10-02-2026, 01:00 PM
Keeping someone alive when they're terminally ill and live in constant pain and discomfort is morally worse than killing a criminal that has commited the worst acts you can imagine.
|
The death row case of Christa Pike
|
|
10-02-2026, 01:00 PM
Keeping someone alive when they're terminally ill and live in constant pain and discomfort is morally worse than killing a criminal that has commited the worst acts you can imagine.
10-02-2026, 01:16 PM
(10-02-2026, 12:25 PM)Jacko Wrote:(10-02-2026, 12:04 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:(10-01-2026, 02:57 PM)Jacko Wrote: Kill the very worse criminals? Fuck no. As Josh says, legislation that allows the sick, elderly or anyone else with zero quality of life to make their own choice to die with some dignity is not the same as the state deciding what action is bad enough to put someone to death. (10-02-2026, 12:58 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:(10-02-2026, 12:25 PM)Jacko Wrote:But different if the subject chooses to die?(10-02-2026, 12:04 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:(10-01-2026, 02:57 PM)Jacko Wrote: Kill the very worse criminals? Fuck no. Depends how you look at it, with the death penalty in place the subject's life would be forfeit due to their actions and choices. Josh has just inadvertently made the case for capital punishment. I have no strong view on it personally. My post was purely an observation of an interesting dichotomy on the bored.
10-02-2026, 01:27 PM
One is killing for mercy, the other for punishment. One driven by compassion, the other revenge.
10-02-2026, 01:35 PM
But both mandated by the State and both carry systemic risk around the finality of death. Miscarriage of justice in the case of the death penalty and coercion or medical oversight failures in the case of assisted dying.
10-02-2026, 01:38 PM
(10-02-2026, 01:35 PM)Jacko Wrote: But both mandated by the State and both carry systemic risk around the finality of death. Miscarriage of justice in the case of the death penalty and coercion or medical oversight failures in the case of assisted dying. One is the decision of the state. The other would primarily be the choice of an individual with free will. I don't understand the link. They're two very separate and complex matters. Both sides of each argument has merits.
10-02-2026, 01:46 PM
(10-02-2026, 01:38 PM)Josh1873 Wrote:(10-02-2026, 01:35 PM)Jacko Wrote: But both mandated by the State and both carry systemic risk around the finality of death. Miscarriage of justice in the case of the death penalty and coercion or medical oversight failures in the case of assisted dying. The dichotomy is, the same person when speaking about capital punishment, 'the state cannot guarantee a flawless system so we can't do it to protect the innocent', then in the same breath re assisted dying, 'the state can manage the system well enough to protect the vulnerable from medical error and coercion, so the risk is acceptable'. To my mind, this is an obvious friction. (10-02-2026, 01:35 PM)Jacko Wrote: But both mandated by the State and both carry systemic risk around the finality of death. Miscarriage of justice in the case of the death penalty and coercion or medical oversight failures in the case of assisted dying. Maybe I'm being pedantic, but allowing someone to make a choice to die isn't the same as being mandated to die by the state. At present, by outlawing assisted dying, the state actually 'mandates' you must carry on - even if you don't want to. Although DNACPR declarations are on odd one. You can also be sued if you follow the declaration and don't resuscitate if it's subsequently decided you didn't follow strict enough checks. But interestingly (for me, anyway) you can be sued if you ignore the declaration and resuscitate patients to keep them alive. It's classed as battery. So, in a way, the same issues, worries and ethical decisions we have with assisted dying have always been with us and we have pretty well accepted that patients have the right to say enough is enough. So surely the question should be about safeguards, rather than morality?
10-02-2026, 02:03 PM
It’s not pedantry if you’re dealing with the lunatic fringe of false equivalence
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
10-02-2026, 02:04 PM
(10-02-2026, 01:52 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:(10-02-2026, 01:35 PM)Jacko Wrote: But both mandated by the State and both carry systemic risk around the finality of death. Miscarriage of justice in the case of the death penalty and coercion or medical oversight failures in the case of assisted dying. See my later post. Due to the finality of death, this is what philosophers call a 'Mirror Image' problem. If one is too risky, then the other must also, by definition, be considered in the same terms. |
|
« Next Oldest | Next Newest »
|