Taxing Times for Labour
#11
The question you really want to find the answer to is what is the tipping point for such a person or company to decide and up sticks because you don't really want to be responsible for any others making the same move.
Reply
#12
(09-08-2026, 08:03 PM)Fido Wrote: The question you really want to find the answer to is what is the tipping point for such a person or company to decide and up sticks because you don't really want to be responsible for any others making the same move.

Might be a bit of a stretch to get inside the mind of someone who has accumulated a personal fortune measured in billions but is still having a grump about his 'stoppages' like we used to back in the days of a wage packet.
Reply
#13
The tipping point is the same as anything Fido, he's 56, a billionaire and set up for life. He'll be able to move to a country that offers him tax advantages that we can't afford, a luxurious lifestyle in a warm country and he will drop in and out of the UK when he needs to. When you have that much money you can do what you like that is what happens. This is as much about his stage of life as it is taxes. Good luck to him, he has the choices - me personally I'd be happy living a luxurious life with a wealth that will last generations and pay whatever tax is due. There also appears to be a narrative that he has moved for tax reasons based entirely on no quotes at all.
Reply
#14
(09-08-2026, 08:14 PM)Øssian Wrote:
(09-08-2026, 08:03 PM)Fido Wrote: The question you really want to find the answer to is what is the tipping point for such a person or company to decide and up sticks because you don't really want to be responsible for any others making the same move.

Might be a bit of a stretch to get inside the mind of someone who has accumulated a personal fortune measured in billions but is still having a grump about his 'stoppages' like we used to back in the days of a wage packet.

Oh, it's a completely different world and nothing I can comprehend, for sure. But if the fella was "fine" paying 300m but the extra 10% of whatever was enough for him to decide to move the whole company then it's something that HMRC should try and get some kind of an insight into. There are loads of folks the world over running FP&A and pricing models to get the right price/margin for their company's products and services to ensure they keep customers and find more with much smaller sums involved.

It'd be interesting to know what kind of leeway is afforded to HMRC as well to convince companies to stay or move to the country. Switzerland have done pretty well in this regard over the years.
Reply
#15
(09-08-2026, 08:03 PM)Fido Wrote: The question you really want to find the answer to is what is the tipping point for such a person or company to decide and up sticks because you don't really want to be responsible for any others making the same move.

No, the actual question that needs to be answered is what is the tipping point for the British public to be able to admit their follies and demands are fucking stupid to be able to stomach the currently politically impossible things to fix the fiscal and economic constraints, while hoping that geopolitical bullshit that we didn't ask for but are subjected to via knock-ons on inflation and therefore monetary policy are resolved favourably to us quickly.

The government needs taxes to pay for things, someone's got to pay those taxes especially when interest rates are pushed up and spending is going up. Are Brexit voters going to accept rejoining the single market? Are retired voters going to accept paying the same amount of tax as workers? Are lower earners going to accept paying more tax to reduce the tax disparity? Are Trump and Putin going to fuck off? Are the media classes and their paymasters going to accept VAT and land tax reforms? I doubt it. So we're stuck treading water while productivity picks up, which it is but that's going to take a fair while to happen to have any meaningful effect.
Reply
#16
(09-08-2026, 08:39 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-08-2026, 08:03 PM)Fido Wrote: The question you really want to find the answer to is what is the tipping point for such a person or company to decide and up sticks because you don't really want to be responsible for any others making the same move.

No, the actual question that needs to be answered is what is the tipping point for the British public to be able to admit their follies and demands are fucking stupid to be able to stomach the currently politically impossible things to fix the fiscal and economic constraints, while hoping that geopolitical bullshit that we didn't ask for but are subjected to via knock-ons on inflation and therefore monetary policy are resolved favourably to us quickly.

The government needs taxes to pay for things, someone's got to pay those taxes especially when interest rates are pushed up and spending is going up. Are Brexit voters going to accept rejoining the single market? Are retired voters going to accept paying the same amount of tax as workers? Are lower earners going to accept paying more tax to reduce the tax disparity? Are Trump and Putin going to fuck off? Are the media classes and their paymasters going to accept VAT and land tax reforms? I doubt it. So we're stuck treading water while productivity picks up, which it is but that's going to take a fair while to happen to have any meaningful effect.

Just for the sake of clarity I was keeping to the theme of the OP without throwing other variants into the mix.
Reply
#17
(09-08-2026, 08:24 PM)Fido Wrote: It'd be interesting to know what kind of leeway is afforded to HMRC as well to convince companies to stay or move to the country. Switzerland have done pretty well in this regard over the years.

Switzerland is a more productive economy, has much better infrastructure to support businesses for both economic services and things like energy and transport all while having fewer trade barriers on its imports and exports of goods, services and people. And while it does need to deal with parts of its population trying to vote for something stupid every few years it has an extremely stable political outlook that encourages cross-party consensus and a stable environment with low levels of national debt. 

HMRC can't promise any of that. It could look at what Greece has done with a one-off payment to avoid tax but as per Italy and Portugal that has issues which manifested and caused them to either lax or abandon similar schemes.
Reply
#18
(09-08-2026, 12:33 PM)Protheroe Wrote: £330 Million this year would pay the salary of:

10,200 new police constables
or 10,000 newly qualified nurses
or 9,700 newly qualified teachers

or Half the cost of the Wednesbury to Brierley Hill Metro Extension

or 1,400 new 3-bed social houses

or 1/3 of the total cost of the Midland Metrpolitan University Hospital

That's the cost of Chris Rokos choosing to change his tax domicile to Greece.

Replacing him requires 115,000 Basic Rate taxpayers.
Shame he's leaving. But highly unlikely to be that much...

https://x.com/TaxJusticeUK/status/2097356592152748434
Reply
#19
(09-08-2026, 08:43 PM)Fido Wrote:
(09-08-2026, 08:39 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-08-2026, 08:03 PM)Fido Wrote: The question you really want to find the answer to is what is the tipping point for such a person or company to decide and up sticks because you don't really want to be responsible for any others making the same move.

No, the actual question that needs to be answered is what is the tipping point for the British public to be able to admit their follies and demands are fucking stupid to be able to stomach the currently politically impossible things to fix the fiscal and economic constraints, while hoping that geopolitical bullshit that we didn't ask for but are subjected to via knock-ons on inflation and therefore monetary policy are resolved favourably to us quickly.

The government needs taxes to pay for things, someone's got to pay those taxes especially when interest rates are pushed up and spending is going up. Are Brexit voters going to accept rejoining the single market? Are retired voters going to accept paying the same amount of tax as workers? Are lower earners going to accept paying more tax to reduce the tax disparity? Are Trump and Putin going to fuck off? Are the media classes and their paymasters going to accept VAT and land tax reforms? I doubt it. So we're stuck treading water while productivity picks up, which it is but that's going to take a fair while to happen to have any meaningful effect.

Just for the sake of clarity I was keeping to the theme of the OP without throwing other variants into the mix.

The tipping point is constrained by the needs of whatever government in charge of the state needs to do to get elected. The British state has to mask the issues that have manifested and compounded over the last 112 years that have led to this point. Are you willing to pay more tax so billionaires stay? Do you think the British public as a whole are?
Reply
#20
(09-08-2026, 08:56 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-08-2026, 08:43 PM)Fido Wrote:
(09-08-2026, 08:39 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-08-2026, 08:03 PM)Fido Wrote: The question you really want to find the answer to is what is the tipping point for such a person or company to decide and up sticks because you don't really want to be responsible for any others making the same move.

No, the actual question that needs to be answered is what is the tipping point for the British public to be able to admit their follies and demands are fucking stupid to be able to stomach the currently politically impossible things to fix the fiscal and economic constraints, while hoping that geopolitical bullshit that we didn't ask for but are subjected to via knock-ons on inflation and therefore monetary policy are resolved favourably to us quickly.

The government needs taxes to pay for things, someone's got to pay those taxes especially when interest rates are pushed up and spending is going up. Are Brexit voters going to accept rejoining the single market? Are retired voters going to accept paying the same amount of tax as workers? Are lower earners going to accept paying more tax to reduce the tax disparity? Are Trump and Putin going to fuck off? Are the media classes and their paymasters going to accept VAT and land tax reforms? I doubt it. So we're stuck treading water while productivity picks up, which it is but that's going to take a fair while to happen to have any meaningful effect.

Just for the sake of clarity I was keeping to the theme of the OP without throwing other variants into the mix.

The tipping point is constrained by the needs of whatever government in charge of the state needs to do to get elected. The British state has to mask the issues that have manifested and compounded over the last 112 years that have led to this point. Are you willing to pay more tax so billionaires stay? Do you think the British public as a whole are?

Alternatively, can you afford to pay more tax if they leave, or do you support public spending cuts if they leave, or are you happy to increase state borrowing if they leave?

It's a binary debate at its core.

Depending on, if like Proth, you think the tax base is fragile, or if you believe the alternative, that the tax base is resilient.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)