The Mythical Plan B
#51
(11-25-2025, 09:33 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(11-25-2025, 09:11 PM)UCEbaggie Wrote: Mason’s lack of tactical nous was really evident away at Watford. We started really well, bossed it for 25mins or so then their coach worked us out did some tactical stuff (a more astute observer could tell you want exactly) and they went on to deservedly win the game. Once they’d adapted Mason showed no ability to then adapt and change to reassert our superiority. It’s been largely downhill ever since

Spot on. It was that game that rang ceaseless alarm bells for me, having tried to give Millwall the benefit of being so bad it was hard to believe

Millwall was an alarm bell for us - it was the first time Mason got his set up completely and utterly wrong, and he was absolutely unable to change it, and you could see the players lose faith.
Reply
#52
The togetherness and fight of the players I've seen over the past few weeks doesn't scream of a group that has lost faith in their manager.

There are things that aren't right and we need to improve upon, again I want to reiterate that, but the attitude of the players on the pitch isn't one of them. It's not as if they've downed tools like they seemingly did under Monwbray and Bruce.

I get the impression they're still playing for Mason.
Reply
#53
I was talking to an ex-England player yesterday who I hadn’t realised had done some coaching at Spurs. He was aware that he was under pressure and asked why. I told him about the appalling in-game management and the dull football. He was pretty shocked and said his coaching sessions at Spurs were incredible and that it sounded like a lack of experience, the champ is brutal etc.

Having gone from thinking he was promising up until the first international break, doubts creeping in in the second to then him being tactically inept, I’m now thinking maybe we should persevere. Well until we lose tonight!
Reply
#54
(11-26-2025, 06:59 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: I was talking to an ex-England player yesterday who I hadn’t realised had done some coaching at Spurs. He was aware that he was under pressure and asked why. I told him about the appalling in-game management and the dull football. He was pretty shocked and said his coaching sessions at Spurs were incredible and that it sounded like a lack of experience, the champ is brutal etc.

Having gone from thinking he was promising up until the first international break, doubts creeping in in the second to then him being tactically inept, I’m now thinking maybe we should persevere. Well until we lose tonight!

And I don’t think anyone is doubting his capabilities on the training ground, and that’s where he should stay, it’s his abilities in the dug out that just aren’t good enough.
Reply
#55
(11-26-2025, 06:59 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: I was talking to an ex-England player yesterday who I hadn’t realised had done some coaching at Spurs. He was aware that he was under pressure and asked why. I told him about the appalling in-game management and the dull football. He was pretty shocked and said his coaching sessions at Spurs were incredible and that it sounded like a lack of experience, the champ is brutal etc.

Having gone from thinking he was promising up until the first international break, doubts creeping in in the second to then him being tactically inept, I’m now thinking maybe we should persevere. Well until we lose tonight!

I think this ties in with how we seemingly start games really well (for the most part). 

Changing things in-game is surely something that comes with experience and is very, very, difficult to teach. It certainly isn't going to come within 16 games.
Reply
#56
(11-26-2025, 06:59 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: I was talking to an ex-England player yesterday who I hadn’t realised had done some coaching at Spurs. He was aware that he was under pressure and asked why. I told him about the appalling in-game management and the dull football. He was pretty shocked and said his coaching sessions at Spurs were incredible and that it sounded like a lack of experience, the champ is brutal etc.

Having gone from thinking he was promising up until the first international break, doubts creeping in in the second to then him being tactically inept, I’m now thinking maybe we should persevere. Well until we lose tonight!

I am one of the rare fans in the give him more time camp because I hear that his coaching is top notch and the players really respond to that and have a very good relationship with him. It's his lack of experience with game management that's the issue and he is having to learn on the job in an environment that is brutal and lacks patience.

He's a resilient and very intelligent bloke, a rarity in football. I am still hopeful that he can improve the game management and go on to become a good manager. I would be ok with steady improvement. Sadly, many of our fans have made their minds up and a steady improvement won't be enough. They want him gone and won't leave that position now until he's out of the door.
Reply
#57
Quote:Sadly, many of our fans have made their minds up and a steady improvement won't be enough. They want him gone and won't leave that position now until he's out of the door.

This is what really frustrates me. He simply can't get anything right in some people's eyes. 

I see nothing terminal with this season, and how we're playing. It's not great, and improvement is needed, but it's not as hopeless and clueless as what I saw under Bruce or Mowbray, for example. 

I really do hope the club stick with him, even if the majority of fans have already judged and written him off.
Reply
#58
I’ve asked on two previous threads for a reason, other than blind faith, to support him. Finally one has come to fruition, the players are enjoying his coaching sessions and this is good to know.

So what’s his No2, Gibbs doing? Clearly not an influence on in-game management? Or does he refuse to listen? Seems this is what needs to be looking at by the club. How can he be better mentored and learn this skill, and it is a completely different skill to setting up a good coaching session? I’m not talking about demoting him to coach, just providing some match day tactical nous.

There’s been many a manager who aren’t good at in-game management but have successful careers.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#59
I'm not in the Mason out camp, yet. My reasons for sticking with him as follows.

I don't think whoever is in charge gets this team to finish in the POs.

Mason hasn't yet had 20 games as our head coach in one of the toughest leagues in the world. The value an extent of what he learns this season and experiences will shape him moving forwards. From a player perspective look at the shift in BTA this season from the last couple. Carlos is cited often here too, I know expectation in this league is different but if we don't finish 6th we might as well finish 16th, it makes zero difference.

I think we're seeing signs of players starting to improve, or reach old heights - MJ and Heggebo.

Next summer we're due a huge overhaul at the top end of the pitch and it would be interesting to see what he can do when he's not picking from Jed Wallace, loads of lads who can't play more than 15mins before they break down , Karlan Grant and a loanee LB from the wet look hair gel merchants down the road.

His coaching record is clearly good, as has been stated elsewhere on this thread.

It's not a great look for the club and certainly Nestor. We wanted Wicky, we got Mowbray, we had to sack Mowbray and then made a huge play for Mason. Have we really got the money to keep pissing away every 15-20 games?

Ultimately and this is my bias. I quite like him. He gets stick for what he says, but that's easy when you lose a few games. He's had a long time studying the game and you can see he has a point to prove.

This season realistically I want to see two things: 1) A commitment to playing a certain way, Nestor spoke about it, Mason spoke about it, let's see some coaching make its way onto the pitch. I think we have a little in the past couple of weeks, and 2) He needs to start getting the most out of this group. If he's fit we need to see minutes for Bany, we need to get the best out of Isaac Price (spoiler - he's not a 10) and Heggebo needs to continue his recent improvement.
Reply
#60
Spot on Ted.

The factor that I'm clinging on to in my 'give Mason time' stance is that I can see coaching, and I can see players responding to that coaching.

In-game management is disappointing, but we're setting up at the start of games, for the most part, really well. That's encouraging.

I at least see some structure in our play, compare that to the mess we saw in Monwbray's last few games.

I genuinely believe there's a good manager here, that's worth persisting with. I actually quite like him and how he comes across in interviews.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: