Taxing Times for Labour
#21
(09-08-2026, 08:56 PM)Logic1 Wrote:
(09-08-2026, 12:33 PM)Protheroe Wrote: £330 Million this year would pay the salary of:

10,200 new police constables
or 10,000 newly qualified nurses
or 9,700 newly qualified teachers

or Half the cost of the Wednesbury to Brierley Hill Metro Extension

or 1,400 new 3-bed social houses

or 1/3 of the total cost of the Midland Metrpolitan University Hospital

That's the cost of Chris Rokos choosing to change his tax domicile to Greece.

Replacing him requires 115,000 Basic Rate taxpayers.
Shame he's leaving. But highly unlikely to be that much...

https://x.com/TaxJusticeUK/status/2097356592152748434

Fine. Let them all go then. You have a very inappropriate username.

(09-08-2026, 08:39 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-08-2026, 08:03 PM)Fido Wrote: The question you really want to find the answer to is what is the tipping point for such a person or company to decide and up sticks because you don't really want to be responsible for any others making the same move.

No, the actual question that needs to be answered is what is the tipping point for the British public to be able to admit their follies and demands are fucking stupid to be able to stomach the currently politically impossible things to fix the fiscal and economic constraints, while hoping that geopolitical bullshit that we didn't ask for but are subjected to via knock-ons on inflation and therefore monetary policy are resolved favourably to us quickly.

The government needs taxes to pay for things, someone's got to pay those taxes especially when interest rates are pushed up and spending is going up. Are Brexit voters going to accept rejoining the single market? Are retired voters going to accept paying the same amount of tax as workers? Are lower earners going to accept paying more tax to reduce the tax disparity? Are Trump and Putin going to fuck off? Are the media classes and their paymasters going to accept VAT and land tax reforms? I doubt it. So we're stuck treading water while productivity picks up, which it is but that's going to take a fair while to happen to have any meaningful effect.

Nothing at all about the nature of the state, what it does and what it doesn't do, what it should and what it shouldn't do. And with it's dire productivity, how on Earth it will ever provide for the needs of the country let alone the wants.

But I'm glad you raise this issue of taxation of the lower paid. That's the elephant in the room here. The lower paid are undertaxed, leaving us reliant on receipts from the higher paid. Idiots, particularly handwringing middle class idiots banging on about Wealth Taxes better be careful what they wish for.
Reply
#22
(09-08-2026, 10:23 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-08-2026, 08:56 PM)Logic1 Wrote:
(09-08-2026, 12:33 PM)Protheroe Wrote: £330 Million this year would pay the salary of:

10,200 new police constables
or 10,000 newly qualified nurses
or 9,700 newly qualified teachers

or Half the cost of the Wednesbury to Brierley Hill Metro Extension

or 1,400 new 3-bed social houses

or 1/3 of the total cost of the Midland Metrpolitan University Hospital

That's the cost of Chris Rokos choosing to change his tax domicile to Greece.

Replacing him requires 115,000 Basic Rate taxpayers.
Shame he's leaving. But highly unlikely to be that much...

https://x.com/TaxJusticeUK/status/2097356592152748434

Fine. Let them all go then. You have a very inappropriate username.

(09-08-2026, 08:39 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-08-2026, 08:03 PM)Fido Wrote: The question you really want to find the answer to is what is the tipping point for such a person or company to decide and up sticks because you don't really want to be responsible for any others making the same move.

No, the actual question that needs to be answered is what is the tipping point for the British public to be able to admit their follies and demands are fucking stupid to be able to stomach the currently politically impossible things to fix the fiscal and economic constraints, while hoping that geopolitical bullshit that we didn't ask for but are subjected to via knock-ons on inflation and therefore monetary policy are resolved favourably to us quickly.

The government needs taxes to pay for things, someone's got to pay those taxes especially when interest rates are pushed up and spending is going up. Are Brexit voters going to accept rejoining the single market? Are retired voters going to accept paying the same amount of tax as workers? Are lower earners going to accept paying more tax to reduce the tax disparity? Are Trump and Putin going to fuck off? Are the media classes and their paymasters going to accept VAT and land tax reforms? I doubt it. So we're stuck treading water while productivity picks up, which it is but that's going to take a fair while to happen to have any meaningful effect.

Nothing at all about the nature of the state, what it does and what it doesn't do, what it should and what it shouldn't do. And with it's dire productivity, how on Earth it will ever provide for the needs of the country let alone the wants.

But I'm glad you raise this issue of taxation of the lower paid. That's the elephant in the room here. The lower paid are undertaxed, leaving us reliant on receipts from the higher paid. Idiots, particularly handwringing middle class idiots banging on about Wealth Taxes better be careful what they wish for.
I agree with you on this. There will be numerous middle class families, who with young kids get significant benefits and child benefit which means they essentially pay no tax. 100k is supposed to be a high salary in the UK. If you earn that, you pay 30k in tax. I know of a family where both earners get around 50k, live in a 900k house, alter their work and pension contributions to ensure they continue to get the child benefit.
Reply
#23
(09-09-2026, 07:51 AM)Logic1 Wrote: I agree with you on this. There will be numerous middle class families, who with young kids get significant benefits and child benefit which means they essentially pay no tax. 100k is supposed to be a high salary in the UK. If you earn that, you pay 30k in tax. I know of a family where both earners get around 50k, live in a 900k house, alter their work and pension contributions to ensure they continue to get the child benefit.

Yep. And have no incentive to take a promotion or work more hours because of it.

PAYE and SA are riddled with disincentives. The Child Benefit and £100K cliff edges have arithmetically insane effects on marginal rates of tax.
Reply
#24
Roles was estimated to be worth £800m in 2020, six years later he is worth £2.3 billion.

And yet some people will argue that there hasn't been a transfer of wealth from the majority to the extremely wealthy minority.
Reply
#25
(09-09-2026, 10:09 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Roles was estimated to be worth £800m in 2020, six years later he is worth £2.3 billion.

And yet some people will argue that there hasn't been a transfer of wealth from the majority to the extremely wealthy minority.

It’s the divide between rich and poor has actually fallen… 

Yours Proth
Reply
#26
(09-09-2026, 10:38 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-09-2026, 10:09 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Roles was estimated to be worth £800m in 2020, six years later he is worth £2.3 billion.

And yet some people will argue that there hasn't been a transfer of wealth from the majority to the extremely wealthy minority.

It’s the divide between rich and poor has actually fallen… 

Yours Proth

The tax received on the difference between 2020 and 2026 would have been very handy for supporting public services, I agree.
Reply
#27
(09-08-2026, 10:23 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-08-2026, 08:39 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-08-2026, 08:03 PM)Fido Wrote: The question you really want to find the answer to is what is the tipping point for such a person or company to decide and up sticks because you don't really want to be responsible for any others making the same move.

No, the actual question that needs to be answered is what is the tipping point for the British public to be able to admit their follies and demands are fucking stupid to be able to stomach the currently politically impossible things to fix the fiscal and economic constraints, while hoping that geopolitical bullshit that we didn't ask for but are subjected to via knock-ons on inflation and therefore monetary policy are resolved favourably to us quickly.

The government needs taxes to pay for things, someone's got to pay those taxes especially when interest rates are pushed up and spending is going up. Are Brexit voters going to accept rejoining the single market? Are retired voters going to accept paying the same amount of tax as workers? Are lower earners going to accept paying more tax to reduce the tax disparity? Are Trump and Putin going to fuck off? Are the media classes and their paymasters going to accept VAT and land tax reforms? I doubt it. So we're stuck treading water while productivity picks up, which it is but that's going to take a fair while to happen to have any meaningful effect.

Nothing at all about the nature of the state, what it does and what it doesn't do, what it should and what it shouldn't do. And with it's dire productivity, how on Earth it will ever provide for the needs of the country let alone the wants.

But I'm glad you raise this issue of taxation of the lower paid. That's the elephant in the room here. The lower paid are undertaxed, leaving us reliant on receipts from the higher paid. Idiots, particularly handwringing middle class idiots banging on about Wealth Taxes better be careful what they wish for.

Not trying to be snippy but what do you think I meant by "British public to be able to admit their follies and demands are fucking stupid"?
Reply
#28
(09-09-2026, 10:52 AM)Fido Wrote:
(09-09-2026, 10:38 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-09-2026, 10:09 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Roles was estimated to be worth £800m in 2020, six years later he is worth £2.3 billion.

And yet some people will argue that there hasn't been a transfer of wealth from the majority to the extremely wealthy minority.

It’s the divide between rich and poor has actually fallen… 

Yours Proth

The tax received on the difference between 2020 and 2026 would have been very handy for supporting public services, I agree.

I agree inequality isn’t a problem and the less governments do about it the less of an issue it’ll become. 

Yours Proth
Reply
#29
(09-09-2026, 09:06 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-09-2026, 07:51 AM)Logic1 Wrote: I agree with you on this. There will be numerous middle class families, who with young kids get significant benefits and child benefit which means they essentially pay no tax. 100k is supposed to be a high salary in the UK. If you earn that, you pay 30k in tax. I know of a family where both earners get around 50k, live in a 900k house, alter their work and pension contributions to ensure they continue to get the child benefit.

Yep. And have no incentive to take a promotion or work more hours because of it.

PAYE and SA are riddled with disincentives. The Child Benefit and £100K cliff edges have arithmetically insane effects on marginal rates of tax.

I used to do a managerial role. For that I got a small honorarium. When my term ended, the opportunity came up again 3 years later. I basically couldn't be arsed. Why take on the pressure and stress when the government gets 62% or I stick it in my pension and have it later (who knows, I might die early). The tax cliff edges are absolutely daft. For many public sector, quasi-public sector jobs, there is no point getting promoted. 

The taking away of child benefit cost me 20k
The increase of VAT on private schools cost me another 20k (my daughter was in one before the tax had even been put in Labour's manifesto, so I'm hardly taking her out of the school as she has all her friends). Hence, why bother trying to get another promotion.
Reply
#30
(09-09-2026, 10:09 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Roles was estimated to be worth £800m in 2020, six years later he is worth £2.3 billion.

And yet some people will argue that there hasn't been a transfer of wealth from the majority to the extremely wealthy minority.

In March 2020 the S&P stood at 2400. Today it is 7700.

If a Hedge Fund manager hadn't got substantially more wealthy since Covid then he wouldn't be doing his job.

In fact the growth in his personal wealth has significantly underperformed the S&P.

Exactly what wealth has been "transferred" from who to who?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: