Posts: 289
Threads: 26
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
0
(03-14-2025, 08:22 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: My son asked me today who I'd consider the best player I've ever seen in the stripes.
I had to think about it as really it will always be a goalscorer or someone who produces magic to change things, rather than the many excellent defenders we've had. I'd say those of my era, past 50 years, Robson has had the most outstanding career, but most of his glory years were after he left us.
However, as far as a quality player goes I think the couple of seasons of Cunningham were the best I've seen. Therefore he takes the accolade. Cyrille of those first 2 seasons was unreal too, but his career didn't materialise as we'd have expected.
Of the past 20 or so years, in our Prem time I'd say prime Pereira is the best I've seen since. I would add Gera at his best is right up there, with Koumas worthy of note too.
I'm sure I've missed a few as well.
Interested to hear your thoughts as there's possibly some worthy of mention I've forgot.
Started thinking about a top 5, but then had to go to a top 10. My only criteria was that I've had to see them in the flesh, but at 54 that gave me some scope and I've tried to keep it to those that did/could have played at the highest level
Bomber
Cyrille
Laurie
Robson
Statham
Bennett (what could've been but for injuries)
Gera
Phillips
Lukaku
Foster
Posts: 31
Threads: 1
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation:
0
Been going since '74 IMO it's Bryan Robson. We all knew he was destined to be the England captain
Posts: 2,836
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
That's a very challenging question to answer. It depends on where Albion were at the time and the impact made by the candidate.
Jeff won us a major trophy. We came close a year later again thanks to Jeff.
Bomber contributed over so many seasons. Played in the 68 Cup final. Reinvented himself in the Giles/Allen/Atkinson era.
Lee Hughes scored so many crucial goals but never played for us in the top flight and disgraced himself.
Bob Taylor scored 96 goals in 238 games in his first spell. He scored 17 in 86 second time around and was key in securing promotion to the EPL. He made 2 EPL appearances.
Who else?
Derek Statham, John Wile (one of the best CHs never capped by England), Robson (who we always knew would go on to greatness).
Here's a list who, IMHO could stake a claim.
I'm sure I've missed loads.
However as stated above, for me, it depends on where we were at the time and what we achieved.
Best keeper
Osborne, Godden, Hoult, Foster
Best RB Howe,
Best LB Statham, Williams, Clement
Best CH Kaye, Wile, Robertson, Bennett, Robson (he did play there when needed), Olsson, McCauley
Midfield Bomber, Giles, Cantello, Robson, Pereira, Morrison, Yacob, Molumbu
Forwards. Clark, Regis, Cunningham, Johnston, Bomber, Astle, Hughes, Taylor, Sneekes, KP, Gera, Odemwingie, Lukaku, Koumas.
Posts: 2,927
Threads: 44
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation:
7
My first game was in 1989 so from that era onwards it would have to be Lukaku for me. Even at such a young age you could see he was pure quality.
Posts: 6,720
Threads: 355
Joined: Mar 2024
Reputation:
40
Laurie
Cyrille
Dekka
Robbo
Willie
Posts: 6,454
Threads: 192
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
(03-14-2025, 09:41 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Laurie
Cyrille
Dekka
Robbo
Willie
Can't find a single fault with this.
Posts: 10,436
Threads: 427
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(03-14-2025, 09:25 PM)Albionmad Wrote: That's a very challenging question to answer. It depends on where Albion were at the time and the impact made by the candidate.
Jeff won us a major trophy. We came close a year later again thanks to Jeff.
Bomber contributed over so many seasons. Played in the 68 Cup final. Reinvented himself in the Giles/Allen/Atkinson era.
Lee Hughes scored so many crucial goals but never played for us in the top flight and disgraced himself.
Bob Taylor scored 96 goals in 238 games in his first spell. He scored 17 in 86 second time around and was key in securing promotion to the EPL. He made 2 EPL appearances.
Who else?
Derek Statham, John Wile (one of the best CHs never capped by England), Robson (who we always knew would go on to greatness).
Here's a list who, IMHO could stake a claim.
I'm sure I've missed loads.
However as stated above, for me, it depends on where we were at the time and what we achieved.
Best keeper
Osborne, Godden, Hoult, Foster
Best RB Howe,
Best LB Statham, Williams, Clement
Best CH Kaye, Wile, Robertson, Bennett, Robson (he did play there when needed), Olsson, McCauley
Midfield Bomber, Giles, Cantello, Robson, Pereira, Morrison, Yacob, Molumbu
Forwards. Clark, Regis, Cunningham, Johnston, Bomber, Astle, Hughes, Taylor, Sneekes, KP, Gera, Odemwingie, Lukaku, Koumas.
This - spot on with those choices.
Posts: 1,077
Threads: 70
Joined: Oct 2024
Reputation:
6
I can just about remember watching Johnny Nicholls who was instrumental in Ronnie Allen's success. That was a great time to be in the Hawthorns.
Other than him, Laurie, who was poetry in motion. I've never seen a footballer dance before or since.
At my age there are too many to mention.
Posts: 1,131
Threads: 164
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
Out of all I have seen live, the most talented has to be Laurie. The best overall I would say Bryan Robson.
Posts: 482
Threads: 12
Joined: May 2019
Reputation:
2
(03-14-2025, 10:14 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (03-14-2025, 09:25 PM)Albionmad Wrote: That's a very challenging question to answer. It depends on where Albion were at the time and the impact made by the candidate.
Jeff won us a major trophy. We came close a year later again thanks to Jeff.
Bomber contributed over so many seasons. Played in the 68 Cup final. Reinvented himself in the Giles/Allen/Atkinson era.
Lee Hughes scored so many crucial goals but never played for us in the top flight and disgraced himself.
Bob Taylor scored 96 goals in 238 games in his first spell. He scored 17 in 86 second time around and was key in securing promotion to the EPL. He made 2 EPL appearances.
Who else?
Derek Statham, John Wile (one of the best CHs never capped by England), Robson (who we always knew would go on to greatness).
Here's a list who, IMHO could stake a claim.
I'm sure I've missed loads.
However as stated above, for me, it depends on where we were at the time and what we achieved.
Best keeper
Osborne, Godden, Hoult, Foster
Best RB Howe,
Best LB Statham, Williams, Clement
Best CH Kaye, Wile, Robertson, Bennett, Robson (he did play there when needed), Olsson, McCauley
Midfield Bomber, Giles, Cantello, Robson, Pereira, Morrison, Yacob, Molumbu
Forwards. Clark, Regis, Cunningham, Johnston, Bomber, Astle, Hughes, Taylor, Sneekes, KP, Gera, Odemwingie, Lukaku, Koumas.
This - spot on with those choices.
Hughes did play 20+ games for us in the top flight mind
|