England v India Test Series!!..
Changing the ball if it goes out of shape should not be allowed. It's a ridiculous rule.

If you don't want the ball to go out of shape, find a way to take wickets and bowl the opposition out quickly, or find a way to stop the batsmen hitting the ball which in turn puts it out of shape.

God, this England team are detestable.
Reply
(07-10-2025, 07:39 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Changing the ball if it goes out of shape should not be allowed. It's a ridiculous rule.

If you don't want the ball to go out of shape, find a way to take wickets and bowl the opposition out quickly, or find a way to stop the batsmen hitting the ball which in turn puts it out of shape.

God, this England team are detestable.

Tbh, yes it should. It's like playing on in a football game with a burst ball. 

What I don't like is the assertion that once again Bazball knows better than the umpires and the suggestion towards the Kookaburra ball which has just seen the most boring round of CC run scoring in recent memory.
Reply
(07-10-2025, 07:26 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Archer back in for England which was predictable. Looking forward to him being asked to bowl a 12-over spell of bouncers after we win the toss and bowl on the hottest day of the year.

Surprised we've gone with one change. There's a couple of obvious swaps that should be on the cards if we lose this match. Crawley (would be looking at Tom Haines from Sussex), Pope needs more runs in the latter stages of a game, Bet he'll should get a chance and Bashir if we're not going to give him any assistance needs to go back to playing county 2nd XI cricket. I'd be looking at Liam Dawson, a much better bowler than previous England stints and more than handy with the bat.

Here's a link below for anyone wondering where the dislikeable and arrogant shouts come from. Funnily enough, as India have scored 1,000 runs over the first two tests I wasn't thinking "god I wish Woakes was bowling 78mph with a Kookaburra" - fucking idiots.

https://x.com/TheCricketerMag/status/194...QHYGw&s=19
It's behind a pay wall, Ted. Although I think the headline and caption put across the point anyway. Agree with all of the above. We are struggling to bed in a genuine quickie and relying on Archer or Wood to suddenly have a run of fitness. Something they haven't done previously.  
Crawley's place ought to be under threat. I've never known a player get to the 20s, 30s, so often and get out cheaply. Unfortunately paired with Duckett one of them is always back in the pavilion early on. This means our natural no.3s and 4s are coming in pretty much as openers. Maybe pressure for places works, eh?
All genuine criticism aside though, I do enjoy watching this England side.  Better judgement on certain calls and another look at how/why players are selected would go a long way to compensating the bowling issues.
Reply
(07-10-2025, 07:43 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(07-10-2025, 07:39 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Changing the ball if it goes out of shape should not be allowed. It's a ridiculous rule.

If you don't want the ball to go out of shape, find a way to take wickets and bowl the opposition out quickly, or find a way to stop the batsmen hitting the ball which in turn puts it out of shape.

God, this England team are detestable.

Tbh, yes it should. It's like playing on in a football game with a burst ball. 

What I don't like is the assertion that once again Bazball knows better than the umpires and the suggestion towards the Kookaburra ball which has just seen the most boring round of CC run scoring in recent memory.

To be fair, India ask for it to be changed just as much. It's not an England thing. Pant and Gill have been very vocal on and off the pitch. The quality of the Duke ball has deteriorated for some reason and should be addressed. It's not arrogant to complain about something that both sides feel so strongly about.
Reply
(07-10-2025, 08:04 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(07-10-2025, 07:26 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Archer back in for England which was predictable. Looking forward to him being asked to bowl a 12-over spell of bouncers after we win the toss and bowl on the hottest day of the year.

Surprised we've gone with one change. There's a couple of obvious swaps that should be on the cards if we lose this match. Crawley (would be looking at Tom Haines from Sussex), Pope needs more runs in the latter stages of a game, Bet he'll should get a chance and Bashir if we're not going to give him any assistance needs to go back to playing county 2nd XI cricket. I'd be looking at Liam Dawson, a much better bowler than previous England stints and more than handy with the bat.

Here's a link below for anyone wondering where the dislikeable and arrogant shouts come from. Funnily enough, as India have scored 1,000 runs over the first two tests I wasn't thinking "god I wish Woakes was bowling 78mph with a Kookaburra" - fucking idiots.

https://x.com/TheCricketerMag/status/194...QHYGw&s=19
It's behind a pay wall, Ted. Although I think the headline and caption put across the point anyway. Agree with all of the above. We are struggling to bed in a genuine quickie and relying on Archer or Wood to suddenly have a run of fitness. Something they haven't done previously.  
Crawley's place ought to be under threat. I've never known a player get to the 20s, 30s, so often and get out cheaply. Unfortunately paired with Duckett one of them is always back in the pavilion early on. This means our natural no.3s and 4s are coming in pretty much as openers. Maybe pressure for places works, eh?
All genuine criticism aside though, I do enjoy watching this England side.  Better judgement on certain calls and another look at how/why players are selected would go a long way to compensating the bowling issues.

Carse and Tongue are quick enough but we have no appreciation of match situation so they end up going at 4-5 an over, hoping they can conjure a wicket out of nowhere or through a batter getting themselves out.

The pitches we're asking for have been crap, no surprise they've asked for "some life" in the Lords pitch, pray for Crawley. 

I too enjoy watching a team thrash it to all parts, it's a skill and it doesn't happen very often. You earn the right to play cricket like that, ultimately it's worthless if you lose games you could have drawn (Edgbaston this series) and end up throwing away matches you have a great chance of winning through stubbornness (Lords last Ashes). The occasional 10/10 performance is worth a lot less when it's followed up with a bunch of 3 and 4/10 games.
Reply
(07-10-2025, 08:26 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(07-10-2025, 08:04 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(07-10-2025, 07:26 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Archer back in for England which was predictable. Looking forward to him being asked to bowl a 12-over spell of bouncers after we win the toss and bowl on the hottest day of the year.

Surprised we've gone with one change. There's a couple of obvious swaps that should be on the cards if we lose this match. Crawley (would be looking at Tom Haines from Sussex), Pope needs more runs in the latter stages of a game, Bet he'll should get a chance and Bashir if we're not going to give him any assistance needs to go back to playing county 2nd XI cricket. I'd be looking at Liam Dawson, a much better bowler than previous England stints and more than handy with the bat.

Here's a link below for anyone wondering where the dislikeable and arrogant shouts come from. Funnily enough, as India have scored 1,000 runs over the first two tests I wasn't thinking "god I wish Woakes was bowling 78mph with a Kookaburra" - fucking idiots.

https://x.com/TheCricketerMag/status/194...QHYGw&s=19
It's behind a pay wall, Ted. Although I think the headline and caption put across the point anyway. Agree with all of the above. We are struggling to bed in a genuine quickie and relying on Archer or Wood to suddenly have a run of fitness. Something they haven't done previously.  
Crawley's place ought to be under threat. I've never known a player get to the 20s, 30s, so often and get out cheaply. Unfortunately paired with Duckett one of them is always back in the pavilion early on. This means our natural no.3s and 4s are coming in pretty much as openers. Maybe pressure for places works, eh?
All genuine criticism aside though, I do enjoy watching this England side.  Better judgement on certain calls and another look at how/why players are selected would go a long way to compensating the bowling issues.

Carse and Tongue are quick enough but we have no appreciation of match situation so they end up going at 4-5 an over, hoping they can conjure a wicket out of nowhere or through a batter getting themselves out.

The pitches we're asking for have been crap, no surprise they've asked for "some life" in the Lords pitch, pray for Crawley. 

I too enjoy watching a team thrash it to all parts, it's a skill and it doesn't happen very often. You earn the right to play cricket like that, ultimately it's worthless if you lose games you could have drawn (Edgbaston this series) and end up throwing away matches you have a great chance of winning through stubbornness (Lords last Ashes). The occasional 10/10 performance is worth a lot less when it's followed up with a bunch of 3 and 4/10 games.

That last sentence doesn't match up with the actual results, seems an incredibly harsh view.

Good performances and excellent wins very much outnumber the shockers.

It feels to me that some people just dislike BM and BS and subconsciously or consciously judge their record with little balance. Grudging praise if they win, usually saying the other team gifted it, and absolutely slaughtering a defeat.

I don't think they are without criticism. I don't like the closed shop feel to the squad, they were far too gung ho although that's been reigned in. However, given we aren’t in a golden age player wise, with depth in red ball cricket being as shallow as I've ever known it, the results have been, in the whole, excellent under them. We've had some of the most entertaining tests in my lifetime.
Reply
(07-10-2025, 08:41 AM)richbaggie Wrote: I don't think they are without criticism. I don't like the closed shop feel to the squad, they were far too gung ho although that's been reigned in. However, given we aren’t in a golden age player wise, with depth in red ball cricket being as shallow as I've ever known it, the results have been, in the whole, excellent under them. We've had some of the most entertaining tests in my lifetime.

Last sentence probably nails it, given the relative lack of top-class players coming through the county system this is arguably the optimal way to play. We'll just have to wear a few when we lose ridiculous games, on the flip side it's given a team with players like Crawley and Bashir roles in winning games that they basically had no right to win.
Reply
We find some incredibly poor ways to get out. Long Hop outside leg stump.

So fragile. Drinks has changed everything. Lacquer off, we could end up 4 or 5 down by lunch if we don't shape up.
Reply
When are the England management going to realise that Crawley is not a test match cricketer. I’m still unsure about Pope.
Reply
(07-10-2025, 11:14 AM)wba13 Wrote: When are the England management going to realise that Crawley is not a test match cricketer. I’m still unsure about Pope.

Doesn't matter when Key is best mates with Crawley's dad. Awful cricketer.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: