WBAUnofficial
Crikey, I agree with Blair - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Crikey, I agree with Blair (/showthread.php?tid=37539)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


Crikey, I agree with Blair - Protheroe - 04-29-2025

Great to see our Tone calling out our crazy growth killing wealth destroying fixation on net zero for what it is.


RE: Crikey, I agree with Blair - Kit Kat Chunky - 04-29-2025

(04-29-2025, 05:12 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Great to see our Tone calling out our crazy growth killing wealth destroying fixation on net zero for what it is.

So what did he do when in power?


RE: Crikey, I agree with Blair - Borin' Baggie - 04-29-2025

I love when climate change denialists amplify straw man arguments to push their anti-solution agenda to ensure that they leave yet another steaming shit for my generation and future generations to fix.


RE: Crikey, I agree with Blair - Protheroe - 04-29-2025

He's not a denialist and neither am I. The only zealot in the room is you, and you don't seem concerned about the cost. But then it pays your wages.

Do I think my kids having a home is more important than the UK going net zero 2050? Yes.

Do I think my kids having a job is more important than the UK going net zero by 2050? Yes.

Do I think it's crazy that we're loading ever more costs and regulations on individuals and businesses when the increase in China's CO2 output last year was greater than UK's entire emissions? Yes.

Is there anyone prepared to disagree with me?


RE: Crikey, I agree with Blair - Borin' Baggie - 04-29-2025

No, he's the one straw manning. As are you.

How does getting to net zero stop us building houses? One of the biggest test cases for scaling CCUS is cement, literally to help build stuff including houses.

How is trying to hobble the fastest growing economic sector in the UK - where even the TBI admit could be worth 5.8% of UK GDP by 2050 - where we have a major geographical advantage to convert into a comparative advantage going to help with getting a job? It's also propping up UK vacancies.

Do you think China are massively expanding renewables and nuclear output to the point that it accounted for 10% of their GDP (US$940bn) in 2024 for shits and giggles?


RE: Crikey, I agree with Blair - Protheroe - 04-29-2025

Like I say, you're a zealot in the pay of the net zero lobby.

The rest of us just look at our bills and unreasonable and often counter productive demands being made on us to achieve precisely nothing on a global scale.


RE: Crikey, I agree with Blair - Borin' Baggie - 04-29-2025

Bla bla bla. I'm in the pay of the energy sector, predominantly made up by companies primarily invested in O+G. Do the maths over who pays my wages.

You keep bringing up costs, I have told you multiple times why the cost of energy is high. It's not my fault you keep wanting to deny the truth and it's not my fault you want to blame literally everything except for the root cause because your delicate worldview doesn't want to accept that it's gas.


RE: Crikey, I agree with Blair - Protheroe - 04-29-2025

The truth is we have the highest energy costs in the world and they are getting higher. We also have a housing crisis and a government loading the building industry with ever more counter productive and costly regulation in pursuit of an irrational goal. Labour has the opportunity to slow the march, concentrate on the real priorities of the day or pay for it at the ballot box.


RE: Crikey, I agree with Blair - Borin' Baggie - 04-29-2025

We have high energy costs because gas sets the marginal price more often than not, the only way to fix that is to make it so that it sets the marginal price less often and the only practical way to do that over the short term is to expand out dispatchable renewables because battery technology isn't there yet and pumped hydro and nuclear aren't there yet. Seriously, what is the actual plan here if not renewables because all I'm hearing is net zero is the problem when we're 25 years out from that and our energy costs are tied to gas.

You cannot ignore the elephant in the room, our reliance on natural gas for generation is the reason we have high energy prices. It's not a coincidence that the day-ahead price collapses when we don't need to use dispatchable gas to meet demand.

Everything about my job revolves around the energy trilemma, every energy model factors in energy security and cost on equal footing to environmental impact. Gas fails on all three at the minute, it used to meet cost but it hasn't since 2021. If you want bills to come down by 2029 I've seen the models, the only thing that works over the next 5 years is building out renewables and transmission networks in areas where they can be fully utilised so we don't need to use dispatchable CCGT plants as much because nothing else can get built by then. That is the solution to the real problem. And coal isn't an option either because that's even more expensive than natural gas which is why natural gas - not renewables - displaced it. If we don't do that then the cost of relying on dispatchable gas to manage demand and stability will rise by nearly £2.5bn by 2030 which gets passed onto electricity bills, that's not even going into heating bills which are impacted by generation demand for gas as most of us use gas for heating.


RE: Crikey, I agree with Blair - man in the corner shop - 04-29-2025

I love the way Proth tries to lecture energy experts and economics professors on here.
A proper David v Goliath.
But in this case Goliath always swats the fly.