So, if I'm interpreting these exchanges correctly, there's an argument to be had that fiscal drag is actually a good thing as it progressively pulls more low-end earners into paying tax to relieve some of the disproportionate burden on high-earners?
|
Taxing Times for Labour
|
|
09-10-2026, 02:28 PM
(09-10-2026, 08:41 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Never ceases to amaze how quickly people fall over themselves in defence of people who have more money than you or I could spend in a dozen lifetimes. I'm not defending the wealthy from avoiding taxes. If I had my way, we would be in the EU. That would allow us to have a common consolidated corporate tax base, we could also harmonise top tax rates and use the single markets economic power on other countries with dodgy tax practices. There could be an EU exit tax as well. This ultimately is why we left the EU. The Rees Moggs of this world wanted us out precisely for these reasons--complex cross-country tax rules allow you to shift profits. Tax harminisation stops it. If we could do that, it would raise rates on the wealthy it would also mean lower rates on the people who earn between 80-150k, who may sound rich but are often working their asses off to pay for an expensive mortgage. The looney Brexiteers just use immigration as the cover to hide the real reason they wanted out--the ability to hide taxes and wealth.
09-10-2026, 02:39 PM
(09-10-2026, 02:28 PM)Logic1 Wrote:(09-10-2026, 08:41 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Never ceases to amaze how quickly people fall over themselves in defence of people who have more money than you or I could spend in a dozen lifetimes. But in practice Luxembourg still gets to offer Amazon a corporate tax haven.
I think the fact that we are so soft on allowing the offshoring of profits earned in the UK qualifies us as a tax haven of sorts. The sort where the money is made before being 'placed across the border'.
That last bit is a quote from the Flemish Ministry of Economic Affairs in response to a company I was working for overdoing the extent to which the mickey was being taken. A line had been drawn... (09-10-2026, 02:28 PM)Logic1 Wrote: I'm not defending the wealthy from avoiding taxes. If I had my way, we would be in the EU. That would allow us to have a common consolidated corporate tax base, we could also harmonise top tax rates and use the single markets economic power on other countries with dodgy tax practices. There could be an EU exit tax as well. This ultimately is why we left the EU. The Rees Moggs of this world wanted us out precisely for these reasons--complex cross-country tax rules allow you to shift profits. Tax harminisation stops it. If we could do that, it would raise rates on the wealthy it would also mean lower rates on the people who earn between 80-150k, who may sound rich but are often working their asses off to pay for an expensive mortgage. The looney Brexiteers just use immigration as the cover to hide the real reason they wanted out--the ability to hide taxes and wealth. The opt-out from tax harmonisation, together with similarly the Euro and Schengen - none of them exactly minor concessions - suggests that the arguments that we used to jump whenever the EU said so were a bit fatuous. (09-10-2026, 12:44 PM)Øssian Wrote: So, if I'm interpreting these exchanges correctly, there's an argument to be had that fiscal drag is actually a good thing as it progressively pulls more low-end earners into paying tax to relieve some of the disproportionate burden on high-earners? Fiscal drag, and the other ridiculous benefit and tax cliff edges simply serve as a brake on aspiration. Unless you're some kind of lunatic or have an enormous mortgage, there is no point slogging your guts out for 40p in the £1 or much less. But it's also true to say that moderate earners do not pay enough tax, leaving us massively over reliant on those who will walk when squeezed too tightly. It also brings us back to the problem, that not enough people are economically active either. And of those that are working Pensioners are exempt from NI which is crackers. (09-10-2026, 12:32 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: It's not envious to call anyone who refuses to share as big a slice as possible when they have more money than most other people combined a selfish cunt, because that's what they are. The fact is that Rokos did share an enormous amount of income with the country for many years, and now he won't. In part that is due to the attitude of people like you who feel the state is somehow entitled to more and more of an individual's income or private wealth. Once you go beyond what any individual (including you) believe is fair then behaviour (including yours) will inevitably change. It's pretty stupid and naive to believe that it won't - yet the party of government is about to layer yet more taxes on businesses and individuals, whilst also believing that building Council Houses will pay for the shortfall in our Defence budget. Just when you think the quality of our governance can't sink any further we are reaching a new low.
09-10-2026, 07:47 PM
You are shamelessly bandwagon jumping Proth. Bloke makes money in a relatively short space of time, realises he’s become mega rich and decides to move to a country that doesn’t tax him as much. Your pathetic argument about it taking x number of hamsters to spin a wheel to make up for it is simply shameful, when you are arguing that people like him and many more should be incentivised to stay and the result of that is that many more hamsters have to spin the wheel.
Fucks sake, the bloke hasn’t even spoken about the reasons he’s leaving.
09-10-2026, 09:31 PM
Does a hedge-fund produce anything meaningful?
(09-10-2026, 07:47 PM)baggy1 Wrote: You are shamelessly bandwagon jumping Proth. Bloke makes money in a relatively short space of time, realises he’s become mega rich and decides to move to a country that doesn’t tax him as much. Your pathetic argument about it taking x number of hamsters to spin a wheel to make up for it is simply shameful, when you are arguing that people like him and many more should be incentivised to stay and the result of that is that many more hamsters have to spin the wheel. My argument is that we should be incentivising more bigger hamsters to spin bigger wheels rather then them fucking off to Monaco, or Texas, or Dubai or Greece. I think your attitude is incredibly flippant and avoids the reality that everyone who goes means more of the burden falls on the rest of us. I've been out tonight to the 30th anniversary of the developer I used to work for before the GFC. Neither of the founders were there. Guess where they live now. (09-10-2026, 09:31 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Does a hedge-fund produce anything meaningful? Good ones do, yes. What a stupid question.
09-10-2026, 10:34 PM
You appear to be arguing that rich people should be incentivised to stay in the Uk instead of doing what rich people have done forever which is fuck off somewhere hot. Not everyone makes decisions based on how much tax they pay. Your own argument is that rich people should pay less tax - that in itself means someone has to make up the shortfall. It’s an idiotic stance
09-11-2026, 05:47 AM
(09-10-2026, 09:56 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(09-10-2026, 07:47 PM)baggy1 Wrote: You are shamelessly bandwagon jumping Proth. Bloke makes money in a relatively short space of time, realises he’s become mega rich and decides to move to a country that doesn’t tax him as much. Your pathetic argument about it taking x number of hamsters to spin a wheel to make up for it is simply shameful, when you are arguing that people like him and many more should be incentivised to stay and the result of that is that many more hamsters have to spin the wheel. Which is? |
|
« Next Oldest | Next Newest »
|
Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)

