsions and behaviour then they should be the very people kept alive to suffer for the remainding years they have.
It's no suprise that some posters have closed minds on debating this and aren't at the very least open to differing views but those exxtremes exst on both sides and have been ever thus. What I often find is those with the wish for capital punishment often don't meet many of the other social values of those with opposing views. This will often cover immigration/ayslum seekers, state benefits and many other areas covered by equality/inequality. Not all, but many.
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 11,931
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
Staggered by the belief that the ‘state’ could control a load of doctors to coerce people into dying so the state could save some money… the agents must have better skills than I ever did
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 9,649
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
"Many that live deserve death. And some that die deserve life. Can you give it to them? Then do not be too eager to deal out death in judgement. For even the very wise cannot see all ends."
Posts: 151
Threads: 5
Joined: Jun 2026
Reputation:
1
10-02-2026, 04:19 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-02-2026, 04:23 PM by Øssian.)
Perhaps simplify things: begin with the question 'Do I want to live in a country where the state has the power to execute people as a punishment?' and take it from there...
Posts: 7,726
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
CC It's not difficult, the coercion comes from bad actors, usually family members. The medical fallibility from the doctors. They are the actual equivalent to the corrupt cops or misinformed jurors/judiciary.
Derek's hypothesis of state controlled means-tested euthanasia is of course, extremely far-fetched.
CA, I am extremely sorry to hear you have had that experience. As I stated, I'm not making a false equivalence because I'm not comparing the morality of the two, mercy vs punishment, I'm comparing the fallibility of the systems that will administer them. Due to the finality of death, there is a clear systemic risk baked into both.
Posts: 9,649
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
For the most part this has been an interesting discussion, BTW.
I genuinely can see both sides of the argument. It's such a tough subject. I don't think there's a right or wrong answer, or view, as I mentioned above.