Posts: 4,258
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
Can't honestly say that the current line-up has given me any more scares than the "first choice" that started the season. Holgate is at least as good as Ajayi, Heggem has slotted into the CB role impressively and Styles is such a good footballer - really good first touch, reads the game well, loves to carry the ball forward. It's almost a waste to play him at full back - makes one wonder how it took so long for Carlos to get him in the team. And Furlong carries on being the complete player at full back, good at both ends of the park. Even back in the days when people used to slag him off, it occurred to me that he did a huge amount of defensive mopping up behind the CBs. 200 games and he's finally getting the kudos he deserves.
Posts: 13,256
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
Furlong got justifiable criticism because he was a liability, but he's easily our most improved player over the past few seasons.
I agree, I would keep this back 4 until something happens to change it. Heggem looks even more capable at cb than left back, Styles has been good (particularly today) as has Holgate. We've also seen briefly this season than when we have Bartley and Heggem as a cb partnership we will get done for pace. You need Bartley or Heggem alongside a faster defensive partner, so either Holgate or Ajayi. As it stands I would take Heggem + Holgate.
Posts: 1,735
Threads: 36
Joined: Sep 2022
Reputation:
5
I think we could do with Bartley’s leadership and he carries more of a threat from set pieces. However, the balance of Heggem and Holgate is really good.
I would choose Holgate over Ajayi or McNair. He has been decent in every game however he has gifted the opposition a chance in each one except Luton.
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
Holgate is very much the same as Ajayi. Has some attributes that sets him above the others, especially in possession and his agility. But he also has the hand grenade tendancy.
We have missed Bartley massively. Both in terms of his calmness when defending, but also his presence in the attacking area. He's really underrated in possession too.
Bart's and Heggem for me at CB.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 9,641
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
It's almost like we've got an excellent coach who knows how to organise XI players so that they're defensively sound, organised, and difficult to beat.
Posts: 3,594
Threads: 27
Joined: Apr 2019
Reputation:
14
(11-11-2024, 07:59 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: It's almost like we've got an excellent coach who knows how to organise XI players so that they're defensively sound, organised, and difficult to beat.
Now you're being silly. Pitchforks at the ready!
Posts: 7,994
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(11-11-2024, 09:40 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: (11-11-2024, 07:59 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: It's almost like we've got an excellent coach who knows how to organise XI players so that they're defensively sound, organised, and difficult to beat.
Now you're being silly. Pitchforks at the ready!
There's not been much criticism of the defence to be fair, it's the other end we've been struggling.
Don't think anyone would argue we have an excellent defensive coach.
Posts: 13,256
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
11-11-2024, 10:23 AM
(This post was last modified: 11-11-2024, 10:24 AM by Sliced.)
(11-11-2024, 07:20 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Holgate is very much the same as Ajayi. Has some attributes that sets him above the others, especially in possession and his agility. But he also has the hand grenade tendancy.
We have missed Bartley massively. Both in terms of his calmness when defending, but also his presence in the attacking area. He's really underrated in possession too.
Bart's and Heggem for me at CB.
Have we? We've conceded 2 in 5 without him, 7 in 10 when he's played, and he hasn't scored or assisted this season.
Defensively, we've improved without Bartley in the team.
Posts: 4,258
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(11-11-2024, 10:23 AM)Sliced Wrote: (11-11-2024, 07:20 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Holgate is very much the same as Ajayi. Has some attributes that sets him above the others, especially in possession and his agility. But he also has the hand grenade tendancy.
We have missed Bartley massively. Both in terms of his calmness when defending, but also his presence in the attacking area. He's really underrated in possession too.
Bart's and Heggem for me at CB.
Have we? We've conceded 2 in 5 without him, 7 in 10 when he's played, and he hasn't scored or assisted this season.
Defensively, we've improved without Bartley in the team.
Bartley's a great player, especially when he's not available
In recent days posters have talked about his leadership - but when weak goals have been conceded in the past he's been criticized on here for "finger-pointing" and apparently blaming his team-mates for everything. It's all about perspective, I suppose.
I'll be a little surprised if Ajayi gets back into the side, because we have good options ahead of him now. I've no idea how much CC values Bartley's contribution. As with our early season form, I'd be inclined to stick with what's working until it stops working.
As a footnote, I've looked into centre backs' scoring record for the Albion. Barts is on 14 from 194 league games, identical to Craig Dawson (OK he didn't play CB all that much for us), but notably a little better than GMac (15 from 203) and quite a lot better than Jonas (12 from 244) and John Wile (24 from 500). The winner is Semi Ajayi, with 12 goals in 157 league games. Not a proper scientific survey, I can't identify which were set piece goals, and the stats were taken from the famously unreliable Wiki. Makes me wonder when Barts' head went out of shape, 'cos his headers are never on target any more.
Posts: 13,256
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
(11-11-2024, 10:56 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (11-11-2024, 10:23 AM)Sliced Wrote: (11-11-2024, 07:20 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Holgate is very much the same as Ajayi. Has some attributes that sets him above the others, especially in possession and his agility. But he also has the hand grenade tendancy.
We have missed Bartley massively. Both in terms of his calmness when defending, but also his presence in the attacking area. He's really underrated in possession too.
Bart's and Heggem for me at CB.
Have we? We've conceded 2 in 5 without him, 7 in 10 when he's played, and he hasn't scored or assisted this season.
Defensively, we've improved without Bartley in the team.
Bartley's a great player, especially when he's not available 
In recent days posters have talked about his leadership - but when weak goals have been conceded in the past he's been criticized on here for "finger-pointing" and apparently blaming his team-mates for everything. It's all about perspective, I suppose.
I'll be a little surprised if Ajayi gets back into the side, because we have good options ahead of him now. I've no idea how much CC values Bartley's contribution. As with our early season form, I'd be inclined to stick with what's working until it stops working.
As a footnote, I've looked into centre backs' scoring record for the Albion. Barts is on 14 from 194 league games, identical to Craig Dawson (OK he didn't play CB all that much for us), but notably a little better than GMac (15 from 203) and quite a lot better than Jonas (12 from 244) and John Wile (24 from 500). The winner is Semi Ajayi, with 12 goals in 157 league games. Not a proper scientific survey, I can't identify which were set piece goals, and the stats were taken from the famously unreliable Wiki. Makes me wonder when Barts' head went out of shape, 'cos his headers are never on target any more.
Good post. Completely agree
|