Crikey, I agree with Blair
#21
(04-30-2025, 09:02 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(04-30-2025, 08:44 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-30-2025, 08:39 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: I don’t think you need to be any kind of expert to observe that TM says to be correct.

"incinerating"?

If you say so.

Burning, whatever, anything else to disagree with in my statement or is it just semantics?

I take issue with your hysterical hyperbole. 

What's clear is that the race to net zero is costing jobs in energy intensive industries. At the same time no one seems to be able to explain what "the green jobs of the future" actually are.

Meanwhile, in the midst of a housing crisis, developers and landlords are being encumbered with excessive and often counter productive regulations in the pursuit of net zero that simply act to reduce supply and jack up purchase prices and rents.

This is also a very UK thing.
Reply
#22
(04-30-2025, 09:17 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-30-2025, 09:02 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(04-30-2025, 08:44 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-30-2025, 08:39 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: I don’t think you need to be any kind of expert to observe that TM says to be correct.

"incinerating"?

If you say so.

Burning, whatever, anything else to disagree with in my statement or is it just semantics?

I take issue with your hysterical hyperbole. 

What's clear is that the race to net zero is costing jobs in energy intensive industries. At the same time no one seems to be able to explain what "the green jobs of the future" actually are.

Meanwhile, in the midst of a housing crisis, developers and landlords are being encumbered with excessive and often counter productive regulations in the pursuit of net zero that simply act to reduce supply and jack up purchase prices and rents.

This is also a very UK thing.

So no then, glad you agree that net zero isn't preventing your kids getting a house or a job.
Reply
#23
Still waiting on how Proth would reduce energy prices over the next 5 years, if it's clear that net zero is the thing that's causing it then it should be very easy to come up with an answer.
Reply
#24
(04-30-2025, 09:25 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Still waiting on how Proth would reduce energy prices over the next 5 years, if it's clear that net zero is the thing that's causing it then it should be very easy to come up with an answer.

The highest energy costs in the world are just one of the prices we are paying for compounding 50 years of poor energy policy (we're agreed on that). A war on our continent clearly isn't helping, is it?

If Russia hadn't invaded Ukraine your pet hate of gas would be an academically niche issue. Not just here, but certainly in Germany.

Read the report and read my posts - this is about the price we're paying in jobs, future job prospects and putting housing and even driving further out of reach of working people - and for what end? 

If you want to force voters into the arms of extremists then making their daily lives ever more expensive / inconvenient and making their dreams ever more distant and unattainable in the pursuit of an utterly pointless goal is a great way to go about it.
Reply
#25
(04-30-2025, 09:46 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-30-2025, 09:25 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Still waiting on how Proth would reduce energy prices over the next 5 years, if it's clear that net zero is the thing that's causing it then it should be very easy to come up with an answer.

The highest energy costs in the world are just one of the prices we are paying for compounding 50 years of poor energy policy (we're agreed on that). A war on our continent clearly isn't helping, is it?

If Russia hadn't invaded Ukraine your pet hate of gas would be an academically niche issue. Not just here, but certainly in Germany.

Read the report and read my posts - this is about the price we're paying in jobs, future job prospects and putting housing and even driving further out of reach of working people - and for what end? 

If you want to force voters into the arms of extremists then making their daily lives ever more expensive / inconvenient and making their dreams ever more distant and unattainable in the pursuit of an utterly pointless goal is a great way to go about it.

Future proofing humanity's economic well being is a pointless goal. Who knew.
Reply
#26
So how would you reduce energy costs over the next 5 years? Spell it out. If it's clear that it's net zero that's the problem then you'd have an answer to that.

I've read the report, do you want me to quote the bit where it spells out the policy failings on nuclear from the 1980s that I've gone over multiple times and our need to embrace nuclear power? Or the reference to carbon capture that I referred to in this very thread? What I hate is bullshit straw man arguments designed to feed the egos of people who don't actually want to fix the problem and have spent decades obstructing solutions, like the aforementioned policy failings on nuclear, because they don't think it will affect them and they don't care about the massive shit they're going to leave future generations to fix.

And if Russia hadn't have invaded Ukraine we'd have more wiggle room to transition to a more energy secure future while other countries replaced their coal plants with gas from the Eurasian market. But unfortunately Russia did invade Ukraine and exposed how energy insecure gas actually is - much like how the OPEC crisis did which pushed France to pursue nuclear power and prompted our own new nuclear plans which were then abandoned by Thatcher's government putting us deeper in the shit today than we otherwise would have been.

What's apparent is you don't have a clue. You've picked a position that net zero is the cause of all our ills and you're working backwards which is why you don't have any answers to reduce energy prices hence your continual avoidance in answering that question, because it's got fuck all to do with net zero and everything to do with the price of gas.
Reply
#27
(04-29-2025, 10:11 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: I love the way Proth tries to lecture energy experts and economics professors on here.
A proper David v Goliath.
But in this case Goliath always swats the fly.

And who might they be? All I see are left wing activists who have never done a shift in their lives. All theory and ideology. School teachers with beards.
Reply
#28
(04-30-2025, 10:09 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: So how would you reduce energy costs over the next 5 years? Spell it out. 

That's not the point I was making, nor the point of Tone's report. 

The pursuit of net zero is not merely an energy production transition is it?

If energy prices remain at such an elevated level (and there's no reason to suggest they won't) then any government who wished to remain in office wouldn't be loading individuals and businesses with ever more cost and inconvenience.
Reply
#29
(04-30-2025, 02:50 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-30-2025, 10:09 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: So how would you reduce energy costs over the next 5 years? Spell it out. 

That's not the point I was making, nor the point of Tone's report. 

The pursuit of net zero is not merely an energy production transition is it?

If energy prices remain at such an elevated level (and there's no reason to suggest they won't) then any government who wished to remain in office wouldn't be loading individuals and businesses with ever more cost and inconvenience.

I referenced the point of the report by talking about CCUS for cement in my first comment, so then there would be more flexibility for cement usage with lower embedded carbon. Same with concrete. Stuff like that is directly referenced in the report. I'm not some deluded Just Stop Oil weirdo who thinks we can turn off all fossil fuels tomorrow and I'm not some Green Party activist who wants to pursue "degrowth" and stop all development. The whole point of that report is that the net zero message needs to shift towards industrialism to ensure we meet it, not bin it off.

You keep harping on about the cost of energy being high because of net zero, I keep telling you it's because of the cost of gas on the Eurasian gas market because that's the root cause.  If you want to bring down the cost of energy - and therefore lower household bills and lower industrial running costs - then we need to use less gas to produce energy.
Reply
#30
How long would it take to shift the majority of our baseline to Nuclear now? I still don't understand how we invented a clean, efficient, very powerful energy generation method and it's just been abandoned.

And anyone uses waste or meltdown as reasons against it has never, ever studied it at any level in their lives past media headlines
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: