Women's Boxing
#51
(09-04-2025, 12:30 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(09-04-2025, 11:54 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: I think that any member of the general public who knows too much about these types of things should not be listened to.  Not because their opinion is wrong or right, nor that the point they are trying to make isn't 'just' - in some way or another.  But the very fact that Joe Public 'understands' (possibly in the Dunning Kruger context, admittedly) some of these terms means that they have been researching them to prove their own preconceived opinion on the matter.  The likelihood of attaining agreement or even compromise is nil. 

In my experience and opinion, which may be Dunning Kruger-like

I have researched the matter, mainly because, as explained, as a sports scientist by trade I find anything like this really interesting. When I had my own PT/Lifestyle business after uni, circa 2009, there were not many coaches that specialised in womens health, male or female. So I did a years training on pre and post natal stuff as well general 'womens health' issues. 

Fwiw.. this was the first article I read on the mattera year or so ago. 

https://shro.org/imane-khelif-unfairly-a...20athletes.

That article is incorrect.

Firstly, the IOC at the time itself stated that gender eligibility is based on the information at stated in the passport only, thus testosterone levels are irrelevant:

https://olympics.com/ioc/news/joint-pari...-statement

Secondly, the article seems to assert as fact that Imane Khelif has Swyer's syndrome. There is no evidence for this, nor has it been reported anywhere else. There has been a leaked medical report, and a diagnosis of Swyer syndrome was not linked to those findings, but a diagnosis of 5-ARD was. 

The article then states that Khelif was "in 2023, at the World Championships, she was disqualified for high levels of testosterone."

Again, this is untrue. The IBA gender eligibility test included chromosomal testing:

https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2024/n...mes-claims


Here the IBA confirm that their testing did not involve testosterone levels:

https://www.iba.sport/news/statement-mad...egulations.

They also provide a breakdown of the timeline here:

https://www.iba.sport/news/iba-clarifies...knowledged
Reply
#52
(09-04-2025, 01:18 PM)Squid Wrote:
(09-04-2025, 12:30 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(09-04-2025, 11:54 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: I think that any member of the general public who knows too much about these types of things should not be listened to.  Not because their opinion is wrong or right, nor that the point they are trying to make isn't 'just' - in some way or another.  But the very fact that Joe Public 'understands' (possibly in the Dunning Kruger context, admittedly) some of these terms means that they have been researching them to prove their own preconceived opinion on the matter.  The likelihood of attaining agreement or even compromise is nil. 

In my experience and opinion, which may be Dunning Kruger-like

I have researched the matter, mainly because, as explained, as a sports scientist by trade I find anything like this really interesting. When I had my own PT/Lifestyle business after uni, circa 2009, there were not many coaches that specialised in womens health, male or female. So I did a years training on pre and post natal stuff as well general 'womens health' issues. 

Fwiw.. this was the first article I read on the mattera year or so ago. 

https://shro.org/imane-khelif-unfairly-a...20athletes.

That article is incorrect.

Firstly, the IOC at the time itself stated that gender eligibility is based on the information at stated in the passport only, thus testosterone levels are irrelevant:

https://olympics.com/ioc/news/joint-pari...-statement

Secondly, the article seems to assert as fact that Imane Khelif has Swyer's syndrome. There is no evidence for this, nor has it been reported anywhere else. There has been a leaked medical report, and a diagnosis of Swyer syndrome was not linked to those findings, but a diagnosis of 5-ARD was. 

The article then states that Khelif was "in 2023, at the World Championships, she was disqualified for high levels of testosterone."

Again, this is untrue. The IBA gender eligibility test included chromosomal testing:

https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2024/n...mes-claims


Here the IBA confirm that their testing did not involve testosterone levels:

https://www.iba.sport/news/statement-mad...egulations.

They also provide a breakdown of the timeline here:

https://www.iba.sport/news/iba-clarifies...knowledged

The sheer mental acrobatics to devalue an article by citing a 'leaked medical document' which has not been certified by anyone, anywhere is astonishing. 

But more importantly proves that her diagnosis isn't formally known. She could well have 5-ARD, she could have Swyer or 10s of other conditions. Either way if would mean she has an XY chromosome. But in terms of all the concerns you keep peddling, they would have hugely different ramifications. 

You seem strangely obsessed with a person's genetic sex, whilst disregarding so many other factors which are just at pertinent to the safety of other competitors. It seems to me that you have an agenda in terms of what you view as being a women, and that is of course your right, but it that doesn't sit well with the facts, the science, or even your own concerns in this case.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#53
(09-04-2025, 03:28 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(09-04-2025, 01:18 PM)Squid Wrote:
(09-04-2025, 12:30 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(09-04-2025, 11:54 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: I think that any member of the general public who knows too much about these types of things should not be listened to.  Not because their opinion is wrong or right, nor that the point they are trying to make isn't 'just' - in some way or another.  But the very fact that Joe Public 'understands' (possibly in the Dunning Kruger context, admittedly) some of these terms means that they have been researching them to prove their own preconceived opinion on the matter.  The likelihood of attaining agreement or even compromise is nil. 

In my experience and opinion, which may be Dunning Kruger-like

I have researched the matter, mainly because, as explained, as a sports scientist by trade I find anything like this really interesting. When I had my own PT/Lifestyle business after uni, circa 2009, there were not many coaches that specialised in womens health, male or female. So I did a years training on pre and post natal stuff as well general 'womens health' issues. 

Fwiw.. this was the first article I read on the mattera year or so ago. 

https://shro.org/imane-khelif-unfairly-a...20athletes.

That article is incorrect.

Firstly, the IOC at the time itself stated that gender eligibility is based on the information at stated in the passport only, thus testosterone levels are irrelevant:

https://olympics.com/ioc/news/joint-pari...-statement

Secondly, the article seems to assert as fact that Imane Khelif has Swyer's syndrome. There is no evidence for this, nor has it been reported anywhere else. There has been a leaked medical report, and a diagnosis of Swyer syndrome was not linked to those findings, but a diagnosis of 5-ARD was. 

The article then states that Khelif was "in 2023, at the World Championships, she was disqualified for high levels of testosterone."

Again, this is untrue. The IBA gender eligibility test included chromosomal testing:

https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2024/n...mes-claims


Here the IBA confirm that their testing did not involve testosterone levels:

https://www.iba.sport/news/statement-mad...egulations.

They also provide a breakdown of the timeline here:

https://www.iba.sport/news/iba-clarifies...knowledged

The sheer mental acrobatics to devalue an article by citing a 'leaked medical document' which has not been certified by anyone, anywhere is astonishing. 

But more importantly proves that her diagnosis isn't formally known. She could well have 5-ARD, she could have Swyer or 10s of other conditions. Either way if would mean she has an XY chromosome. But in terms of all the concerns you keep peddling, they would have hugely different ramifications. 

You seem strangely obsessed with a person's genetic sex, whilst disregarding so many other factors which are just at pertinent to the safety of other competitors. It seems to me that you have an agenda in terms of what you view as being a women, and that is of course your right, but it that doesn't sit well with the facts, the science, or even your own concerns in this case.

Your article was wrong. To restate:

The article claimed: "The match was authorized by the Olympic Committee based on the intersex athlete hormonal levels". This is untrue. As stated above, the IOC went with passport sex, no measurement of hormone levels was required. 

Then the article claimed: "Thus, the match could be played safely, given that science and the Olympic Committee had considered it “acceptable.” Again, what science? The IOC did not conduct any genetic or hormonal tests prior to the match. The IOC considered it safe, because the IOC accepted passport sex, with no other testing required.


Then the article claims "However, in 2023, at the World Championships, she (Khelif) was disqualified for high levels of testosterone". This is untrue. It did not happen. Again, as my link stated, this was due to failing a sex test.

That is three events which the author has stated as taking place, which never occured. Then the article repeatedly links Swyer syndrome to Khelif, despite there being no evidence of any diagnosis of that condition. This article proves nothing. 

I have pointed out, with links, that several items it asserted as fact were untrue. Instead of acknowledging this, you have instead ignored those and seized on one element. So you clearly don't have possession of the facts, or you wouldn't be citing such an easily disproven article.

This is a discussion about women's boxing so sex is very relevant to the conversation, not a "strange obsession". Genetic sex is the marker now being used by the IAAF, WBC and almost certainly the IOC in future competitions. So genetic sex is the matter at hand.
Reply
#54
We are arguing differently things.

I am not disputing she has a an XY chromosome. I haven't stated as fact that she has Swyers Syndrome. I am not saying any sporting bodies are not using genetic testing to inform their eligibility criteria. I do have eyes and I can read all of that for myself.

I am suggesting, and have done throughout, that I do not believe that genetic testing, alone, based on what we do/do not understand about DSDs and genetics, will be the silver bullet in achieving the outcomes in the areas what you keep purporting as your main concerns; safety of the competitors and sporting integrity. There too many other elements to just use genetics to appease people.

You keep referring to sex. Sex isn't just genetics. Let's take a women with Sywers as an example. Has a fully functioning birthing system. But no ovaries. So that women is capable of carrying a baby, delivering a baby. She has almost all of the female gonads, fully functioning female genitalia and has always lived as a women. But she has an XY chromosome. Is she a women? Can she compete as a women? I believe so, even if sports bodies currently do not.

You give me grief over not sticking up for women yet your so quick to disregard a sizeable number of women yourself. The irony is most definitely not lost on me.

P.s. the article was never about the decision made for me. It's about the flaws in using genetic testing alone.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#55
(09-04-2025, 05:28 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: We are arguing differently things.

I am not disputing she has a an XY chromosome. I haven't stated as fact that she has Swyers Syndrome. I am not saying any sporting bodies are not using genetic testing to inform their eligibility criteria. I do have eyes and I can read all of that for myself.

I am suggesting, and have done throughout, that I do not believe that genetic testing, alone, based on what we do/do not understand about DSDs and genetics, will be the silver bullet in achieving the outcomes in the areas what you keep purporting as your main concerns; safety of the competitors and sporting integrity. There too many other elements to just use genetics to appease people.

You keep referring to sex. Sex isn't just genetics. Let's take a women with Sywers as an example. Has a fully functioning birthing system. But no ovaries. So that women is capable of carrying a baby, delivering a baby. She has almost all of the female gonads, fully functioning female genitalia and has always lived as a women. But she has an XY chromosome. Is she a women? Can she compete as a women? I believe so, even if sports bodies currently do not.

You give me grief over not sticking up for women yet your so quick to disregard a sizeable number of women yourself. The irony is most definitely not lost on me.

P.s. the article was never about the decision made for me. It's about the flaws in using genetic testing alone.

As was said several pages back, laws are generally made in the interests of the majority. Women are 50% of the global population. Swyers affects 1 in 80,000 (estimated). I am quite happy to prioritise the interests of the former over the latter. Particularly as chromosomal testing is the most workable solution, whereas the case by case argument put forward in that article you shared would only serve to benefit lawyers and keep the CAS perpetually busy.
Reply
#56
I haven't proposed a case by case basis, do you actually read my posts? I haven't actually proposed a solution because I don't have all the research at hand.

If I was to guess at a solution for your concerns it would have to be more specific I think. I would list all the DSDs that cause a significant swing towards masculinity throughout puberty, and also limit testosterone in female athletes to 4 nmol/l. This does not then just target a very narrow group, most of whom won't have an advantage, but a much larger group of women sadly. But your concerns would be fully addressed.

What the solution will be to the additional barriers that some women would then face to access sport/competition on top of all the others that already exist, I don't really know. But it would be data/research driven at least rather than over simplified populism.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#57
If someone born a raised as a woman has a genetic particularity such as 5-Ard that gives them an advantage then they shouldn’t compete against other women.

If they have a genetic particularly such as Swyers which gives them no physical advantage then they should be allowed to compete.

In the latter case there is no disadvantage or increased danger to women without Swyers.

That’s completely logical.
Reply
#58
(09-04-2025, 11:54 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: I think that any member of the general public who knows too much about these types of things should not be listened to.  Not because their opinion is wrong or right, nor that the point they are trying to make isn't 'just' - in some way or another.  But the very fact that Joe Public 'understands' (possibly in the Dunning Kruger context, admittedly) some of these terms means that they have been researching them to prove their own preconceived opinion on the matter.  The likelihood of attaining agreement or even compromise is nil. 

In my experience and opinion, which may be Dunning Kruger-like
Dunno. I started looking into this when the case was raised (and discussed on here), 1st time around. I was genuinely interested as I am way out of my depth and like to think I am open minded. All I found is, as the song says, the more I found out the less I know.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)