England v India Test Series!!..
You've not really answered it. You've had a bit of a hissy fit throwing abusive words at me. You stated we are punching above our weight...

Since 2023:

Drawn the Ashes 2-2. Lost a series to India 4-1. Beat Windies 3-0. Beat Sri Lanka 2-1. Lost to Pakistan 2-1. Beat NZ 2-1. Drawn to India 2-2.

We're 3rd in the ICC Test rankings.

A mix of good. Bad. And par. But I'm really struggling to see anything as punching above our weight in there. I think we're about where we should be, tbh. We've got players in the top 20 of the ICC players ranking, and the only team that outranks us in terms of numbers of players is the Aussies with their bowling attack, but of course that's skewed with the recent Broad retirement, and Jimmy not being selected anymore, combined with the likes of Wood, Archer, Robinson and even Woakes, missing some serious time with injury.

I will absolutely refute our potential squad isn't competitive with the likes of Australia and India, certainly not to the point where you can label England as underdogs.

If we were no.1 in the Test rankings, and went to India and won there, or won the Ashes, and had a more consistent record, then yes, that would maybe be punching. But our record shows that we have failed to beat good sides (India, Australia , Pakistan), NZ away is the exception, and have beaten sides we should (Windies and Sri Lanka).

So, which part of the above is us punching well above our weight? It's completely inaccurate, unless you expect us to lose every single Test series, and if so, then you're right, I suppose.

(08-04-2025, 12:28 PM)Old Fart Wrote: Yesterday was all about game management.  Brook had the bowlers in despair.  He could have plodded on for another 90 minutes, added 50 and then show boated with 25 runs to get and five or six wickets in hand. 

As for this morning's effort,  the first job is to defend your wicket.  We were waving the bat around like we were swatting flies.  The balls were wide and shoulder height and we still swiped at them like we had six balls left to get the 30. 

We had all day to get the runs.  There was no need to wave the fucking bat around and fall into the trap that was obviously being laid. 

 If the ball is on the wicket block it. If the ball is low and wide, hit it low to avoid being caught.  Anything else just leave it.  One run every couple of overs would have seen us home. 

I don't know what the instructions were this morning  but to me it looked like there weren't any. 

A very naïve performance.

(08-04-2025, 01:18 PM)wba13 Wrote: This isn’t sour grapes because India deserved the draw, but Indian all rounder Pant was allowed to bat in two tests though injured and India could bring in a better wicketkeeper who played virtually the entirety of those matches while Pant rested.England on the other hand were disadvantaged when Woakes was injured and we cannot bring in a replacement.
So effectively India played two tests with 12 men and we played most of 1 match with 10 men this cannot be right.
Yes it’s the rules but rules can be changed. Especially for severe injuries to a player.

Same as you, not sour grapes. But the injury rule has to be looked at. It's ridiculous playing a Test with 10 players, because you can't sub in another player, but you can sub fielders in and out all day. 

It needs looking at. 

England didn't lose the Test match, and failed to win the series, because of that rule, however. We should have won inspite of it.
Reply
Only Root, Brook and a fully fit Stokes would get into the India or Australia sides. We hang with them every time we play them at home in spite of this imbalance.

Crawley, Pope, all our spinners and all our seamers aside from Atkinson and Archer would struggle to get a game for the next tier of countries, Pakistan, NZ and South Africa. Yet we're ranked above them with these players playing leading roles.

The 2nd facet of the punching is the 17 tests prior to Bazball. 1 win in 17, against all comers. Also why have you only gone back to 2023. Stokes and McCullum took charge in 2022 and won 8 out 9 tests that year.
Reply
McCallums post match interview perplexing to say the least replying to the question England have no pre Ashes warm up matches he said touring & times have changed they don’t need them!!!..
He talking bollocks England rocked up to India under 48hrs prior to the first test buggered of back to Dubai for mid series break we’re hammered in the series 4-1 non of Englands losses remotely close!!..
Just for the record India’s batmen were here a good month before the first test & have scored the most runs of any touring Indian team.
McCallums plans do not bode well for the Ashes!!..
Reply
Because 2022 is 3 years ago and a good portion of players in those squads no longer play for England. It also has no relevance to your claim we are punching above our weight now. I assumed you meant now, and not 3 years ago!

Getting back to winning ways after the poor run isn't us punching above our weight. That's more to do with how poor we were before and us restoring parity.

So I ask again, which part of the results since 2023 have seen us punching above our weight? Or since 2024? You chose. Either way, we haven't gotten results to justify 'punching above our weight'.

I also believe you're seriously underestimating our talent pool to suit your argument.

Duckett
Root
Brook
Stokes
Archer
Wood

Wouldn't look out of place in the Aus/Indian. The likes of Pope, Atkinson, Smith have shown they can belong with the best in Test cricket.

I'm just not seeing this plucky underdog narrative you're trying to spin. Sorry. We're about par as far as I can tell. It's neither bad or spectacular. We compete with the best, lose series and win series, and beat teams we should. Nothing more. Nothing less.

(08-04-2025, 01:49 PM)pindgill Wrote: McCallums post match interview perplexing to say the least replying to the question England have no pre Ashes warm up matches he said touring & times of changed they don’t need them!!!..
He talking bollocks England rocked up to India under 48hrs prior to the first test buggered of back to Dubai for mid series break we’re hammered in the series 4-1 non of Englands losses remotely close!!..
Just for the record India’s batmen were here a good month before the first test & have scored the most runs of any touring Indian team.
McCallums plans do not bode well for the Ashes!!..

I'm not so sure about the need for a team to have a tour is essential, I'd prefer to see it than not, don't get me wrong.

However, what I'd definitely like to see is as many of our players as possible signing for Sheffield Shield clubs to get a feel for Australia conditions and how pitches play, so they're ready for the Ashes. That has always seemed more beneficial to me than touring against random teams. 

It's something Australian players seem to do when they tour for the Ashes.

Either way, we can't be planning on rocking up to the first Test without any preparation be it players playing in the Aus domestic league, or warm up matches. Can we?
Reply
Well how can we have warm up games with snow on the ground In Australia, them Aussies will try anything to win.I've heard there closing all the DIY shops to stop Smith buying sandpaper. Also sowing up all pockets to stop them hiding any.
Reply
What a series finale!

Superb entertainment from both sides and if test cricket was at deaths door then we have witness it's glorious re-birth.

This series had everything to grab the attention. As so many have iterated a 2-2 draw was a fair result. Neither team deserved to lose the series.

Inquests on both sides will be held on how to be better but I cannot fathom the criticism of Harry Brook. His century should have paved the way for a home victory, and had he played on to secure the victory by batting in the same vein it would have been hailed as an innings for the ages. He got out playing the way he got his century. Any other way he may not have got England so close.

In conclusion though this test was WON by India and not LOST by England. Both teams had opportunities to press home a real advantage but the fightbacks made this the great and closely contested game it played out to be.

It was also very fitting that Siraj struck the final blow, given his trials and tribulations yesterday. A truly world class bowler who stepped up in te absence of Bumrah.

(08-04-2025, 02:13 PM)wba13 Wrote: Well how can we have warm up games with snow on the ground In Australia, them Aussies will try anything to win.I've heard there closing all the DIY shops to stop Smith buying sandpaper. Also sowing up all pockets to stop them hiding any.

Let's make sure there's no dirt lying around either  Big Grin
Reply
(08-04-2025, 02:29 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: What a series finale!

Superb entertainment from both sides and if test cricket was at deaths door then we have witness it's glorious re-birth.

This series had everything to grab the attention. As so many have iterated a 2-2 draw was a fair result. Neither team deserved to lose the series.

Inquests on both sides will be held on how to be better but I cannot fathom the criticism of Harry Brook. His century should have paved the way for a home victory, and had he played on to secure the victory by batting in the same vein it would have been hailed as an innings for the ages. He got out playing the way he got his century. Any other way he may not have got England so close.

In conclusion though this test was WON by India and not LOST by England. Both teams had opportunities to press home a real advantage but the fightbacks made this the great and closely contested game it played out to be.

It was also very fitting that Siraj struck the final blow, given his trials and tribulations yesterday. A truly world class bowler who stepped up in te absence of Bumrah.

(08-04-2025, 02:13 PM)wba13 Wrote: Well how can we have warm up games with snow on the ground In Australia, them Aussies will try anything to win.I've heard there closing all the DIY shops to stop Smith buying sandpaper. Also sowing up all pockets to stop them hiding any.

Let's make sure there's no dirt lying around either  Big Grin

Agree with every word of that.
Reply
(08-04-2025, 01:49 PM)pindgill Wrote: McCallums post match interview perplexing to say the least replying to the question England have no pre Ashes warm up matches he said touring & times have changed they don’t need them!!!..
He talking bollocks England rocked up to India under 48hrs prior to the first test buggered of back to Dubai for mid series break we’re hammered in the series 4-1 non of Englands losses remotely close!!..
Just for the record India’s batmen were here a good month before the first test & have scored the most runs of any touring Indian team.
McCallums plans do not bode well for the Ashes!!..

And yet in the 5 away series England have played under McCullum they’ve won the opening test every time so maybe they don’t need warm up matches

(08-04-2025, 01:54 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Because 2022 is 3 years ago and a good portion of players in those squads no longer play for England. It also has no relevance to your claim we are punching above our weight now. I assumed you meant now, and not 3 years ago!

Getting back to winning ways after the poor run isn't us punching above our weight. That's more to do with how poor we were before and us restoring parity.

So I ask again, which part of the results since 2023 have seen us punching above our weight? Or since 2024? You chose. Either way, we haven't gotten results to justify 'punching above our weight'.

I also believe you're seriously underestimating our talent pool to suit your argument.

Duckett
Root
Brook
Stokes
Archer
Wood

Wouldn't look out of place in the Aus/Indian. The likes of Pope, Atkinson, Smith have shown they can belong with the best in Test cricket.

I'm just not seeing this plucky underdog narrative you're trying to spin. Sorry. We're about par as far as I can tell. It's neither bad or spectacular. We compete with the best, lose series and win series, and beat teams we should. Nothing more. Nothing less.

(08-04-2025, 01:49 PM)pindgill Wrote: McCallums post match interview perplexing to say the least replying to the question England have no pre Ashes warm up matches he said touring & times of changed they don’t need them!!!..
He talking bollocks England rocked up to India under 48hrs prior to the first test buggered of back to Dubai for mid series break we’re hammered in the series 4-1 non of Englands losses remotely close!!..
Just for the record India’s batmen were here a good month before the first test & have scored the most runs of any touring Indian team.
McCallums plans do not bode well for the Ashes!!..

I'm not so sure about the need for a team to have a tour is essential, I'd prefer to see it than not, don't get me wrong.

However, what I'd definitely like to see is as many of our players as possible signing for Sheffield Shield clubs to get a feel for Australia conditions and how pitches play, so they're ready for the Ashes. That has always seemed more beneficial to me than touring against random teams. 

It's something Australian players seem to do when they tour for the Ashes.

Either way, we can't be planning on rocking up to the first Test without any preparation be it players playing in the Aus domestic league, or warm up matches. Can we?

There’s about 20 Aussies playing for counties over here this year and only two are regulars in their test team. That’s how strong the Aussie pool of players is. How many England players are offered contracts to play in the Sheffield Shield? None. Obviously our test players wouldn’t be available during the Aussie season but nobody outside the squad gets invited, whereas the vast majority of theirs over here aren’t in the test team
Being brutally honest 
Reply
(08-04-2025, 11:34 AM)Old Fart Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 11:27 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 11:26 AM)Old Fart Wrote: Despite his century, Brook decided to showboat. 

 The way he was playing he could have seen the game out just by knocking the ball about on the ground and taking singles and twos. 

Unprofessional behaviour with a touch of arrogance and lack of clear instruction from the team manager, unless he told him to act like a twat.

You've managed to win the award for stupidest post on this thread, and that takes some doing.

Jesus fucking christ.

Thanks.  I shall wear the badge with honour.

From Jonathan Agnew BBC Sport

If you go back to key moments in this match, particularly with 73 runs needed with seven wickets in hand, England should be winning from there. 
There will be comments about Harry Brook's dismissal and I'll be one who says, really, was that necessary? With the game just within your grasp, the really hard-nosed professional attitude is that you win the game.
Joe Root and Brook had just snatched the game away from them with such an incredible 195-run partnership.
But if you speak to Michael Vaughan and Sir Alastair Cook, people who have scored far many more Test runs than I have, they'll say they're OK with it, so an old-timer shrugs his shoulders and says 'fair enough'.
But Brook was the only one who could have seized the game in the manner that he did because Root just played in his quiet, professional way.
He has since said he regretted the shot got that him out and fair enough to him, it's big of him to say that. You just hope that next time, in Sydney when they're 2-1 up to win the Ashes, he'll see England home!

Maybe not the most stupid post of the day? 
Reply
(08-04-2025, 08:09 PM)Old Fart Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 11:34 AM)Old Fart Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 11:27 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 11:26 AM)Old Fart Wrote: Despite his century, Brook decided to showboat. 

 The way he was playing he could have seen the game out just by knocking the ball about on the ground and taking singles and twos. 

Unprofessional behaviour with a touch of arrogance and lack of clear instruction from the team manager, unless he told him to act like a twat.

You've managed to win the award for stupidest post on this thread, and that takes some doing.

Jesus fucking christ.

Thanks.  I shall wear the badge with honour.

From Jonathan Agnew BBC Sport

If you go back to key moments in this match, particularly with 73 runs needed with seven wickets in hand, England should be winning from there. 
There will be comments about Harry Brook's dismissal and I'll be one who says, really, was that necessary? With the game just within your grasp, the really hard-nosed professional attitude is that you win the game.
Joe Root and Brook had just snatched the game away from them with such an incredible 195-run partnership.
But if you speak to Michael Vaughan and Sir Alastair Cook, people who have scored far many more Test runs than I have, they'll say they're OK with it, so an old-timer shrugs his shoulders and says 'fair enough'.
But Brook was the only one who could have seized the game in the manner that he did because Root just played in his quiet, professional way.
He has since said he regretted the shot got that him out and fair enough to him, it's big of him to say that. You just hope that next time, in Sydney when they're 2-1 up to win the Ashes, he'll see England home!

Maybe not the most stupid post of the day? 
The argument is that without Brook's innings England wouldn't have got close to winning the game. That's very true. 

However, once he'd got England to the cusp of victory, he should have reigned in his attacking instincts and taken 1s & 2s as he was doing until that kamikaze shot. Did Joe Root tell him to calm down and nurdle the runs?

 India were a spent force. The bowlers were serving up easy meat.

All credit to India for getting off the floor and turning the tables so they were the side exerting pressure which England couldn't deal with.

Down under England will face a team that gives no quarter. Once they have their foot on your throat they rarely give you any respite.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)