Women's Boxing
#1
I can't find the original thread, which is a shame as some of the comments have aged like milk, especially the one calling Angela Carini a "drama queen", but the Court of Arbitration for Sport have issued a press release stating that that Imane Khelif has filed an appeal stating that they should be allowed to participate in the World Boxing Championships without undergoing a genetic test. 

Link to CAS press release:.https://www.tas-cas.org/fileadmin/user_upload/CAS_Media_Release_11650_appeal_EN.pdf

Link to media coverage:

https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2025/s...cas-boxing


In case people want to argue that Khelif is refusing to be tested because the test is too invasive, the test involves either a cheek swab or blood test:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/athletics/ar...d07jq6vpeo
Reply
#2
Have they established whether she was born male or female yet?
Reply
#3
(09-03-2025, 07:18 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Have they established whether she was born male or female yet?

I thought they said she was definitely a she at birth?? i lose track though. I don't see this as any different to having a drug test in sport, just make sure all boxers do the same test and surely there's no issue?
Reply
#4
The difficulty in these situations is finding the hill to die on


Do we do parameter testing and say you have to fit into certain physical characteristic bands? E.g. certain limb length, bone density, lung capacity , heart capacity. As we do for weight in boxing for example. Or do they do sex assigned at birth as the decider?

I am sure it was confirmed that Khalif was female at birth but had a degree of intersexed characteristics.

Such a difficult one for not only her but the sport too.

Unlike that fella who swims.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#5
(09-03-2025, 07:37 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: The difficulty in these situations is finding the hill to die on


Do we do parameter testing and say you have to fit into certain physical characteristic bands? E.g. certain limb length, bone density, lung capacity , heart capacity. As we do for weight in boxing for example. Or do they do sex assigned at birth as the decider?

I am sure it was confirmed that Khalif was female at birth but had a degree of intersexed characteristics.

Such a difficult one for not only her but the sport too.

Unlike that fella who swims.

Only on the first page and somebody is still trying the Phelps gambit.

This is why I wanted to find the old thread, because I'd actually gone to the bother of posting the times from a good medal race for Phelps v the equivalent women's competition.

Here they are again:

Results from the final
Rank Lane Name Nationality Time Notes
1st place, gold medalist(s) 5 Michael Phelps United States 50.58 OR
2nd place, silver medalist(s) 4 Milorad Čavić Serbia 50.59 ER
3rd place, bronze medalist(s) 3 Andrew Lauterstein Australia 51.12 OC
4 6 Ian Crocker United States 51.13
5 2 Jason Dunford Kenya 51.47
6 1 Takuro Fujii Japan 51.50 AS
7 7 Andriy Serdinov Ukraine 51.59
8 8 Ryan Pini Papua New Guinea 51.86


Final
Rank Lane Name Nationality Time Notes
1st place, gold medalist(s) 4 Lisbeth Trickett Australia 56.73 OC
2nd place, silver medalist(s) 5 Christine Magnuson United States 57.10
3rd place, bronze medalist(s) 3 Jessicah Schipper Australia 57.25
4 2 Zhou Yafei China 57.84
5 6 Tao Li Singapore 57.99
6 7 Jemma Lowe Great Britain 58.06
7 8 Gabriella Silva Brazil 58.10
8 1 Inge Dekker Netherlands 58.54

As is clear for all to see, the difference between the male and female times is vast. Hence we have separate sporting competitions for males and females.

Also, I'd add the people this is most difficult for are the women who were 1)Punched in the face by someone with male strength and 2)Denied a fair sporting competition and losing out on the opportunity of a career defining and life-changing gold medal. I imagine that would be pretty difficult too.
Reply
#6
But if she was born a female then isn't the complaint effectively - she's stronger than me I don't like it? Now obviously if she's gone through male puberty that's hugely different as the times you've posted show. I've no idea where you draw the line if you start cherry picking women who are stronger through whatever genetics (but aren't men).
Reply
#7
(09-03-2025, 07:58 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: But if she was born a female then isn't the complaint effectively - she's stronger than me I don't like it? Now obviously if she's gone through male puberty that's hugely different as the times you've posted show. I've no idea where you draw the line if you start cherry picking women who are stronger through whatever genetics (but aren't men).

guess it depends if she's taken medication for it as well, that could affect her strength and suchlike?
Reply
#8
If she's taken meds to make her stronger then surely you're into PED territory and she shouldn't be allowed to compete with men or women.

Elite sport is full of people with genetic advantages, I'm struggling to think of a sport that doesn't have it.
Reply
#9
It is likely that a genetic test would show XY chromosomes, meaning that Khelif has a disorder of sexual development.

This disorder is likely to be 5-ARD, which is the same condition that Caster Semanya has. People with this condition go through male puberty and have male levels of testosterone.

This means that it is fundamentally unfair for them to compete in women's competitions and in the case of boxing, dangerous.

So no, the complaint isn't "She's stronger than me and I don't like it". It is "This person is genetically male and has the physical advantages of male strength and stamina. It is agreed that males should not compete in women's competitions, therefore this person should not be allowed to compete in women's competitions".
Reply
#10
(09-03-2025, 08:26 AM)Squid Wrote: It is likely that a genetic test would show XY chromosomes, meaning that Khelif has a disorder of sexual development.

This disorder is likely to be 5-ARD, which is the same condition that Caster Semanya has. People with this condition go through male puberty and have male levels of testosterone.

This means that it is fundamentally unfair for them to compete in women's competitions and in the case of boxing, dangerous.

So no, the complaint isn't "She's stronger than me and I don't like it". It is "This person is genetically male and has the physical advantages of male strength and stamina. It is agreed that males should not compete in women's competitions, therefore this person should not be allowed to compete in women's competitions".

Yeah fair enough.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)