![]() |
|
Bellingham v Edwards - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Bellingham v Edwards (/showthread.php?tid=42088) Pages:
1
2
|
Bellingham v Edwards - Albionmad - 07-13-2026 I never saw Edwards play. I was born in 1961. All I have to go on is some grainy footage from yesteryear. By all accounts Duncan was a collosus who never shirked a tackle, was primarily defensive but could get forward without hesitation. It was a different era. Pitches were substandard as were boots and footballs. However subjective it may be I'd be interested to know if Bellingham is comparable in any way with Dudleys's finest son RE: Bellingham v Edwards - baggy1 - 07-13-2026 Big Sam is fuming RE: Bellingham v Edwards - Johnnykayeengland - 07-14-2026 How can we know without evidence? All I know is that Bobby Charlton, maybe England's best ever player, said that Edwards was the best he'd ever seen. Better than him. And he played with Best and Law. .... RE: Bellingham v Edwards - baggiebloke - 07-14-2026 My Dad played against Edwards in an Army match. RE: Bellingham v Edwards - Mullers - 07-14-2026 I was born far too late to see Edwards play, but everything you read and hear from those who did (especially growing up/living in the Black Country) suggests he was one of a kind. For Bobby Charlton to say Edwards was the only player who made him feel inferior says a lot. Terry Venables said had it not been for Munich, it would have been Duncan Edwards lifting the World Cup in 1966, not Bobby Moore. A lot of Man Utd fans from the time get offended when comparisons are made, which seems fair. I remember reading an article about Phil Jones, noting that he was mentioned in the same sentence as Duncan Edwards during his early days at Man Utd, and how that built him up far too much. Jones was good then, but clearly not *that* good. Bellingham on the other hand - I think he might be the best all-round player I’ve ever seen. And in the modern-era for a player of his ability to have such maturity and humility feels rare. However far we go in this World Cup, he’s been incredible. RE: Bellingham v Edwards - baggiebloke - 07-14-2026 For anyone who's interested... https://duncanedwardsunited.com/army-days RE: Bellingham v Edwards - oldun - 07-14-2026 (07-14-2026, 06:53 AM)Mullers Wrote: I was born far too late to see Edwards play, but everything you read and hear from those who did (especially growing up/living in the Black Country) suggests he was one of a kind. For Bobby Charlton to say Edwards was the only player who made him feel inferior says a lot. Terry Venables said had it not been for Munich, it would have been Duncan Edwards lifting the World Cup in 1966, not Bobby Moore. I think I may have seen him play, but Jude is very similar in the way he strides about the pitch RE: Bellingham v Edwards - BertieTheBaggie - 07-14-2026 Thing is it’s impossible nearly to make comparisons with players from The 80s like Maradona v Messi so talking about someone whose heyday was 65 years ago is utterly pointless. For the past 20 years during Messi’s career we’ve seen the big clubs assemble talent like never before helping their star player see more of the ball. We’ve also seen better pitches, higher player protection and sports science help with them keeping themselves in top condition. In this era as the internet has opened up the world we’ve also seen the wonderful goals galore. It’s all created these global stars. Edwards had a couple of great years but the footage of him is so rare that all we have is stories. Let’s face it the evidence of Pele being the best ever gets overlooked now due to the fact that we have so little of his goals on video. To add to this is emotional attachment. Find blokes 50 plus and most will say Maradona is the best player ever. The era saying Pele are almost gone. Even 70 year olds only just about remember the tale end of his career and only saw 2-3 games he was in. Bellingham, Messi etc etc have had unique conditions backed by huge amounts of money allowing them to flourish. Edwards might have been the best player these isles had ever produced but some Pathe news clips from the days of Billy Haley and brylcreem isn’t going to cut it. RE: Bellingham v Edwards - Peachy - 07-14-2026 Bellingham is the sort of player that if you asked him to play centre half for a game of magnitude he'd look absolute class doing it. He is a special talent without a doubt. RE: Bellingham v Edwards - Josh1873 - 07-14-2026 Bellingham will never had a dual carriageway way named after him. |