The Mythical Plan B
#61
(11-26-2025, 07:46 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(11-26-2025, 06:59 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: I was talking to an ex-England player yesterday who I hadn’t realised had done some coaching at Spurs. He was aware that he was under pressure and asked why. I told him about the appalling in-game management and the dull football. He was pretty shocked and said his coaching sessions at Spurs were incredible and that it sounded like a lack of experience, the champ is brutal etc.

Having gone from thinking he was promising up until the first international break, doubts creeping in in the second to then him being tactically inept, I’m now thinking maybe we should persevere. Well until we lose tonight!

I am one of the rare fans in the give him more time camp because I hear that his coaching is top notch and the players really respond to that and have a very good relationship with him. It's his lack of experience with game management that's the issue and he is having to learn on the job in an environment that is brutal and lacks patience.

He's a resilient and very intelligent bloke, a rarity in football. I am still hopeful that he can improve the game management and go on to become a good manager. I would be ok with steady improvement. Sadly, many of our fans have made their minds up and a steady improvement won't be enough. They want him gone and won't leave that position now until he's out of the door.

Fans are fickle Rich, a few wins and things change very quickly. Ultimately, it’s best for the club if he turns it around and succeeds ASAP, whether he will remains to be seen but just how much more time can Nestor afford him?
In the form of his life.
Reply
#62
(11-26-2025, 07:46 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(11-26-2025, 06:59 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: I was talking to an ex-England player yesterday who I hadn’t realised had done some coaching at Spurs. He was aware that he was under pressure and asked why. I told him about the appalling in-game management and the dull football. He was pretty shocked and said his coaching sessions at Spurs were incredible and that it sounded like a lack of experience, the champ is brutal etc.

Having gone from thinking he was promising up until the first international break, doubts creeping in in the second to then him being tactically inept, I’m now thinking maybe we should persevere. Well until we lose tonight!

I am one of the rare fans in the give him more time camp because I hear that his coaching is top notch and the players really respond to that and have a very good relationship with him. It's his lack of experience with game management that's the issue and he is having to learn on the job in an environment that is brutal and lacks patience.

He's a resilient and very intelligent bloke, a rarity in football. I am still hopeful that he can improve the game management and go on to become a good manager. I would be ok with steady improvement. Sadly, many of our fans have made their minds up and a steady improvement won't be enough. They want him gone and won't leave that position now until he's out of the door.


I'm with you Rich
Reply
#63
(11-26-2025, 08:45 AM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote:
(11-26-2025, 07:46 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(11-26-2025, 06:59 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: I was talking to an ex-England player yesterday who I hadn’t realised had done some coaching at Spurs. He was aware that he was under pressure and asked why. I told him about the appalling in-game management and the dull football. He was pretty shocked and said his coaching sessions at Spurs were incredible and that it sounded like a lack of experience, the champ is brutal etc.

Having gone from thinking he was promising up until the first international break, doubts creeping in in the second to then him being tactically inept, I’m now thinking maybe we should persevere. Well until we lose tonight!

I am one of the rare fans in the give him more time camp because I hear that his coaching is top notch and the players really respond to that and have a very good relationship with him. It's his lack of experience with game management that's the issue and he is having to learn on the job in an environment that is brutal and lacks patience.

He's a resilient and very intelligent bloke, a rarity in football. I am still hopeful that he can improve the game management and go on to become a good manager. I would be ok with steady improvement. Sadly, many of our fans have made their minds up and a steady improvement won't be enough. They want him gone and won't leave that position now until he's out of the door.

Fans are fickle Rich, a few wins and things change very quickly. Ultimately, it’s best for the club if he turns it around and succeeds ASAP, whether he will remains to be seen but just how much more time can Nestor afford him?

They are Midge but I do think it's hard for people to change their stance once made. He'll always be one defeat away from being a chump again and steady improvement won't be enough.
Reply
#64
(11-26-2025, 09:00 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(11-26-2025, 08:45 AM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote:
(11-26-2025, 07:46 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(11-26-2025, 06:59 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: I was talking to an ex-England player yesterday who I hadn’t realised had done some coaching at Spurs. He was aware that he was under pressure and asked why. I told him about the appalling in-game management and the dull football. He was pretty shocked and said his coaching sessions at Spurs were incredible and that it sounded like a lack of experience, the champ is brutal etc.

Having gone from thinking he was promising up until the first international break, doubts creeping in in the second to then him being tactically inept, I’m now thinking maybe we should persevere. Well until we lose tonight!

I am one of the rare fans in the give him more time camp because I hear that his coaching is top notch and the players really respond to that and have a very good relationship with him. It's his lack of experience with game management that's the issue and he is having to learn on the job in an environment that is brutal and lacks patience.

He's a resilient and very intelligent bloke, a rarity in football. I am still hopeful that he can improve the game management and go on to become a good manager. I would be ok with steady improvement. Sadly, many of our fans have made their minds up and a steady improvement won't be enough. They want him gone and won't leave that position now until he's out of the door.

Fans are fickle Rich, a few wins and things change very quickly. Ultimately, it’s best for the club if he turns it around and succeeds ASAP, whether he will remains to be seen but just how much more time can Nestor afford him?

They are Midge but I do think it's hard for people to change their stance once made. He'll always be one defeat away from being a chump again and steady improvement won't be enough.

I would snap your hands off for steady improvement. But in his first 4 months, there has been no sign of any improvement. If anything we, as a team, and him, as a tactician have got worse if anything. 

There seems to be a strange narrative from a few that fans who are not happy with the blunt and obvious lack of nous are 'fickle' or have an 'agenda' or a 'bias'. The same was said about people when they questioned Bruce and ToMo. Who both are also nice people, who had good relationships with players. 

I like Mason, he seems a really well rounded, empathetic chap. Is obviously a very good coach. But he has shown absolutely zero management ability.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#65
(11-26-2025, 09:51 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(11-26-2025, 09:00 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(11-26-2025, 08:45 AM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote:
(11-26-2025, 07:46 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(11-26-2025, 06:59 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: I was talking to an ex-England player yesterday who I hadn’t realised had done some coaching at Spurs. He was aware that he was under pressure and asked why. I told him about the appalling in-game management and the dull football. He was pretty shocked and said his coaching sessions at Spurs were incredible and that it sounded like a lack of experience, the champ is brutal etc.

Having gone from thinking he was promising up until the first international break, doubts creeping in in the second to then him being tactically inept, I’m now thinking maybe we should persevere. Well until we lose tonight!

I am one of the rare fans in the give him more time camp because I hear that his coaching is top notch and the players really respond to that and have a very good relationship with him. It's his lack of experience with game management that's the issue and he is having to learn on the job in an environment that is brutal and lacks patience.

He's a resilient and very intelligent bloke, a rarity in football. I am still hopeful that he can improve the game management and go on to become a good manager. I would be ok with steady improvement. Sadly, many of our fans have made their minds up and a steady improvement won't be enough. They want him gone and won't leave that position now until he's out of the door.

Fans are fickle Rich, a few wins and things change very quickly. Ultimately, it’s best for the club if he turns it around and succeeds ASAP, whether he will remains to be seen but just how much more time can Nestor afford him?

They are Midge but I do think it's hard for people to change their stance once made. He'll always be one defeat away from being a chump again and steady improvement won't be enough.

I would snap your hands off for steady improvement. But in his first 4 months, there has been no sign of any improvement. If anything we, as a team, and him, as a tactician have got worse if anything. 

There seems to be a strange narrative from a few that fans who are not happy with the blunt and obvious lack of nous are 'fickle' or have an 'agenda' or a 'bias'. The same was said about people when they questioned Bruce and ToMo. Who both are also nice people, who had good relationships with players. 

I like Mason, he seems a really well rounded, empathetic chap. Is obviously a very good coach. But he has shown absolutely zero management ability.

It's not a narrative, it's always been the case with football fans that once they make their mind up about someone, it's rare that they have a balanced view after that. I can be guilty as much as anyone. It's human nature.

As for Mason, saying "zero management ability" is the case in point about how unbalanced a view can get once a mind is made up. 

Bruce and Tomo did not have good relationships with players by the way. Not 2nd time around in Moggas case.
Reply
#66
I meant they are fickle in the sense that if he suddenly put 6 wins in a row together, people would change their tune. Unlikely, I admit.
In the form of his life.
Reply
#67
(11-26-2025, 10:00 AM)richbaggie. Wrote: It's not a narrative, it's always been the case with football fans that once they make their mind up about someone, it's rare that they have a balanced view after that. I can be guilty as much as anyone. It's human nature.

As for Mason, saying "zero management ability" is the case in point about how unbalanced a view can get once a mind is made up. 

Bruce and Tomo did not have good relationships with players by the way. Not 2nd time around in Moggas case.

Not sure it is an unbalanced view, Rich. I can't think of many if any games this year where he has out thought, out manoeuvred or out smarted the opposition manager. 

Pretty much every decision he make makes me scratch my head.

Does this mean I don't want him to turn it around? No. I would like nothing more to see him making good decisions which positively impact games. But I just don't see any evidence of it.

Also I wasn't aware that ToMo wasnt well received? I thought he was loved by the players.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#68
(11-26-2025, 09:51 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(11-26-2025, 09:00 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(11-26-2025, 08:45 AM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote:
(11-26-2025, 07:46 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(11-26-2025, 06:59 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: I was talking to an ex-England player yesterday who I hadn’t realised had done some coaching at Spurs. He was aware that he was under pressure and asked why. I told him about the appalling in-game management and the dull football. He was pretty shocked and said his coaching sessions at Spurs were incredible and that it sounded like a lack of experience, the champ is brutal etc.

Having gone from thinking he was promising up until the first international break, doubts creeping in in the second to then him being tactically inept, I’m now thinking maybe we should persevere. Well until we lose tonight!

I am one of the rare fans in the give him more time camp because I hear that his coaching is top notch and the players really respond to that and have a very good relationship with him. It's his lack of experience with game management that's the issue and he is having to learn on the job in an environment that is brutal and lacks patience.

He's a resilient and very intelligent bloke, a rarity in football. I am still hopeful that he can improve the game management and go on to become a good manager. I would be ok with steady improvement. Sadly, many of our fans have made their minds up and a steady improvement won't be enough. They want him gone and won't leave that position now until he's out of the door.

Fans are fickle Rich, a few wins and things change very quickly. Ultimately, it’s best for the club if he turns it around and succeeds ASAP, whether he will remains to be seen but just how much more time can Nestor afford him?

They are Midge but I do think it's hard for people to change their stance once made. He'll always be one defeat away from being a chump again and steady improvement won't be enough.

I would snap your hands off for steady improvement. But in his first 4 months, there has been no sign of any improvement. If anything we, as a team, and him, as a tactician have got worse if anything. 

There seems to be a strange narrative from a few that fans who are not happy with the blunt and obvious lack of nous are 'fickle' or have an 'agenda' or a 'bias'. The same was said about people when they questioned Bruce and ToMo. Who both are also nice people, who had good relationships with players. 

I like Mason, he seems a really well rounded, empathetic chap. Is obviously a very good coach. But he has shown absolutely zero management ability.

Because you can’t recognise your own bias. Pretty much since Mason has been at the club you’ve criticised him, you clearly don’t rate him, which is fine, I didn’t rate TM or Val and I got it horribly wrong with regards to Bruce. Ultimately Mason will be judged on results, but I am mindful that the owners and Nestor made the decision to employ someone with no experience of management other than a handful of games as caretaker, and that judging them after 16 games one way or another, with a squad in transition seems a tad unfair at this stage.
Reply
#69
My concern is that he is a complete tyro which is a huge gamble. Like a developing player, I'd have preferred someone with some "hard-league" exposure and (positive) experience in proper management (for want of a better word than head coach)

I'm unconvinced this is going to work. I would love it if it did. But head and heart naysayers.
Reply
#70
Is it bias to point out the things you think Mason has got wrong in a thread about his managerial ability? Or are they just someone's observations?

Tough to disagree with what Lurker says but also I'm with Dekka in so much that it's early days, in a season where I don't think we can finish about about 8th. For once we're in a position to actually give a manager time.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)