Blue Labour
#11
(07-02-2025, 08:46 AM)baggy1 Wrote: You could clamp down on what people eat but you'd see that as state interference, so unfortunately that is a reality.

Welfare is my biggest concern as to rising cost. As much as Dekka doesn't believe it, there is a level of abuse of this system that is getting bigger especially after Covid. 

Attempting to prevent Fatty Bruce from eating another Ginsters will not stop us all aging and the dependency ratio reaching crisis point.

There's a huge level of abuse of PIP, it's blindingly obvious from the sheer scale of new applications. But as I said, Gordon Brown created the Client State and too few people were prepared to countenance dismantling it in 2010, including you most probably.
Reply
#12
(07-02-2025, 09:55 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-02-2025, 08:46 AM)baggy1 Wrote: You could clamp down on what people eat but you'd see that as state interference, so unfortunately that is a reality.

Welfare is my biggest concern as to rising cost. As much as Dekka doesn't believe it, there is a level of abuse of this system that is getting bigger especially after Covid. 

Attempting to prevent Fatty Bruce from eating another Ginsters will not stop us all aging and the dependency ratio reaching crisis point.

There's a huge level of abuse of PIP, it's blindingly obvious from the sheer scale of new applications. But as I said, Gordon Brown created the Client State and too few people were prepared to countenance dismantling it in 2010, including you most probably.

Here's the problem in a nutshell - reduced level of monitoring, as you continuously call for, leads to increased abuse of any system. If you reduce the level of application monitoring then more abuse will get through. And yet you want to a) reduce the workforce and its pay and conditions that carry out the monitoring, and b) at the same time complain that the monitoring is not good enough and they need to do more.
Reply
#13
(07-02-2025, 08:46 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(07-02-2025, 08:32 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-02-2025, 08:06 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Based on your predictions before the election this was always meant to be no matter who got voted in, so maybe the problem isn't the government, it's the legacy.

You're right, it's the legacy of Gordon Brown creating a client state which has grown into a monster. No backbench Labour politician has the guts to reform it.

Every politician knows that health and welfare are already unaffordable. None of them seem prepared to do anything about it.

I'm expecting another huge tax grab in October, I'd prepare yourself accordingly if I were you.

Health is what it is due to population growth and modern health issues putting strain on the services. You could clamp down on what people eat but you'd see that as state interference, so unfortunately that is a reality.

Welfare is my biggest concern as to rising cost. As much as Dekka doesn't believe it, there is a level of abuse of this system that is getting bigger especially after Covid. 

I'm prepared, Income Tax is what it is, the rumours about ISA allowances dropping to £4k unless SSISA are meh, and I can't see them going after pensions again unless they kill the industry by taking away the salary sacrifice. They've hit IHT by including pensions, which I actually agree with, so can't see how that would be increased. PAs are frozen anyway. Bit of a bind to see where it will come from tbh.

The problem is declaring there is widespread fraud in PIP etc is fine, but you do have to have some proof and a workable solution put together that works and protects those that are genuinely in need. The fact this whole bill was about cutting billions from the budget first and reform was an afterthought/slogan to justify the cuts, when Reeves own sums didn’t add up. 

If the original proposal was done properly it would have consulted disability organisations first, tried to find a reason why PIP had seen such an uptake and why access to work for the disabled who can work is so poor. They have done the bare minimum on this and unless they do it won’t work it’ll just push problems into other areas of social care, health, local authority provision. IMO it wouldn’t have solved any problems or saved anywhere near the money it was supposed to in the medium to long term. 

For example how many people on long term sick could work if the NHS cut waiting times for ops and mental health? 

Is there any incentive for businesses to take on someone with additional needs? What would encourage employers to help with this? 

Can they take people who will never work and will always need care that they can’t afford on their own out of the draconian UVC and reassessment system. 

B1 bangs on at an individual on an obscure WBA messageboard for solutions when it’s abundantly clear that Starmer, Reeves and Kendall had no solutions other than to cut billions and then scrabble around for ill thought out solutions afterwards. A pathetic way to run anything let alone a country. 

Btw how much do Starmer advisers cost? Anyone even some on here could see the iceberg that was heading the governments way with the way they’ve navigated the Good ship Shitshow.
Reply
#14
(07-02-2025, 10:16 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(07-02-2025, 09:55 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-02-2025, 08:46 AM)baggy1 Wrote: You could clamp down on what people eat but you'd see that as state interference, so unfortunately that is a reality.

Welfare is my biggest concern as to rising cost. As much as Dekka doesn't believe it, there is a level of abuse of this system that is getting bigger especially after Covid. 

Attempting to prevent Fatty Bruce from eating another Ginsters will not stop us all aging and the dependency ratio reaching crisis point.

There's a huge level of abuse of PIP, it's blindingly obvious from the sheer scale of new applications. But as I said, Gordon Brown created the Client State and too few people were prepared to countenance dismantling it in 2010, including you most probably.

Here's the problem in a nutshell - reduced level of monitoring, as you continuously call for, leads to increased abuse of any system. If you reduce the level of application monitoring then more abuse will get through. And yet you want to a) reduce the workforce and its pay and conditions that carry out the monitoring, and b) at the same time complain that the monitoring is not good enough and they need to do more.

I'm sorry, do I?

What I actually want to do is to dismantle is the Client State. You do that in Tax Credits for instance by simply not taking money off people in the first place, only to give it back.

I am very much all for a workforce monitoring and establishing who is in genuine need, as clearly there's a huge cohort who're not - unless we're more disabled and unhealthy than virtually every other nation on Earth.
Reply
#15
Again Dekka makes up his own words and then complains about it. Nobody said widespread. Much in the same way that Chunk has never come across overtime in the modern world, it exists whether or not you believe in it.

The disappointing side of what is happening is there are no solutions that will appease everyone, they put a solution in place and made it clear that the most vulnerable would not be impacted and in fact better off. But why would you believe that when some bloke off youtube says differently. I would guarantee that for every person that was genuinely in need, if they had simply gone through the new process they could have seen they would be ok.

You are an advocate for disability rights Dekka, it would be interesting to see where any of the conditions in the new scoring would have made anyone you know who currently gets one off the benefits worse off. If you could articulate that it would be interesting.
Reply
#16
(07-02-2025, 10:24 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The problem is declaring there is widespread fraud in PIP etc is fine, but you do have to have some proof and a workable solution put together that works and protects those that are genuinely in need. The fact this whole bill was about cutting billions from the budget first and reform was an afterthought/slogan to justify the cuts, when Reeves own sums didn’t add up. 

If the original proposal was done properly it would have consulted disability organisations first, tried to find a reason why PIP had seen such an uptake and why access to work for the disabled who can work is so poor. They have done the bare minimum on this and unless they do it won’t work it’ll just push problems into other areas of social care, health, local authority provision. IMO it wouldn’t have solved any problems or saved anywhere near the money it was supposed to in the medium to long term. 

For example how many people on long term sick could work if the NHS cut waiting times for ops and mental health? 

Is there any incentive for businesses to take on someone with additional needs? What would encourage employers to help with this? 

Can they take people who will never work and will always need care that they can’t afford on their own out of the draconian UVC and reassessment system. 

B1 bangs on at an individual on an obscure WBA messageboard for solutions when it’s abundantly clear that Starmer, Reeves and Kendall had no solutions other than to cut billions and then scrabble around for ill thought out solutions afterwards. A pathetic way to run anything let alone a country. 

Btw how much do Starmer advisers cost? Anyone even some on here could see the iceberg that was heading the governments way with the way they’ve navigated the Good ship Shitshow.

You're half right. Liz Kendall has been working in this area for 30 years - I'm pretty damned sure she wanted real welfare reform. 

She knew Labour's Manifesto committed her to finding £3.5bn.

Unfortunately she is allied to an incompetent Chancellor who having reversed herself into a fiscal straitjacket decided to change to whole thrust of the Green Paper from one which promoted savings via Welfare Reform to one which simply promotes savings. Blame Reeves, don't blame Kendall who I have a lot of sympathy for.
Reply
#17
(07-02-2025, 10:43 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-02-2025, 10:16 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(07-02-2025, 09:55 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-02-2025, 08:46 AM)baggy1 Wrote: You could clamp down on what people eat but you'd see that as state interference, so unfortunately that is a reality.

Welfare is my biggest concern as to rising cost. As much as Dekka doesn't believe it, there is a level of abuse of this system that is getting bigger especially after Covid. 

Attempting to prevent Fatty Bruce from eating another Ginsters will not stop us all aging and the dependency ratio reaching crisis point.

There's a huge level of abuse of PIP, it's blindingly obvious from the sheer scale of new applications. But as I said, Gordon Brown created the Client State and too few people were prepared to countenance dismantling it in 2010, including you most probably.

Here's the problem in a nutshell - reduced level of monitoring, as you continuously call for, leads to increased abuse of any system. If you reduce the level of application monitoring then more abuse will get through. And yet you want to a) reduce the workforce and its pay and conditions that carry out the monitoring, and b) at the same time complain that the monitoring is not good enough and they need to do more.

I'm sorry, do I?

What I actually want to do is to dismantle is the Client State. You do that in Tax Credits for instance by simply not taking money off people in the first place, only to give it back.

I am very much all for a workforce monitoring and establishing who is in genuine need, as clearly there's a huge cohort who're not - unless we're more disabled and unhealthy than virtually every other nation on Earth.

That appears to be the problem, it isn't clear otherwise people wouldn't be arguing that it doesn't exist. 

And it appears I don't understand your use of 'client state' - it might help here by explaining what you mean.
Reply
#18
(07-02-2025, 10:51 AM)baggy1 Wrote: And it appears I don't understand your use of 'client state' - it might help here by explaining what you mean.

Kendall is portrayed by the Labour left and the puerile disabled demonstrators as a wild-eyed axewoman. Yet all the Government is trying to do is to reduce the rate at which the Welfare bill is rising. Last night showed the huge political difficulties there would be even if the rate of growth were reduced  let alone if real cuts were planned. This is no accident. This is what Gordon Brown spent 13 years working towards.

He may have been one of the worst PMs in history but as a political strategist he knew exactly what he was doing. His introduction of Tax Credits was not about alleviating poverty so much as creating a new class of benefit recipient - not just those out of work and on the borderline of poverty but those in full-time work in good health who would previously never have come near benefits.

In 1979, 43.1 per cent of households received more in benefits than they paid in taxes. (The definition used in the report includes state spending on benefits in kind, such as the NHS and state education.)

Brown's handiwork led to that increasing from 43.1 to 53.4 per cent - or in real terms, added a further three million households to the ledger of those who are net recipients of the state. And it's the middle income earners who have transformed the picture. In 1990 the average household in the middle group of earners used to pay £1,673 more in tax than it received in benefits.

Twenty years later those middle earners had become net recipients - taking on average £4,589 more in benefits than they paid in taxation. That is a dramatic change.

If you divide households into five groups, from the poorest through to the highest earners, you'd find in 2010 that the top fifth effectively pays for the rest of the country to receive benefits.

Gordon Brown essentially made the vast majority of us all clients of the State, and as such dependent / grateful to the Labour Party for the scraps thrown to us. The bungs to us in Covid relief and Energy price relief have deeply embedded this. The huge rise in sickness and disability claims since Covid is all part of the same pattern.

That’s what I wish to dismantle.
Reply
#19
Universal basic income anyone?
Reply
#20
(07-02-2025, 11:03 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-02-2025, 10:51 AM)baggy1 Wrote: And it appears I don't understand your use of 'client state' - it might help here by explaining what you mean.

Kendall is portrayed by the Labour left and the puerile disabled demonstrators as a wild-eyed axewoman. Yet all the Government is trying to do is to reduce the rate at which the Welfare bill is rising. Last night showed the huge political difficulties there would be even if the rate of growth were reduced  let alone if real cuts were planned. This is no accident. This is what Gordon Brown spent 13 years working towards.

He may have been one of the worst PMs in history but as a political strategist he knew exactly what he was doing. His introduction of Tax Credits was not about alleviating poverty so much as creating a new class of benefit recipient - not just those out of work and on the borderline of poverty but those in full-time work in good health who would previously never have come near benefits.

In 1979, 43.1 per cent of households received more in benefits than they paid in taxes. (The definition used in the report includes state spending on benefits in kind, such as the NHS and state education.)

Brown's handiwork led to that increasing from 43.1 to 53.4 per cent - or in real terms, added a further three million households to the ledger of those who are net recipients of the state. And it's the middle income earners who have transformed the picture. In 1990 the average household in the middle group of earners used to pay £1,673 more in tax than it received in benefits.

Twenty years later those middle earners had become net recipients - taking on average £4,589 more in benefits than they paid in taxation. That is a dramatic change.

If you divide households into five groups, from the poorest through to the highest earners, you'd find in 2010 that the top fifth effectively pays for the rest of the country to receive benefits.

Gordon Brown essentially made the vast majority of us all clients of the State, and as such dependent / grateful to the Labour Party for the scraps thrown to us. The bungs to us in Covid relief and Energy price relief have deeply embedded this. The huge rise in sickness and disability claims since Covid is all part of the same pattern.

That’s what I wish to dismantle.

Tough to argue with that tbf.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: