WBAUnofficial
The best player who has played for the Albion? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: The best player who has played for the Albion? (/showthread.php?tid=36954)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


The best player who has played for the Albion? - Spandaubaggie - 03-14-2025

My son asked me today who I'd consider the best player I've ever seen in the stripes.

I had to think about it as really it will always be a goalscorer or someone who produces magic to change things, rather than the many excellent defenders we've had. I'd say those of my era, past 50 years, Robson has had the most outstanding career, but most of his glory years were after he left us.

However, as far as a quality player goes I think the couple of seasons of Cunningham were the best I've seen. Therefore he takes the accolade. Cyrille of those first 2 seasons was unreal too, but his career didn't materialise as we'd have expected.

Of the past 20 or so years, in our Prem time I'd say prime Pereira is the best I've seen since. I would add Gera at his best is right up there, with Koumas worthy of note too.

I'm sure I've missed a few as well.

Interested to hear your thoughts as there's possibly some worthy of mention I've forgot.


RE: The best player who has played for the Albion? - Bob Fossil - 03-14-2025

Heart says Cyrille
Head says Bomber


RE: The best player who has played for the Albion? - Duffers - 03-14-2025

Gera.

Koumas and Kanu probably the two most technically gifted players I’ve seen in the stripes.


RE: The best player who has played for the Albion? - Pf1ster - 03-14-2025

Willie Johnson and Laurie Cunningham for me.


RE: The best player who has played for the Albion? - Boinger - 03-14-2025

I’m 52, so didn’t see Brown or Cunningham live at Albion. Cyrille a hero, saw latter years with us, but best player I’d say KP. One of the clubs worst decisions not to give him an extension


RE: The best player who has played for the Albion? - Jacko - 03-14-2025

Since 88.

I always pick a technical player when this comes around but if you think hard about it in my time would Ben Foster not be RIGHT up there? Would have got in most Premier League teams throughout his career.

The most gifted I've seen was Jase hands down. Pereira was very good.

Best striker we've had was Odemwingie. Lukaku of course was never ours. Phillips only got goals for us in the 2nd tier, Taylor similarly.

Could you make a case for Gareth McAuley? Johnny Evans?

Whole thing makes me wish I'd seen Robson, Cunningham etc.

Best player in my first season was Don Goodman. Although it was the year Martyn Bennett got the injury.


RE: The best player who has played for the Albion? - Midget In A Pinstripe Suit - 03-14-2025

Matheus Pereira


RE: The best player who has played for the Albion? - Jerry - 03-14-2025

Statham, most complete Albion player I have seen at the Albion.

Robson the legend his controlling of the game. It was said the best he played was at Albion not Utd. Also was said his best position was sweeper but never played there as he was a good midfielder.

Cunningham was just graceful and best in league in our almost season but too short a time with us.

Regis could have been if he had got that nasty streak and greater desire to score goals.

Never saw some of the greats, Allen, Barlow, etc but they should not be forgotten.


RE: The best player who has played for the Albion? - Lurker#3 - 03-14-2025

Koumas, Gera, Pereira


RE: The best player who has played for the Albion? - Spandaubaggie - 03-14-2025

(03-14-2025, 08:27 PM)Duffers Wrote: Gera.

Koumas and Kanu probably the two most technically gifted players I’ve seen in the stripes.

I sometimes watch old matches from my youth, but it's a different planet to now in many ways.

Football now is better due to pitches, sports science and the evolution of the game- the Hawthorns pitch was little better than Black Patch Park once the late autumn kicked in. Now it's like pitches from mid Aug to mid Oct all year round. It's made a huge difference.

It's a shame the better players of the old football era that you probably saw the tale end of were not afforded the advancements of pitches and sports science we've seen in the past 20 years.

That's why I find it so hard comparing the 70s/80s teams to now.

I would agree Gera for what he did consistently is the best we've seen of the modern bowling green pitch era. Pereira never really got the chance at the top level whilst with us.