WBAUnofficial
The death row case of Christa Pike - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: The death row case of Christa Pike (/showthread.php?tid=42911)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9


The death row case of Christa Pike - CarlosCorbewrong - 10-01-2026

I’d been following this, lightly, as I’ve always had some morbid fascination with death row after reading a Grisham book as a kid.

Pike, a nasty piece of work no doubt, was the first woman in Tennessee to face the death penalty in 200 years and was 19 when convicted. It’s been an appeal process with twists and turns however last night she survived two ‘lethal’ doses of pentobarbital and, with some irony, is now receiving life supporting care.

Mental.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cq8r6rjdvlx6o


RE: The death row case of Christa Pike - HawkingsHalfpint - 10-01-2026

She was a really fucked-up kid and that was never properly taken into account. Not excusing her actions one bit, but everyone was baying for blood so ferociously her childhood was never properly considered.

A fucked up country with fucked up laws fucks up. It’s hardly a surprise!


RE: The death row case of Christa Pike - CarlosCorbewrong - 10-01-2026

(10-01-2026, 06:48 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: She was a really fucked-up kid and that was never properly taken into account. Not excusing her actions one bit, but everyone was baying for blood so ferociously her childhood was never properly considered.

A fucked up country with fucked up laws fucks up. It’s hardly a surprise!

Yeah, I thought that bit was particularly sad that a) the defence failed to present that info b) it wasn’t sufficient to prevent the death penalty c) she got the death penalty but her boyfriend, 17 at the time, escapes it. 

You can’t excuse people because of the abuse they suffered as kids - but if ever there was a legitimate mitigation for the death penalty this must be it, surely?


RE: The death row case of Christa Pike - Dumbo - 10-01-2026

(10-01-2026, 07:06 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 06:48 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: She was a really fucked-up kid and that was never properly taken into account. Not excusing her actions one bit, but everyone was baying for blood so ferociously her childhood was never properly considered.

A fucked up country with fucked up laws fucks up. It’s hardly a surprise!

Yeah, I thought that bit was particularly sad that a) the defence failed to present that info b) it wasn’t sufficient to prevent the death penalty c) she got the death penalty but her boyfriend, 17 at the time, escapes it. 

You can’t excuse people because of the abuse they suffered as kids - but if ever there was a legitimate mitigation for the death penalty this must be it, surely?

She carved a pentagram into the victims chest. Carved in her skull and kept a piece to show off.

Hopefully the third dose finishes her off.


RE: The death row case of Christa Pike - HawkingsHalfpint - 10-01-2026

An eye for an eye and we all go blind eventually.

That’s my view on the death penalty. There are people FAR more deserving than a girl who was raped as a toddler. No matter how barbaric her crimes, you have to ask ‘why’.

Anyway I’m being way too topical for this time of a morning!


RE: The death row case of Christa Pike - SW4Baggie - 10-01-2026

(10-01-2026, 07:35 AM)Dumbo Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 07:06 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 06:48 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: She was a really fucked-up kid and that was never properly taken into account. Not excusing her actions one bit, but everyone was baying for blood so ferociously her childhood was never properly considered.

A fucked up country with fucked up laws fucks up. It’s hardly a surprise!

Yeah, I thought that bit was particularly sad that a) the defence failed to present that info b) it wasn’t sufficient to prevent the death penalty c) she got the death penalty but her boyfriend, 17 at the time, escapes it. 

You can’t excuse people because of the abuse they suffered as kids - but if ever there was a legitimate mitigation for the death penalty this must be it, surely?

She carved a pentagram into the victims chest. Carved in her skull and kept a piece to show off.

Hopefully the third dose finishes her off.

It's rarely so simple though...  Despite being very left of centre on many social and political issues, I tend to fall pretty hard right on crime and punishment, and wrestle with views on the death penalty regularly.

She had a terrible upbrining, and the systems that were supposed to protect her completely neglected their duties and ended up contributing to creating a monster. Not every rough upbringing leads to this type of behaviour, but pretty much everyone who does this type of killing comes from the same pattern. it's not excusing what she did, but mixing abuse, drugs, mental disabilities and a completely inept system will cause these incidents.

On the death penalty, I have 2 issues with this case; firstly, she was in custody for 30 years... surely one of the justifications for the death penalty is that there is no chance of rehab and it's cheaper than incarceration, surely that goes out of the window if you've had someone locked up for 3 decades? Secondly, this is not the first case of the death penaltry being bungled. If you are going to implement it, do it bloody right.


RE: The death row case of Christa Pike - Merkinagogo - 10-01-2026

I find it hard to condone a death sentence - too many miscarriages of justice to not have an 'undo' option - regardless of whether it is right or not, but how they can't manage to complete the process is ridiculous. Can you imagine going to a vet to have a pet 'put to sleep' and them screwing it up. How hard is it - big dose of morphine and there we are.


RE: The death row case of Christa Pike - Birdman1811 - 10-01-2026

Problem the US is having, drs won't assist with an execution, against their oath. The suppliers of the drugs won't sell to them since they find it legally tricky, so the drugs are out of date, given by untrained people. More and more are failing.


RE: The death row case of Christa Pike - Vinebaggie - 10-01-2026

Just did a bit of AI research, and the figures are hard to come by, but between 1975 and 2005 68 people released from prison after a murder / manslaughter charge were subsequently convicted of manslaughter / murder. The victaims were, probably, innocent and with even greater probability known to the perpetrator. I know there is an inevitability with the death penalty of an innocent person being killed by the state ( undoubtedly the Birmingham 6 would have incorrectly gone to the gallows ) but the current policy is creating innocent victaims of murder at the hands of people who are being released.
Personally I'd like a referendum on the death penalty and I honestly don't know which way I'd vote but I'd like the debate.


RE: The death row case of Christa Pike - Merkinagogo - 10-01-2026

(10-01-2026, 08:48 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Problem the US is having, drs won't assist with an execution, against their oath. The suppliers of the drugs won't sell to them since they find it legally tricky, so the drugs are out of date, given by untrained people. More and more are failing.

I didn't know that, pretty mad situation all over then