The death row case of Christa Pike
#41
29 people have been executed in the US this year. There are over 2,000 people on death row. It seems there is a bit of an unofficial shift away from the death penalty, which I imagine is mostly down to all the various legal challenges preventing the actual executions.

After this botched job that is only going to amplify. There is already a halt on executions in Tennessee, that will probably be followed nationwide, and I can't see how the injection can be used again.
Reply
#42
(10-02-2026, 10:25 AM)wba13 Wrote: I will not change what I think.

To the surprise of absolutely no-one.
Reply
#43
(10-02-2026, 10:25 AM)wba13 Wrote: I will not change what I think.

Not trying to.

See, a common mistake people make with discussions and debates is that you're trying to change the oppositions viewpoint, you're not, you're pulling people in the middle to your side and preventing more people going to the other side.
Reply
#44
Is there a right or wrong answer to this debate?
Reply
#45
(10-02-2026, 09:27 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: It doesn't even actually as a deterrent in any way either. In fact data suggests the exact opposite, crime is worse in areas with the death penalty.

I'm all for a more barbaric prison structure for the worst cases, people for whom there is no rehabilitation into society. It must never be an option to execute them.

As Ian Hislop once said - it's not a deterrent to kill the wrong people
Reply
#46
(10-02-2026, 11:37 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Is there a right or wrong answer to this debate?

As usual with anything moral, not really, there's so many shades of grey it's difficult. However I'm very happy in my viewpoint that no state should have the power to murder it's citizens.
Reply
#47
(10-02-2026, 11:37 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-02-2026, 09:27 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: It doesn't even actually as a deterrent in any way either. In fact data suggests the exact opposite, crime is worse in areas with the death penalty.

I'm all for a more barbaric prison structure for the worst cases, people for whom there is no rehabilitation into society. It must never be an option to execute them.

As Ian Hislop once said - it's not a deterrent to kill the wrong people

Israel and America must have missed that pearl of wisdom.
Reply
#48
(10-01-2026, 02:57 PM)Jacko Wrote: Kill the very worse criminals? Fuck no.

Kill the little old man who thinks he's a burden on his family? G'wed then.

Love this place  Big Grin

With regards to this US case, two points, the accomplice was a minor hence no death penalty. The State execution protocol has a failsafe if the first lethal injection doesn't work, of a 2nd injection. No one bothered to add a failsafe if the 2nd also doesn't work, so legally they had to stop. Likely she'll have a serious brain injury I'd imagine.

Assuming you're on the wind up but the two examples given couldn't be more different.
Reply
#49
(10-02-2026, 12:04 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 02:57 PM)Jacko Wrote: Kill the very worse criminals? Fuck no.

Kill the little old man who thinks he's a burden on his family? G'wed then.

Love this place  Big Grin

With regards to this US case, two points, the accomplice was a minor hence no death penalty. The State execution protocol has a failsafe if the first lethal injection doesn't work, of a 2nd injection. No one bothered to add a failsafe if the 2nd also doesn't work, so legally they had to stop. Likely she'll have a serious brain injury I'd imagine.

Assuming you're on the wind up but the two examples given couldn't be more different.

State legislated killing criminals, and state legislated killing the sick and elderly (sorry - assisted dying), is state legislated killing at the end of the day.
Reply
#50
(10-02-2026, 12:25 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(10-02-2026, 12:04 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 02:57 PM)Jacko Wrote: Kill the very worse criminals? Fuck no.

Kill the little old man who thinks he's a burden on his family? G'wed then.

Love this place  Big Grin

With regards to this US case, two points, the accomplice was a minor hence no death penalty. The State execution protocol has a failsafe if the first lethal injection doesn't work, of a 2nd injection. No one bothered to add a failsafe if the 2nd also doesn't work, so legally they had to stop. Likely she'll have a serious brain injury I'd imagine.

Assuming you're on the wind up but the two examples given couldn't be more different.

State legislated killing criminals, and state legislated killing the sick and elderly (sorry - assisted dying), is state legislated killing at the end of the day.
But different if the subject chooses to die?
I don't know where I sit on the difficult debate around assisted dying.
But I do know that it's more complicated than that.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)