PSR breach reported by John Percy
(05-14-2026, 11:43 AM)MGalea Wrote:
(05-14-2026, 11:14 AM)BaggieSloth Wrote: Am i correct in thinking though - depending how the vote goes on Friday - PSR might not even be a thing as it will be PCR that replaces it?

Yes - correct.

Squad Cost to "Football" Revenue Ratio of 85% 

Including the ability to inject £10m a season into the revenue.

https://www.fourfourtwo.com/competition/...cost-ratio

As explained when it came in for the Prem.

So our most recent revenue was about £30m, so our squad cost must be around £24m to comply? Surely our squad already cost that or more?

Dike £8m? Heggebo £5.5, Phillips £3.5, Gilchrist £2.4, George £1.3 - £21.5m just there... Or do they then use that cheat code amortisation, and say Dike only cost £2m Heggebo is 1.7? and so on?
Reply
(05-14-2026, 12:17 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(05-14-2026, 11:43 AM)MGalea Wrote:
(05-14-2026, 11:14 AM)BaggieSloth Wrote: Am i correct in thinking though - depending how the vote goes on Friday - PSR might not even be a thing as it will be PCR that replaces it?

Yes - correct.

Squad Cost to "Football" Revenue Ratio of 85% 

Including the ability to inject £10m a season into the revenue.

https://www.fourfourtwo.com/competition/...cost-ratio

As explained when it came in for the Prem.

So our most recent revenue was about £30m, so our squad cost must be around £24m to comply? Surely our squad already cost that or more?

Dike £8m? Heggebo £5.5, Phillips £3.5, Gilchrist £2.4, George £1.3 - £21.5m just there... Or do they then use that cheat code amortisation, and say Dike only cost £2m Heggebo is 1.7? and so on?

You're only allowed to do that if you have a V and two Ls in your name.
Reply
(05-14-2026, 10:35 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(05-14-2026, 08:15 AM)sickParrot Wrote: Are we sure about the double jeopardy rules, I cant find anything on this and the verdict suggests the opposite?

Reading the EFL doc, does it suggest a stitch-up? The club were allowed to account for the Foundation one way in the earlier years, then the EFL refused to allow that when looking at the later 3-year period.

(05-14-2026, 12:05 AM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote: Therefore, a -£16m or below FFP loss is the magic number for the next Assessment Period.

No magic number here, the next assessment is still a fresh rolling test, and this lot have already shown they can make “a new and different decision” and “look again” at earlier treatment.

In the context of EFL/Premier League Profitability and Sustainability Rules (PSR), "double jeopardy" refers to the argument that a club should not be punished twice for the same financial period's losses. Key points are that EFL rules prevent auditing the same season for multiple breaches, while Premier League cases have relied on arguing "natural justice" to avoid excessive "double counting" of losses over overlapping periods.

Premier League, yes, there is precedent from the Leicester and Everton cases. In the EFL, I cannot find a rule and the written reasons suggests overlapping years can still be looked at again. I hope your right but its difficult not to be cynical.
Reply
(05-14-2026, 12:17 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(05-14-2026, 11:43 AM)MGalea Wrote:
(05-14-2026, 11:14 AM)BaggieSloth Wrote: Am i correct in thinking though - depending how the vote goes on Friday - PSR might not even be a thing as it will be PCR that replaces it?

Yes - correct.

Squad Cost to "Football" Revenue Ratio of 85% 

Including the ability to inject £10m a season into the revenue.

https://www.fourfourtwo.com/competition/...cost-ratio

As explained when it came in for the Prem.

So our most recent revenue was about £30m, so our squad cost must be around £24m to comply? Surely our squad already cost that or more?

Dike £8m? Heggebo £5.5, Phillips £3.5, Gilchrist £2.4, George £1.3 - £21.5m just there... Or do they then use that cheat code amortisation, and say Dike only cost £2m Heggebo is 1.7? and so on?

It'll be based on the cost amortised over contract length for sure.

Also includes wages, staff wages and agents fees.
Reply
(05-14-2026, 12:50 PM)MGalea Wrote:
(05-14-2026, 12:17 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(05-14-2026, 11:43 AM)MGalea Wrote:
(05-14-2026, 11:14 AM)BaggieSloth Wrote: Am i correct in thinking though - depending how the vote goes on Friday - PSR might not even be a thing as it will be PCR that replaces it?

Yes - correct.

Squad Cost to "Football" Revenue Ratio of 85% 

Including the ability to inject £10m a season into the revenue.

https://www.fourfourtwo.com/competition/...cost-ratio

As explained when it came in for the Prem.

So our most recent revenue was about £30m, so our squad cost must be around £24m to comply? Surely our squad already cost that or more?

Dike £8m? Heggebo £5.5, Phillips £3.5, Gilchrist £2.4, George £1.3 - £21.5m just there... Or do they then use that cheat code amortisation, and say Dike only cost £2m Heggebo is 1.7? and so on?

It'll be based on the cost amortised over contract length for sure.

Also includes wages, staff wages and agents fees.

We'd be releasing and re-signing Dike so he'd be nil cost outside wages.
Reply
(05-14-2026, 12:43 PM)sickParrot Wrote:
(05-14-2026, 10:35 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(05-14-2026, 08:15 AM)sickParrot Wrote: Are we sure about the double jeopardy rules, I cant find anything on this and the verdict suggests the opposite?

Reading the EFL doc, does it suggest a stitch-up? The club were allowed to account for the Foundation one way in the earlier years, then the EFL refused to allow that when looking at the later 3-year period.

(05-14-2026, 12:05 AM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote: Therefore, a -£16m or below FFP loss is the magic number for the next Assessment Period.

No magic number here, the next assessment is still a fresh rolling test, and this lot have already shown they can make “a new and different decision” and “look again” at earlier treatment.

In the context of EFL/Premier League Profitability and Sustainability Rules (PSR), "double jeopardy" refers to the argument that a club should not be punished twice for the same financial period's losses. Key points are that EFL rules prevent auditing the same season for multiple breaches, while Premier League cases have relied on arguing "natural justice" to avoid excessive "double counting" of losses over overlapping periods.

Premier League, yes, there is precedent from the Leicester and Everton cases. In the EFL, I cannot find a rule and the written reasons  suggests overlapping years can still be looked at again. I hope your right but its difficult not to be cynical.

I've read the case again and it seems to be established precedent.

When I used the term double jeopardy I perhaps used the wrong term, overlap maybe better but either way.

From the Written Reasons.


Attached Files Thumbnail(s)
   
Reply
(05-14-2026, 01:58 PM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote: I've read the case again and it seems to be established precedent.

When I used the term double jeopardy I perhaps used the wrong term, overlap maybe better but either way.

From the Written Reasons.

I see what you’re saying. It is hard to make sense of it because they seem to be making it up as they go along.
Reply
(05-14-2026, 01:03 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-14-2026, 12:50 PM)MGalea Wrote:
(05-14-2026, 12:17 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(05-14-2026, 11:43 AM)MGalea Wrote:
(05-14-2026, 11:14 AM)BaggieSloth Wrote: Am i correct in thinking though - depending how the vote goes on Friday - PSR might not even be a thing as it will be PCR that replaces it?

Yes - correct.

Squad Cost to "Football" Revenue Ratio of 85% 

Including the ability to inject £10m a season into the revenue.

https://www.fourfourtwo.com/competition/...cost-ratio

As explained when it came in for the Prem.

So our most recent revenue was about £30m, so our squad cost must be around £24m to comply? Surely our squad already cost that or more?

Dike £8m? Heggebo £5.5, Phillips £3.5, Gilchrist £2.4, George £1.3 - £21.5m just there... Or do they then use that cheat code amortisation, and say Dike only cost £2m Heggebo is 1.7? and so on?

It'll be based on the cost amortised over contract length for sure.

Also includes wages, staff wages and agents fees.

We'd be releasing and re-signing Dike so he'd be nil cost outside wages.

If it includes wages then I think most teams would be well over the limit!
Reply
(05-14-2026, 08:44 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-14-2026, 08:25 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(05-14-2026, 08:23 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Thanks for the explanation BIC!

Could this also explain why we have decided not to appeal the charge, as ultimately, the punishment meant we finished 21st, not 19th, so it probably cost us 100k or so in prize money, but the positive is that we have put another 25M into what we can "lose" in terms of keeping certain players, or spending in the forward line that desperately needs investment.

As I understand it, there is no positional prize money in the Champ.

Just looked it up and you're right...

Would explain why there are so many dead rubbers at the end of the season.

Either that or Pulis manages a lot of clubs that got to 40 points in early March.
Reply
20/24 clubs voted in favour of replacing PSR with SCR from next season, as reported by John Percy.

Our PSR saga starts and ends with the Perce.
He’s gorra gew, Franksy!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 7 Guest(s)