Well done Thieves
#61
(06-24-2026, 11:47 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-24-2026, 11:24 AM)baggy1 Wrote: It is taxed, as part of inheritance tax.

[Image: giphy.gif]

I've never seen the fascination with this 'wholly unearned income' line. It's an investment that has added benefits i.e. a roof over your head, in the same way that you will have benefits when you invest in shares i.e. value of the shares plus the dividends. House value is taxed by stamp duty at point of purchase / sale and ultimately as part of inheritance tax or taxed on profit on sale if it is a second home / rental. 

Added to that you are taxed annually on the value through council tax and there is this new annual tax, is it over £2m, that doesn't impact me so I haven't looked at it.

How many ways do you want to tax it?
Reply
#62
Well inheritance tax wont apply on your main home if it is left to direct descendants and less than £1 million, £500,000 per person, so that removes the IHT clause.

Stamp Duty is a tax to the purchaser not the seller so has nothing to do with growth.

Stating that your home is an investment is part of the problem. Its not subject to CGT, if it was then you would be taxed on the growth less any expenses, as happens with rental properties.

I should also add that CGT dies with you, so any growth in additional properties/assets is untaxed completely for the owner of the asset.

The current Council Tax system is also an utter shambles and be interesting to see how that evolves when revaluing is done for the new rules in 2029. The cynic in me can see bands being amended and council tax rates being hiked accordingly.
Reply
#63
The final point is the key one - if the Council Tax system is a shambles, how is anyone planning on introducing a land value tax?

Point 1 is oversimplifying a bit and you do need to take into account all assets and not just house value plus the figure you use is for two people, not just one.

Point 2 is pretty irrelevant because the tax is being paid on the growth by someone, it's not uncollected.

Point 3 highlights that some properties are taxed on value.
Reply
#64
If a Land Value Tax is going to be introduced then the system will need to overhauled, I suspect that is the reason why the additional Council Tax charge has been deferred until 2028. I also don't understand why the upper limit on the new 'Mansion Tax' is £5 million. The residents of Bishops Avenue must be laughing their nuts off.

Its hardly oversimplifying it, the RNRB was bought in by Osborne specifically for that reason. The growth in your main residence is untaxed via PPR already, the obsession with protecting the value and passing everything to descendants is part of the problem

Stamp Duty is not paid on growth, its paid on the value and ultimately its a charge for transferring an asset. It should be binned off, utterly useless tax.

Rental properties are investments and like most other investment subject to CGT on sale/transfer. The fact that you can hold them until death and any retained gain is wiped is utterly ridiculous. Just encouraging people to hoard assets and no 'income' for the current Government of the day.

In the next 20/30 years we are going to see a ginormous transfer of wealth, without wishing to generalise completely (and then does) the next generation are far more interested in doing what they want to do now and not worried about the future. Be past my time on this planet regardless
Reply
#65
Agree, £5m seems pretty pointless as the whole point is to tax the mansions (just not the really big ones apparently)

It is oversimplifying it, as the allowance is to cover all assets, your wording suggests that just the house value is taxed. With pensions added in then there is definitely going to be an increase in taxation revenue.

Yes you are correct, I did see me word it as growth and thought about editing but thought that would be cheating, especially if you'd already started a response.

The rental properties point - does that happen often? I would have thought, with no basis, that people would just sell up and take the funds from the property when a) they needed it or b) renting became a pain. And I get what you are saying about CGT at that point but doesn't that increase the likelihood of paying IHT on that property (at a higher rate)?

Agree generally about the final point although the experience with my kids is that they are working hard to build their lives now and we might pass on anything left to the grandkids, which I can see happening more and more.
Reply
#66
(06-24-2026, 12:42 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I've never seen the fascination with this 'wholly unearned income' line. It's an investment that has added benefits i.e. a roof over your head, in the same way that you will have benefits when you invest in shares i.e. value of the shares plus the dividends. House value is taxed by stamp duty at point of purchase / sale and ultimately as part of inheritance tax or taxed on profit on sale if it is a second home / rental. 

Added to that you are taxed annually on the value through council tax and there is this new annual tax, is it over £2m, that doesn't impact me so I haven't looked at it.

How many ways do you want to tax it?

Stamp Duty distorts the housing market, reduces transactions and disincentivises downsizing in particular. Scrap it.

In no universe are you taxed annually on the value through Council Tax. A two bedroom terraced house in Washington, Tyne & Wear pays more in Council Tax than the King does for the Royal Residence at Buckingham Palace. Council Tax is derived from the value of a house in the same way that cheese is derived from a whale. It's not. Scrap it.

LVT is the only intelligent solution, and there's not a serious economist who opposes the principles underpinning it. 

IHT is, and will always be a voluntary tax.
Reply
#67
I think the point i was trying to make, all be it badly, was that for most the £500,000 per person alllowances for Estates less than £2 million should mean that most people wont pay IHT on their main residence. The fact that on 1st death their RNRB can be inherited by a Spouse and offset against a future property, regardless of whether the deceased lived in it is also odd!

My experience is that assets tend to be retained as there is a deep hatred of paying any tax at all! As you say IHT is payable at 40% so better to pay the CGT and then gift it and then survive for 7 years. Interestingly I have never met a beneficiary of an Estate who wants to pay for life insurance to cover the potential IHT liability of their inheritance which probably says a lot about who worries about IHT more!

The Pension rules are an absolute shocker from April 2027 and again in my view far more onerous than people realise. If you die after the age of 75, unused pension funds are subject to IHT (not between Spouses) and then income tax for the beneficiary on what is left. The big kicker is that if your unused pension funds, when added to your Estate, means that your Estate value is in excess of £2 million then the Residential Nil Rate Band gets reduced. It is utterly penal and for a generation that wants to pass as much as possible to the next generation and have less to spend their actual income on it is a shocker.
Reply
#68
(06-24-2026, 02:00 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-24-2026, 12:42 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I've never seen the fascination with this 'wholly unearned income' line. It's an investment that has added benefits i.e. a roof over your head, in the same way that you will have benefits when you invest in shares i.e. value of the shares plus the dividends. House value is taxed by stamp duty at point of purchase / sale and ultimately as part of inheritance tax or taxed on profit on sale if it is a second home / rental. 

Added to that you are taxed annually on the value through council tax and there is this new annual tax, is it over £2m, that doesn't impact me so I haven't looked at it.

How many ways do you want to tax it?

Stamp Duty distorts the housing market, reduces transactions and disincentivises downsizing in particular. Scrap it.

In no universe are you taxed annually on the value through Council Tax. A two bedroom terraced house in Washington, Tyne & Wear pays more in Council Tax than the King does for the Royal Residence at Buckingham Palace. Council Tax is derived from the value of a house in the same way that cheese is derived from a whale. It's not. Scrap it.

LVT is the only intelligent solution, and there's not a serious economist who opposes the principles underpinning it. 

IHT is, and will always be a voluntary tax.

Where can I get some of the Whale Cheese?
Raw Sausage
Reply
#69
(06-24-2026, 02:13 PM)BasingBaggie Wrote: I think the point i was trying to make, all be it badly, was that for most the £500,000 per person alllowances for Estates less than £2 million should mean that most people wont pay IHT on their main residence. The fact that on 1st death their RNRB can be inherited by a Spouse and offset against a future property, regardless of whether the deceased lived in it is also odd!

My experience is that assets tend to be retained as there is a deep hatred of paying any tax at all! As you say IHT is payable at 40% so better to pay the CGT and then gift it and then survive for 7 years. Interestingly I have never met a beneficiary of an Estate who wants to pay for life insurance to cover the potential IHT liability of their inheritance which probably says a lot about who worries about IHT more!

The Pension rules are an absolute shocker from April 2027 and again in my view far more onerous than people realise. If you die after the age of 75, unused pension funds are subject to IHT (not between Spouses) and then income tax for the beneficiary on what is left. The big kicker is that if your unused pension funds, when added to your Estate, means that your Estate value is in excess of £2 million then the Residential Nil Rate Band gets reduced. It is utterly penal and for a generation that wants to pass as much as possible to the next generation and have less to spend their actual income on it is a shocker.

The pension rules are penal. From previous conversations there are some on here who just don't see that, nor the behaviourial issues it could give rise to.
Reply
#70
There is a problem here that Proth refuses to accept, Pension pots were being used as a device to avoid inheritance tax and not just pensions any more. As time went on that abuse got bigger and bigger and eventually couldn't be ignored. People were allowed to put money in tax free and ultimately, if unused they would be able to pass it on tax free. The amounts that were being put into pensions were fast becoming obviously larger than they would ever need to use for their retirement (their pension). The abuse of the system by those that could afford it meant that everyone got punished and then ironically those that could afford it are the ones moaning after fucking it for everyone.

The behavioural issues will be that people don't invest in pensions any more than they will need to take out. There is a vague threat that people won't invest and therefore pull from the state in later life in there somewhere.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)