England v India Test Series!!..
(08-04-2025, 11:06 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Are we allowed to have a conversation about how Baz has let both Australia and India leave these shores with drawn series, despite having great chances to beat them both?

2018 our last series win at home against India. 2015 for Australia and we've certainly not improved our fortunes away from home. McCullum has some serious explaining and thinking to do for me.

Nah. India absolutely deserved two Test wins from this series. They played briliantly for a lot of the Series, as did England.

The thing people always always forget - there's two teams playing. India won that last game as much as England lost it.
Reply
(08-04-2025, 11:11 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 11:10 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 11:08 AM)wba13 Wrote: Great series , deservedly drawn,  but I do hope the umpires sit down and look at themselves because the have not been up to starboard though out this series.
But well done to India for coming back and winning this test match.
Certainly wasn't plain sailing.

They shouldn't take a bow...

Soem of those players need a stern talking to
Reply
2-2 Australia at home
1-4 India away
2-2 India at home

People will cite win ratios and percentages but in big series we've not delivered under this leadership, our moments of sloppiness, sorry, the way we play and our inability to sense the moments to really step on the throat of the opponent have cost us.

Australia at Edgbaston - stupid declaration. Australia at Lords without Nathan Lyon - fell victim to short ball theory (twice). India at Edgbaston - didn't even try and bat the day. India at the Oval - cruising to victory and tried one trick too many in a situation where the risk far outweighed the reward.

Not good enough.
Reply
(08-04-2025, 11:09 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: We just never converted good positions into a dominant position. That's a definite theme under old Baz, that people seem to overlook. 

Take a look at the below from this Test alone. We're lucky India didn't capitalise, either. 

We won the toss and bowled in favourable conditions, but bowled poorly. Conceding too many wides and extras. Missed opportunity.

We then got off to an excellent start in the 1st innings, but went on to lose our last 7 wickets for 100 runs. Failing to take a substantial first innings lead. Missed opportunity. - India bowled exceptionally well to take those last wickets for the runs they did.

6 dropped catches in India's seconds innings, leading to a substantial run chase. Missed opportunity. yes the drops were bad, but India capitalised

We were then 300-3 chasing 370 odd. Then collapsed. Missed opportunity. again, some very good Indian bowling caused this as much as any poor shots from England

We have to find a way of converting good positions into dominant positions, and not allow the opposition a sniff. We consistently fail to put the opposition away. That failure has cost us this Test match and this series. It's something that desperately needs addressing before the Ashes, because I can tell you now Australia won't give England as many chances as India have, as soon as we let Australia back into a game they will punish us.

Two teams in every game. Give India credit at the same time as criticising England. It's always both.
Reply
(08-04-2025, 11:13 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: 2-2 Australia at home
1-4 India away
2-2 India at home

People will cite win ratios and percentages but in big series we've not delivered under this leadership, our moments of sloppiness, sorry, the way we play and our inability to sense the moments to really step on the throat of the opponent have cost us.

Australia at Edgbaston - stupid declaration. Australia at Lords without Nathan Lyon - fell victim to short ball theory (twice). India at Edgbaston - didn't even try and bat the day. India at the Oval - cruising to victory and tried one trick too many in a situation where the risk far outweighed the reward.

Not good enough.

Agreed. 

It's not been the revolution people think. But it's OK, because we hit a few more boundaries and make more exoctic shots that are more at home in the IPL than anyone else. Failure to beat the top sides in a Test series has been a recent theme. 

But don't let recent results against the top sides get in the way, because we've beaten Ireland and Zimbabwe, don't you know!
Reply
Or India and Australia are better than a side that has been rebuilt from a team that had 1 win in 17.

We are punching well above our weight, entirely because of the way we play.
Reply
(08-04-2025, 11:15 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 11:13 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: 2-2 Australia at home
1-4 India away
2-2 India at home

People will cite win ratios and percentages but in big series we've not delivered under this leadership, our moments of sloppiness, sorry, the way we play and our inability to sense the moments to really step on the throat of the opponent have cost us.

Australia at Edgbaston - stupid declaration. Australia at Lords without Nathan Lyon - fell victim to short ball theory (twice). India at Edgbaston - didn't even try and bat the day. India at the Oval - cruising to victory and tried one trick too many in a situation where the risk far outweighed the reward.

Not good enough.

Agreed. 

It's not been the revolution people think. But it's OK, because we hit a few more boundaries and make more exoctic shots that are more at home in the IPL than anyone else. Failure to beat the top sides in a Test series has been a resent theme. 

But don't let recent results against the top sides get in the way, because we've beaten Ireland and Zimbabwe, don't you know!

Christ alive. I'm done with this thread I think.

(08-04-2025, 11:16 AM)Jacko Wrote: Or India and Australia are better than a side that has been rebuilt from a team that had 1 win in 17.

We are punching well above our weight, entirely because of the way we play.

This.
Reply
(08-04-2025, 11:12 AM)strawman Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 11:11 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 11:10 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 11:08 AM)wba13 Wrote: Great series , deservedly drawn,  but I do hope the umpires sit down and look at themselves because the have not been up to starboard though out this series.
But well done to India for coming back and winning this test match.
Certainly wasn't plain sailing.

They shouldn't take a bow...

Soem of those players need a stern talking to

Reading some of this we sounded quite rudderless
Reply
(08-04-2025, 11:16 AM)Jacko Wrote: Or India and Australia are better than a side that has been rebuilt from a team that had 1 win in 17.

We are punching well above our weight, entirely because of the way we play.

Utter nonsense. In that time we've had two of the greatest bowlers of all time, and one of the best batsman of all time, Stokes would get into any international team in the world. 

Let's not pretend we're some plucky underdog with a team full of no hopers. We have a plethera of talent that competes with any Nation.
Reply
(08-04-2025, 11:12 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 11:06 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Are we allowed to have a conversation about how Baz has let both Australia and India leave these shores with drawn series, despite having great chances to beat them both?

2018 our last series win at home against India. 2015 for Australia and we've certainly not improved our fortunes away from home. McCullum has some serious explaining and thinking to do for me.

Nah. India absolutely deserved two Test wins from this series. They played briliantly for a lot of the Series, as did England.

The thing people always always forget - there's two teams playing. India won that last game as much as England lost it.

Since lunch on Day 4 at OT India have been brilliant, guts, mental toughness and perhaps the knowledge that if they stayed in the game long enough we'd give them a chance and we did.

I'm taking nothing away from what India brought to the series, Gill was excellent, Krishna, Siraj, Bumrah, Jadeja, Washington all contributing. 

Fact remains that from the position we were in when Brook got out, we had both hands on the game. India were done, they were flat, they were gone. Great sides who win series against the best opposition do not give teams a way back in as often as this England side to and it is what will prevent them being truly great. India didn't do anything special to get back into this game, just waited for England to make their mistake and then bowled well when it started swinging.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: