Bellingham v Edwards
#11
(07-14-2026, 07:38 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Bellingham will never had a dual carriageway way named after him.

Duncan Edward’s never had his shirt number retired  Tongue
Reply
#12
(07-14-2026, 07:38 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Bellingham will never had a dual carriageway way named after him.

He does have a bridge named after him. Having said that, it’s a HS2 bridge - poor delivery, overpriced, great for Birmingham but inadequate for England aren’t exactly the connotations Jude will want to be associated with…
Reply
#13
I unfortunately never got to see Edwards play, but I do remember this I was told Man Utd were playing in Europe I think and someone in the crowd said who is this guy. Edwards everyone is raving about he’s done nothing. The next Minute Edwards picks up the ball strides past 2 players and from 30yards plants it in the top corner. The Guy turned round and said I rest my case. If true I don’t know but a great story.
From what I was told by family and friends he was out of this world. Having said that Bellingham even at his young age is probably the best I have seen in an England shirt wonderful player.
Reply
#14
Bryan Robson might be an easier comparison with Bellingham, simply because more posters will have seen him play at club and international level.
Reply
#15
Bellingham frequently turns up in big games/competitions. Not sure the same could be said for Robson (English teams were shit, internationally and banned, at a club level). Or Gascoigne, to a lesser degree, for that matter.

I can’t compare Edwards but it goes without saying (so I’ll say it) - it was a different game then, so comparisons are unfair. I watched a fair chunk of the 66 WC Final. There was some right cloggers in that game - very average when compared to the skill, pace and technique of, even, some of the early exits from this year’s WC.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#16
(07-14-2026, 11:18 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Bellingham frequently turns up in big games/competitions. Not sure the same could be said for Robson (English teams were shit, internationally and banned, at a club level). Or Gascoigne, to a lesser degree, for that matter.

I can’t compare Edwards but it goes without saying (so I’ll say it) - it was a different game then, so comparisons are unfair. I watched a fair chunk of the 66 WC Final. There was some right cloggers in that game - very average when compared to the skill, pace and technique of, even, some of the early exits from this year’s WC.

You are an utter wind up merchant and don’t have a clue about football, if you think the 66 World Cup winners were cloggers you really ought to get a life.  Angry
Reply
#17
"you really ought to get a life"

arf!

Sundog reincarnated
Reply
#18
Of course it's impossible to compare. Bobby Charlton's famous quote and numerous other utterances by the generations that started me off going to football, are all we have to go on. JB is probably the most effective English player in my lifetime, surpassing Bryan Robson.
My dad and grandad knew the Edwards's, they lived by me. They vouched for his brilliance. So much so my grandad who had contacts in the game wrote to Arsenal recommending they sign him. He explained, to everyone's horror,  our local clubs were actually rubbish at looking after the player both financially and medically. Arsenal wrote back explaining they already knew all about him but he was bound elsewhere. All I could say when my grandad told me this was at least Albion wouldn't have got him killed in a plane crash. I was at Big Duncs funeral in my pram, along with everyone else from the Priory/Wrenna and most of Dudley.
Reply
#19
(07-14-2026, 01:03 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: Of course it's impossible to compare. Bobby Charlton's famous quote and numerous other utterances by the generations that started me off going to football, are all we have to go on. JB is probably the most effective English player in my lifetime, surpassing Bryan Robson.
My dad and grandad knew the Edwards's, they lived by me. They vouched for his brilliance. So much so my grandad who had contacts in the game wrote to Arsenal recommending they sign him. He explained, to everyone's horror,  our local clubs were actually rubbish at looking after the player both financially and medically. Arsenal wrote back explaining they already knew all about him but he was bound elsewhere. All I could say when my grandad told me this was at least Albion wouldn't have got him killed in a plane crash. I was at Big Duncs funeral in my pram, along with everyone else from the Priory/Wrenna and most of Dudley.
That's a fantastic post. Exactly the thing I was hoping for. I grew up 4 miles from Dudley and 2 miles from Stourbridge. So Duncan and Jude, although not Baggies, resonate deep within me. To have 2 undoubtedly world class players who come from my roots is something to cherish.

Here's hoping Jude and England bring it home.
Reply
#20
(07-14-2026, 11:41 AM)albion_pigeon Wrote: "you really ought to get a life"

arf!

Sundog reincarnated

IMBERSEAL!!!
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)