Burnley Match Fred
(11-08-2024, 09:44 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: We look like a side who are solid and well organised despite our defensive injuries who also seem to have every attacking player bang out of form. Not sure why it needs the inquest, let alone questioning of the best manager we've had since Hodgson.

Club record number of draws in a row is why it needs an inquest. Probably close to record fewest goals scored too I'm guessing??
Reply
(11-08-2024, 10:36 AM)MrBater Wrote: Club record number of draws in a row is why it needs an inquest. Probably close to record fewest goals scored too I'm guessing??

I saw somewhere that we have broken a record for the least home goals in the start to a season for any team.
Reply
Throw all the stats around you want. The only relevant stats are:

5th with 22 points after 14 games. Just 2 defeats. That'll do for me.
Reply
(11-08-2024, 10:33 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(11-08-2024, 09:16 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: My point was the hypocrisy that fans display when they’ve decided they either really like or dislike a manager. If this was Pulis, Irvine or Allardyce the knives would be out but because it’s Corberan it’a sacrilege to question the results and manager. If there was consistency I wouldn’t have bothered replying the thread but there isn’t.

I don't think it is hypocrisy. I suggest Carlos has goodwill because of the terrible situation we were in both on and off the pitch and how he has turned it around.  He lives and breathes the job and I reckon this is appreciated by our fans.
 Pulis earned the wrath of the fans by never even trying to win a game. Our football currently is nowhere near the level of tedium. Further, the suspicion he was doing very nicely financially on the fly did not adhere him to many either inside or out of the club. I could go on but his record of getting us safe then switching off so as to not set any precedent for the future was an indication of his plans. A thoroughly dislikable individual.
  Irvine was given a poisoned chalice, an unpopular appointment that showed no ambition he was the victim of an owner looking to maximise pickings. Other than being underwhelmed, I personally had no issue with him.
 Big Sam? I was out on a limb there. First, no manager in Europe would have kept that squad up.  I thought it was a half decent appointment and believe he could have made a fist of getting us back up but he wasn't interested as we couldn't give him the means to do so.
 Carlos is popular because he has earned it. Simple.

It’s amazing how many games Pulis won in a very tough/most competitive league in the world without trying to. It’s almost as if you’re trying to shoehorn different rules on different managers when it comes to being objective Wink It’s ok we all do but some think they don’t and aren’t currently. 

I don’t want CC sacked but I’m not going to say he deserves any special treatment or one, two years etc to build a squad it’s just not and never will be how football works anymore.
Reply
(11-08-2024, 10:36 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(11-08-2024, 09:44 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: We look like a side who are solid and well organised despite our defensive injuries who also seem to have every attacking player bang out of form. Not sure why it needs the inquest, let alone questioning of the best manager we've had since Hodgson.

Club record number of draws in a row is why it needs an inquest. Probably close to record fewest goals scored too I'm guessing??

For the reasons as stated in my post. It's not the end of the world.
Reply
Not everything has to come down to "Carlos In" or "Carlos Out".
It's fair to laud the start, and the points on the board, but it's also fair to question the current drought.
I want him to continue and I want him to succeed, but, like it or not, 0-0's are not a good staple diet for fans, especially those in the ground. Last night was a cold, damp, school night and the lack of highlights definitely built frustration.
Yes, we can all appreciate the chess-like tactics of negating the opposition's threat and keeping a tight ship, but it doesn't make great viewing. Don't get me wrong, it was a great result, in isolation, especially considering our injuries, it's more the trend that is worrying. CC simply has to find a way of creating, and scoring, more chances and it's not going to happen by merely shuffling the personnel. He's tried that and it hasn't worked. That means it has to be a change to shape, formation or approach.
Contrary to popular belief, the vast majority of our fans are actually extremely knowledgeable, loyal and patient, so, if he was to throw a bit of caution to the wind and play less reserved and it didn't instantly bear fruit, the majority would be onboard, if it meant they could anticipate games with a bit more enthusiasm and gusto. Because, IMO, that's what's missing now It's hard to get excited about our next game. A massive part of being a football fan is the anticipation, and hope, and getting the old butterflies for the next match and that's all a bit lacking at present.

The comparisons to Pulis are a bit wide of the mark though, for one simple reason. Pulis would have been happy with this set of results. CC, I'm pretty sure, is not.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)