PSR breach reported by John Percy
EFL regulations prohibit charging a club for a breach related to a season that has already been included in a previous, sanctioned breach.
Reply
(05-13-2026, 09:37 PM)Albionmad Wrote:
(05-13-2026, 09:12 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(05-13-2026, 08:25 PM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote:
(05-13-2026, 07:56 PM)richbaggie Wrote:
(05-13-2026, 07:07 PM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote: Had a quick read. 69 Pages for a small overspend is ridiculous in general. As is over 2.5 weeks for publication 

The Community Expenditure element seems pretty objectionable by the EFL. The Interest element I have no issue with them challenging that specific point. It could be open to abuse and nonsense by less scrupulous owners..see the Bournemouth £71m Net debt waiver in 2023 in the PL which the PL basically permitted on takeover.

Has the Community bit been accepted given the circs combined with the Interest recharge element being disallowed that would seem balanced to me and may have meant narrow compliance tbh to 2024-25..I would have to look again at the numbers.

For balance the Club Statement post Sanction didn't reference Interest as a point of dispute at all.

Finally a Silver Lining among the cloud could be that the £37m Pre Tax minus Allowables becomes £13m plus Allowables for a future Assessment as the EFL have a provision vs double jeopardy. Eg if the FFP loss was £28m, £29m it becomes £13m thereby making compliance a lot easier to 2025-26 and 2026-27

Re the last paragraph. As unpalatable the ruling was, the double jeopardy rule works in our favour and we would be daft to appeal.

Yep. Smart thing to do..plausibly could  look to appeal on one point ie the Charitable bit not the Interest bit but could work out for the best.

Being dumb here but can someone explain how it becomes £13 million?
I'm also a bit thick. What's this double jeopardy all about?
Is it written in stone that we have an advantage going forward?
Or will it be something they move the goalposts on in the future?

The media really don't explain this stuff well. No reason for the goalposts to be moved at all, it's established practice in the Championship as far as I can see.

Effectively, as I understand it based on past cases.

Say the WBA costs average £7m-£8m in FFP add-backs and it is £13m x 3.

In 2023-24, WBA Group level lost £37m Pre Tax which in P&S/FFP terms I expect will have been £29m, £30m.

The next year lost £18m Pre Tax but also pre add-backs..but also re-add the Interest stuff 

That -£29m and say -£12m to -£13m becomes -£13m and -£12m to -£13m. Once a breach is crystallised in an FFP sense that loss is capped at the upper threshold ie £13m.

Club A..example not this case but a worked example.

-£15m FFP loss
-£10m FFP loss
-£25m FFP loss

£11m overspend.

For the year after the £25m one breach proven etc.

-£10m FFP loss- remains as it is.
-£13m FFP loss- adjusted down to the max.

Therefore, a -£16m or below FFP loss is the magic number for the next Assessment Period.

This isn't WBA extrapolated but with the Seles
Reply
(05-14-2026, 12:05 AM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote:
(05-13-2026, 09:37 PM)Albionmad Wrote:
(05-13-2026, 09:12 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(05-13-2026, 08:25 PM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote:
(05-13-2026, 07:56 PM)richbaggie Wrote: Re the last paragraph. As unpalatable the ruling was, the double jeopardy rule works in our favour and we would be daft to appeal.

Yep. Smart thing to do..plausibly could  look to appeal on one point ie the Charitable bit not the Interest bit but could work out for the best.

Being dumb here but can someone explain how it becomes £13 million?
I'm also a bit thick. What's this double jeopardy all about?
Is it written in stone that we have an advantage going forward?
Or will it be something they move the goalposts on in the future?

The media really don't explain this stuff well. No reason for the goalposts to be moved at all, it's established practice in the Championship as far as I can see.

Effectively, as I understand it based on past cases.

Say the WBA costs average £7m-£8m in FFP add-backs and it is £13m x 3.

In 2023-24, WBA Group level lost £37m Pre Tax which in P&S/FFP terms I expect will have been £29m, £30m.

The next year lost £18m Pre Tax but also pre add-backs..but also re-add the Interest stuff 

That -£29m and say -£12m to -£13m becomes -£13m and -£12m to -£13m. Once a breach is crystallised in an FFP sense that loss is capped at the upper threshold ie £13m.

Club A..example not this case but a worked example.

-£15m FFP loss
-£10m FFP loss
-£25m FFP loss

£11m overspend.

For the year after the £25m one breach proven etc.

-£10m FFP loss- remains as it is.
-£13m FFP loss- adjusted down to the max.

Therefore, a -£16m or below FFP loss is the magic number for the next Assessment Period.

This isn't WBA extrapolated but with the Seles

Thanks for the explanation
Reply
Are we sure about the double jeopardy rules, I cant find anything on this and the verdict suggests the opposite?

Reading the EFL doc, does it suggest a stitch-up? The club were allowed to account for the Foundation one way in the earlier years, then the EFL refused to allow that when looking at the later 3-year period.

(05-14-2026, 12:05 AM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote: Therefore, a -£16m or below FFP loss is the magic number for the next Assessment Period.

No magic number here, the next assessment is still a fresh rolling test, and this lot have already shown they can make “a new and different decision” and “look again” at earlier treatment.
Reply
Thanks for the explanation BIC!

Could this also explain why we have decided not to appeal the charge, as ultimately, the punishment meant we finished 21st, not 19th, so it probably cost us 100k or so in prize money, but the positive is that we have put another 25M into what we can "lose" in terms of keeping certain players, or spending in the forward line that desperately needs investment.
Reply
(05-14-2026, 08:23 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Thanks for the explanation BIC!

Could this also explain why we have decided not to appeal the charge, as ultimately, the punishment meant we finished 21st, not 19th, so it probably cost us 100k or so in prize money, but the positive is that we have put another 25M into what we can "lose" in terms of keeping certain players, or spending in the forward line that desperately needs investment.

As I understand it, there is no positional prize money in the Champ.
Reply
(05-14-2026, 08:25 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(05-14-2026, 08:23 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Thanks for the explanation BIC!

Could this also explain why we have decided not to appeal the charge, as ultimately, the punishment meant we finished 21st, not 19th, so it probably cost us 100k or so in prize money, but the positive is that we have put another 25M into what we can "lose" in terms of keeping certain players, or spending in the forward line that desperately needs investment.

As I understand it, there is no positional prize money in the Champ.

Just looked it up and you're right...

Would explain why there are so many dead rubbers at the end of the season.
Reply
(05-14-2026, 08:15 AM)sickParrot Wrote: Are we sure about the double jeopardy rules, I cant find anything on this and the verdict suggests the opposite?

Reading the EFL doc, does it suggest a stitch-up? The club were allowed to account for the Foundation one way in the earlier years, then the EFL refused to allow that when looking at the later 3-year period.

(05-14-2026, 12:05 AM)BristolCityInPeace Wrote: Therefore, a -£16m or below FFP loss is the magic number for the next Assessment Period.

No magic number here, the next assessment is still a fresh rolling test, and this lot have already shown they can make “a new and different decision” and “look again” at earlier treatment.

In the context of EFL/Premier League Profitability and Sustainability Rules (PSR), "double jeopardy" refers to the argument that a club should not be punished twice for the same financial period's losses. Key points are that EFL rules prevent auditing the same season for multiple breaches, while Premier League cases have relied on arguing "natural justice" to avoid excessive "double counting" of losses over overlapping periods.
Reply
Am i correct in thinking though - depending how the vote goes on Friday - PSR might not even be a thing as it will be PCR that replaces it?
Reply
(05-14-2026, 11:14 AM)BaggieSloth Wrote: Am i correct in thinking though - depending how the vote goes on Friday - PSR might not even be a thing as it will be PCR that replaces it?

Yes - correct.

Squad Cost to "Football" Revenue Ratio of 85% 

Including the ability to inject £10m a season into the revenue.

https://www.fourfourtwo.com/competition/...cost-ratio

As explained when it came in for the Prem.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 7 Guest(s)