Well done Thieves
#51
(06-24-2026, 06:05 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Once again you’re completely blind to the unintended consequences of a policy that will raise buttons. By adding unnecessary complexity and reducing investor choice the government will end up with less investment via self select ISAs. Precisely the opposite outcome of that stated by Reeves.

There are times that I have liquidated large parts of my portfolio, for which the miserly interest on balances from the platform or from money market instruments will now be taxed at 40%. What purpose can that possibly serve apart from raising the thick end of fuck all? And penalising anyone not stupid enough to want to buy a £20,000 snapshot of the market each year?

The rules haven't been announced yet but based on what has been leaked the only tax liability will be those who hold 100% of their funds in Money Market Funds. In essence a Cash ISA to get around the new rules. If you are that bothered about investing in money market funds then invest 99% and no tax liability. Its hardly complex ffs.
Reply
#52
(06-24-2026, 09:21 AM)BasingBaggie Wrote:
(06-24-2026, 06:05 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Once again you’re completely blind to the unintended consequences of a policy that will raise buttons. By adding unnecessary complexity and reducing investor choice the government will end up with less investment via self select ISAs. Precisely the opposite outcome of that stated by Reeves.

There are times that I have liquidated large parts of my portfolio, for which the miserly interest on balances from the platform or from money market instruments will now be taxed at 40%. What purpose can that possibly serve apart from raising the thick end of fuck all? And penalising anyone not stupid enough to want to buy a £20,000 snapshot of the market each year?

The rules haven't been announced yet but based on what has been leaked the only tax liability will be those who hold 100% of their funds in Money Market Funds. In essence a Cash ISA to get around the new rules. If you are that bothered about investing in money market funds then invest 99% and no tax liability. Its hardly complex ffs.

Can you link to news on that? I've not read that interpretation anywhere.
Reply
#53
https://www.gov.uk/government/publicatio...-factsheet

Well this is from the Government website. For the record i don't agree with the new rules but there is a ludicrous amount of money sat in Cash ISAs that are basically do sod all
Reply
#54
(06-24-2026, 09:30 AM)BasingBaggie Wrote: https://www.gov.uk/government/publicatio...-factsheet

Well this is from the Government website. For the record i don't agree with the new rules but there is a ludicrous amount of money sat in Cash ISAs that are basically do sod all

Thank you.

And you're right anyone who has enough spare to put five-figures away and puts it into a cash ISA needs their head testing.
Reply
#55
My main issue with the new rules if that they don't apply to people over the age of 65. I would bet £100 of Nigel Farage's no strings gift that most cash ISAs are held by people over the age of 65. An index linked state pension, defined benefit schemes and tax free savings, not all but a vast majority. As they are the age group that are most likely to vote no Politician will do anything to change it.

I met someone who was incandescent with rage over Rachel Reeves and the loss of the WFH. He was aged 88 and his pension was £246,000pa ffs.
Reply
#56
(06-24-2026, 10:21 AM)BasingBaggie Wrote: My main issue with the new rules if that they don't apply to people over the age of 65. I would bet £100 of Nigel Farage's no strings gift that most cash ISAs are held by people over the age of 65. An index linked state pension, defined benefit schemes and tax free savings, not all but a vast majority. As they are the age group that are most likely to vote no Politician will do anything to change it.

I met someone who was incandescent with rage over Rachel Reeves and the loss of the WFH. He was aged 88 and his pension was £246,000pa ffs.

Don't forget the entirely unearned housing wealth.
Reply
#57
(06-24-2026, 10:27 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-24-2026, 10:21 AM)BasingBaggie Wrote: My main issue with the new rules if that they don't apply to people over the age of 65. I would bet £100 of Nigel Farage's no strings gift that most cash ISAs are held by people over the age of 65. An index linked state pension, defined benefit schemes and tax free savings, not all but a vast majority. As they are the age group that are most likely to vote no Politician will do anything to change it.

I met someone who was incandescent with rage over Rachel Reeves and the loss of the WFH. He was aged 88 and his pension was £246,000pa ffs.

Don't forget the entirely unearned housing wealth.

Yes. That has to be taxed. People were sitting in their houses watching their values go up by more than their annual salary for some years.
Reply
#58
(06-24-2026, 10:04 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-24-2026, 09:30 AM)BasingBaggie Wrote: https://www.gov.uk/government/publicatio...-factsheet

Well this is from the Government website. For the record i don't agree with the new rules but there is a ludicrous amount of money sat in Cash ISAs that are basically do sod all

Thank you.

And you're right anyone who has enough spare to put five-figures away and puts it into a cash ISA needs their head testing.

Yes, makes you wonder. A drinking pal I knew put the maximum cash in a cash ISA for his missus every year. Sadly they both now have dementia. I bet their offspring can't wait.
Reply
#59
(06-24-2026, 10:43 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote:
(06-24-2026, 10:27 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-24-2026, 10:21 AM)BasingBaggie Wrote: My main issue with the new rules if that they don't apply to people over the age of 65. I would bet £100 of Nigel Farage's no strings gift that most cash ISAs are held by people over the age of 65. An index linked state pension, defined benefit schemes and tax free savings, not all but a vast majority. As they are the age group that are most likely to vote no Politician will do anything to change it.

I met someone who was incandescent with rage over Rachel Reeves and the loss of the WFH. He was aged 88 and his pension was £246,000pa ffs.

Don't forget the entirely unearned housing wealth.

Yes. That has to be taxed. People were sitting in their houses watching their values go up by more than their annual salary for some years.

It is taxed, as part of inheritance tax.
Reply
#60
(06-24-2026, 11:24 AM)baggy1 Wrote: It is taxed, as part of inheritance tax.

[Image: giphy.gif]
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)