Blue Labour
#21
(07-02-2025, 01:50 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Universal basic income anyone?

We essentially have it already.
Reply
#22
(07-02-2025, 02:39 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-02-2025, 01:50 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Universal basic income anyone?

We essentially have it already.

That’s kind of my point. Why not formalise it and make it more equitable and functional.

It genuinely can contribute to mobility and growth when done properly.

The problem at the moment isn’t just what you outline above (and I agree with you about the impact it has had) but the narratives and SFPs attached to what it is for and what it means to recipients.

Tax credits were actually very enabling for a period before they became more of a dependency and a disruptor to personal ambition and incentives for wage and career development
Reply
#23
(07-02-2025, 11:03 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-02-2025, 10:51 AM)baggy1 Wrote: And it appears I don't understand your use of 'client state' - it might help here by explaining what you mean.

Kendall is portrayed by the Labour left and the puerile disabled demonstrators as a wild-eyed axewoman. Yet all the Government is trying to do is to reduce the rate at which the Welfare bill is rising. Last night showed the huge political difficulties there would be even if the rate of growth were reduced  let alone if real cuts were planned. This is no accident. This is what Gordon Brown spent 13 years working towards.

He may have been one of the worst PMs in history but as a political strategist he knew exactly what he was doing. His introduction of Tax Credits was not about alleviating poverty so much as creating a new class of benefit recipient - not just those out of work and on the borderline of poverty but those in full-time work in good health who would previously never have come near benefits.

In 1979, 43.1 per cent of households received more in benefits than they paid in taxes. (The definition used in the report includes state spending on benefits in kind, such as the NHS and state education.)

Brown's handiwork led to that increasing from 43.1 to 53.4 per cent - or in real terms, added a further three million households to the ledger of those who are net recipients of the state. And it's the middle income earners who have transformed the picture. In 1990 the average household in the middle group of earners used to pay £1,673 more in tax than it received in benefits.

Twenty years later those middle earners had become net recipients - taking on average £4,589 more in benefits than they paid in taxation. That is a dramatic change.

If you divide households into five groups, from the poorest through to the highest earners, you'd find in 2010 that the top fifth effectively pays for the rest of the country to receive benefits.

Gordon Brown essentially made the vast majority of us all clients of the State, and as such dependent / grateful to the Labour Party for the scraps thrown to us. The bungs to us in Covid relief and Energy price relief have deeply embedded this. The huge rise in sickness and disability claims since Covid is all part of the same pattern.

That’s what I wish to dismantle.

I agree with the principal here but I would push back on the inclusion of education and the NHS in that for the reason that both of those improve everyones life wether or not they use them. Best example there is that if I don't have children I will still benefit from everyone being educated, or the availability of the NHS whether or not i use it. 

The whole system needs reform but, as you say, we have become a nation whereby any reform is seen as taking money off someone. We've only got to look at the reactions from WFA and the welfare reforms.
Reply
#24
(07-02-2025, 02:42 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Why not formalise it and make it more equitable and functional.

I've thought long and hard about UBI for years.

You can only introduce this by radically reshaping the tax system and abolishing other distortions like the minimum wage - otherwise any remaining incentives to individuals will wither and die. And we all become clients of the state.

I doubt this story will engender sympathy but this is reality for many of my friends kids at the moment:
https://www.cityam.com/100k-isnt-a-big-s...a9JyrEfaxg
Reply
#25
A few critiques of the article - it uses inflation to increase the expenses but not his salary: £50k salary increase (no adjustment for inflation) resulting in a £6k net disposable income (after taking into account inflation). Can’t have it both ways. A £50k salary in 2019 is equivalent to £65k today, so he’s had a 58% increase resulting in disposable income increase of 27% taking into account he’d doubled his rent without inflation isn’t quite the heartbreak story it’s made out to be.

Then there is the better living situation that he is now in compared to when he was on £50k and surprise surprise, living in your own rental is more expensive than a shared rental.

Tax: he’s moved up a tax bracket and that’s the same for everyone.

Pension: he’d be daft not to pay into his pension seeing as it would bring him below the £100k so it could be next to free.

I’d also be having a word with him about his life choices if he were my kid. Both of mine earn less than him, both married, both in their own home (mortgaged) and both with kid or will be soon. He needs to shit or get off the pot with his missus as well. My kids made sacrifices with going out, holidays, and combining their lives,

I know it’s a hypothetical scenario and it’s the recent angle for the anti-taxation groups to hang their hats, but there isn’t much sympathy here in the real world I’m afraid.
Reply
#26
The actual problem is that the top 20% of earners threshold is ~£45k before tax. That's low for a first world country, countries like Slovenia, Poland, Estonia and Czechia are catching up and the former already has a higher median income.

I also don't consider income to be a good indicator for whether someone's a "net beneficiary", voluntary social or charitable work is just one way things get distorted - especially family carers. Other distortions like whether you went to private school or whether you're an immigrant come into play.

As for "Blue Labour", they are entirely a social policy group - not the "more economically aligned with the Tory party group" and not the current government. Glasman is a MAGA weirdo who hangs out with Curtis Yarvin in his own free time ffs.
Reply
#27
Dont forget pre working tax/child tax credits

we had married tax allowance or whatever it was called

Those whom didnt have kids or couldnt lost that reduction

The money went to those with kids & went up for every one there after

Hence why so many work shy increased their offspring because it was financially worth it
Reply
#28
(07-02-2025, 10:47 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Again Dekka makes up his own words and then complains about it. Nobody said widespread. Much in the same way that Chunk has never come across overtime in the modern world, it exists whether or not you believe in it.

The disappointing side of what is happening is there are no solutions that will appease everyone, they put a solution in place and made it clear that the most vulnerable would not be impacted and in fact better off. But why would you believe that when some bloke off youtube says differently. I would guarantee that for every person that was genuinely in need, if they had simply gone through the new process they could have seen they would be ok.

You are an advocate for disability rights Dekka, it would be interesting to see where any of the conditions in the new scoring would have made anyone you know who currently gets one off the benefits worse off. If you could articulate that it would be interesting.

You keep arguing these cuts were about reform, they weren’t, they were written on the back of a fag packet after Reeves and the Treasury had to find savings. Even the civil servants that are ‘working’ on the detail of these alleged reforms says they had barely even up until the vote worked upon them. There was no consultation with disability groups or those potentially effected, there is no detail about how they will get more people back in the work and there is no impact statement before the vote. That is not a bill it’s a cost cutting exercise, that they want to justify so they are labelled ‘reforms’. 

Just admit the whole thing has been handled appallingly and is incredibly ill thought out (no thought more accurate) culminating in the farce yesterday with Kendall floundering. 

No policy should be cut first consult later or have you abandoned the notion you talk to experts these days? You used to be all for them during Brexit. 

How can anyone judge whether these cuts/reform would work with such scant and ill thought out information presented to people. 

They haven’t as far as I know even clarified if the mist severely disabled can get the health element of universal credit until the are 21, that’s a cut if they can’t of hundreds of pounds a month from the age of 16 (how is that fair?) and given most people whonlooo after term in that situation have to give up full time work or have to become full time carers, how exactly would that help those families? It’s easy to pontificate from a position of relative comfort that there is no need to worry but when you see this government floundering, lying and using divisive language it’s hard to trust a single word they say. 

I cannot believe you are still defending this clusterfuck of a bill, when it’s become clear to most how truly terrible it was/is.
Reply
#29
When the experts make up obviously disingenuous statements then they are not experts at all. The examples you cited from the experts were easily disproved and yet you don’t acknowledge that at all. I’ve asked you to actually try the scoring mechanism for all those you know and let me know if any are disadvantaged, I’m genuinely interested, but you seem either unable or unwilling to try this.
Reply
#30
(07-02-2025, 09:27 PM)baggy1 Wrote: When the experts make up obviously disingenuous statements then they are not experts at all. The examples you cited from the experts were easily disproved and yet you don’t acknowledge that at all. I’ve asked you to actually try the scoring mechanism for all those you know and let me know if any are disadvantaged, I’m genuinely interested, but you seem either unable or unwilling to try this.

The experts are wrong but anecdotal evidence. Dear me.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)