Better, worse or the same…
#1
I’ve taken the stance that I don’t see much difference between the performances between Corberan’s team and Mowbray’s.  Sure I’ve bitten at a few who clearly didn’t want Mowbray from the start and take great delight in anything negative.  I can see some of the failings, I just don’t like people revelling in it.

Some thought it was the end of the world when CC left and no one could do as good a job, if you feel so strongly why are you moaning if you’re belief is that Mowbray isn’t delivering?  You expected it!

Anyway, let’s ignore the subtle differences on the pitch and look at reality of results.

CC had us in 7th position when he left 40 points from 22 games.  An average of 1.59 points per game (ppg).


However if you remove our lightening start from our first 6 games (2.67 ppg) his average in his last 16 games was 1.18 ppg.

Our form had really gone.

Ignoring the games without a manager and on to Mowbray.

His 13 games have yielded 17 points, 1.30 ppg.  If you ignore his first game in charge, he was appointed on the Friday, then it’s 
16 points from 12 meaning 1.33 ppg.

So overall his ppg is lower, but he has lifted us from the 16 game slump under Carlos after our start.  

This to me indicates he’s not particularly failing, but he’s not hugely turned us round.  Given most thought CC was the greatest since Megson then it’s no surprise we’ve only marginally picked up. I don’t buy into the better squad, Price and Armstrong have come at the cost of Palmer going, he’s also had red cards and injuries too.

What is clear 1.33 will only yield 9/10 more points, which is unlikely to be enough.  But Mowbray picked us up outside the play-offs to begin with so maybe asking for improvement on that is too much?
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#2
Agree, if you ignore all the games we won, Mowbray is doing a far better job than CC.
Reply
#3
We lost a future Champions League manager and swapped him for a clogger that couldn’t get a team with Jason Koumas, Zoltan Gera, Robert Koren, Diomansy Kamara and Kevin Philips to score against Derby.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#4
I thought the PPG were similar, so with that in mind, in every single way, including results we have gotten worse. All whilst having, IMVHO, a better, more balanced squad. Easy one that.

The only thing that has changed is our general, rough, philosophy. Almost like we've played a computer game and pressed the "attacking mentality" and "higher defensive line" buttons.

As I have said all along, he gets till the summer regardless for me. But we are showing little sign of improvement, in fact we seem to be getting worse.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#5
(03-30-2025, 05:37 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: I’ve taken the stance that I don’t see much difference between the performances between Corberan’s team and Mowbray’s.  Sure I’ve bitten at a few who clearly didn’t want Mowbray from the start and take great delight in anything negative.  I can see some of the failings, I just don’t like people revelling in it.

Some thought it was the end of the world when CC left and no one could do as good a job, if you feel so strongly why are you moaning if you’re belief is that Mowbray isn’t delivering?  You expected it!

Anyway, let’s ignore the subtle differences on the pitch and look at reality of results.

CC had us in 7th position when he left 40 points from 22 games.  An average of 1.59 points per game (ppg).


However if you remove our lightening start from our first 6 games (2.67 ppg) his average in his last 16 games was 1.18 ppg.

Our form had really gone.

Ignoring the games without a manager and on to Mowbray.

His 13 games have yielded 17 points, 1.30 ppg.  If you ignore his first game in charge, he was appointed on the Friday, then it’s 
16 points from 12 meaning 1.33 ppg.

So overall his ppg is lower, but he has lifted us from the 16 game slump under Carlos after our start.  

This to me indicates he’s not particularly failing, but he’s not hugely turned us round.  Given most thought CC was the greatest since Megson then it’s no surprise we’ve only marginally picked up. I don’t buy into the better squad, Price and Armstrong have come at the cost of Palmer going, he’s also had red cards and injuries too.

What is clear 1.33 will only yield 9/10 more points, which is unlikely to be enough.  But Mowbray picked us up outside the play-offs to begin with so maybe asking for improvement on that is too much?

Agree with this. Saved me having to make post.

Would add Mowbray has not been able to play arguably our best player this season, Maja.

I think both Corberan and Mowbray are competent coaches at this level, but they can't turn water into wine. This is a decent, hard working squad of goodish championship players, but it's a way off from being one that can challenge for automatic promotion, which is where we need to be.
Reply
#6
(03-30-2025, 07:04 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: We lost a future Champions League manager and swapped him for a clogger that couldn’t get a team with Jason Koumas, Zoltan Gera, Robert Koren, Diomansy Kamara and Kevin Philips to score against Derby.

This "future Champions League manager" bollocks is going to get very tedious. It could be decades before we realise it isn't going to happen.
Reply
#7
Fair post. There really is little difference between CC’s last 12 and Mowbray’s first 12.
Our away form has always been an issue so anyone claiming that we wouldn’t have lost to Norwich under CC is just deluded. Nor can they claim that we wouldn’t have drawn with Hull at home, as this season has been littered with such results.
The squad is no better, with only Price being a genuine success and the future champions league quip is just daft. He may, he may not. At this moment he very much is not, however! Lamp Frankard is but no one wanted him!
We’ll finish around the 70 point mark so nothings changed on that score.
Whilst its correct to criticise TM now, he shouldn’t, and won’t, be judged until the end of the season, so those who seem so keen for him to fail just to be proven right are ridiculous IMVHO. Will they boycott Wembley if we get there or just turn up in Corberan masks?
Reply
#8
(03-30-2025, 07:04 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: We lost a future Champions League manager and swapped him for a clogger that couldn’t get a team with Jason Koumas, Zoltan Gera, Robert Koren, Diomansy Kamara and Kevin Philips to score against Derby.

Yet we thumped a bigger spending Wolves side in the semi final

Stop re-writing history to fit your agenda.

Derby had Darren Moore at the back that day and we didn’t deserve to lose.

I really liked Carlos but we were often as dull as dishwater. Remind me how many we thumped Oxford away and Millwall at home by.
Reply
#9
(03-30-2025, 07:46 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I thought the PPG were similar, so with that in mind, in every single way, including results we have gotten worse. All whilst having, IMVHO, a better, more balanced squad. Easy one that.

The only thing that has changed is our general, rough, philosophy. Almost like we've played a computer game and pressed the "attacking mentality" and "higher defensive line" buttons.

As I have said all along, he gets till the summer regardless for me. But we are showing little sign of improvement, in fact we seem to be getting worse.

Your last paragraph there is how I feel: sometimes we look alright, sometimes we look pretty clueless. Some games Mowbray’s approach- which I’m not quite sure what that is as everything differs from game to game - has won us points (Leeds / Burnley / maybe Sheff W) but other games cost us points (yesterday / Hull / Plymouth).

I’m not so worried about the points or the play offs but expect to see by the summer a clearly defined style of play and some consistency in selection. If the season ended today I’d not be that confident for next season with him in charge.
Reply
#10
(03-30-2025, 09:05 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 07:46 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I thought the PPG were similar, so with that in mind, in every single way, including results we have gotten worse. All whilst having, IMVHO, a better, more balanced squad. Easy one that.

The only thing that has changed is our general, rough, philosophy. Almost like we've played a computer game and pressed the "attacking mentality" and "higher defensive line" buttons.

As I have said all along, he gets till the summer regardless for me. But we are showing little sign of improvement, in fact we seem to be getting worse.

Your last paragraph there is how I feel: sometimes we look alright, sometimes we look pretty clueless. Some games Mowbray’s approach- which I’m not quite sure what that is as everything differs from game to game - has won us points (Leeds / Burnley / maybe Sheff W) but other games cost us points (yesterday / Hull / Plymouth).

I’m not so worried about the points or the play offs but expect to see by the summer a clearly defined style of play and some consistency in selection. If the season ended today I’d not be that confident for next season with him in charge.

Brilliantly put Clem, mirrors my thoughts perfectly.
"IMO of course..."
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)