Taxing Times for Labour
#31
(09-09-2026, 01:47 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-09-2026, 10:09 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Roles was estimated to be worth £800m in 2020, six years later he is worth £2.3 billion.

And yet some people will argue that there hasn't been a transfer of wealth from the majority to the extremely wealthy minority.

In March 2020 the S&P stood at 2400. Today it is 7700.

If a Hedge Fund manager hadn't got substantially more wealthy since Covid then he wouldn't be doing his job.

In fact the growth in his personal wealth has significantly underperformed the S&P.

Exactly what wealth has been "transferred" from who to who?

None, to no-one, from nobody.
Reply
#32
(09-09-2026, 12:17 PM)Logic1 Wrote:
(09-09-2026, 09:06 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-09-2026, 07:51 AM)Logic1 Wrote: I agree with you on this. There will be numerous middle class families, who with young kids get significant benefits and child benefit which means they essentially pay no tax. 100k is supposed to be a high salary in the UK. If you earn that, you pay 30k in tax. I know of a family where both earners get around 50k, live in a 900k house, alter their work and pension contributions to ensure they continue to get the child benefit.

Yep. And have no incentive to take a promotion or work more hours because of it.

PAYE and SA are riddled with disincentives. The Child Benefit and £100K cliff edges have arithmetically insane effects on marginal rates of tax.

I used to do a managerial role. For that I got a small honorarium. When my term ended, the opportunity came up again 3 years later. I basically couldn't be arsed. Why take on the pressure and stress when the government gets 62% or I stick it in my pension and have it later (who knows, I might die early). The tax cliff edges are absolutely daft. For many public sector, quasi-public sector jobs, there is no point getting promoted. 

The taking away of child benefit cost me 20k
The increase of VAT on private schools cost me another 20k (my daughter was in one before the tax had even been put in Labour's manifesto, so I'm hardly taking her out of the school as she has all her friends). Hence, why bother trying to get another promotion.

Well there is one person on here who would comprehensively disagree that the disincentives you describe actually matter and perhaps also have a snipe that "if you can afford private education etc". 

Which essentially encapsulates much that is wrong in this country. In particular most people don't recognise just how much tax thresholds have been eroded by inflation and government freezes, and that this really does have real impacts on behaviour.
Reply
#33
(09-10-2026, 07:08 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-09-2026, 12:17 PM)Logic1 Wrote:
(09-09-2026, 09:06 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-09-2026, 07:51 AM)Logic1 Wrote: I agree with you on this. There will be numerous middle class families, who with young kids get significant benefits and child benefit which means they essentially pay no tax. 100k is supposed to be a high salary in the UK. If you earn that, you pay 30k in tax. I know of a family where both earners get around 50k, live in a 900k house, alter their work and pension contributions to ensure they continue to get the child benefit.

Yep. And have no incentive to take a promotion or work more hours because of it.

PAYE and SA are riddled with disincentives. The Child Benefit and £100K cliff edges have arithmetically insane effects on marginal rates of tax.

I used to do a managerial role. For that I got a small honorarium. When my term ended, the opportunity came up again 3 years later. I basically couldn't be arsed. Why take on the pressure and stress when the government gets 62% or I stick it in my pension and have it later (who knows, I might die early). The tax cliff edges are absolutely daft. For many public sector, quasi-public sector jobs, there is no point getting promoted. 

The taking away of child benefit cost me 20k
The increase of VAT on private schools cost me another 20k (my daughter was in one before the tax had even been put in Labour's manifesto, so I'm hardly taking her out of the school as she has all her friends). Hence, why bother trying to get another promotion.

Well there is one person on here who would comprehensively disagree that the disincentives you describe actually matter and perhaps also have a snipe that "if you can afford private education etc". 

Which essentially encapsulates much that is wrong in this country. In particular most people don't recognise just how much tax thresholds have been eroded by inflation and government freezes, and that this really does have real impacts on behaviour.

I don't know who that person is, but doubt they have ever managed people and likely bumble along in the 40-50k range and get frustrated with all the people around them getting promoted and not them.
Reply
#34
Never ceases to amaze how quickly people fall over themselves in defence of people who have more money than you or I could spend in a dozen lifetimes.

Keep punching down at the easy targets, lads.
Reply
#35
I'm more concerned about replacing the £1 in every £1000 Income Tax that this guy paid. If that doesn't concern you too then I can't help you because you're completely missing the point.
Reply
#36
What is the reason he has left Proth? Which new tax has finally done it for him?
Reply
#37
I think it's more a question of "what has the UK done to incentivise him remaining here?" - and for the thick end of 20 years, the answer is - nothing.

The drip drip of anti-entrepreneurial sentiment in this country has become a torrent. At the same time the public finances are such a catastrophe that increased taxes are inevitable. High income individuals already pay a hugely disproportionate amount of income tax. Every time one leaves the burden will fall more greatly on lightly taxed lower and middle earners.

The very people, who have zero incentive to work more hours or take a promotion because of tax and benefit cliff edges.

How do you propose we replace that £1 in every £1000 Income Tax that has now gone?
Reply
#38
So nothing new then. Bloke makes money and goes to a warm country to pay less tax shocker. Are you going to be running this thread every time we get a new taxpayer come into the country to tell those of us at the twilight of our taxpaying years that we can ease off?
Reply
#39
You cannot change the return on owning, investing and creating capital and assume nobody changes their behaviour. That is where the politics and economics of envy becomes expensive.

Like I asked, how do replace someone who paid £1 in every £1,000 Income Tax if your whole narrative and policy platform disincentivises wealth creation and demonises the wealthy?

You also need to replace Nassef Sawiris, John Fredriksen, Lakshmi Mittal, Michael Platt, Jim Ratcliffe, Christian Angermayer - even Eddie Hearn FFS.

I look forward to your schedule of HNW tax payers who've chosen to domicile themselves here in the last few years. I suspect it won't take me long to read it.
Reply
#40
It's not envious to call anyone who refuses to share as big a slice as possible when they have more money than most other people combined a selfish cunt, because that's what they are.

Even more so in the context of a society where so many issues felt by those who have the least are being laid at the doors of the defenceless (usually immigrants) for the gain of the super-wealthy.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)