Posts: 3,488
Threads: 101
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
(03-30-2025, 09:05 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: (03-30-2025, 07:46 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I thought the PPG were similar, so with that in mind, in every single way, including results we have gotten worse. All whilst having, IMVHO, a better, more balanced squad. Easy one that.
The only thing that has changed is our general, rough, philosophy. Almost like we've played a computer game and pressed the "attacking mentality" and "higher defensive line" buttons.
As I have said all along, he gets till the summer regardless for me. But we are showing little sign of improvement, in fact we seem to be getting worse.
Your last paragraph there is how I feel: sometimes we look alright, sometimes we look pretty clueless. Some games Mowbray’s approach- which I’m not quite sure what that is as everything differs from game to game - has won us points (Leeds / Burnley / maybe Sheff W) but other games cost us points (yesterday / Hull / Plymouth).
I’m not so worried about the points or the play offs but expect to see by the summer a clearly defined style of play and some consistency in selection. If the season ended today I’d not be that confident for next season with him in charge.
Probably about where I’m at though so disappointed in our attacking play/goals under Tony.
Expected him to get much more out of us going forward though at the expense of a worse defence.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(03-30-2025, 08:22 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Fair post. There really is little difference between CC’s last 12 and Mowbray’s first 12.
Our away form has always been an issue so anyone claiming that we wouldn’t have lost to Norwich under CC is just deluded. Nor can they claim that we wouldn’t have drawn with Hull at home, as this season has been littered with such results.
The squad is no better, with only Price being a genuine success and the future champions league quip is just daft. He may, he may not. At this moment he very much is not, however! Lamp Frankard is but no one wanted him!
We’ll finish around the 70 point mark so nothings changed on that score.
Whilst its correct to criticise TM now, he shouldn’t, and won’t, be judged until the end of the season, so those who seem so keen for him to fail just to be proven right are ridiculous IMVHO. Will they boycott Wembley if we get there or just turn up in Corberan masks?
We should be getting to the playoffs, the squad is in the top six in the division. TM has had one promotion with the best squad and biggest wage bill and that’s about it at this level. I hear the argument he can make young players better, that’s fine but ultimately we need promotion and soon, the longer we linger in this division the less likely that is to happen. If we fail to reach the playoffs this year, there can be no excuses it’s a failure and I doubt given the current manager record that will improve next season… quite the contrary.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(03-30-2025, 07:46 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I thought the PPG were similar, so with that in mind, in every single way, including results we have gotten worse. All whilst having, IMVHO, a better, more balanced squad. Easy one that.
The only thing that has changed is our general, rough, philosophy. Almost like we've played a computer game and pressed the "attacking mentality" and "higher defensive line" buttons.
As I have said all along, he gets till the summer regardless for me. But we are showing little sign of improvement, in fact we seem to be getting worse.
I don't understand the better, more balanced squad comment.
In truth without Maja or a player similar to him and at his ability, this squad is not as well balanced.
The signing of Price has the potential to be a great one, possibly Bany too. But the other two were short term punts, which to date haven't come off.
Once we signed Armstrong, Lankshear was unlikely to get time on the pitch and I'm not sure Armstrong is a good fit for our squad
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(03-30-2025, 10:03 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (03-30-2025, 07:46 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I thought the PPG were similar, so with that in mind, in every single way, including results we have gotten worse. All whilst having, IMVHO, a better, more balanced squad. Easy one that.
The only thing that has changed is our general, rough, philosophy. Almost like we've played a computer game and pressed the "attacking mentality" and "higher defensive line" buttons.
As I have said all along, he gets till the summer regardless for me. But we are showing little sign of improvement, in fact we seem to be getting worse.
I don't understand the better, more balanced squad comment.
In truth without Maja or a player similar to him and at his ability, this squad is not as well balanced.
The signing of Price has the potential to be a great one, possibly Bany too. But the other two were short term punts, which to date haven't come off.
Once we signed Armstrong, Lankshear was unlikely to get time on the pitch and I'm not sure Armstrong is a good fit for our squad
Under the last coach. When Maja fatigued on 60 mins who did hame have up top as an option? Wallace. ToMo has Armstrong, Dike and Lankshear. The squad has more options and should be competing better.
Look back to when CC had BTA and Dike both fit. They were both regularly clocking goals as subs in the last 25. Because he was managing the options he had effectively. If he had, Dike, Lankshear and Armstrong. A fully fit Grady and MJ, and a powerful running CM in Price, he would have most certainly turned those draws into wins more often since Jan. IMVHO of course.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 7,408
Threads: 458
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
We are clearly not good enough, but somehow are handing in there, not by our own good play but other side’s shortcomings.
I think we will make the play offs because other sides are not taking advantage of our results. If we do make it then it’s anybody’s. Do you really think the side finishing third whoever it will be, will be up for the play offs after getting 90 + points and not going up, they will be devastated. Finish 5th or 6th and the 3rd place is anybody’s.
Posts: 7,711
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
(03-30-2025, 10:16 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (03-30-2025, 10:03 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (03-30-2025, 07:46 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I thought the PPG were similar, so with that in mind, in every single way, including results we have gotten worse. All whilst having, IMVHO, a better, more balanced squad. Easy one that.
The only thing that has changed is our general, rough, philosophy. Almost like we've played a computer game and pressed the "attacking mentality" and "higher defensive line" buttons.
As I have said all along, he gets till the summer regardless for me. But we are showing little sign of improvement, in fact we seem to be getting worse.
I don't understand the better, more balanced squad comment.
In truth without Maja or a player similar to him and at his ability, this squad is not as well balanced.
The signing of Price has the potential to be a great one, possibly Bany too. But the other two were short term punts, which to date haven't come off.
Once we signed Armstrong, Lankshear was unlikely to get time on the pitch and I'm not sure Armstrong is a good fit for our squad
Under the last coach. When Maja fatigued on 60 mins who did hame have up top as an option? Wallace. ToMo has Armstrong, Dike and Lankshear. The squad has more options and should be competing better.
Look back to when CC had BTA and Dike both fit. They were both regularly clocking goals as subs in the last 25. Because he was managing the options he had effectively. If he had, Dike, Lankshear and Armstrong. A fully fit Grady and MJ, and a powerful running CM in Price, he would have most certainly turned those draws into wins more often since Jan. IMVHO of course.
Difficult to argue with this. Mowbray has got himself into a bit of a mess with both tactics and teams selection. He's only played a true 10 in one game (Portsmouth - and Grady was outstanding that day), he's crow barring Price into the side in anything other than his best position. He's not getting the best out of his wingers and amazingly he's also not getting anything out of Armstrong, a player who scored over 60 goals for him at other clubs.
Midfield is a state, Molumby for me muddies the waters of what we're trying to do in particular, but also there is no need for both Mowatt and Swift in the same team, they are both doing the same job. I dont buy into that being Swift's fault yesterday, he turned over possession 70 yards from our goal. Mowatt did similar in a recent home game resulting in a goal. The defence have to react better. If that had been us there would be no way we'd have made 3 incisive passes and scored.
Mowbray needs to get some clarity and now with only one more midweek game there is no need to manage anyone including Easter weekend. Pick a team and system and largely stick to it for the last 7 (10) games.
Posts: 7,971
Threads: 254
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
That first paragraph is bang on
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(03-30-2025, 10:39 AM)Jacko Wrote: (03-30-2025, 10:16 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (03-30-2025, 10:03 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (03-30-2025, 07:46 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I thought the PPG were similar, so with that in mind, in every single way, including results we have gotten worse. All whilst having, IMVHO, a better, more balanced squad. Easy one that.
The only thing that has changed is our general, rough, philosophy. Almost like we've played a computer game and pressed the "attacking mentality" and "higher defensive line" buttons.
As I have said all along, he gets till the summer regardless for me. But we are showing little sign of improvement, in fact we seem to be getting worse.
I don't understand the better, more balanced squad comment.
In truth without Maja or a player similar to him and at his ability, this squad is not as well balanced.
The signing of Price has the potential to be a great one, possibly Bany too. But the other two were short term punts, which to date haven't come off.
Once we signed Armstrong, Lankshear was unlikely to get time on the pitch and I'm not sure Armstrong is a good fit for our squad
Under the last coach. When Maja fatigued on 60 mins who did hame have up top as an option? Wallace. ToMo has Armstrong, Dike and Lankshear. The squad has more options and should be competing better.
Look back to when CC had BTA and Dike both fit. They were both regularly clocking goals as subs in the last 25. Because he was managing the options he had effectively. If he had, Dike, Lankshear and Armstrong. A fully fit Grady and MJ, and a powerful running CM in Price, he would have most certainly turned those draws into wins more often since Jan. IMVHO of course.
Difficult to argue with this. Mowbray has got himself into a bit of a mess with both tactics and teams selection. He's only played a true 10 in one game (Portsmouth - and Grady was outstanding that day), he's crow barring Price into the side in anything other than his best position. He's not getting the best out of his wingers and amazingly he's also not getting anything out of Armstrong, a player who scored over 60 goals for him at other clubs.
Midfield is a state, Molumby for me muddies the waters of what we're trying to do in particular, but also there is no need for both Mowatt and Swift in the same team, they are both doing the same job. I dont buy into that being Swift's fault yesterday, he turned over possession 70 yards from our goal. Mowatt did similar in a recent home game resulting in a goal. The defence have to react better. If that had been us there would be no way we'd have made 3 incisive passes and scored.
Mowbray needs to get some clarity and now with only one more midweek game there is no need to manage anyone including Easter weekend. Pick a team and system and largely stick to it for the last 7 (10) games. Nailed it Jacko.
Posts: 624
Threads: 42
Joined: Mar 2024
Reputation:
0
I was disappointed yesterday and still am but the table never lies at the end of a season, so let's be patient and see what it's says come 3rd May .Don't now if there's any break in contract clause but if we fall short imo he should go ,but I'm just one of many thousands with an opinion and my opinion counts for sweet FA .
Posts: 2,953
Threads: 67
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
12
(03-30-2025, 10:00 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (03-30-2025, 08:22 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Fair post. There really is little difference between CC’s last 12 and Mowbray’s first 12.
Our away form has always been an issue so anyone claiming that we wouldn’t have lost to Norwich under CC is just deluded. Nor can they claim that we wouldn’t have drawn with Hull at home, as this season has been littered with such results.
The squad is no better, with only Price being a genuine success and the future champions league quip is just daft. He may, he may not. At this moment he very much is not, however! Lamp Frankard is but no one wanted him!
We’ll finish around the 70 point mark so nothings changed on that score.
Whilst its correct to criticise TM now, he shouldn’t, and won’t, be judged until the end of the season, so those who seem so keen for him to fail just to be proven right are ridiculous IMVHO. Will they boycott Wembley if we get there or just turn up in Corberan masks?
We should be getting to the playoffs, the squad is in the top six in the division. TM has had one promotion with the best squad and biggest wage bill and that’s about it at this level. I hear the argument he can make young players better, that’s fine but ultimately we need promotion and soon, the longer we linger in this division the less likely that is to happen. If we fail to reach the playoffs this year, there can be no excuses it’s a failure and I doubt given the current manager record that will improve next season… quite the contrary.
How do you know that our squad is in the top 6 in the division?
I see this a lot. But to know that, you'd have to spend a lot of time watching Bristol city, Cardiff, Sunderland Coventry , Millwall....
I bet you don't.
|