Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(11-11-2024, 10:23 AM)Sliced Wrote: (11-11-2024, 07:20 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Holgate is very much the same as Ajayi. Has some attributes that sets him above the others, especially in possession and his agility. But he also has the hand grenade tendancy.
We have missed Bartley massively. Both in terms of his calmness when defending, but also his presence in the attacking area. He's really underrated in possession too.
Bart's and Heggem for me at CB.
Have we? We've conceded 2 in 5 without him, 7 in 10 when he's played, and he hasn't scored or assisted this season.
Defensively, we've improved without Bartley in the team.
With and without Bart's the defensive stats are not too far apart at all in all fairness. Which again points at how well set up we are.
Theres only a 0.02 xGA increase, from 0.92 - 0.94 when he hasn't been in the team in the league this year tbf. What Barts does offer is a better range of passing though. He has completed on average 1 more progressive pass per 90 than Holgate. Whilst helping us keep possession much more effectively by attempting nearly 25 more passes per 90.
Its unlike me, but what more important is how I feel when we are defending with Barts at the back than the raw stats (shock horror, I know). I would have felt much more comfortable with us holding on yesterday with Kyle there heading everything away. Which again makes no statistical sense as Holgate has our most clearances/90 in the squad.
Its good that we can make changes at the back and still be so solid either way.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 9,641
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
11-11-2024, 12:45 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-11-2024, 12:47 PM by Josh1873.)
I'm Bartley's biggest critic, but he's been ace this season so far. Especially when Captaining. However, I wouldn't say we miss him, but that's due to how well Holgate and Heggem have done, rather than anything negative against Kyle.
I wouldn't automatically start him when he's back fit, either. Again, nothing against how he played before, but due to the form of his replacements. It's how a good strong squad should be - if you lose your place, your replacement is strong and will be in good form, it's up to you to step up and take your place back when you get your chance. It's a healthy position to be in.
I'd also say, if CC does want to bring Barley right back in, then I certainly wouldn't be dropping Style for Heggem to slot back in at LB.
For all the negativity of late, I feel the squad has depth to it.
Posts: 7,711
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
When Bartley is fit he comes in for Holgate imo. I don't think he's been great and some of his passing is very lazy. There is a concern with pace without Ajayi but it's a risk I'd be willing to take.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(11-11-2024, 12:41 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (11-11-2024, 10:23 AM)Sliced Wrote: (11-11-2024, 07:20 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Holgate is very much the same as Ajayi. Has some attributes that sets him above the others, especially in possession and his agility. But he also has the hand grenade tendancy.
We have missed Bartley massively. Both in terms of his calmness when defending, but also his presence in the attacking area. He's really underrated in possession too.
Bart's and Heggem for me at CB.
Have we? We've conceded 2 in 5 without him, 7 in 10 when he's played, and he hasn't scored or assisted this season.
Defensively, we've improved without Bartley in the team.
With and without Bart's the defensive stats are not too far apart at all in all fairness. Which again points at how well set up we are.
Theres only a 0.02 xGA increase, from 0.92 - 0.94 when he hasn't been in the team in the league this year tbf. What Barts does offer is a better range of passing though. He has completed on average 1 more progressive pass per 90 than Holgate. Whilst helping us keep possession much more effectively by attempting nearly 25 more passes per 90.
Its unlike me, but what more important is how I feel when we are defending with Barts at the back than the raw stats (shock horror, I know). I would have felt much more comfortable with us holding on yesterday with Kyle there heading everything away. Which again makes no statistical sense as Holgate has our most clearances/90 in the squad.
Its good that we can make changes at the back and still be so solid either way. This is where stats can mislead. Other than playing the ball 10 yards to Ajayi or Furlong, Bartley can't pass water. He has his strengths, no doubt, particularly in a battle when we are under pressure. But all in all he is a pretty limited centre back and in no way suited to the playing out from the back policy which appears compulsory right now.
Posts: 2,465
Threads: 34
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(11-10-2024, 11:39 PM)Sliced Wrote: Furlong got justifiable criticism because he was a liability, but he's easily our most improved player over the past few seasons.
I agree, I would keep this back 4 until something happens to change it. Heggem looks even more capable at cb than left back, Styles has been good (particularly today) as has Holgate. We've also seen briefly this season than when we have Bartley and Heggem as a cb partnership we will get done for pace. You need Bartley or Heggem alongside a faster defensive partner, so either Holgate or Ajayi. As it stands I would take Heggem + Holgate.
I am half of the opinion that we need a "quick 'un" as one of the centre backs. My other half of opinion, however, tells me we did perfectly fine with Jonas and GMac as a partnership. I think as long as our centre backs have the brains then we can get away without the speed.
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(11-11-2024, 04:03 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: (11-11-2024, 12:41 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (11-11-2024, 10:23 AM)Sliced Wrote: (11-11-2024, 07:20 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Holgate is very much the same as Ajayi. Has some attributes that sets him above the others, especially in possession and his agility. But he also has the hand grenade tendancy.
We have missed Bartley massively. Both in terms of his calmness when defending, but also his presence in the attacking area. He's really underrated in possession too.
Bart's and Heggem for me at CB.
Have we? We've conceded 2 in 5 without him, 7 in 10 when he's played, and he hasn't scored or assisted this season.
Defensively, we've improved without Bartley in the team.
With and without Bart's the defensive stats are not too far apart at all in all fairness. Which again points at how well set up we are.
Theres only a 0.02 xGA increase, from 0.92 - 0.94 when he hasn't been in the team in the league this year tbf. What Barts does offer is a better range of passing though. He has completed on average 1 more progressive pass per 90 than Holgate. Whilst helping us keep possession much more effectively by attempting nearly 25 more passes per 90.
Its unlike me, but what more important is how I feel when we are defending with Barts at the back than the raw stats (shock horror, I know). I would have felt much more comfortable with us holding on yesterday with Kyle there heading everything away. Which again makes no statistical sense as Holgate has our most clearances/90 in the squad.
Its good that we can make changes at the back and still be so solid either way. This is where stats can mislead. Other than playing the ball 10 yards to Ajayi or Furlong, Bartley can't pass water. He has his strengths, no doubt, particularly in a battle when we are under pressure. But all in all he is a pretty limited centre back and in no way suited to the playing out from the back policy which appears compulsory right now.
I think, and always have, that this is a bit of a misnomer with Bart's, IMVHO.
He's obviously not the most nimble footed. He's not 'technical' like Heggem or Furlong, or even Holgate to be fair to him. But his passing is accurate, efficient and reliable across all distances.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 4,258
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(11-11-2024, 06:55 PM)baggie_ray Wrote: (11-10-2024, 11:39 PM)Sliced Wrote: Furlong got justifiable criticism because he was a liability, but he's easily our most improved player over the past few seasons.
I agree, I would keep this back 4 until something happens to change it. Heggem looks even more capable at cb than left back, Styles has been good (particularly today) as has Holgate. We've also seen briefly this season than when we have Bartley and Heggem as a cb partnership we will get done for pace. You need Bartley or Heggem alongside a faster defensive partner, so either Holgate or Ajayi. As it stands I would take Heggem + Holgate.
I am half of the opinion that we need a "quick 'un" as one of the centre backs. My other half of opinion, however, tells me we did perfectly fine with Jonas and GMac as a partnership. I think as long as our centre backs have the brains then we can get away without the speed.
I seem to recall that GMac was known to be pretty quick in the sprint, especially for someone so tall.
|